Ireland: After the elections what next? On Wednesday August 17, a public debate took place in Belfast between John Mc Anulty, member of Belfast City Council and of People's Democracy, Irish section of the Fourth International, and Danny Morrison, elected member of the Northern Ireland Assembly, and of Sinn Fein.
The theme of the debate, 'After the Elections - What Next?' posed an important question for the anti-imperialist movement in Ireland, coming after the gains made by Sinn Fein in the recent election. The interest it aroused was demonstrated by the very large attendance at the meeting, organised by the James Connolly Society which exists to promote open discussion between republicans and socialists.
We reprint here the texts of the speeches made by the main contributors. These were first published in Socialist Republic, tember issue. John MCANULTY
The victories of Sinn Fein in the Assembly elections and more recently in the Westminster elections have an importance beyond the undoubted immediate gain for Sinn Fein as an organisation.
It shows that after 15 years of punishing oppression and brutality the nationalist population in the North are still undefeated, still willing to struggle on, still willing to register resistance to British rule. The importance of this should not be underestimated. Sinn Fein won similar victories in the 1950s but in a time of calm and when traditional nationalism had stood aside in despair. These victories now, after a long and bitter struggle, and in the teeth of opposition from the SDLP, the Southern politicians and the Catholic church. The support gained is a real barrier to British plans.
Already, the gains from the election have reversed a British strategy of many years standing to present the IRA as isolated criminals and their own repression as simply a 'police action' . The votes for Sinn Fein have made nonsense of this explanation.
John McAnulty (DR)
paper of People's Democracy, in its Sep-
This vote, plus the bloody trauma of the H Block struggle, has convinced sections of the [British] Labour Party left and progressive forces in America and elsewhere that Britain has no solution to offer here and a whole new layer of solidarity has been created.
The key point here is that any solidarity internationally ultimately depends on mass struggle here. But despite the election successes, the mass struggle on the streets and in the factories is at a low ebb. The fact is that while we face new opportunities, we also face many new problems.
After the high point of struggle here the nationalist masses were filled with enthusiasm and confidence and successive British and Unionist opponents struggled from expedient to expedient without any clear strategy. Now we face an extreme right-wing British government which understands that no real conciliation or cosmetic reform is possible. One aspeet of this is their decision to continue the Assembly in the face of a total nationalist boycott. The hysteria in republican circles at the time of the Assembly's formation has been followed by a dangerous apathy. We should not forget that as long as the Assembly exists it acts to stake a British claim that any future solution will be a partition solution. Neither should we forget that it was through the Assembly that the Unionists lobbied for the 'Shoot to kill' policy that nationalists are suffering from today.
In response to this the Southern parties and the SDLP have offered their 'Council for a New Ireland'. This is a real threat to the anti-imperialist movement. Irish capitalism sees the vote for Sinn Fein as a threat to itself. Before, it could, from time to time, indulge in nationalist rhetoric in order to obtain some leverage over British strategy. In this crisis they need to crush the anti-imperialist sentiment of Irish workers to survive. The only direction that the forum can move in is towards further repression internally and more collaboration with Britain. The
21
role of the Southern parties in the attack bate. They win sections of the working on women's rights enshrined in the pro- class to their program and in voting for posed amendment to the constitution this program workers take a first step. shows this clearly. It is up to revolutionaries to present them
Finally, one of the most basic new with the next step of uniting in mass elements we face is the economic crisis of struggle against capitalism and imperialimperialism. The early period of this ism. struggle was fuelled by an economic It is the job of revolutionaries to preboom which brought a new confidence to pare and organise and unify the struggle Irish workers, especially in the North. to pose the question of power. That is Now we face recession, cuts, and mass why we need a revolutionary party and unemployment. Not unreasonably the that is what Peoples Democracy is fightanti-imperialist movement is expected to ing to build. answer these questions. There are many problems to be re-
Posing these questions helps us to solved. But there are also many opporbegin the process of finding answers. In tunities. The main point is that we do the North today there are many localised not have to resolve all these problems fightbacks: against informers, against now. plastic bullets, against the "Shoot to kill' Many will resolve themselves in action. policy, and also fightbacks on unemploy- What we do need to do is to unite toment, cuts and housing. It is our job to gether to build united action. Gerry unify these and bring them together in Adams' recent speech advocating passive one mass struggle which should have as resistance to the British occupation is a its focus opposition to the Assembly. welcome move in this direction.
Such a movement could extend itself should not delay but come together now through all 32 counties by opposing the to build a movement of the working class fake solutions posed by the 'Council for a that can throw out the imperialists and New Ireland' and challenging not only their capitalist collaborators and put forBritish imperialism but the collaboration ward the real solution to the crisis of imof Irish capitalism. perialism — an Irish Workers' Republic!
Above all we need the strength of the working class, especially in the 26 coun ties. For years, the Workers Party has burrowed away in the labour bureaucracy and it has paid off in increased support for them. We need to challenge them but not by copying them. The H Block-Armagh movement showed that it is possible to approach workers from outside the labour movement and win support. And we can learn from our mistakes then by also working seriously and consistently in the labour movement. Here a great challenge faces the Republican Movement. It has shown a new openness, a new enthusiasm and a new level of organisation in relation to the working class. But it has yet to put forward new policies to deal with the economic crisis and this is an essential element in building a real movement of the working class.
Apart from these strategic difficul ties, there is a more general political problem facing the anti-imperialist movement. The decision to stand in elections was pre-dated by a long discussion around the old argument: If elections could achieve Danny MORRISON anything, they would make them illegal.'
Sinn Fein's victories have settled this The first thing before we can discuss to some extent without clarifying the role the way forward is to take into account of elections in the revolutionary pro- not only recent events and developments, cess. We in Peoples Democracy believe not only revolutionary strategy, but the that revolutions are made by the mass of tradition of nationalist resistance in the the people rather than by individual North. Since partition left the people of groups no matter how large or well organ- the North isolated and condemned, ised. People must free themselves. They through the civil rights struggle and the cannot be freed by an external agency. process of armed struggle, the nationalist
The sort of debate that the Connolly people of the North have come back time Society is holding tonight is of great value and time again and have borne every cross to the activists who attend but it doesn't forced upon them. reach the mass of working people. They It is extremely important to underlearn from their own experience and their stand that out of that nationalist tradiown actions. It is here that elections are tion there was always a Republican Moveimportant. Through elections, revolu- ment which had potential - revolutiontionaries win a platform in political de- ary potential - to be radical and which 22 was of the people. From the struggle -from civil rights through armed struggle, through the heroic sacrifice of ten young men, and if need had been women in Armagh gaol, on hunger strike throughout 1981, what they represented was genuine determination and grit of a people determined to be free. And we have to appreciate that, we have to look at why that exists, we have to examine why that doesn't largely exist in the twenty-six counties and what has contributed to that development, what is behind partition, what is behind the driving force of the Irish revolution, which I believe is the Republican Movement.
Sinn Fein's election involvement didn't come about by accident. The ability of the movement in 1981 to ensure that Bobby Sands was elected didn't come about by accident either. There were a number of people in the Republican Movement who for a number of years believed that areas like Fermanagh, South Tyrone, Mid Ulster, areas like West Belfast had potential for inflicting poll defeats against nationalist collaborators and in creating a republican veto over British attempts and SDLP attempts to sell down the stream the war and struggle.
You have to be very wary of what potential the elections have unleashed. For example, as John McAnulty said, if voting could have got one anywhere, the British, and in fact all the colonial powers, would have banned it years ago. All we're managing to do is exploit certain weaknesses in the nature of British colonial rule in the North of Ireland - that is all we're managing to do.
But this electoral intervention has its weaknesses, it has its strengths. Its weaknesses are pitfalls which no revolutionary organisation or revolutionary should allow himself or herself to fall into. There is a danger and it has been warned against, of falling into clientelism with regards to the constituency advice centres which have absolutely no use unless we are to realise the consciousness of the people.
The positive developments of the recent mandate given to Sinn Fein have obviously been seen, in overturning British propaganda on Ireland which has stated that the popular Republican strug gle had no support. That's how they were able to introduce criminalisation, build the H-Blocks and stick young men and women away and weaken the strug gle. We were able to overturn that by our political successes. We were able to show in America, in Europe, Australia and elsewhere that the nationalist people of the North remain undefeated, that the nationalist people of the North despite what they had gone through, were in fact certain where they were going. Remember the conditions against which Sinn Fein gained its first 65,000 votes and then the 100,000 plus votes.
What we were fighting, and indeed when the IRA announced the strategy of the long war, what we were saying was this; the British are not going to be got out of Ireland constitutionally. The Brit-
ish are going to have to be fought on a number of separate fronts. It was going to take a considerable amount of time to remove the British presence from Ireland and during the course of that revolution (because that's what it's going to be) will be the flourishing of certain ideas with regard to the liberation of every single man, woman and child with regards to attitudes in the home, our attitudes towards gay people, our attitudes towards how economics is generated, how people live, how property should be redistribued. And that is, in fact, what we hope to gain at the end of the day - complete and absolute control of our lives and to be able to determine what we do with our lives.
Our struggle is very certainly unique with regards to the liberation struggles in other countries throughout the world and, in particular, in other third world countries. For example, the struggle here is being fought against a background of mass media disinformation and information. No other struggle took place against such a background, no other successful struggle, and in fact it is true to say that whenever we fight with an Armalite in one hand and a ballot paper in the other it's an experiment, an historic experi ment. Whenever the Yanks were fighting in Vietnam and whenever the Vietcong were fighting against them and indeed in Namibia, in Angola, in Mozambique, none of those soldiers were faced with the exact repereussions of their actions against the enemy. But every time a shot is fired in the North of Ireland, or a landmine is exploded, and there are fatalities or casualities, the media draws through the mill the exact effect of that operation on the total community here.
I think the nationalist people of the North have to be congratulated, and certainly the Republican Movement has to be clapped on the back, considering what it has withstood over the last 14 years. The struggle is going to be a long struggle, the political successes are only going to reap certain benefits to the struggle. They have shown there is popular support, they have overturned British propaganda. Now what we hope to do, and indeed this is where the problem arises, because problems always arise from success, the problems which we face North, South and in Britain and internationally, have to be analysed, have to be examined and we have to come up with strategies which dovetail on certain fronts.
The Republican Movement has developed as a result of certain divisions in Ireland and certain attitudes. The electoral successes in the North, and indeed if we are to develop these in the South where people largely consider the institutions of the state as legitimate, presents us with major difficulties and I honestly don't know how we are going to overcome them.
People who are not particularly tied to our tradition can put forward certain strategies which are difficult for the Republican Movement to overcome, be-
Bma Ed a dis i dia cause unfortunately whenever Britain divided Ireland, in 1920 with the Government of Ireland Act, and whenever she enforced that, in 1921, actual recognition of Free State institutions, and not just the Oath of Allegiance with De Valera was later to ditch, but the actual institutions of the state led to a major problem, led to a split and led to the Civil War. Indeed, down the decades one has often been considered as a traitor if one ever entered into institutions which other men and women had died opposing. The Republican split in 1969 enforced that division and it presents major problems to us. For example, if Sinn Fein, in order to develop the popular struggle in the North, in order to link in with and properly represent working-class interests, advocate entry into Leinster House, it would still present major problems and possibly insuperable problems and potentially split problems.
So we have many, many problems to face. Also I would personally be afraid that we would attract to our movement people who are really interested in political careers. At the present point in time, given the abstentionist policy of the Republican Movement and the fact that, at least internally, anyone who stands for election has to declare an oath of allegiance to the Republican Movement, republican philosophy, and ideology. 1 would be afraid that we would attract to our movement people who would be interested in getting into debating chambers, into parliament for their own ends and for their sectional ends and not for the ends of the people. We are going to have to remember this point whenever we discuss the way forward. Secondly, inside the North, I believe that the nationalist community is basically sound
We've had many crosses to bear, from the time of internment and from the HBlocks which replaced internment.
The H-Blocks and Armagh gaol were filled with young men and women on the basis of signed, forced incriminating statements made by these people under spells of 7 days in Castlereagh, Gough barracks and Strand road. Whenever the Brits found that that had been blown wide open, they then moved from there to the present strategy of using hired perjurers. Now we're going to have to mount a street campaign against that which will also have its limitations because the British appreciate absolutely the value of this strategy.
It has the potential of rending the nationalist community apart, it certainly creats distrust and of course a major by-product of it is that Republican activists, along with ordinary people, are going to go to gaol for long periods of time. We are going to have to determine strategies and tactics to fight all these problems. The electoral victories give us the opportunity to link in with people in Britain who sympathise with national unity. But to this day, no organisation, along with ourselves let me modestly add, has produced or finalised a strategy for British withdrawal. We come up with statements like 'Disarm the RUC or UDR!' or with statements like Immediate, total British withdrawal!' and yet the various scenar•ios are going to present us with major problems. The Republican Movement is fighting a long struggle and it is prepared to develop its strategy as it goes along.
I believe that we totally and absolutely need unity but I also think that comrades in other organisations have to bear respect for the traditions of the Republican Movement.
23