Why I became a revolutionist
The following is from the introduclory chapters of Bernadette Devlin McAliskey's political autobiography, edited by Gerry Foley. (Copyright from a book to be published next year by Brandon Book Publishers, Dingle Ireland.) The final version that will appear in the book will be further edited. The subheadings have been added by IV.
A long and complex historical development set the stage for the renewal of the fight for Irish national liberation that began in 1968-69. That in fact was what the Northern Ireland civil rights movement represented, although I was not aware of it at the time. Indeed, the leaders of the movement-conservatives, moderates, and the most radical socialistswere convinced and determined that it had to be something else. Their ideas of what it should be, of course, differed, but they were all agreed that it had to be a new "modern" sort of a movement that could avoid the quicksands in which all the attempts to resume the march of national liberation had become bogged down for the last fifty years.
Although I had grown up steeped in Irish history, I was far from understanding the historical forces that were being set in motion. I was shaped by that history and placed by it in a position to play a central role in the struggie that was beginning. The part I came to play was determined by an interaction between my understanding, rational forces that I did not understand, and blind chance. But as the struggle advanced, I had to try to gain a conscious understand. ing of the forces that were at work. I had to in order to survive and move forward. And the same is true of all of my generation who became involved in the fight that started in 1968-69 and who remain in it. This book is a history of that process more than it is a history of the civil rights movement or of the last ten years of struggle.
In the decade preceding the start of the civil rights movement, the largest IRA military campaign against British rule in Northern Ireland since the war of Irish independence had flickered to a demoralizing end. It was officially concluded in 1961, after it had in fact faded out. The war had failed to rouse the oppressed community even though the majority of the oppressed people showed their support for the IRA in the 1955 elections in Northern Ireland. The IRA leadership itself decided that there was something wrong with the traditional approach. It began to explore ways of using its organization to build mass social struggles around concrete, immediate demands.
In the late 1960s in Ireland, there did seem to be real possibilities for winning social reforms without directly confronting the national issue. The 1960s were a period of rapid economic development in the twenty-six counties that make up the formally independent part of Ireland. There was a rise of trade-union struggles and of demands for bringing the backward social welfare system into line with the standards existing in the rest of the British Isles. On this basis, the long moribund Irish Labour Party began to take on some life as a Social Democratic alternative. The major Irish unions affiliated to it, and it began to attract youth and other elements interested in reform and progress.
In the six counties that make up Northern Ireland, a British province, the 1960s were a period of "liberalization." We were led to believe that we were finally going to enjoy the benefits of being "British subjects." The people of Northern Ireland are supposed to enjoy both the "advantages" of British citizenship and "home rule." A local parliament was established in Stormont Castle outside Belfast in 1920, during the war of independence, allegedly a part of a British plan for extending "home rule" to the entire island. There was also to be a local parliament in Dublin to administer the areas where there was a large Catholic, nationalist majority. These two local governments were to be linked in a Council of ireland, which has never met.
In fact, what happened was that the British overlords handed over to their historic auxiliaries, the pro-imperialist Protestant ruling class, as much of the country as they could effectively control.
"Home rule" in Northern Ireland meant the rule of a completely reactionary combination of sweat-shop bosses and landlords, whose social and economic position depended on the oppression of the Catholic population, the descendents of the Irish people who were robbed of their lands and rights by the English conquest and settlement. This "home rule" was based on forces that were the equivalent of racist gangs in other coloniesthe Royal Ulster Constabulary (RUC) and
"special" auxiliary constabulary, known as the "B-Specials." Oppression of the Catholic minority was an integral part of the system.
From the standpoint of tht ro. testant rulers and those who identified their interests with them, the oppresser of the Catholics was necessary to keep the latter from becoming the majority. They had to be forced to emigrate in larger numbers than Protestants. From the standpoint of both the Protestant rulers and their British overlords, the Protestants had to be given privileges at the expense of the Catholics in order to assure their continued support for British rule.
The meager advantages granted the Protestant masses paid off twofold for the rulers. The Protestants were given a feeling that they had a stake in the status quo and therefore had something to lose from social change. They were also kept in constant fear of the Catholic population that they knew must resent the privileges they had and be plotting to take them away.
FROM ILLUSIONS OF REFORM
TO REVOLUTIONARY MILITANCY So, all that "home rule" for Northern Ireland was in reality was a license for repression, an excuse for maintaining a more repressive and reactionary setup than existed in any other "part" of the United Kingdom.
But in the 1960s, this system seemed to be changing. The Stormont prime minister, Terence O'Neill, began making friendly faces at the Catholic middle-class. He actually let himself be photographed with nuns, and informed Protestants that if the living standards of Catholics were improved they "would live like Protestants....They will refuse to have eighteen children." The world seemed to be changing so rapidly that the Catholics in Northern Ireland could hope that the anomaly of a stagnant, bigoted, repressive enclave in the United Kingdom could not much longer be maintained. Northern Ireland society would have to become more like the rest of the modern European world, more like Britain.
My generation of Catholics was the second to gain some real access to higher education. The first were the new Catholic middle class leaders such as John Hume, who were also the first leaders of
23
the civil rights movement. They had expected to be accepted into "respectable" circles, but found themselves still excluded by the traditional pattern of discrimination. That was what turned them back toward their own community and toward organizing protests. We were the second wave, a broader social layer, more ready to fight. We also had higher aspirations than the older generations of Catholics, more of an awareness of what was going on in the world outside, and also more illusions. It was possible for us, even the most radical of us, to believe that we could win major changes in the system through peaceful mass protests alone.
We were part of the general reformist ferment that was opening up the Catholic community to new ideas, new forms of action and organization, and new hope. This ferment was also breaking down the traditional political structures in the Catholic community and thereby opening up the way for us to take a leading role. But the circumstances of the time and the influence at work made us especially iconoclastic and self-centered. We tended to look down on the nationalist tradition, which in the long impasse since the War of Independence had become more and more reduced to sterile sentiment, if not empty bombast and hypocrisy. We were not interested in the traditional nationalist organizations, which seemed to us to be just survivals of the past. The republican forms of organization the antiquated rituals of nineteenth century military conspiracy-particularly put us off. We were not much interested in organization. We were attracted by new ideas and action, by the chance to take initiatives, to express ourselves.
However, in the space of a few months, we opened up the flood gates of the long dammed up Irish revolution. It swept us along as it did all the political forces in the oppressed community. We were forced to learn to navigate in it by being tossed on reef after reef. Those who refused to go with the current, the 1960s leadership of the IRA (which came to call itself the "Official" IRA) were politically destroyed by it, eventually becoming a disgrace to their own former principles. In order to maintain their predetermined course, they had to turn on their own revolutionary members, murdering some and driving most away.
Ireland became an unparalleled laboratory for studying the dynamics of mass movements. We saw the price that had to be paid for political mistakes. We learned. A new Irish revolutionary generation came of age. And the components of a new mass revolutionary movement began to come together for the first time since the 1913-1922 period, a movement that can achieve the freedom of Ireland.
The new upsurge of the national liberation struggle since 1969 has in fact borne the imprint of the changes in Ireland that we saw, of the consciousness of my generation, and of the forms of mass 24 action that we promoted. In this generation, the activists in the struggle have been led rapidly to an understanding that a social revolution is necessary for liberation and that it must be based primarily on the working class and must be part of a world movement against capitalism and imperialism. The pressures impelling activists to this understanding have been extremely powerful. Even those who started from the narrowest and most conservative point of view have been rapidly obliged to accept this outlook if they wanted to stay in the struggle.
THE TRAINING OF A REVOLUTIONIST I was a very hard working student through grammar school. I did not think about politics in a conscious way. My idea was to get through, get to university, and get into a position where I could support the rest of the family. My first three years in the university I concentrated exclusively on getting a first-class honours degree in psychology.
Most of the students I knew ran out of their grant by midyear and sent home for money. I not only lived on my grant, I actually sent money home from it. That meant that I basically lived to work. In those first three years, I did not attend one single political meeting.
In January 1967, my mother died, leaving me responsible for the rest of the family. So, in the summers of 1967 and 1968, in return for their material assistance, I worked for my mother's brothers, who kept a public house. But I wasn't prepared to ask them for money without working for it. Actually, this experience furthered my political education, taking me out of the close, protective atmosphere of the university. learned more about the society in which I lived.
Working in the bar, I could see the restrictions that there were on people. It became obvious that it was possible for Catholics and Protestants to maintain friendships only by blocking off parts of their lives. That was most noticeable around the Twelfth of July, the time of the big Orange marches. The Catholic patrons quietly endured the insult of their Protestant friends, however unintentional or unconscious. Apparently, they believed that after the Twelfth, it would all go away again.
I remembered that as a child living on a mixed housing estate, our Protestant friends were not allowed to play with us during the month of July. All friendships were temporarily suspended. This was accepted. The month would pass, and they would all come sneaking back, and be welcomed again as freinds.
The first civil rights march was in August 1968. It started in Coalisland, near Cookstown, and went to Dungannon, about five miles away. I was never very clear about why I went. I was at home, away from the university, and so I did not go as a student. I did not go either because I was involved in political activity in the university. I was not. But I was aware of the issue that sparked the demonstration.
The issue was discrimination against Catholics in the allocation of council houses, specifically what was known as the Caledon incident. A house had been given to an unmarried Protestant woman and denied to a Catholic family that had been waiting for years. The march was organized by the Social Justice Campaign. Austin Curry was involved. He was a young Catholic politician, a school teacher. He was regarded at the time as an outsider and a radical by most of the clergy and the established Catholic politicians. He later became one of the main figures in remodeling the bourgeois Catholic party so that it could survive in changing times.
There were probably some people who went to that march and never went on another, but these must have been very few. I was determined at the end of that first march that I was going to be on the second and the third and all the rest of them, even though I was still not very clear about what I wanted.
The speakers were Gerry Pitt, a member of the British parliament for the main Belfast Catholic ghetto, Betty Sinclair of the Communist Party, and Erskine Holmes of the Liberal Party. I remember nothing that any of them said, except that Gerry Fitt promised that he would lead us through the police, who refused to allow us to enter the town; and that of course he did not.
What I remember is the solidarity of the people who were there and the feeling of pride and determination that they communicated. I remember the confrontation with the police and the sort of reaction it produced in me. The realization hit that you could not even walk on your own street and state your mind, that the police would stop you. That made me feel determined that whatever else I might be prepared to put up with, I was not going to let the police keep me from saying my piece. I thought that all my life I had let people walk over me and then once I went onto the street to say my bit, the whole apparatus of the state came down on me to try to shut me up. I could not put it in words. But I realized then once and for all what my place was in this society and that I was not going to accept it.
The bulk of those who marched that day were from the immediate area. Most of them were probably unemployed young people. There were also a lot of people in their forties, fifties, and sixties. In later years when I came back to live in this area, I found out that they were the people who were maintaining the resistance here. They were the fighters of the 1940s. They were the layer who became involved in the struggle at the age of seventeen and eighteen in the 1930s and 1940s. Some of them had become active on the question of unemployment. But most of them became involved as republicans.
There were a large number of woon that march, although they were not organized as women. Most of them were members of political groups, or were there with their husbands. There were a lot of families. Many people brought children on their shoulders. They were very lighthearted. It was not such a big crowd, I think, looking back on it, may. be two or three thousand. But people had never gathered before in this area in such large numbers. This created energy, enthusiasm, and a spirit in the people. This gave them confidence that now they were really off their knees. And it was only once they were off their kness, that they realized that they had been on them for so many years.
I remember that I was surprised to see people from the university in Belfast such as Michael Farrell and Patricia Drinan, people that I'd seen around the university and known to be political people. I remember being surprised that they had come to Coalisland and that they all had banners.
The next march was held in Derry City on October 5. I had a male friend, English by birth and Irish by parentage. He was a strong republican and wanted to go. I was determined to go myself. So, the two of us went there on our own. Many of the same people were therestudents from Belfast. There were also the young Derry activists, people like Johnnie White and Eamon McCann, whom I didn't know at the time.
I remember that there had been a running argument in the papers about whether the Derry march was going ahead or was going to be banned. It was banned. But that made me even more determined to go.
Even after all the things that have happened in the last ten years, the memory of that march still stands out in my mind. I can still see it clearly when I close my eyes-the police wading into the marchers and beating them, the water cannon coming down. It was terrifying. I was terrified, and I think everyone was terrified. But terrified as you were, something made you know that you were going to come back for more. And from that day on, people kept doing that. They kept being beaten off the streets and coming back on again, then being beaten off again and coming back. It seems like a kind of madness when you look back on it. You ask yourself in hindsight why you kept coming back for more. Well, you just did. You knew that you had to. You knew that if you let them beat you down, you would never be able to lift yourself again. You would have to accept that having discovered your place in society that it was good enough for you. So, everytime they tried to drive us off the streets, we became more angry and determined, and that anger and determination started to put Nor. thern Ireland into the headlines of the world press.
The new term at university started the week after the Derry march. A meeting was called by the Young Socialist
Alliance, the Liberals, and the Republican Clubs. Its purpose was to organize a march to city hall to protest against the brutality of the police in Derry. A lot of students became strongly involved in it. Of course, the march was halted by the police before it got to city hall. A rally was held in front of the police lines. I remember Michael Farrell speaking. did not know Farrell personally, but I knew that he was involved with the Young Socialist Alliance. He was obviously the best speaker there. He could articulate what we felt. I do not remember what he said particularly but I remember that it was what we felt. Someone said that we would stay there until hell froze over. I think that it was Farrell, although he later denied it. I know that I was quite prepared to stay sitting there as long as necessary. But after a while we marched back to the university.
The crowd moved in a spontaneous way. We filed in orderly ranks back into the student union building, which had a big assembly hall in the basement. The leaders went down there, so the rest of the march followed. There were several thousand students. The hall was packed. A very impromptu meeting started. People got up to speak. A chair was elected. We discussed the whole question of the march, why we had been stopped, and police brutality. The only ones with any clear idea of why it was all happening was the group of people around Michael Farrell.
Yet, I remember thinking at the time that these people were the Young Socialist Alliance. My Catholic training told me that these people were subversives. They were going to jump on this bandwagon and lead us all down the dreaded road to Communism, rape all the nuns, and burn all the chapels. So, I sat there listening to Farrell and thinking that what he was saying was right and that it was what I felt but also being very suspicious because it was Farrell who was saying it.
Bernadette Devlin McAliskey (DR) It was at that meeting that People's Democracy was constituted. It began as a very loose organization. It was decided that there would be another march. This was the first political meeting that I ever attended. I was sitting there like all the other people feeling excited about the march.
The question of filing for the march came up. And one after the other, the students who had organized the initial march got up and explained why they couldn't file for the next one themselves. Their fathers wouldn't allow it. The dean of their faculty would make trouble for them. I got so angry that I stood up in the middle of the crowd and said: I'll file for the march." I'm not sure why I did it. I think that it was an instinctive reaction. All these people who were making excuses were middle class kids to me. I had a gut reaction against them. They were all too nice to go any further now that the going was getting tough. And so I said: "I'll file for the march." I don't have anything to lose. And, of course, that was greeted with cheers and sighs of relief, that some idiot had been found who would do it. (The person "filing" for the march was legally responsible for anything resulting from it.)
COMBINATION OF NATIONALIST
AND WORKING CLASS TRADITIONS My personal background put me at the crossroads of the tendencies that were developing. I had absorbed the Irish revolutionary tradition as a child, but I grew up outside the world of the republican movement. Along with this, - gained a strong consciousness of being part of the working class and of the social and economic problems faced by working people in Northern Ireland.
I was the middle child of a family of six. My father died when I was about nine years old. What I remember most about him is that when he was home he
did not work, That was because there were no jobs in our area. The only work to be hand was in England.
My father, I suppose, was not typical of the men of his generation in that when he was not working, he helped a lot in the home. He took me to school as a child. It was my father who put us to bed and told us bedtime stories. As a child, though, I wasn't aware that the stories I was told were not the same that English children of my age would hear.
I was not brought up on the tales of Hans Christian Anderson or Little Red Riding Hood but on tales of the mythical Gaelie heroes Finn Mac Cumhail and Cuchullain, of the People of the Goddess Dana, the gifted ancient folk, who, it was told, retired under the hills when ironusing warriors first occupied our country. I was brought up on tales of the Irish struggle, of the Peep O'Day Boys, Connoily, and Larkin.
These stories were very simply told. It was not until I went to grammer school that I realized that I had been given a grounding in Irish history. It was not until I was an adult that I realized that I had been given a republican version of Irish history and a labour-oriented one as well. For an Irish child like me, getting a basic political education was as natural as growing up in an Irish family. It was part of this also that as a teenager I became interested in. Gaelie, the old language of our people, and came to spend my summers in west Donegal, where the continuity of the language and tradition has been maintained to this day. (This was contingent, of course, in the "education" system. Young nationalist/Catholic people not selected for "grammer" education had no such opportunity.)
The role of the language, by the way, indicates something about the way tradition works in Ireland. The Irish language and the lore and attitudes associated with it make up the oldest stratum of tradition in our country. But the language only really became a generally accepted part of nationalism in this century. It was made so by the generation that prepared the way for the 1916 rising and the war of independence.
More than any other leader of that generation, Patrick Pearse, the leader of the 1916 rising, was responsible for the fusion of the language question and nationalism. He explained what he thought about the role of the language in a speech he gave in 1913, called "The Coming Revolution"
"I have come to the conclusion that the Gaelic League, as the Gaelic League, is a spent force; and I am glad of it. I do not mean that no work remains for the Gaelic League, or that the Gaelic League is no longer equal to work; I mean that the vital work to be done in the new Ireland will be done not so much by the Gaelic League itself as by men and movements that have sprung from the Gaelic League or have received from the Gaelic League a new baptism and a new life of grace. The Gaelic League was no reed shaken by the wind, no mere vox cla-
26 mantis: it was a prophet and more than a experience of being a Catholic and a na- Catholie and a na. prophet. But it was not the Messiah. I tionalist in Northern Ireland but the prodo not know if the Messiah has yet come, blems of being dependent on the Welfare and I am not sure that there will be any State. It was not that we were povertyvisible and personal Messiah in this re- stricken in the worst sense of the word demption: the people itself will per- but that we had to go to the state bureauhaps be its own Messiah, the people la- cracy for clothing, food, education, shelbouring, scourged, crowned with thorns, ter, everything we needed to live. It may agonising and dying, to rise again immor- be, on the other hand, that because we tal and impassible. For peoples are divine were Catholics and nationalists, that we and are the only things that can properly were always part of the ungrateful poor, be spoken of under figures drawn from that we had a pride in ourselves and a feeling that we had been robbed and a the divine epos.
"If we do not believe in the divinity feeling of being morally superior to the of our people, we have had no business, power that had robbed us and now or very little, all these years in the Gaelic deigned to give us back a few necessities League. In fact, if we had not believed in of life. the divinity of our people, we should in I don't ever remember being grateall probability not have gone into the ful to that great body that gave us the Gaelic League at all. We should have money to keep going. What I remember made our peace with the devil, and per- is always resenting the bureaucracy, hathaps might have found him a very decent ing to have to go to that office and state sort; for he liberally rewards with how many pairs of shoes you possessed attorney generalships, bank balances, villa and whether or not you had a change of residences, and so forth, the great and the underwear so that they could decide whelittle who serve him well. Now, we did ther you needed more. Of course, they not turn our backs on all these desirable never believed you. And this bureaucracy things for the sake of is or ta [the two represented an alien power that had condifferent aspects of the verb "to be" in quered us and made us second-class citiGaelic]. We did it for the sake of Ireland. zens in our own country. In other words, we had one and all of us I was nurtured on stories about the (at least, I had, and I hope that all you evils of British rule. But in my case, like had) an ulterior motive in joining the that of most republicans as 1 later learned, not all these stories were about Gaelic League. We never meant to be Gaelic Leaguers. We meant to do some- what the British had done in Ireland. I thing for Ireland, each in his own way. was also told about the wrongs of British Our Gaelic League time was to our tute- rule in other countries. Our consciouslage: We had first to learn to know Ire- ness of our own oppression led us to symland, to read the lineaments of her face, pathize with other peoples who suffered to understand the accents of her voice; to similar wrongs. It gave us a basic groundrepossess ourselves, disinherited as we ing in practical internationalism. were, of her spirit and mind, re-enter into The history of the land agitation in our mystical birthright. For this we went the nineteenth century and the work of to school to the Gaelic League. It was a Connoily and Larkin in building the good school, and we love its name and modern Irish labour movement was interwill champion its fame throughout all the woven in my education with the older days of our later fighting and striving. traditions and myths. I learned it the But we do not propose to remain school- same way I learned the old songs, and the boys forever." new ones.
Thus, the language became part of My parents made me particularly the program that armed an entire genera- aware of being part of the working class. tion of Irish men and women for war, the My father came from a working-class war that established the principle of Irish background. But my mother did not. nationhood, although it failed to achieve She came from the lower middle class. real national liberation. Her people were farmers and shop-
But before my grandfather's time, keepers. It was generally considered in the Irish language and lore were not a my mother's family when I was a child major part of the national tradition for that she had married beneath herself. most Irish people. Our tradition is a My father was always looked down growing, constantly changing thing. Ideas on by my mother's side of the family.
accepted yesterday are So, our reaction was to identify particumixed up with the most ancient heritage larly strongly with our father, to take a of our people; and forgotten and half- special pride in his background. forgotten deeper layers are continually mother, who was a very unpolitical perbeing ploughed up and reincorporated son, reinforced that attitude in us after into the living tradition. In this way, the his death. She refused to rely on her Gaelic language and myths become a own people. She made us very aware of basic part of my education. the difference between them and us. We
I had reason to reflect on the na- were working people. What we looked to ture of the Irish nationalist tradition in order to improve our situation was later in my life when I had to deal with education. That led me to the university. the main organizational embodiment of It made me a very serious student. But it this tradition-the Irish republican move- led me finally further than that, into involvement in the Irish struggle for freement.
However, what made the strongest dom, into becoming a conscious workingimpression on me growing up was not the class revolutionist, a Marxist.