International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Dissident Movement in the USSR

· International Viewpoint No. 12, 2 August 1982 · pp 7-9 · 3,057 words

Soviet Union Eastern Europe Repression and political prisoners

The tasks and responsibilities that fall on us today are incomparably greater than they were before this campaign. To give impetus to the struggles of the workers and the peasants who have been hard hit by the government's policies, to represent these masses at the national level and in parliament, to build mass solidarity with our comrades in Central America, to build the party of revolutionists that the exploited people of Mexico need, for all these tasks these new forces are desperately needed. w dissident mov

LAST ISSUE UNTIL SEPTEMBER This is the last issue of International Viewpoint before the summer break. The first issue after the break will be dated September 20. It will contain a major article by Ernest Mandel on the developing threat of imperialist war and the growth of the anti-war movement.

This appeal is particularly directed to all those readers who took out the introductory special subscription. This issue is the last of that offer. Don't miss the next one. ement emerges ir Laetitia CAVAIGNALS

On Tuesday, April 6, in Moscow, agents of the Soviet bureaucracy carried out rather widespread raids in "dissident" circles. In all, fifty searches were carried out, and twelve persons were arrested. The silence in Western Europe about this repressive operation shows how long gone are the days of the hypocritical sermons about human rights, accompanied by the shedding of many tears about the fate of the opposition in the USSR.

Another factor in this silence, perhaps, is that there were no well known personalities among those arrested, such as Andrei Sakharov or others. They were people like Andrei Fadin, Boris Kagarlitski, Yuri Khavkin, Pavel Kudyukin, and Vladimir Chernitski.

In their apartments, considerable literature was found. This included issues of the samizdat magazine Socialism and the Future, an appeal to the Italian Communist party made in the name of this magazine, documents on Poland, the replies of the

I the USSR Polish Workers (published below in a box). This material was confiscated.

These five "nobodies" were jailed in Lefortovo prison, probably charged on the basis of Article 70 of the Soviet penal code, which is unusual for a first offense. In accordance with this article, they face seven years in a prison camp and five years internal exile.

The following article points up the changes that have been occurring in the dissident movement and the repression that it faces. It shows also that support for the democratic movement in the USSR is important for more than humanist or moral reasons. It is becoming more than ever a political necessity. In fact, the repression is coming down not just against people "who think differently" (the literal translation of the word dissident in Russian) but also against people who are fighting to achieve genuine socialism.

The inspiring fight that they are waging has to be matched editors of Variants to questions posed by 'Alternative, issues of the magazine Left

A few lines sometimes have more value and meaning than a long speech or a spectacular action. This is true, for example, of the Statement to the Polish Workers that is published below.

This statement is both an exemplary declaration and an act of solidarity. It does not limit itself to evoking feelings of enthusiasm and admiration. It does 8 the French magazine by an equally inspiring international campaign of solidarity with

Turn, the Appeal to them.

and expresses more, particularly about facts of life in the Soviet Union that are ignored by the mass media. These lines alone are enough to explode all the accepted Sovietology and the cliches about the dissident movement.

One of the first things about it is that it represents a postmortem of the dissident movement itself. The opposition in the USSR has in fact been buried in the same coffin as the detente policy. Nonetheless, there has never been such systematic repression in the Brezhnev period as there is todaymarrests and sentences are almost daily events.

In the West, the hypocritical tearjerking speeches about the dissidents have been followed quite quickly by indifference. The silence that has now fallen on the oppositionists in the USSR is reveal.

Unofficial Soviet Historian Roy Meduedev (DR) ing of two things: First, it says a lot about Jimmy Carter-type professions of "humanitarian" concern. The chess game between states in which they were pawns, has been dropped. But, most of all, this silence points up a profound inability to analyze the nature of dissidence in Soviet society.

The dissident movement was not simply the appearance of a variable but always limited number of conscious individuals. What it represented was a reflection of real and profound processes at work in Soviet society. In this respect, the dissident movement cannot be crushed for a long period. Without an understanding of this fact, it would be impossible to see and predict that, in the face of repression, the democratic move. ment would inevitably undergo a recomposition that would require other forms of organisation and action. This appeal for solidarity with the Polish workers is a tangible sign of this.

A NEW OPPOSITION CURRENT However, in reading the statement, the clearest break from the past that shows up is on the political level. It puts in perspective the picture of a Soviet opposition that, marked by the experience of fifty years of Stalinism, tended to reject everything connected with the word "socialism." This view was also promoted to a considerable extent by the Western press, which played it up. The opposition that fitted this picture was centered either on programs for moral regeneration or activity deliberately kept limited to defending human rights.

Now, it is no longer possible to identify the opposition as a whole with the big names such as Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn and Andrei Sakharov.

It was this one-sided view, moreover, that led to the presentation of a distorted imade of "Poland no riowad distorted image of "Poland as viewed from the Soviet Union." No alternative current was seen. People talked about either a sympathetic current, but one that seemed to observe the events in Poland through a telescope (Poland is another "planet," it has another history, another sort of working class; therefore, its experience has little meaning for the USSR); or a bitterly hostile current, open to nationalist and stomach-centered" arguments (these Poles, they go on strike and we have to feed them; that's why there isn't anything in our stores anymore).

But these Soviet dissidents not only express their solidarity with the Polish workers but also their "hope and confidence" in them. In this respect, it is important to point up a very significant detail, which represents another break from the past in this appeal. It is deliberately left unsigned.

We have become used to general statements by the opposition, almost always associated with familiar faces, signed by "big names." But here we have a concise, explicit, and committed statement, but a faceless one. And this fact must not be interpreted only as a technical and tactical response to the repression of recent years. It is the reflection of a new political decision.

All these features, which mark a clear difference from the conceptions of the "traditional" dissidents, are worth pointing up precisely because they are new. However, we cannot avoid the conclusion that it would be wrong to think that something unusual is necessarily "accidental." It would be wrong to think that the authors of this anonymous statement are exceptional individuals who have miraculously remained exempt from the laws that shape the lives of Soviet citizens, the imprint left by history on them. It would be wrong to think that they are atypical dissidents.

This statement, which indicates the rise of a new opposition current in the Soviet literary figure Andrei Sinyausky, persecuted for his ideas in the 1960s (DR)

USSR, in fact represents a balance sheet.

And balance sheet means an experience.

If this new current represents a break

With the decimated generation of oppositionists from the 1970s, this does not mean that the new current should be counterposed to them. This break could only have taken place on the basis of a balance sheet of the experience and activity of the dissidents in the 1970s.

This balance sheet, which in fact marks a new departure, is not, it should be stressed, a balance sheet of the repression. Such a balance sheet would have served only to bring on repression. It is an expression of political reflection, which could not have developed without the gains and experience of the democratic movement in the preceeding years.

Doubtless, it is still too early to define this new "post-human rights" generation. It seems possible, however, to see a number of projects related to the start of this new thinking. One is free unions. This represents a clear decision not to separate economic problems and demands from the question of human rights. Another is the Moscow magazine Poiski, which was aimed at bringing together the various democratic currents so as to make it possible to work out a program.

More generally, there is the development of "associations," such as the Initiative Group for the Defense of the Rights of Invalids, the Federation of Free Trade Unions (SMOT), the almanach Women and Russia in Leningrad. In fact, the logic of these organizations, which no longer have as their goal a "vague" defense of human rights but the defense of certain specific categories of citizens meant the emergence at a certain point of a political alternative, an alternative conception of organizing society.

REFLECTION ON THE PAST It is only now that such reflection is assuming a definite form, a better defined political form. This is being expressed in several new samizdat journals, the majority of which criticize the Soviet regime from a socialist point of view. The names that might be cited are Poedinok ("Duel"), Levyi Povorot ("Left turn"), Sotsialism i Budushche ("Socialism and the Future"). We might also mention the Initative Group for People's Democracy. But the most important thing is to look at the main lines emerging in this new "Results and Prospects."

In the first place, there is a definite end to the illusions created by the Twentieth Congress of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union in February 1956 about the government. It took more than a decade to get rid of these illusions, which were given impetus by the so-called return to "Leninist legality" for which the Twentieth Congress was supposed to have opened the road. In this sense, such hopes, illusory as they were, were a political factor, and helped promote the development of opposition Marxist currents.

Later, when the opposition understood that the ending of mass terror did not mean the ending of repression (it simply became more refined and rational) but was designed to provide security for the bureaucratic caste, when they understood that this caste would defend its monopoly of power with teeth and claws, this "oppositionist legalism"-which sought to gain the ear of the government, to "influence, change, warn" in order to change its policy-became a constitutionalism.

Thus, the movement advocated "limiting the struggle to exposing the abuses of the government, its violation of its own laws (1)." In exchange for this self-limitation, it hoped to achieve a certain legality. The results of this effort are now clear. One was repression that forced the human rights movement on the defensive. Another was a logic, arising out of the detente policy, which impelled the movement to direct all its activities and energies toward the West.

It is only now that these "new wave" oppositionists are coming to a clear understanding of the price that had to be paid for such an orientation, and that is what represents a real balance sheet. The legalism that was supposed to be nonpolitical concentrated on talking to the government and made the movement almost totally dependent on the Western press. Most of all, it placed it "hopelessly outside of Soviet society.

This is the analysis in particular of the editors of the magazine Variants (who claim to have a Social Democrat, socialist, and "Eurocommunist" orientation). For example, they say: "The fact is, and we can only deplore it, a neighborhood party secretary is incomparably closer to daily reality than Andrei Sakharov and the Group to Monitor the Application of the Helsinki Accords.

The dissident movement found that it was largely closed in on itself and almost totally cut off from the masses and their concerns. The masses, bludgeoned by the regime's argument "It's them (the West) or us," lined up almost entirely behind the category "us.

Thus, drawing a critical balance sheet of a weakened, ineffective dissident movement living an enclosed life, that "politically disarmed itself vis-a-vis the government," the new oppositionists lay out the general framework for a new orientation.

Their objective is no longer to obtain certain legal rights from the government. They have stopped entirely directing their appeals to it. The days of begging are over. They no longer make it their ultimate goal to make an impact in the Western press and gain the support of international public opinion. It is in this regard that their "faceless statement" takes on a political meaning.

Their objective quite clearly is not to orient themselves any longer toward the government and the Western regimes but "toward the masses. " The way out of the crisis of the dissident movement is to create "in the near future various political organizations and to direct them to *the people on the bottom' with concrete social programs." It is on this basis that the new forms of opposition are developing.

And this orientation requires in turn breaking with the conception of dissidents as "martyr enthusiasts," which unquestionably puts off the masses (2), breaking with the conception of "professional dissidents" who in daily life and their activity are not integrated into the life of the society.

So, the "new wave" are in favor of reintegrating dissidents into the society but also of a political reintegration, whose terms are still to be defined:

"Of course, we have to grow a lot more to reach the Polish level, but for us the main lesson to be drawn is the following: We have to try to find foundations for our activity in the real needs of the society (defined not 'in a general way' but on the basis of precise studies), by putting forward achievable programs. What we need is not a purely moral opposition or a reactionary utopian or communist utopian one. We need an opposition based on concrete social and political questions."

Thus, this emerging current, which says that "the foundamental task is to bring together all supporters of democracy and socialism" seems to be a promising successor to the dissident movement of the 1970s. This is undoubtedly the way that the "authoritative bodies" of the state also saw it. The only conceivable response from the bureaucracy was not long in coming.

Frightened by the Polish events, mired down in Afghanistan, incapable of remedying the growing economic difficulties, the bureaucracy finds itself obliged to lash out in a clumsy and unwontedly precipitate way. This is amply demonstrated by the recent measures severely restricting communication with the West, as well as by the extent of the police raids and the severity of the charges against those hauled in. 1. This quotation as well as the following ones are taken from the interview with the editors of the magazine Variants, which appeared in issue No. 15 (March-April 1982) of l'Alternative, published in Paris. 2. In this respect, it is instructive to compare the statement published here with that of the editors of Poiski i Razyshlenia, published in Moscow in January 1981 under the title "How Shameful It is To Be Russian," which was republished in French in issue No. 12 (January 1981) of l'Alternative. 1. Aleksandr Ivanovich Herzen (18121870), born in Moscow, died in Paris. Editor of the first oppositionist Russian magazine, the Polar Star, later the Bell. A populist pan-Slav democrat.

DECLARATION TO THE POLISH WORKERS

Dear Polish comrades, friends, brothers, and sisters,

Today when your country is passing through a difficult period, we send you this statement expressing our admiration and our solidarity. There is very little that we can do to help you; we can only place our hopes and our confidence in you.

Today, after a year and a half of revolution, the gains of the Polish working class, recognized by the Gdansk agreements and consolidated by the consistent struggle of the workers, are threatened.

The experience of history teaches us that when reaction suffers a defeat, it is quick to resort to military force. The terrible threat of military dictatorship hangs over Poland.

We are with you, friends!

All of us are with you in the public squares of Warsaw and Gdansk, in the factories in Katowice and Lodz, and in the prisons where the KOR socialists and leaders of Solidarnose are languishing.

We are there, where for the first time in history a people has dealt a severe blow to a totalitarian regime, to a puppet regime. We believe that the workers can counter the force of bayonets and tanks with the power of their organization and their unity.

What happened in Hungary and in Chile must not be repeated in Poland.

We believe in the Polish working class, in its capacity to defend its gains.

Today you are in the vanguard of the world workers movement, in the first ranks of those fighting for a democratic socialism. A defeat for Solidarnose would be a catastrophe for the progressive forces of the entire world.

We socialists, Social Democrats, and honest people in Russia join with the millions of people who hope for your victory.

We repeat the prophetic words of Herzen (1): There are no longer frontiers between Russia and Poland. But Europe knows what Poland represents. It is a nation abandoned by all to a fight against impossible odds, which has since shed rivers of blood on every battlefield where peoples have fought for their freedom.

Everyone knows this people.

Poland can be destroyed but it cannot be forced to accept subjection.

-Long live the heroic Polish workers!

-Long live Solidarnose!

-Long live democratic socialism!

-For your freedom and ours!

SOVIET DISSIDENTS

December 14, 1981

(from the Bulletin "News From the USSR," edited by Kronid Lyubarski,

Munich, June-July 1982.)

10

← Mexican Trotskyists' Breakthrough — Interview with Edgar Sanchez · After the Elections in Mauritius →

Something wrong on this page?