International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

The Political Implications of the Abortion Referendum in Ireland

· International Viewpoint No. 38, 17 October 1983 · pp 20-21 · 1,624 words

Britain and Ireland Women's liberation

The political implications of the abortion referendum in Ireland

Aine FURLONG On September 7 voters in the formally independent Irish Republic (the 26 counties of the South) added this clause to the constitution:

"The State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right to life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect and, as far as practicable, by its laws to vindicate and defend that right."

The overall result was 66.45 per cent voting 'yes' and 32.87 voting 'no'. The turnout was 53.67 per cent, about 20 per cent lower than the turnout for a general election or for the referendum on entry into the EEC in 1972.

The voting figures reflect a sharp division between rural and urban areas on the question. In Dublin, the main urban centre, there were 51.36 per cent 'yes' votes and 48.09 per cent 'no' votes, compared to results in the rural West of over 70 per cent 'yes' votes.

A decisive cause of this sharp division was the open intervention by the Catholic hierarchy in the last few weeks of what had been a long and stormy public debate. Their statements had a much greater impact in the rural areas than in the cities. They thus boosted their allies - but at a price. For the results also showed that a large number of Catholics had broken with the Church's teaching over a 'moral' issue.

Such direct intervention has been unusual in recent times - of late the hierarchy has preferred to exercise its power behind the scenes. However, such interventions are not new. The last open break by large numbers of Catholics with the hierarchy on a 'moral' question was in the 1890s when the bishops aided in driving Charles Stewart Parnell, leader of the Home Rule for Ireland movement, to an early death in disgrace after he was cited as co-respondent in a divorce case. In so doing they got rid of an awkward obstacle to British government plans by leaving the nationalist movement leaderless, and thus easier to control, for a short period. But with the loss of Parnell, the most radical leader of the bourgeois section of the movement, the radicals looked for more militant answers.

In recent times the best-remembered political intervention by the Church was over the proposal in the 1947 Health Act to provide free health care for mothers and children. The hierarchy opposed this on the grounds that they would lose con20 trol over the hospitals if they received more state funding. Although they won on this battle the influence and power of the Church in the political arena has declined markedly in the period since.

The referendum victory for the bishops looks like being very short-lived. This is the shared assessment of the forces active in the Anti-Amendment Campaign (AAC). Is this just an attempt to look for a 'silver lining"?

The best yardstick to use is to ask not 'what does the Amendment say?' , but 'what will it do in practice?'. It is supposed to stop abortions, but abortion is already illegal in Ireland under the 1861 Offences Against the Person Act, passed in the Westminister parliament when all of Ireland was still a British colony.

HAVE THE RIGHT WON A THOROUGHGOING VICTORY?

Two years ago, when the pro-amendment campaign started, ten Irish women a day were going to Britain for an abortion. Ten Irish women will have done the same on September 7, will be doing so today, and will go on doing so for the foreseeable future.

An 'anti-abortion' clause in the constitution only makes sense if Ireland's "invisible abortions' are stopped or curtailed. When the pro-amendment campaign started they put forward a particularly vicious motivation for their aim: a constitutional change would allow any citizen to act on behalf of the 'defenceless' foetus, and thus serve a High Court injunction on any woman suspected of planning an abortion in Britain.

The implications would be horrific -pregnancy testing at air and sea ports, imprisonment of pregnant women, and so on. Most people in Ireland are opposed to abortion, but they would not endorse this sort of reactionary rubbish.

The pro-amendment forces then gradually retreated on this argument. In the end they argued that the amendment would merely stop any change in the existing law and medical practice...if this was true, the whole exercise was pointless.

Of course this is not its sole purpose. The amendment will encourage rightists who wish to close down clinics that refer women to Britain for abortions. Preparing to meet such attacks is now a priority task for those who mobilised against the amendment.

But, on the other side of the debate, politicians have been scared by their alliance with the far right. As the referendum results came in, one hypocritical 'anti-abortion' TD (member of parliament) after another declared that he (it was usually he) thought the restrictions on contraception should be eased, the question of divorce looked at, laws on illegitimacy reformed and so on. The strength of the anti-amendment campaign forced them to make these moves -according to the opinion polls there is now a 2:1 majority in favour of abolishing the constitutional ban on divorce. Two years ago it was 1:1. There may even be a referendum on divorce at the time of the EEC elections in June 1984.

THE POLITICAL PARTIES AND THE REFERENDUM

The main governmental party, Fine Gael, was opposed to the wording of the amendment, although it was in favour of introducing an amendment on this question into the constitution. The party leader and Taoiseach (prime minister) Garret Fitzgerald, called for a 'no' vote. But his party was crippled with internal divisions - serious enough to badly damage its ability to stay in office for a full term.

If this government falls, the ruling class will face major problems. There were three general elections within the eighteen months from June 1981 to November 1982 in order to try and achieve a stable government. An early collapse of the present Fine Gael/ Labour coalition would reopen a crisis of governmental instability at a time when the bourgeoisie needs strong and brutal policies.

The major opposition party, Fianna Fail, hopes to benefit from this crisis. In accordance with their history as the traditional nationalist bourgeois party they remained monolithically united in support of a 'yes' vote. But, true to their opportunist form, they were the first to make noises about changing the laws on divorce and contraception.

The Labour Party, like Fine Gael, split badly over the referendum. They will lose support on both right and left after this result, and are already losing support because of their participation in this viciously anti-working class government.

The main gainers in this situation are likely to be the extreme anti-Republican Workers Party, who took a clear, and very opportunist stand against the amendment on the grounds of opposition to making the constitution 'sectarian' towards Protestants. On the other hand, they refused to affiliate to the AAC and joined the anti-abortion bandwagon for electoral reasons.

REPUBLICANS LET WOMEN DOWN

Sinn Fein, the main anti-imperialist party, were not involved officially in the campaign at all. Their position was of opposition to the amendment, but not

to support the vote 'no' campaign, as they do not recognise the Southern constitution and therefore would not vote at all.

Neither individual Sinn Fein participation in the campaign, nor the presence of all the smaller anti-imperialist parties in the AAC, could offset the damage this did to the anti-imperialist and nationalist movement in the eyes of those who look to it to bring answers to social, political and economic questions. Fianna Fail's support for the 'yes' campaign was accompanied with the usual hypocritical "republican' rhetoric. So, in the end, the effect was that the idea that Republicanism equals Catholicism was strengthened, and an unwise emphasis given to the 'anti-Protestant' nature of the amendment by the liberal anti-Republican AAC leadership.

A clear lesson has to be learnt for the future — Republican socialism will mean nothing unless there is active support to all the struggles of the oppressed in Ireland. No other method will advance the cause of Irish unity. Women want answers now about their rights - they will not be convinced by promises of what will happen after British control of Ireland is ended. The divorce referendum is coming soon. This will test whether or not this lesson has been learned.

WHAT NEXT?

Overall, the result was a considerable achievement for the anti-amendment forces, representing tens of thousands of Irish voters who rejected a sectarian approach to the Southern constitution.

The size of the 'no' vote certainly means that the issue has not been decided for all time, and to that extent also represents something of a set back for the far-right supporters of the pro-amendment campaign, who wanted a derisory 'no' vote. The question of abortion and a woman's right to choose will be more and more discussed in post-referendum Ireland.

From this point of view, along with the proposal to hold a conference for anti-amendment activists to discuss how to prepare for future defence campaigns - against attacks on family planning clinics, individual women, etc. — the proposal for an international tribunal is important.

Such a tribunal, to investigate the crimes against Irish women as regards their right to control their own fertility, would allow Irish women to build links with the broad international women's movement which has had to face these sorts of attacks in many countries. It would also be an ideal forum to open up the debate on the right to choose by drawing out the links between the right of contraception and the right to abortion.

← No Justification for French Troops in Chad · Ireland: What Next After the Elections — Debate →

Something wrong on this page?