Argentina: a battered working class begins to raise its head again
Jean Pierre BEAUVAIS
BUENOS AIRES — "The military, they aren't gone yet, but they're already threatening to come back." He spoke in a low voice. Was it out of fear of being overheard? On his tired face, you could read a succession of fear and hatred, resignation and hope.
But Juan was virtually a privileged person. He was a survivor. In this ruined country, bled white and beaten to its knees by seven years of dictatorship, he was still alive. He had not been through the concentration camps or been tortured. He even had a job.
For fifteen years, Juan has worked in the automotive industry. In 1974, he was in the Renault factories in Cordoba, when the 8,000 workers there waged an exemplary struggle that lasted for months to defend their buying power and force the release of their imprisoned trade-union leaders. At the time, he was elected a shop steward.
"Three years later, in 1977, a year after the military took power, everybody who had held a position of leadership in the conflict — several hundred people — were without a job. Dozens were in prison or 'missing.' "
Later, Juan found a new job in the Volkswagen factories in Monte Chingolo in the suburbs of Buenos Aires. In 1974, he was earning the equivalent of about 2,000 francs a month (US 285 dollars). Today, holding a job at the same level of skills, he earns the equivalent of 570 francs (US 82 dollars). In 1974, he worked 43 hours per week. Now he has to work 53 hours. "That's the cost of the defeat, of the depression," Juan said.
"The automotive industry was one of the key sectors of the Argentine economy. It was in the hands of foreign capital. The market and production were divided up among Ford, Fiat, General Motors, Renault, Peugeot, Citroen, Volkswagen, and Mercedes.
"At the time of the big mobilizations in 1969 and 1974-75, the auto workers and our union, SMATA, played a militant, leading role. Under the dictatorship, we became one of the main targets of the repression. At the same time, the multi-nationals got a completely free hand to restructure their operations to adjust to the economic crisis.
"Some of them moved out of the country, almost overnight. That was what General Motors and Citroen did, for example. Others reconsolidated. Fiat and Peugeot, for example. In six years, five of the big factories shut down, and two thirds of the workers in the industry were left without jobs. In the other factories, those that are still working today, productivity has been increased two or three times, while real wages have dropped about 70%."
Juan could have added that his wages are now less than half those of a Volkswagen worker in Sao Paulo, Brazil. Ten years ago, this relationship was exactly the reverse. He could have added, too, that his buying power, which in 1974 was equivalent to one third that of a Volkswagen worker in Germany, is not a tenth of that today. The relationship between the buying power of Renault workers in Argentina and in France is about the same.
To say that Juan was optimistic would be an exaggeration. Overwhelmed by the day-to-day struggle for existence, he nonetheless had hope. "For six years, the atmosphere at the Monte Chingolo factory was dominated by fear. Fear of repression, fear of being laid off, fear of hunger...For some months now, it has been different. We are discussing again among ourselves. Assemblies are being held. And in response to new threats of layoffs bandied about by the management, we even organized a march in the neighborhood near the factory. That was on December 7. At the time, I could hardly believe it..."
Aldo enjoyed none of the privileges Juan did. He is married, with two children. He is a plasterer, and for close to two years he has been without a job. Being without a job for him means being without any resources whatsoever. There are no unemployment benefits for the two million unemployed in Argentina (about 20% of the economically active population). The story of Aldo's life is the history of the country's descent into poverty. This has meant absolute poverty in a country that is being deindustrialized.
It was only the support of his family, the spontaneous solidarity in the neighborhood of Pompeya where he lives, and above all the soup kitchens run by the parish that enabled Aldo, his wife, and children to survive. Aldo remembers vividly the hardest times. For example: "When the teacher came to the house last winter. The price of food had gone up again. She could not longer divide the food in the school cafeteria between those children who could pay and those who could not."
What was his greatest fear? "Sickness. A lot of the people in the neighborhood who are working can no longer pay to go to the doctor. Besides, the doctor moved out. For a while, two voluntary nurses maintained a church-supported clinic. But the health services said that that was illegal, so they had to stop."
Polio has reappeared in the working-class suburbs of Buenos Aires. But in Aldo's neighborhood the priest ran a free vaccination campaign.
What can a building worker approaching middle age like Aldo hope for? The building industry is one of the hardest hit by the economic crisis. It is functioning at about 30% of capacity, according to the bosses' own statistics. Half-built buildings, deserted building sites abound in Buenos Aires.
A few months ago. on the recommendation of experts sent by the International Monetary Fund, who were anxious to see that the situation did not go over "the threshold of the unbearable," the military government announced that the payment of unemployment benefits was being studied. But if Aldo ever thought that he might benefit from this, he will soon be disillusioned. The projected payments — 200 francs (18 US dollars) a month will only go, under certain conditions, to workers who lost their jobs in 1982! That represents about 10% of those presently unemployed. And, owing to the government's lack of credit, the application of this measure has been suspended.
A quick calculation would show, however, that the annual cost of these unemployment benefits amounts to barely 2% of the interest on the short-term credits granted in recent weeks by the banks of the imperialist powers. These credits have been allocated primarily for replacing the military materiel destroyed during the Malvinas war.
The stories of these two, Aldo the unemployed plasterer; Juan, the automobile worker, show better than any statistics could the nature and extent of the economic crisis in Argentina. The effects and manifestations of this crisis are all the more striking in a country that, even though it remained economically dependent, had nonetheless undergone a certain industrial development. Moreover, the Argentine working class also — long the largest and most concentrated proletariat in Latin America — has strong traditions of struggle and organization that go back decades.
One indication of the impact of the crisis is that grim and unsanitary shantytowns are mushrooming around Buenos Aires, and they look very much like those that surround other Latin-American cities. But the men and women crowded into them are not uprooted people coming from poor and overpopulated areas. Such people scarcely exist in Argentina.
The Argentine shantytown dwellers are former blue- and white-collar workers who are now unemployed. They have been ejected from their factories, ejected from their homes because they could no longer pay the rent, and forced out of their neighborhoods, where the price of food was too high. They are outcasts from the city, outcasts from a society where illiteracy, undernourishment, and sickness are growing rapidly.
Other, better off layers, are also being hit. A large number of professionals, technicians, architects, and doctors have had to leave the country because they could not make a living there, and they have gone to swell the ranks of the hundreds of thousands of exiles scattered in Latin America, the United States, and in Europe. Among those who have stayed, there is no telling how many are eking our a living in marginal jobs. Thousands of trained professionals are earning their living today as taxi drivers in the capital city.
"The cost of the depression, the cost of the defeat," Aldo said. The defeat also has other faces, other voices. The most moving, the most courageous are those of the mothers who have devoted their lives to searching for their "missing" children. The demonstration they have held every Thursday afternoon for years on the Plaza de Mayo in front of the president's palace has become a constant challenge to which the dictatorship has no answer.
Where are they? Where are these 25 to 30 thousand "missing" Argentinians? They army still has secret detention centers. How many have died under torture in the marine mechanics school near the River stadium, where the big football matches are held? How many have perished a few steps away in the basement of the central police department between Moreno and Caballo streets? Whose bodies lie in the special areas of the cemetaries under lines of grim crosses marked "N.N." for "No Name"?
A few of the "missing" have reappeaed in recent months — mutilated, broken people, full of fear and guilt. They are obsessed by one question: "Why did I get out? Why not the others? Did I collaborate?"
"We have to kill as many people as necessary to restore peace," the former head of the junta, General Videla, said. One of his aides, General Saint-Just, who was governor of Buenos Aires Province, made things clearer: "In the first place, we are going to kill all the subversives, then their accomplices, then those who remain passive, and finally the cowards." That was at the "heyday" of the dictatorship.
Today, when the hatred and isolated regime is at the end of its rope, when the government is supposed to be returned to civilian hands late this year, the time is no longer favorable for such speeches. The military would like that sort of thing to be forgotten. So, history is being rewritten. Excesses may have been committed, they say. But these were individual cases in the framework of a "war" against "subversion" directed from abroad, against terrorism.
The military hope to whitewash and salvage their institutions, to get people to forget against whom and at whose expense they waged their "war on the home front."
But the reality is there to be seen, naked, grotesque. The enemy was not some remote "subversives." It was the masses of workers, the working class, its trade-union activists, its politically aware activists. It is these workers who make up the great majority of the dead, the "missing," the prisoners, and the victims of the economic pillage that accompanied this "war."
And the people who directed this war are those who have accumulated and are accumulating fabulous fortunes. They are the bosses of the multinationals sitting in their glass and steel towers. They are the inhabitants of the gilded ghettos, who live in a luxury by no means inferior to their counterparts in Paris, London, or New York. Since 1976, these people have stashed 6 billion dollars in Switzerland, according to a recent study by the Swiss Socialist deputy Jean Ziegler. This amounts to 15% of Argentina's enormous foreign debt.