International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Britain's New Attempt to Stabilise Partition — Interview with John McAnulty

International Viewpoint No. 28, 18 April 1983 · pp 12-14 · 2,757 words

Britain and Ireland National liberation

The Northern Ireland Assembly

- Britains new attempt to stabilise partition The continuous struggle of British imperialism to impose its domination in Ireland has met equally continuous and determined resistance. The hunger strikes in the H Blocks of Long Kesh prison in the North of Ireland aroused tremendous interest and support throughout the world, and impulsed the largest mass movement in Ireland itself since the War of Independence.

But, since the relative defeat suffered in that struggle British imperialism has been able to introduce a new plan - setting up an Assembly in the North to try and co-opt a section of the nationalist population into running the affairs of the Six Counties, and to reassert the dominance of the pro-British Loyalist Protestant population (see IV No 13, 20 September 1982).

At the time of the recent conference of People's Democracy (PD - Irish section of the Fourth International) in Dublin, Penny Duggan spoke to John McAnulty, PD member elected to Belfast City Council on May 1981, about the present situation, and the perspectives of PD today.

Within the general orientation outlined by comrade McAnulty the organisation will continue its activity in the campaign against the anti-abortion amendment to the Constitution (see IV No 25, 7 March 1983), build solidarity with workers struggles against austerity, take steps to consolidate its system of press and propaganda around the monthly newspaper Socialist Republic, pamphlets, and regular public meetings, while maintaining and extending its active role in the trade unions squabbles among the Unionists themselves?

A. I think that there is a great deal of fear of the Assembly within the nationalist population. It has had some immediate effects - the first demand was for a 'shoot to kill' policy. And the British responded by instituting a 'shoot to kill' policy against Republican activists.

Also, in the long term, the Assembly represents a solution to the Northern problem which involves no real concessions to any section of the nationalist population. This obviously has repercussions within that population.

I think that the reason that this hasn't been reflected in street demonstrations is twofold. First of all, it's not possible to simply be against the Assembly without having an alternative. So, the question of programme is raised as an immediate issue for the whole of the working class. The question of leadership is raised. And really the only alternative to the Assembly, the only alternative to the continued partition of Ireland, is a workers republic. Which is maybe expressed in a transitional way through demands for a constituent assembly, etc. But that isn't an immediate issue, and it's one that the traditional organisations, both anti-imperialist and working-class, haven't yet come to terms with.

The second factor is related to the first. The recession, the austerity offen- first. The recession. the austeritv offensive, is really beginning to hit. People find themselves swamped by the immediate demands of day-to-day existence, and the Republican leadership haven't really been able to draw the connection between that crisis and the political crisis of imperialist rule.

In that sense also people are looking for an answer. It is the convergence of those things that constitutes the crisis both for the imperialists, and to a certain extent for the anti-imperialist movement. Can they provide the leadership necessary?

Q. On the question of programme. Under the impact of the mass struggle, and the influence of PD and Bernadette, we've seen at least a section of the Republican movement develop politically, on questions such as the need for unity of the anti-imperialist movement, using the platform provided by elections, etc. Can you tell us what you think about that, and how significant it is?

A. Well, I think in an historical sense it is very significant. Traditionally the Republican movement has been a petty bourgeois nationalist movement. It remains so, but it is a movement that is coming under increasing pressure from its largely working-class membership.

In the short term the question is not how far the Republican movement has moved from traditional positions, from the old position of the dominance of mil. itary struggle to the question of mass action, class actions, et. It is how do the Republicans measure up to the demands of the class struggle today? And the answer to that is the Republican •.

and anti-imperialist struggle, which will the proposed Council of Ireland.

Question. The Assembly elections were the last major political event in the Six Counties. What was the impact of these elections, particularly in the context of the decline of the mass movement following the defeat of the H Block hunger strike?

Answer. Well, you've got to put the elections in the context of British strategy over the last fifteen years. This strategy has been reasonably consistent - to restabilise the partition of Ireland, and thus ensure British imperialism's control over the Irish working class. The failure of the hunger strike presented them with an opportunity to move forward. The establishment of the Assembly marked the way in which they attempted to continue this strategy.

The collapse of the mass movement, the absence of mass struggle in the streets, meant that in a physical sense they were able to do that rather easily. But in a political sense the hunger strike had rather deeprooted repercussions.

The most immediate, and also the most significant and long term of those, was the rallying of support around the Sinn Fein candidates in the elections. This has had two effects, rather it has had three effects. The first is blocking the advances toward the establishment of a new Stormont in the North. Secondly, it has a long term effect in the sense that it destroys the whole ideological basis of British intervention in Ireland → that the Republican movement is a small group of terrorists. The elections established plain focus on opposition to the Assembly and ly the mass support for Republicanism, for an end to British rule in Ireland, and the international dimension of the Irish situation — exposing it as a colonial struggle which must be resolved.

Thirdly, the effects of the hunger strike went well beyond the traditional Republican milieu. So, one of the outcomes of the elections was that it was made totally impossible for the Social Democratic and Labour Party (SDLPbourgeois nationalist party) to take their seats and participate in this farce. And even the most pro-imperialist sections of the Southern bourgeoisie had to realise participation in the re-establishment of this sort of Assembly was impossible.

There's one other thing that has become clear since the elections. That's the question of the autonomy of the Loyalist section of the working class. It's clear that the Assembly is part of British strategy, and not initiated by any struggle by the Loyalists. It is also quite clear that the Loyalist bourgeoisie no longer has the coherence and the strength to transform this Assembly into the old reactionary and authoritarian strong-state Stormont.

Q. But since the Assembly elections we haven't seen the mass movement on the streets in the North at all. So what do you think this means they feel about the Assembly? Do they see it as a threat, an attempt to re-establish Stormont? Or does it seem meaningless, dominated by

movement has not been able to meet that challenge so far. So, we have not seen in their turn to electoral politics an immediate translation of that into a mass struggle policy, but rather a tendency toward pure electoralism. Using elections in somewhat the same way that the bourgeoisie uses them.

I'm hopeful of further development in Republicanism, but I think that revolutionary Marxists must be clear about the mechanism of how that will happen. The mechanism is the pressure from the working class on the Republican leadership, and not necessarily a conscious understanding by the Republican leadership of the tasks posed by the Irish revolution.

Q. Obviously the process of the Irish revolution cannot be separated from what is going on in British politics.

One of the most important features of British politics today is the development of a left current within the Labour Party. One of the leading spokespersons of that left, Ken Livingstone, Labour leader of the Greater London Council, has taken a very strong stand on his support for the struggle of the Irish people. He recently came to Belfast to meet leaders of Sinn Fein.

What was the reaction of the nationalist population to his visit? Was it welcomed, seen as positive? Do you think this is going to be an important element in the development of the interconnection between the British and Irish revolutions - such a link between the nationalist movement and the Labour left in Britain?

A. I think that Livingstone's visit was admirable, especially given the hysterical reaction of the British media, which was echoed by the traditional Labour bureaucracy.

I think it had two consequences. The first, here in Ireland, is that the Republicans realised that there really is a solidarity in the British working class that can be reached. This will help to turn traditional Republicans away from a bombing campaign in Britain, which achieves nothing, to political action, which can have positive effects, and help develop the political struggle in Ireland, and aid the turn toward the working class.

Secondly, if Ken Livingstone had been acting as an individual that would have been admirable enough. But the truth is he represents a significant movement within the British Labour Party. It's a movement that is starting to draw lines in the class struggle in Britain itself, and beginning to realise that the Irish question has a real and central signif-

Everyday British presence on the streets (DR) icance.

I think that Livingstone's situation is that he is realising that not in a defensive way — that the left need to protect themselves from the right - but in a relatively offensive way. He realises the need to develop not just an alternative economic programme for British workers, but an alternative political programme which is an anti-imperialist programme.

I'd just like to add that I recently attended a conference on plastic bullets in Manchester which I thought was rather significant. I think that during the hunger strike the British left found themselves in rather an invidious position.

In the past they'd taken rather abstract positions, rather than addressing themselves to the immediate needs of the Irish struggle, which is really the motorforce for building solidarity. I think that the lessons of this are starting to sink home.

What I found in Manchester was a current that had based itself centrally in the debate in the Labour Party, and has significant trade-union support. Now, how far that movement develops depends to a certain extent on the development of the British class struggle.

It also depends to some extent on ourselves and the development of the Irish movement, because obviously no British movement can hope to succeed unless Irish workers are making clear what their demands are.

Q. As a local councillor you must be very aware of the day-to-day effects of the economic crisis on the nationalist population in the Six Counties. What possibilities do you see for struggle either on questions like jobs, or on more social questions like housing, social security benefits, etc? What relationship will this have to the national struggle -will it give it an impetus, or will the two struggles run parallel?

A. Well, I think that the question has different implications in the North and South. What we find in Ireland today is that there is a fightback against the austerity offensive. The chief characteristic of this fightback is that it is fragmented and sectoralist, especially in the North. The reason for that is that every struggle in Ireland for democratic rights, for the rights of workers against austerity, etc., runs up against the question of partition and of imperialist domination of the country's economy. I think that the solution to that is more immediate in the South. Take for example the recent struggle of the workers in the Ranks flour mills in the South. Although the bureaucracy concentrated the struggle around the immediate situation of the workers the redundancies arose directly from imperialist intervention, the dumping of flour on the Irish market.

In the North the questions come up against a sectarian barrier which is rather harder to break down. I think that that barrier can be broken down. But that depends to a very large extent on the ability of Southern workers to formulate a programme and build a united movement which can offer an immediate alternative to Protestant workers in the North.

Now, I think that in the short term what we're trying to do in the North is to build an anti-imperialist current. It may seem rather more attractive right away to issue a call for 'workers unity' in a very general sense, but in fact that doesn't answer the programmatic questions. We have to address those workers in struggle who have a real political consciousness of what the demands of the struggle are.

Q. You said earlier that the H Block hunger strike had really internationalised the Irish struggle and that wide support had been gained internationally. What do you think this illustrates about the importance of the Irish revolution at an international level, and, coming out of that, what do you think are the tasks for the Irish solidarity movement internationally?

A. Well, if I can answer that in reyerse order. For the solidarity movement what I think comes to the forefront now is the realisation that the hunger strike represented a struggle between the Irish people and British imperialism.

So, it's now necessary for those activists. concerned, with the Irish ques-

13

tion to move to the root of the problem and demand British withdrawal from Ireland. I think that recent developments such as the controversy over the St Patrick's Day March in New York show that tide of awareness within the proletariat worldwide. Other developments such as the EEC decision to report on the North, against the opposition of Britain, represent the divisions among the bourgeoisie internationally about the solution to this question and Britain's role here

But I think that for conscious revolutionaries the key question is to realise Ireland's strategic importance. It's a country dominated by imperialism. It is also a country that is on the edges of Europe and part of the EEC. So there isn't any solution here that is a partial one. The question resolves itself into the victory of imperialism or the victory of the workers. The victory of imperialism would have consequences world wide. To mention just one, the entry of the 26 counties into NATO and the establishment of Ireland as an armed beach head in the deployment of Cruise missiles and in the war drive of imperialism.

A defeat for imperialism would have the opposite effect. In the words of both Lenin and James Connolly - it would provide a spark for fuelling the European revolution. So, the national question in Ireland isn't some sort of optional question, it's a strategic question in world revolutionary politics. It's not something that exists on the sidelines. It's something that demands action now.

Q. So, just to end can you tell us what People's Democracy will be doing in the next while?

A. I should say at this point that PD has been going through a difficult period since the ending of the hunger strike. This was partly due to an overestimation of the possibilities of the situation, also to the failure of our organisation to realise the full meaning of the programme of Trotskyism in Ireland.

We've recently had our annual conference and that's meant a new turn for the organisation. This turn is in the direction of developing our programme, building our organisation, and making a real turn to the Irish working class. I think that to understand this, in general terms, what you have to understand is the dynamic of the Irish revolution.

What you have is a politically conscious vanguard which organises traditionally around the Republican moment. Then you have a layer of workers in struggle that traditionally organises through the trade-union movement. The sectoralist way in which both these structures organise means that neither by themselves can lead to victory. What People's Democracy represents is a politically conscious movement organised around a Marxist programme. What we're trying to do now is strengthen that political consciousness in order to make the fusion of all three traditions a reality. 14

← Bolivian Miners Demand Workers Management — Interview with Felipe Vasquez · French Carworkers Strikes — A Blow Against Mitterrand's Austerity — Interview →

Something wrong on this page?