International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Document: New Organisation of American Revolutionaries: Why Socialist Action Formed, What We Stand For

· International Viewpoint No. 46, 13 February 1984 · pp 23-25 · 2,955 words

United States Fourth International Soviet Union Stalinism

Why Socialist Action formed... Who we are, what we stand for We publish below major extracts from an article that appeared in the first issue of Socialist Action, a new monthly journal published in the United States, sponsored by an organization with the same name.

This organization was initiated by American Fourth Internationalists who were expelled from the Socialist Workers Party, the organization in solidarity with the Fourth International in the USA.

At its October 1983 meeting, the United Secretariat of the Fourth International decided to continue to regard them as in the framework of the Fourth International (to the extent this is compatible with American law) and urged the SWP to reverse its organizational course and immediately and collectively reintegrate the expelled comrades. Until this is done, the United Secretariat recognizes that the comrades expelled from the SWP because of their political views will have no choice but to organize collectively in order to, on the one hand participate in the discussion for the upcoming World Congress of the Fourth International and fight for their political views, and on the other to carry out their responsibilities as revolutionary class-struggle militants.

The headline and crossheads are from Socialist Action Vol 1, No 1, December 1983. Socialist Action can be obtained by writing , to the Socialist Action Publishing Association, 3435 Army Street, No. 308, 94110 San Francisco, California, USA. The subscription price for twelve issues is 6 dollars in North America, other countries.

Soci Ac

Every new political group is obligated to explain its origins and aims. This preview issue of our newspaper (we begin regular publication early next year) is to introduce ourselves to you, who we hope • Will become our regular readers. Socialist Action is a newspaper. It is also the name of a national organization founded at a conference in Chicago at the end of October 1983. It was initiated by a group of long-time socialists and activists in the antiwar, women's liberation and union movements who had been expelled from the Socialist Workers Party in the course of the last two years....

We have taken this step because the SWP is in the process of abandoning the including Mexico, and 20 dollars for Alist TION principles upon which it was founded. Denied the opportunity to reverse this course and forced outside the SWP, we in Socialist Action have no choice but to attempt, from the outside, to stop the degeneration of the SWP. We strive to be reintegrated into the SWP on the basis of the democratic rights traditionally guaranteed to party members. This includes our right to maintain our faction inside the SWP. In the meantime we continue to carry on the political and organizational work of the revolutionary party of socialist workers.

The movement that became the Socialist Workers Party was founded in 1928 by a small group of leaders of the Com-

23

munist Party, led by James P. Cannon, who chose to follow Trotsky in the fight with the Stalin bureaucracy. After their expulsion, they too formed a public faction of the CP, becoming a separate political party only after the CP had irretrievably moved from revolutionary positions. In the 1930s the new organization led a number of important battles of the US labor movement, most notably the teamster general strike in Minneapolis in 1934. It participated in building the CIO unions in the late 1930s and in the post-World War II labor strike wave. Eighteen leaders of the SWP and of the Teamsters Union in Minneapolis were railroaded to jail for a year at the beginning of World War II for their militant unionism and their socialist objections to placing confidence in the American ruling class's objectives in the war. Two of the four of those 18 who remained in the SWP were expelled in 1982, and one of them, Jake Cooper, is a member of the National Committee of Socialist Action.

In the 1950s the SWP, although reduced to a small isolated group by the anticommunist witch-hunt, put up an effective fight for civil liberties against the McCarthyite witch-hunters. best-known victory was a many-year national campaign by Jimmy Kutcher, a legless World War II veteran fired by the thought-controllers from his clerical job at the Veterans Administration for his socialist ideas. His campaign for reinstatement won the endorsement of unions numbering millions of members and was championed by such well-known civil libertarians as I. F. Stone. Kutcher succeeded in getting his job back and setting a precedent that saved the jobs of many others whose views the government disapproved of. This year Jimmy Kutcher fell vietim to a purge in his own party.

In the 1960s the SWP was one of the first organizations on the Left to campaign for the construction of a mass, nonexclusive coalition to oppose the US invasion of Vietnam. Its representatives became leaders of the National Mobilization Committee to End the War in Vietnam, and of its youth affiliate, the Student Mobilization Committee. These committees were instrumental in calling demonstrations in Washington, San Francisco and New York in which as many as a million North Americans participated at one time (November 1969). Many of us in Socialist Action took part in building those actions, which we are convinced helped to persuade the American people to oppose the war, isolated the Johnson and Nixon administrations and saved the lives of many draftees and many of the heroic people of Vietnam. A dispute over perspectives for US Marxists

It is not our intention in future issues of Socialist Action to dwell on differences with the Socialist Workers Party. Nevertheless, an account of the political dispute as it concerns major issues on which all sections of the Left have taken 24 and must take positions can only help to define our own trajectory as well as that of the SWP. Even after some years of rapid decline in membership, the SWP remains one of the four or five largest organizations of the US Left, and its experience in seeking to build a party of committed revolutionists should have interest to everyone engaged in a similar enterprise.

Immediately following the August 1981 party convention - the last that will be held before next summer, a year overdue - a sharp dispute erupted in the SWP over three issues. These proved to have some relationship: our assessment of Trotsky's Marxism; our attitude toward capitalist and Stalinist governments in conflict with imperialism but simultaneously engaged in political repression within their own borders; and our willingness to participate in and build formations such as the women's, antinuclear and antiwar movements, as well as the unions, of which a majority of the party's ranks were members.

Marx and Engels, the founders of the modern socialist and communist movements, originally posed the idea of a socialist reorganization of society as a possibility only for relatively industrialized countries. They reasoned that without large-scale industry, national planning would be impossible. Further, small farmers, shopkeepers and artisans would be against nationalization of their workplaces, while factory workers, who did not own the factories previously, would be in favor of nationalization as a means to take over control from private capitalists. Hence, without a majority of workers in the population there seemed to be no basis for any substantial government ownership on which the planned development of production for human needs could rest.

In the early years of the 20th century, large revolutionary movements arose in many under-developed countries. This posed for the first time the question of whether revolutions in primarily peasant nations could move relatively swifly to socialist nationalizations and the beginnings of planned economies, or whether they would have to retain private ownership of industry with its consequent draining off of resources into the pockets of a wealthy minority.

It was the Russian Marxist movement that first began to discuss this question seriously, around the time of the 1905 Russian revolution. Leon Trotsky was the first of the Russian Marxists to propose the possibility of a revolution against the tsar that would set up an openly socialist government. This was the essence of his famous "theory of permanent revolution." At that time virtually the entire Marxist movement doubted the possibility of such a course. Even Lenin, the greatest of the Russian Marxists, disagreed with Trotsky's idea. Later, in 1917, Lenin concluded independently that nothing short of a socialist government could solve Russia's problems. His thinking in effect converged with that of Trotsky's in the period leading up to the Bolshevik revolution in October 1917.

Afterward, during the rise of Stalin, the conservative bureaucracy sought to discredit its opponents on the Left by slandering Trotsky and working to discredit all of his ideas, including that of permanent revolution. Although this was really an attack on Lenin as well, it fitted in with the general retreat by the Stalinists from any serious attempt to organize revolutionary movements. In place of the struggle for socialism, they called for broad antiimperialist or antifascist movements and governments that in practice proved loose enough to leave the power in the hands of the liberal capitalist parties. The usual consequence was the defeat of revolutionary mass mobilizations through their failure to take decisive action in a period of revolutionary crisis.

Immediately after the party convention in 1981, with no possiblility for anyone who disagreed to reply, Jack Barnes, the SWP's central leader, announced that he no longer accepted the idea of fighting for a directly socialist revolution in underdeveloped countries. This led in the summer of 1983 to the publication of a special issue of the SWP's theoretical magazine New International, in which Barnes insisted that "our movement must discard permanent revolution" (p. 13).

To reject one of the fundamental ideas of the organization in a public magazine, without it having allowed a discussion of it, was a gross violation of the democratic rights of the party membership.

Politically, many party members were convinced that this break with the strategy of Lenin and Trotsky marked a serious adaptation to Stalinist ideology. Many of the same arguments used by Stalin in the 1920s against the Leninist Opposition in the Soviet Communist Party were used by the SWP leadership, in this magazine and in other articles, to attack the party's own previous positions, which it had held for more than 50 years. In 1982 supporters of Trotskyist ideology and supporters of the Fourth International began to be expelled from the SWP on a variety of organizational pretexts. Poland and Iran

On December 13, 1981, martial law was declared in Poland and the Stalinist government began the decapitation of the 10-million member Solidarnose union led by Lech Walesa. In 1968 at the time of the invasion of Czechoslovakia, the SWP had participated in joint demonstrations and protest meetings with other groups on the Left. The same was true of all the organizations of the Fourth International. At that time the Trotskyists sought to exclude from such protests anticommunists or groups that did not have a record of forthright opposition to the crimes of capitalist governments, such as the US war in Vietnam.

In 1981 it was clear the SWP did not

International Viewpoint 13 February 1984

want to be too prominent in support of movement. Finally even the trade the Polish workers - this might embar- unions, where the membership had all rass the party in its relationship with gone to escape the "petty bourgeois"

revolutionaries in Central America who ary." Left, also became nothing but "petty did not agree with this policy. This time bourgeois bureaucrats."

the SWP rejected demonstrations of any

Party members in the unions confine kind, refused to participate in virtually their activity largely to general socialist all meetings of the Left to support Soli- propaganda work with individual workdarnose and held only a few pro forma meetings of its own. ers. Because this is not oriented around actual issues that appear in workers' lives The SWP's program since 1935 has or around the organizations they belong been to designate the Soviet bureaucracy to now, such work has proven ineffectual as something less than a new ruling class, but nevertheless unreformable. Its offi- our common foe and has won very few members to the cial position is for "political revolution," party.

The SWP has patently been going We are for a sharp break from this that is, to state that the restoration of workers' democracy is possible only tion over the last two years. Its leaders through a dramatic internal transforma- many good people in an organization to policy of self-isolation. We regret that through the removal of the bureaucrats explain it as an effort to draw even closer which we devoted many years have workby revolutionary means while preserving to the revolutionaries of Cuba and Cen- ed themselves into such a corner. the social advances made possible through the property nationalizations. after the beginning of 1982, this concept Shortly trial working class, on the other hand, tral America, on the one hand, and to root the party more deeply in the indus- have a special concern here because while we are no longer members of the SWP, both we and the SWP are sympathizers of also Militant, the newspaper reflecting the from The extensive colonization of the same world movement. Moreover, it SWP's viewpoint. In its place ambiguous formulas appeared that could be inter- believe that a different process has been party members into basic industry. We is a movement in which our perspective holds a strong majority, although the retaking place. lationship of forces is reversed here in the the Polish CP. preted as calling merely for the reform of Since the last party convention, the United States. We would like to see all

A similar course was followed in the SWP has publicly renounced the most supporters of the Fourth International in SWP's coverage of Iran. After the bitter basic ideas of the Trotskyist movement, the United States belong to a single orof which it was a leading part for half a ganization. To express that idea we have struggle between the Khomeini regime century. This momentous decision was decided to organize ourselves as a publie and Mujahedeen began in the fall of 1981, never put up for a vote or even discussed, faction of the SWP, since it is the larger the SWP's press refused for many months and this in a party that had a long and of the two groups in this country that are to defend any victims of repression in highly respected democratic tradition. A in solidarity with the Fourth InternationIran, whether they were Mujahedeen suppurge has been launched against support- al. Organizing ourselves as a public facporters who had fought the government ers of the Fourth International and of tion expresses our hope that the party or innocent bystanders. The SWP ad- Trotskyism in the party, and they are be- will restore its prior democratic norms, vanced a general argument that it served the aims of reaction to criticize, ing systematically expelled. The major- readmit the expelled as a body, and open

City of the Fourth International has be- a discussion of the wrong political line it within an imperialist country, govern- come alarmed at this development. has embarked on in the last two years. ments under attack by imperialism. The the October meeting of the world organi- We hope to work with all others, inconsequence of this stance self- zation's leading body, the United Secre- cluding the SWP, who want to engage in censorship. tariat, an overwhelming majority charac- real struggles against the masters of our about torture of every variety of dissenter terized the wave of expulsions from the society. Although we are beginning as a Kurdish national minority areas, use of in Iranian prisons, military assaults on the SWP as a political purge aimed at the In- small organization, from the outset we ternational and recognized the right of have committed ourselves to participate private progovernment armed organiza- those expelled to form a new organiza- as fully as we are able in the central fights tions to halt the land reform - none of tion that would have all rights of fraternal of our day. As this issue of Socialist this could be found in The Militant.

collaboration with the world organization Action indicates, we are working to build

We understand the problem of play- the SWP's approach to organizations day through broad struggle coalitions ing into the hands of the many reaction- outside its own ranks. such as the ones being built around op-

In the last several years the SWP has position to US intervention in Central ary propaganda campaigns orchestrated tended to view everyone else engaged in America. We are also convinced that only by the Reagan government and its agents invasion in hysteria, the hue and cry over the Soviet the press. of Afghanistan, the meetings We saw the anti-Iranian are leaders of faraway revolutions whom the party does not have to work with the struggle against the evils of capitalism as a "petty bourgeois." The exceptions a world movement, with a disciplined events that change their focus from day membership, strategy, can hope to have an effect on a press and an overall where the unspeakable General Haig de- anyway. This designation swallowed up to day and from city to city. That is why clared his "Solidarity with Solidarity." the SWP's work in the women's move- we have chosen to carry out our work But we are also convinced, as Trotsky ment, then the antinuclear power move- through Socialist Action. We hope that used to say when pressured to make simi- ment, later the antinuclear weapons many of you will join us. International Viewpoint 13 February 1984

25

← Southern Africa: Mass Response to New Racist Constitution · Around the World: Denmark, European Youth, Portugal →

Something wrong on this page?