International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

The Zionist Crimes and Palestinian Isolation

· International Viewpoint No. 13, 20 September 1982 · pp 2-4 · 3,696 words

Middle East Soviet Union France Africa

Versión en castellano: Los crímenes sionistas y la soledad de los palestinos (Inprecor n.º 30, octubre de 1982)

In German: Die Palästinenser waren allein, 3. September 1982 (Inprekorr Nr. 8 (147), 16. September 1982)

The Zionists' crimes and the Palestinians' isolation

Daniel BENSAID

The siege of West Beirut lasted 79 days. For more than two months, the Zionist army (Tsahal) waged war on the Palestinian and Lebanese population. To break the resistance, it resorted to the most barbaric means-from cutting off water and electricity to blanket terror bombing, including the use of fragmentation bombs and attacks on hospitals.

It is still impossible to calculate exactly the number of victims (according to the official Lebanese sources, 17,825 persons were killed and 30,103 wounded; the Palestinian figures are higher). This represents a massacre comparable to the crushing of the Paris Commune in 1871. It was carried on day after day in front of the cameras of all the world's TV networks.

And still the world did not respond, or at best only weakly!

The Habib Plan, imposed by imperialism and guaranteed by the presence of American, French, and Italian troops, is the confirmation of this isolation of the Lebanese and Palestinian fighters. It provides for keeping Israeli troops in Lebanon and installing an ultrareactionary regime.

For all those who mobilized alongside the Palestinian resistance, the struggle continues to force the withdrawal of the Zionist troops and all imperialist forces from Lebanon, as well as to defend democratic rights, which are now being directly threatened by the Christian Phalangists.

But in order to mobilize for the new phase of the struggle, it is necessary to draw the lessons of the last two months as clearly as possible.

Zionism has starkly revealed its underlying nature and its role as the ally of American imperialism in the region. From start to finish, it was only able to carry out its military expedition thanks to diplomatic cover from the U.S. (reflected by one vote after the other in the U.N. Security Council) and to U.S. economic and military aid. The existence of the state of Israel, as it is presently constituted, has been shown to be indissolubly linked to its big imperialist backers.

The Zionist state has also revealed its colonial structure. Since its origins, it has been based on the expulsion of the Arab workers and peasants from the process of production, on the expropriation of their land, and racial discrimination.

During his skirmishes with the French president Mitterrand, Israeli Premier Manahem Begin revealed this whole attitude. Begin went so far as to say that the French criticisms of Israel were simply an expression of spite by a country that, in the face of the Israeli military successes against the Arabs, felt humiliated by its defeat in the Algerian war (1954-62). It is hard to imagine a cruder kind of colonialism or racism.

As for the "labor left" in Israel, it showed that it remains largely united in support of the imperialist aims of the Zionist state, and that this takes precedence over any "left" character it may claim. The Labor Party endorsed the "Peace in Galilee" operation.

In fact, the leader of the Labor Party, Shimon Peres, accepted a mission from the Begin government to defend the motives of the Zionist state in New York and Paris.

TRAITORS AND ACCOMPLICES

The attitude of the other major powers involved in the conflict was also revealed quite clearly.

This is true first of all of American imperialism. Israeli defense minister, General Ariel Sharon, said several times publicly that he had advised the Americans of the Israeli military plans well before the operations were launched. These revelations were by no means unintentional. They were designed to publicly implicate Israel's American ally.

As for the Soviet Union, it did not go beyond formal protests. Its passivity was explicitly denounced by the Palestinian leaders themselves. For example PLO chief Abu Ayad said: "We have stood up better against the Israeli army than all the Arab armies....The Soviet attitude therefore is all the more inexplicable. We have questioned Moscow both publicly and privately. We have gotten only symbolic encouragements. How can the Soviet Union afford to be so passive when the U.S. is involving itself so flagrantly in the fight? I don't understand it (1)."

The Soviets have had an easy way out by throwing the ball back into the camp of the Arab countries. They have argued, not without some cynicism, that they could not try to be "more Arab than the Arabs." But this does not make it any less clear that their abstention marks the limits of their involvement in the Middle East and reveals their basic motives.

The Soviets support for the PLO, thus, remains subordinated to what they regard as more enduring and advantagous diplomatic alliances, not for the sake of mobilizing the masses against imperialism but for the interests of the Soviet state.

Thus, it has become clear that the Soviet Union will not go beyond defending the Syrian regime, which remains its last significant ally in the region. On the other hand, it does not think that it has an essential stake in the survival of the PLO.

The role played by Soviet diplomacy in this conflict will certainly be instructive for the USSR's other allies in Latin America. Soviet "solidarity" will never go beyond what serves the clear state interests of the USSR. Anyone who tries to see it as generous internationalism is headed for some bitter disillusionments.

The Soviet betrayal is matched only by that of the Arab states. They literally did not lift a finger to help the Palestinian and Lebanese peoples. The PLO came to the Arab League summit held in Tunis on June 26-27, that is two weeks after the start of the Zionist aggression, with a 14point solidarity plan.

This plan called for effective involvement of the Arab states in the armed struggle in Lebanon, condemnation of the U.S., because of its backing of Israel, as "the main enemy of the Arab nation"; immediate recall of the Arab ambassadors in Washington; boycott of American institutions and freezing of U.S. contracts in the Arab countries; and withdrawal of Arab funds deposited in U.S. banks. Not a single point of this plan was accepted, and the summit took no initiative.

Egypt has kept its ambassador in Israel, and Saudi Arabia has officially welcomed Beshir Gemayel, head of the ultrarightist Christian Phalange, thereby granting him the legitimacy in the eyes of the Muslim population of Lebanon he needed to get himself elected president.

This betrayal of the Arab states is acutely and vociferously resented by the Palestinian fighters in West Beirut. But it is nothing new. It is in a line of continui1. Le Monde, July 23, 1982.

3

ty with the massacre of September 1970 (Black September) conducted by King Hussein of Jordan, the anti-Palestinian counteroffensive supported by Syria in April 1976, and the Camp David Accords by which Egyptian President Anwar as-Sadat freed Begin's hands so that he could turn against the Palestinians in Lebanon. But this sort of betrayal has never been so blatant. And so it seems inevitable that it will lead relatively soon to political differentiations in the ranks of the Arab nationalists.

Finally, the West European imperialist powers took some distance from the U.S. by a few inconsequential votes in the U.N., but they took no significant reprisals against the Israeli aggression-no boycott, not even an embargo, on arms deliveries.

The most wretched aspect of the whole affair is that against the background of the dereliction of the USSR and the Arab states, Francois Mitterrand was able to appear, thanks to Begin's unbridled verbal attacks on him, as the most feithful cunnortor of tha Doloctinion and faithful supporter of the Palestinian and Lebanese peoples.

In June, after the onset of the Israeli invasion of Lebanon, Francois Mitterrand spoke during his visit to Vienna in favor of a withdrawal of "all three foreign armies" from Lebanon. Thus he lumped together the Syrian army, the Zionist army, and the Palestinian resistance, forgetting that unlike the first two, the Palestinian forces still have no homeland or state to which they could withdraw. In fact, this false symmetry, this false pretense of fairness, amounted to justifying the Israeli military presence as long as there were Palestinian forces in Lebanon.

Finally, at the end of the day, Francois Mitterrand is giving his support to a plan that calls in practice for evacuating and dispersing the Palestinians while keeping a Zionist army of occupation in Lebanon indefinitely.

The presence of the French Interposition force represents his support for the expulsion of the Palestinians and his support of the election of Beshir Gemayel to the presidency of the Lebanese state, in a military barracks and under the pressure of Israeli tanks.

In invading Lebanon, Ariel Sharon and Menahem Begin set three explicit goals:

-First, to smash the infrastructure and military backbone of the Palestinian resistance, whose activity threatened to combine with the upsurge of mobilizations in the occupied territories.

-Secondly, to drive the Syrian forces out of Lebanon and weaken Syria.

-Finally, to help set up an allied regime in Lebanon that would be ready to sign an agreement with Israel complementary to the Camp David Accords with Egypt.

Besides these avowed goals, there were at least two others. One was to reaffirm Israel's role as the irreplacable special ally of imperialism in the region. The other was to restore Israeli national unity and mobilize Israeli public opinion in order to overcome the effects of growing economic and social problems.

With these goals, the Israeli offensive became possible as a result of an international conjuncture and especially favourable for the Zionist operation.

It came in the context of the imperialist counteroffensive, and, after the unanimous support given by the imperialist countries to the British colonial expedition to the Malvinas, there was hardly any danger of serious condemnation by any imperialist country.

While the Israeli offensive fitted into this context, it could also take advantage from a certain margin of maneuver created by the imperialist crisis of leadership and the hesitations of American diplomacy (the replacement of U.S. Secretary of State Alexander Haig by George Shultz).

The Israeli government benefited from the paralysis of the USSR, which remains bogged down in its own problems in Poland and Afghanistan. It also benefitted from the divisions and impotence of all the so-called nonaligned bodies, which are being more and more torn apart by the international polarization.

Thus, for the two months that the siege of Beirut lasted, the Arab League was unable to take the slightest initiative. The Tripoli summit of the Organization of African Unity had to be adjourned for lack of a quorum. The Bagdad conference of the Nonaligned Movement had to be postponed because of the Iran-Iraq war and transferred to New Delhi.

In these conditions, the Zionist operation was able to partially achieve its objectives without being able to accomplish any of them completely.

First and foremost, the PLO suffered a severe military defeat resulting in the smashing of its positions in Lebanon, in the expulsion and dispersion of its military vanguard. But it was not defeated without a fight. Contrasting with the abjectness of the Arab regimes, the PLO's 79 days of heroic resistance have given a

Yasser Arafat at a press conference (DR) new legitimacy to the national and democratic demands of the Palestinian people.

This accomplishment, however, is not enough to turn a military defeat into a political victory. Dispersed in eight Arab states (Iraq, Syria, Saudi Arabia, North Yemen, South Yemen, the Sudan, Algeria, and Tunisia), all of which are hostile in varying degrees to the PLO (let's not forget Jordanian King Hussein's hypocritical embraces of PLO leaders), the leadership and best trained military forces of the PLO will be kept under close surveillance. The Arab regimes will be more conscious than ever that the Palestinian resistance will have an anti-imperialist authority for the Arab masses that they have lost, if they ever had any. This will be another reason for redoubled surveillance.

There will be no lack of pressures trying to force the PLO to change its approach and become a diplomatic pawn in the maneuvers of the Arab states. Walid Jumblatt, leader of the Lebanese National Movement, indicated this in his own way on June 26 when he said: "The PLO needs a new leadership that will take a different approach in defending Palestinian rights.... What is essential is a new Palestinian legality, a new strategy, a new leadership...I am aware that the PLO is in danger of a split and that a civil war among Palestinians is not impossible (2)."

As regards the withdrawal of the Syrian units belonging to the Arab Dissuasion Force in Lebanon, Israel has not at all achieved its objective. It seems, however, in a position to get what it wants by force. The Israeli armies are face to face with the Syrian army in the Bekaa valley, and Damascus is almost within range of the Israeli artillery.

However, such a test of strength might force the USSR to react this time, because it would endanger its last diplomatic ally in the region. Israel may, therefore, try to negotiate a joint with2. Interview with Walid Jumblatt in Le Monde of July 26, 1982.

drawal of its own troops and the Syrian little David against a plotting gang of Go- that they cannot control and which-by forces. But such a process will obviously liaths represented by the Arab states. its very presence can stimulate an autobe subordinated to the consolidation first This time, they have carried out what was nomous mobilization of the exploited in Lebanon of a regime allied with Israel undeniably an aggression operation and oppressed in their own countries. and then of this alliance itself. tramping on the frontiers and institutions In a nutshell, in order to defend the

For the moment, without engaging of a neighboring state without even national and democratic rights of its peoopenly in military operations against the bothering to declare war. And the objec- ple effectively, the Palestinian resistance Palestinian resistance, Beshir Gemayel's tive was to crush a people without a needs a leadership that will take class Christian Phalange has begun to build the country and without a state, abandoned positions toward the policies of the Arab nucleus of their police force and their ad- by all, people whose new diaspora will regimes, as well as internationalist posiministration in the wake of the Israeli hold up to the Jewish community in Pal- tions that can sharpen the contradictions army in the Chouff mountains and in the estine the image of its own past. of Israeli society. It is understandable Saida region. They have been able to sal- how difficult it is to form such a leadervage the weapons left behind by the Pal- THE PLO AT THE CROSSROADS ship based on the refugee camps, whose estinians and Syrians, which the Zionist populations are uprooted and lacking in occupiers have generously failed to take The Lebanon war and the siege of experience of working-class struggle. themselves. Moreover, Beshir Gemayel Beirut have illustrated once again the Nonetheless, the terrible blows that was installed as president on a military special features of the Palestinian libera- the Palestinian resistance has suffered in base in the shadow of Zionist bayonets. tion struggle. This struggle has been the last fifteen years make necessary a

As regards its fourth objective, waged up till now mainly by a dispersed critical balance sheet and a process of

Israel has no doubt established itself people without ar as the most zealous ally of imperialism social base. in the region. It has shown that if need The Palestin be it can act under the pretext of self- strength from the defense in a way that would be difficult large numbers of for an American expeditionary force. emigrated through This is especially true at a time when Arab Emirates sin Yankee imperialism is finding it so diffi- depends to a larg cult to overcome the "Vietnam syndrom" grants and still mo and act even in its own private preserve of military aid of the Central America and the Caribbean. In these con

Finally, the results of the Zionist ing that a humili operation are most doubtful as regards pushed to the edge the internal situation in Israel. It might duction should see seem that Menahem Begin has achieved rallying point and his goal and mobilized Israeli public opin- a national dignity ion. The polls taken at the end of August hard to maintain. showed 82% support for the "Peace in However, th Galilee" operation. Nonetheless, cracks struggle is up agair in the Zionist bloc appeared that are un- problems than an! precedented in a war situation. tion struggle.

For several years now the economic colonial occupatic situation in Israel has been deteriorating. community, whic Chronic unemployment has appeared. pressed itself and The inflation rate has been oscillating be- aims to drive out tween 100% and 130%. The government than exploit them is applying a monetarist policy calling for the technological the reprivatization of certain sectors and alism-is what giv the elimination of numbers of jobs. Now strength. It is s this general trend is going to be com- flexes of national pounded by the costs of the war. by the trauma

In August, it was officially estima- This is wh ted that the war had already cost 1.2 bil- against Zionism r lion dollars, or 10% of the national bud- class antagonisms class get. Inflation for the month of July hit itself and an inter a record high of 9.2%. The government between the Pales has taken steps to reduce state subsidies ment and the Jewi on consumer goods and to increase state Likewise, th charges. has to base self

There have been drastic hikes in imperialist mobil the prices of fuel, milk, transport, tele- masses. It cann communications, and electricity. Sales coming into co taxes have been increased and special imperialist policie taxes imposed on travel abroad. A state regimes. The PI bond campaign has been launched, inclu- stick to a line o ding compulsory purchase for nine the internal affai months, with the money deducted from It has not, howev the gross wages of most Israeli earners. these states from

The day will obviously come when brutal way in the the cost is going to be counted up. This resistance. accounting is going to be all the more Jordan, Syri painful because for the first time Israel peatedly interver had to wage an undisguiseably dirty war. against the Pal ly territorial or stable clarification. Significant in this respect is

Yasser Arafat's answer to a Le Monde reian resistance draws its porter who asked him what he thought refugee camps and the were the main mistakes made by the PLO Palestinians that have ding this long conflict. The Palestinian out the region and the leader said: "We have not been able to se 1948. Materially, it explain our cause to the Israelis; we have • extent on these emi- not understood the Israeli mentality." re on the financial and Arafat reduced what is a fundamenArab regimes. tal political problem to one pedagogical litions, it is not surpris- one. Nonetheless, he put his finger on ated, dispersed people, the key question, how to break up the s of the process of pro- social cement of Zionism. And he ofthe armed struggle as a fered the first elements of a positive the main expression of answer: that they have to fight "Our National Council has adopted several resolutions calling for the opening e Palestinian liberation of a discussion with the democratic forces st much more complex in Israel and we are ready to establish re, other national libera- lations with all those that recognize our does not face simple right to self-determination (3)." ın but another national The danger is that this realism will 1 not long ago was op- open the way to diplomatic deals in the has formed a state that framework of the Camp David Accords, he Arab workers rather rather than for a revolutionary strategy. . This-over and above With regard to the question of relaaid it gets from imperi- tions with the Arab states, the PLO has es the state of Israel its not given any public indication of the till able to exploit re- lessons it has drawn. They must certainly self-defense sharpened involve a painful reassessment of the poof the Nazi genocide. licy followed by the PLO leadership in , an effective struggle the 1975-76 Lebanese civil war, in partiequires developing the cular the accords that allowed Syria to orwithin Israeli society ganize the election of President Elias nationalist convergence Sarkis on October 18, 1976, and made it tinian liberation move- possible to lay the goundwork for the sh proletariat. Phalangist counteroffensive at a time e Palestinian resistance when the Palestinian forces and the MNL primarily on the anti- were within inches of a military victory. ization of the Arab But this time the betrayal of the t achieve this without Arab regimes was so flagrant and so deepnflict with the pro- ly resented that it will be difficult for the s of most of the Arab PLO to avoid a reexamination of this O has always tried to question. f "noninterference" in Regardless of whether the PLO as rs of the Arab states. a whole is able to change or whether a er, been able to prevent new course will be possible only after interfering in the most new differentiations within it, after the life of the Palestinian siege of Beirut, the PLO finds itself at a new historic turning point. It is as decia, and Lebanon have re- sive as the one that after the failure of the ed with armed force Arab states brought the PLO to the foreestinian resistance in front of the Arab anti-imperialist movenad to wage an undisguseaoty aırty wal.

1970, 1976, and 1982. The Arab regimes ment at the end of the 1970s.

In the past, the Israeli leaders have cannot tolerate the existence on their teralways been able to present their military

Interview with Yassar Arafat in Le

3.

operations as battles fought by a valiant ritory of a political and military force

Monde of August 10, 1982.

5

← Why I Became a Revolutionist · Second Open Letter of the RCG in Lebanon — Document →

Something wrong on this page?