Bolivian miners demand workers management of industry Interview with a Fourth Internationalist miners leader On October 31, 1982, the new Bolivian president, Siles Suazo, announced that his government would institute comanagement in the administration of the state-owned mines.
The date chosen for the announcement was a symbolic one. It was the thirtieth anniversary of the nationalization of the mines by the government that emerged from the revolution of 1952.
The party that held the government at the time, and the mantle of the revolution, was the Movimiento Nacionalista Revolucionaria (MR — Revolutionary Nationalist Movement). This party has since moved clearly to the right and split into three successor groups.
The most right-wing, the MNR-Historico, which cooperated with the Banzer dictatorship, is headed by Paz Estenssoro, who presided over the nationalizations.
The MNR-I (Left MNR) is headed by the present president, Siles Suazo. And the Revolutionary Party of the Nationalist Left is led by Juan Lechin, the chairman of the Bolivian Labor Confederation, the COB.
A few days after Siles Suazo's announcement of the comanagement project, Juan Lechin rejected it, saying that it was nothing more than a "copy of the West German model, aimed at setting up labor-management boards in the state enterprises." (Le Monde, November 11, 1982.)
In this way, a debate started up on the comanagement proposals put forward by the government of the Union Democratica Popular (People's Democratic Union, a coalition including the MNR-1, the CP, and the MIR). The plans call for boards including an equal number of representatives of the unions and the government.
This scheme for administering the state-owned enterprises, which represent about 80% of the key industrial installations in the country, has the backing of the Bolivian Communist Party. The CP dominates the COB and serves as the transmission belt between the government and the unions.
The comanagement plan has also won the approval of other pro-Moscow CPs. For example, it was hailed in the March 3 issue of the French CP's theoretical journal, Cahiers du communisme, which noted:
"A commission has been charged with drawing up plans for comanagement in the productive public enterprises, and henceforth the two most important, COMIBOL (the mines) and the YPFB (petroleum) will be run by boards made up of three government representatives and three elected representatives of the workers."
The Bolivian section of the Fourth International, the Partido Obero Revolucionario-Combate (POR-Combate, Revolutionary Workers Party) opposes the comanagement scheme. Along with other revolutionary currents, it is calling for a majority for labor in the labormanagement boards. This alternative is also supported by the leaders of the miners union, the FSTMB, which belongs to the COB.
The arguments for a workers majority in the comanagement boards are explained, among other things, in the following interview with Felipe Vasquez, a member of the Executive Committee of the FSTMB and of the POR-Combate. The interview was given to Carlos Illades in the Huanuni mining area in February.
tions, the size of families, prices, and so forth.
After this study, we reached the conclusion that in May-June 1982, the minimum living wage for a family of six was 11,330 pesos a month (about 500 US dollars). Our study was unprecedented in Bolivia. Previously, everybody limited themselves to making calculations on the basis of increases in the cost of living. accepted by he goers dent, nd it not If the miners' demand is not the FSTMB do?
A. For the moment, the government has not rejected our demand. But, unless we get a favorable response after the end of the hundred-day "social truce" the government has asked for, that is, after mid-February, we will start to mobilize.
As I have said, a minimum living wage with automatic cost-of-living increases is a demand that we cannot give up.
Q. What is the position of the FSTMB on the "comanagement" in the state enterprises that the UDP government is talking about?
A. Since 1970 we have been discussing the question of workers participating in the management of the public enterprises. This was a way of challenging the government bureaucracy's control of these enterprises.
At the same time, it was necessary to mount a counter-attack against sections of the bourgeoisie that wanted - and still do want - to denationalize the key sectors of the economy. We had to point out how the workers could run the economy on a different basis.
It was also necessary to make it clear that the reason the state-owned enterprises went into the red and have stayed there was the bureaucratic management imposed by the bourgeoisie.
For a whole period "comanagement" as the workers understood it had a progressive character, since it represented a vigorous struggle against reactionary governments that were trying to reprivatize the strategic sectors of the economy.
When we talked about "comanagement" in 1970, in reality we were fighting for a workers majority in the administration. Likewise now, we don't want the whole thing to be reduced - as the present government does - to mere technical administration.
We want the workers to have a direct influence over the use of resources, in determining a planned allocation of resources, in the sale of products, etc.
Q. What are the different positions on the question of comanagement within your union?
A. There are three general points of view.
Some support the government's position, that is, for parity between government and union representatives in the administration of the enterprises. The involvement of workers representatives in
Question. What is the basis for the demand that the miners have presented to the government for a minimum wage with a cost-of-living increase?
A. To go back into history a bit, we can say that since 1942 the miners have been the standard-bearers of the demand for a living minimum wage.
For several decades, this has been the demand that the workers have been most interested in. But it was simply ignored both by the MR governments under Paz Estenssoro and the military regimes that followed.
Since November 1981, the Huanuni 10 miners have maintained that the demand for a living minimum wage is inseparable from the demand for a sliding scale of wages. This was the only consistent answer for the workers facing the crisis that has gripped the country.
Up till now, the miners union is the only organization that has made a serious study of the question of a living minimum wage and of the sliding scale needed to compensate for inflation.
We have taken into consideration the patterns of consumption among the working people, the nutritional needs that are linked to our geographic condi-
this scheme would amount to no more than a simple administrative role.
The workers representatives would not have the slightest power of decision with respect to financial matters. In other words, the government wants to involve workers representatives in the framework of relationships of capitalist exploitation.
Then, there is the position that is being put forward by the revolutionary organizations. It calls for a majority for the workers in the comanagement boards and the right of workers to a say in the financial dealings of the enterprises, in the sale of the products, and so forth.
In other words, we are calling for a change of orientation in the management of the enterprises in order to move toward workers self-management.
Finally there is a position based on ultraleftist notions. Those who hold it declare their total opposition to "co-management." They call for workers control, but have not defined very well what this would mean.
At present, the FSTMB is discussing this question in a national commission made up of representatives of the government and of the COB. But we miners have made it clear that this discussion should begin among the rank-and-file workers and not be channeled from above.
Q. Some people think that the participation of the workers in the administration of the nationalized enterprises could undermine the fight for a minimum living wage with automatic cost-of-living increases. This could happen, they argue, because the workers would be drawn into assuring the profitability of the enterprises. What do you think about that?
A. We miners think that we could get rid of the bureaucrats, if we reorganized the use of resources, and if we brought in new machines we could make the enterprises profitable.
In the case of those enterprises that bring in the least profit, we would seek ways of increasing production. But all of that requires a rectification of the government's policy toward the mining industry. It is necessary to work out a policy designed to bring about a substantial improvement in the living and working conditions of the miners.
For all these reasons, we think that there is no basis for the argument that workers "comanagement" would be an obstacle to winning a living minimum wage.
If the government does not accept the formula of "comanagement" with a workers majority, there are two possible alternatives.
We may decide not to participate in the "comanagement" bodies. Or within the framework of "comanagement," we may take up a vigorous fight on the trade-union level, with the active participation of comrades involved in "co-management."
Q. What do the miners think about what the UDP has been doing in the government?
A. We miners took the lead in the Bolivian people's fight for democratic rights. Our idea was that this would make it easier for us to organize and therefore to carry on our fight in more favorable conditions.
With the November 1981 strike at Huanuni, we won respect for the rights of labor. Then, we waged a struggle for political rights, and we made headway there, too.
At the time, on the basis of its program, the workers thought that the UDP would follow an anti-imperialist policy, introduce a living minimum wage with an automatic cost-of-living increase, and so forth.
Concrete experience has opened the workers' eyes about the UP government. A technocratic team has assumed the dominant role in the government and imposed a series of measures, such as those decreed in November (1), which dealt a severe blow to the workers' aspirations.
The government has not put defending the workers' interests first. We, for our part, have taken our distance from the government. It is an index of the workers' rejection of the UDP's policy that in the elections that have been held since November nongovernmental left slates have won.
Thus, despite the opposition of the Bolivian Communist Party, the miners have confirmed their class independence in several congresses.
Q. What has been the reaction of the workers to the departure of the Movement of the Revolutionary Left (MIR)
Bolivian miners underground (DR) from the government in January?
A. Not everybody had seen it the same way. Nonetheless, most workers agree on one point: The governmental crisis has been the reflection of the contradictions that run through the regime because of its composition. (2)
We workers are very concerned about the present situation. This is because it is the most reactionary sectors that have gained the most from the breakup of the government coalition.
The workers do not confuse bourgeois democracy with workers democracy. But they have a stake in the present democratic process and are demanding that it be deepened. This does not prevent us in the least from preparing to deal with an attempt to reestablish a dictatorship, which is clearly in the works.
Q. In your opinion, what are the immediate perspectives for the Bolivian workers movement?
A. I think that the decisive moments are approaching. In such a context, there will be an increase in workers' mobilizations, and there will be a tendency for the workers to radicalize.
In Bolivia, there have been a lot of attempts to impose bourgeois solutions, both civilian and military. All these schemes have failed. The only possible alternative for the workers is a workers government and socialism. 1. This refers to the austerity program instituted by the UP government shortly after coming into office. For the details, see IV, No 22, January 24, "The Bolivian Cauldron." by S. Romande. 2. The executive branch is run by a coalition of reformist parties (the UP) with different strategies, that of the MIR being particularly right wing. The legislature is dominated by the right.
11