International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Women's Rights and Belgian Unions

· International Viewpoint No. 6, 10 May 1982 · pp 6-8 · 2,518 words

Women's liberation Low Countries Trade unions Italy

The Struggle for Women's Rights and the Trade Union Movement

The largest International Women's Day demonstration in Europe took place in Belgium on March 6, 1982. It brought together women from the women's movement with wide layers of the trade union movement around a common set of demands. This marks an important new stage in the development of the struggle for women's rights and their eventual liberation we look to see carried forward elsewhere.

The effects of the economic crisis in Europe have fallen particularly heavily on women. The attempt by the bosses to make the working class pay with its jobs and living standards for the capitalist crisis has threatened to reverse the gains won by women over the last twelve years.

From the late 1960s a new wave of feminist radicalisation developed throughout the advanced capitalist countries which permeated every layer of society. Increasingly the demands and actions of this new women's movement became intertwined with those of the labour movement as feminist activists became militants of the trade unions and mass parties of the working class.

stage of feminist radicalisation among working women and stimulated far-reaching debates on tactics and strategy within the women's movement, particularly on the question of what alliances to forge in the struggle for women's rights.

Under the impact of the initiatives of the women's movement the labour movement was forced to adopt policies and then to take action for women's rights. Some notable successes were won at this level. For example, in 1979 the British TUC, in calling a demonstration against proposed anti-abortion legislation, became the first national trade union federation in the world to call a mass national demonstration in defence of women's rights.

The fightback of the workers movement against the austerity measures of the bosses has been forced to take up the specific defence of women's rights as workers. Increasingly it is becoming obvious that the workers movement cannot defend itself unless it defends the interests of all the most vulnerable groups within it.

These three articles look at how this process is developing class.

This process had important effects. by Ida DEQUEECKER bv Ida DEQUEECK ER

Twelve thousand women demonsstrated for International Women's Day on Saturday March 6 in Brussels. The demonstration was organised by the co-ordinating committee Women against the Crisis' . This group brings together groups from the autonomous women's liberation movement (socialist-feminist groups known as 'Fem-Soc' ', women's cafes, women's centres, battered women's refuges, etc.) with women's organisations from the two main trade-union federa• tions, the socialist General Workers Federation of Belgium (FGTB-ABVV) and the Christian Democrat trade-union federation (CSC-ACV). Also involved are the women's sections of the Socialist Parties, the LRT-RAL and JGS-SJW (Belgian section of the Fourth International and its youth organisation) and the Belgian Communist Party and the Workers Party which is Mao-Stalinist. In addition are the women's sections of the two trade-union mutual benefit societies.

The platform for the demonstration demanded the right to work, the right to unemployment benefit, the maintenance of buying power, and women's economic independence. It was openly opposed to the Liberal-Christian Democrat government's policy of cutting social spending; taking up such slogans as 'Keep the index' (the automatic linking of wages to the price index), 'No to discrim- wages to the price index, Down dith the ination against women' Martens government'.

The weight of the labour movement within the demonstration was striking compared with the previous year when the women's groups had been the dominant element. Thus, the demonstration was clearly within the framework of the workers mobilisation against the allbourgeois parties government that

It engendered a new

These three articles look at how this process is developing to a greater or lesser extent in Belgium, France, and Britain.

emerged from the elections of November 8, 1981.

The two demonstrations 'Women against the Crisis' for International Women's Day in 1981 and 1982 took place in the context of increasing opposition to the austerity policies of the government and the employers. These austerity policies have been significantly stepped up since Autumn 1981. They combine a general attack on wages and social security with measures that particularly effect more vulnerable social groups such as women, youth, and immigrants.

In autumn 1980 the Christian Democrat government wanted to impose a freeze on all wages. Two measures particularly affected women. One was a change in the rules of unemployment benefit to create a new category of 'cohabitants' (someone living with someone else who has a job). Such 'cohabitants' have a reduced right to unemployment benefit. Secondly, there was an adjustment in the procedures relating to longterm unemployed aimed at depriving them of their right to unemployment benefit. The majority of unemployed women are of course 'cohabitants'. And the majority of the long-term unemployed just happen to be women as well.

Today 78,151 women have been unemployed for more than three years, compared to 28,397 men. After the change in the rules regarding benefits for the long-term unemployed 9,000 women and 400 men were deprived of their unemployment benefits in 1981.

Only women put up any real resistance to these measures. The opposition of the workers movement to wage cuts (the FGTB organised a rally of 100,000 in Brussels on January 24, 1981) was ended by a cross- sectoral agreement in February 1981 in which the two main trades unions agreed to accept a partial wage freeze for two years.

The first Women against the Crisis' demonstration on March 7, 1981, mobilised 7,000 people. Even though it was the product of the struggle of the whole labour movement, it was unable to win any broader support for the specific demands of women. This was partially due to the fact that the Catholic trade-union federation, the CSC-ACV, did not participate because demands on abortion were included in the platform. But the underlying reason was that the reformist trade-union movement does not in practice take up women's demands, and the trade-union bureaucracy looks askance at autonomous women's mobilisations. The Social-Democratic leadership of the FTB fought to the last minute against the participation of the FGTB women's commissions in this demonstration. Their case was helped by the fact that the CSC did not participate.

The Liberal-Christian Democrat government, which came to power in November 1981, took 'special powers' to lower wages through attacking the automatic indexing of wages to prices and devaluing the Belgian franc. Another of its targets was social security. These measures hit women twice. There was a further reduction of unemployment benefit for 'cohabitants' , and social security was cut down on the basis of the composition and income of the household--which strongly resembles the introduction of a 'means-test' • In addition, they encouraged the extension of part-time work in both the public service and the private sector. The justification of these measures is that they are 'a policy that promotes family life'.

7

The governmental measures, combined with the attacks of the bosses against wages and jobs, met once more with resistance from the workers movement. However this resistance has been fragmentary, developing unevenly in Flanders and the Walloon country. This fragmentation is a product of the divisive policies of the Flemish Catholic labour federation, which is linked to the governmental Christian Democrat party. It has rejected common action with the FGTB.

It is characteristic of the trade-union struggle that the bureaucracy has only organised action to get into negotiations and it is ready to accept austerity alongside the government and bosses. But it has not offered any perspective to the workers struggles that have erupted since the beginning of 1981 and which have already involved conflicts with the line of the bureaucracy.

This division in the trade unions gives the government ample room to pursue its policies. Therefore unity in action remains a central question which is decisive for the outcome for all struggles and demands.

The Women against the Crisis' mobilisation this year reflected this complex character of the workers resistance to austerity. There is a growing radicalisation of women, and a desire to struggle. This led to the formation of a united front of women from the FGTB and CSC, which was completely supported by the national leaderships of the two unions. Indeed, the General Secretary of the FGTB-ABVV, Debunne, attended the demonstration. The declaration for the demonstration clearly stated that women's demands are an integral part of the workers struggles. But despite this women's struggles remain relatively isolated, partly due to the scattered patterns of social struggles.

Women's growing realisation of their situation is the product of a number of factors. The objective material base is the rise in the number of women in paid employment. In 1971, some 928,905 women worked, making up 31% of workforce. In 1979, despite the economic crisis, this number had risen to more than 1,004,720. Today women are 36% of the 8 workforce. More and more women base their expectations on getting jobs, being independent, and running their own lives.

This deep-seated conviction that women have a right to economic independence was shown notably by the fact that the women of the Christian Democrat union, the CSC, who are traditionally more influenced by the notion that 'women's place is in the home' , stated at the press conference for the ] March 6 demonstration: 'Women will no longer accept being pushed into a position of dependence on their husbands....Economic independence is a precondition for the equal treatment of women and men'

• In Belgium, as in all advanced capitalist countries, a new wave of radicalisation among women developed during the 1970s. This was part of the worldwide social crisis that opened up in 1968. This new autonomous women's movement developed outside the organised workers movement through women's centres, women's cafes, battered women's refuges, ete. But a socialist feminist current also developed, 'Fem-Soc' . Although today these groups lack perspectives they con-

AVORTEMENT HURS P PRESENT DE 1A 6.00H D' APPEL I° YOUR ZITTER YAN HET tinue to grow. But under the weight of the crisis they will stagnate without the support of women from the workers movement.

Nonetheless, it is the activities and initiatives of the women's movement, which often have a broad impact, that have allowed feminist ideas to permeate every level of society. For the last ten years a Women's Day has taken place in Belgium on November 11, which brings together women from all parties and unions.

The economic crisis has brought into sharp relief the contradiction between feminist objectives that the establishment claims to support (with laws like the law on equality of treatment at work), and the actual situation of women.

One of the first and most obvious consequences of the crisis is the rise in female unemployment. Of those totally unemployed on January 30, 1982, 255,992 were women and 173,461, men. The rate of unemployment for men has only just begun to rise faster than that for women. Today the total unemployed stands at 450,000. Women are much more likely to have their right to unemployment benefit removed. There are now five job vacancies for every 100 unemployed. From June 1980 to June 1981 the number of job vacancies went down by 80,000. There is no hiring, and even the Minister of Labour cannot pretend otherwise: 'One cannot be very optimistic about the creation of jobs in the classical sense. There will always be a greater demand for work than can be met. This is because, among other factors, women are increasingly presenting themselves in the labour market?

Thus, radicalisation is developing in a new layer of working and trade union women. They see their gains being attacked, and that the response of the trade unions is inadequate. In some instances, for example in the big shops, the unions even share responsibility for the discriminatory measures against women, like part-time work.

The trade-union bureaucracy, with the limited actions that they organise, do not offer even the shadow of a perspecAU COISE PENAL STRAFRECHT

KENEBIL BATBA I B00 1 м ти LAVAN tive for women. Yet the rate of unionisation for women is as high as that for men-around 80 per cent.

There exists therefore a layer of women throughout the unions who are ready to get involved in actions around their specific interests; a layer of young feminist women, women who have trade union posts. Within the FGTB, although the women's commissions have only a consultative role, they have grown in number; and every proposal to establish a new one is immediately successful. In the CSC-ACV it is the white-collar women, who have better structures for organising activity, who are radicalising first.

At present, this layer of women in the unions looks to forces outside the workers movement to take initiatives, in particular to the socialist feminist current "Fem-Soc' in which the revolutionary Marxists, the LRT-RAL (Belgian section of the Fourth International), are active. Moreover, it is this current who have initiated the unified actions of the last three years, which have been the culminating

The demand for abortion remains a major debale in Belgium (DR)

The demand for abortion remains a major debale in Belgium (DR)

WEN FEMIES V

TEGEN DE CONTRE LA

KRISIS CRISE

Belgian 'Women against the Crisis' demonstration (DR)

points of the women's struggle in Belgium. Two days before the March 6 demonstration this year the daily newspaper De Morgen quoted the spokeswoman of the FTB women's commission as saying: 'We have everything to gain from collaboration between the FGTB and the socialist feminist groups

UNITY DOES NOT FALL FROM THE SKY The impact of the dramatic sharpening of austerity policies, under the pressure of the deepening crisis, has created the conditions for these unified initiatives. One of the factors in their success has been that they seek to involve women from both the main trade unions. This has only happened as the result of a political battle in which the socialist feminist groups and the LRT-RAL have played a central role.

The This article was written by the Women's Secretariat of the Ligue Communist Revolutionnaire, French section of the Fourth International. It was first published in the LCR's monthly review, Critique Communiste. The translation is by IV.

The victory of the Socialist Party in France on May 10, 1981, came at a time when a number of questions were posed for organised women's groups. What would be their future, their forms of activity, their structure?

The term of the outgoing president, Giscard, who represented the bourgeois parties, had corresponded with the emer-

The original manifesto of Women against the Crisis' contained the demand for abortion to be decriminalised. This placed a barrier in the way of involving women from the Catholic trade unions, despite their willingness to become involved in these initiatives in action directed against government policy.

This lesson was learnt after the 1981 International Women's Day demonstration. The new manifesto no longer contains the demand on abortion. However, this entailed a long debate with the radical feminist current who did not want to 'sacrifice' a women's demand for the sake of unity, which they thought overemphasised the struggle against the effects of the economic crisis.

← Workers' Spring Begins in Poland · Women's Movement After Mitterrand →

Something wrong on this page?