International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Poland Special: Documents

International Viewpoint No. 66, 24 December 1984 · pp 17-26 · 10,883 words

This article was cut at the top of the page the printed contents gives it, because its headline could not be found in the machine-read text. Its opening may carry the end of the article before it.

Eastern Europe Soviet Union

NIEZALEZNE SAMORZADNE ZWIAZKI ZANODOWE SOLDARIOSC GWARANTEM. ODNOWY KRAJU for the renewal of the country.' (DR) March 1981: Independent and self-managed trade unions — Solidarnose - are the guarantee

A reply to charter 84 In April and May 1984 the text of a mysterious document entitled 'Charter 84' was circulated by Radio Free Europe. Apparently put out by the underground trade-union commission (TKZ) of Solidarnosc in the Lenin shipyards in Gdansk, this document has a distinctly nationalistic and clerical flavour to it. The authenticity of the document has been neither confirmed nor denied by the commission in question. Charter 84 was ignored by practically the entire underground press of Solidarnosc but it excited a violent reaction on the part of the weekly Kos, paper of the Committee for Social Resistance (KOS). Among other criticisms mainly addressed to Radio Free Europe the paper published a lengthy analysis of Charter 84 written by one of the main organisers of KOS known under the pseudonym of Dawid Warsawski. Below we reproduce extracts from this article.

Secondly, our incorporation in the

Western cultural world led to accepting certain "certain concepts and institutions in the social and political spheres."

Thanks to these, we are aware of the possibility of "a social order called democracy, which means the state has to recognize the rights of the society, and of a type of state called a republic, which belongs to all citizens." This is supposed to be why "Poland did not set out a course of expansion and enslavement, and why "here it never came to the rule of the army, the police or a bureaucracy."

Next, the authors of the Charter proceed to characterize those to whom the appeal is directed. They base themselves "on the most recent events, thus, on the period in which, in our opinion, you showed your nature most clearly." The events in question concern solely "Polish-Soviet relations."

"When, in an attempt to save the ...

country, working people formed Solidarnose, you decided that the course of events in Poland had to be reversed, and the ruling group subservient to you in one night trampled on the accord reached in August." The authors conclude: "You did not permit us workers and farmers to have even a share in the running of our country." They then proceed to make an indictment.

"We accuse you of doing everything possible to reduce us to being your slaves." «You are trying to block off our own course of historical development." "You are trying to take God out of our lives." "You want to drag us into the pit of your moral degradation." "You want to cut us off from the rest of our Western cultural world." "You are dragging us down to the level of your own backwardness." And so on.

"We accuse you, finally," the authors write," of having the ultimate responsi bility for all the shooting that led to our already blood-soaked soil being steeped with the blood of the workers.

The TKZ document goes on, picking up an earlier thread:

"You justify all this generally by saying that it is part of the established realities created by war. "However," the authors continue, "we do not feel bound by the decisions...that created those realities."

In summary, the document compares the strength of both sides and concludes: "In terms of physical force, you have the advantage...but the situation is reversed as regards moral strength. It is you who are afraid that your society will become infected with our spirit of freedom. You are afraid of all free nations...and above all of your own countrymen, those noble Russians who not only perceive the truth but who are more and more prepared to suffer for it."

The authors end by saying, "History is knocking at your door. Today, it is only knocking; tomorrow it will bang with its fists."

This is indeed a strange document. In it there is a mixture of political naivete toward the West, dizzy glorification of

17

Dawid WARSZAWSKI

Charter 84 is made up of three sections. "An Appeal to Poles at Home and Abroad," "An Appeal to the Governments of the USA and Great Britain," and "An Appeal to the Russians, That,; All the Citizens of the Soviet Union."

The "Appeal to the Poles" concludes that "our strivings for independence are now gaining extraordinarily in purposefulness." On the other hand, "while the Russians keep trying to force their disastrous domination over us, we hesitate to let them know clearly what is on our mind."

The contents are as follows: In the .... "Appeal to Governments," "the signatures the Western governments we read set on the Yalta Accords have served as tombstones weighing more and more heavily on the drow of Do t heavily on the grave of Polish freedom International Viewpoint 24 December 1984 and sovereignty. Indeed, they create the impression that the "Soviet Union is not the guard of the East European prison house of peoples but rather the maintainer oflaw and order."

The authors of the Charter say that failure to oppose the "Sovietization of East Europe" could help to open up the way for Russia to "swallow up the West altogether."

The main part of the document is,

The main part of the document is, however, the "Appeal to the Russians. In the introduction, the authors stress that Poland's historical distinctiveness is due to two factors - its acceptance of Christianity from Rome and, with that, its incorporation into the world of Western culture. The first instilled into Polish consciousness the conviction of "the inviolable dignity of the human personality" and that "human beings are desti zed to live in freedom."

our own past and present, and all in the context of arrogance toward the East. This is the stuff of all the nightmares in Polish political life, starting from the attitude toward the Uniates (1) and concluding with the demagoguery of the Confederation for an Independent Poland.

To be sure, this melange is the last refuge of Polishness in moments of peril, but it is only one more nightmare. The fact that this view has gained the endorsement of what is certainly the most important TKZ in Poland is both significant and deeply disturbing. Therefore, we must make a logical analysis of the contents of the Charter.

The basic idea is, of course, valid and important. The ultimate aim of our fight is regaining our independence. And we should speak clearly about this, even if immediate tactical considerations make it advisable to avoid raising this question in the union's official documents. Mobilizing Polish public opinion around this question at home and, above all, abroad is a very important and badly neglected task of our work. It deserves every support.

Moreover, the view that the Yalta agreements are a basic source of our misfortunes is quite correct, if you consider Yalta as the conclusion of a certain historical process.

From the West they want a repudiation of the Yalta agreement. From the East, they want recognition of the bases of Poland's distinetiveness, hoping no doubt that it will relinquish Poland, stricken with the pangs of guilt and repentance. It is striking that the TKZ directs its appeal to the Western governments on the one hand but to the citizens of the USSR on the other, and not the other way around.

In both the USA and Great Britain power is exercised, and was exercized at the time of Yalta, by democratic governments answerable to their own societies.

It is incomprehensible that appeals on this question should be addressed to governments. Today, as forty years ago, our bondage is the price the West pays for the sake of its own tranquility. There is little to indicate that they have come to think that this deal has ceased to be profitable for them, although lately there have been some new and promising political moves on the question....

The most astonishing section of the Charter, however, is concerned with the . East and not the West. The title alone is mind-boggling. "An Appeal to the Russians, That is, All the Citizens of the Soviet Union." They choose to ignore the existence of the Estonians, Latvians, Lithuanians, White Russians and Ukrainians, to mention only our nearest neighbors. And that's not the worst of it. They submit their grievances about the West to the governments, since the peoples of course love Poland and would not let any harm be done to it except through inadvertence. But they have the audacity to turn to the Soviet citizens and accuse them of crimes committed 18

ZETAZA (7MMHEК 2 280к MA CHI

NI TEL by their regime, a regime that before moving against Poland managed to slaughter about 15 million of its own citizens....

The picture of our country that emerges from this TKZ document is a dishonest glorification. We do not have any reason to be ashamed of our history. In comparison with other European countries and especially our neighbors, we come out quite well. As to whether "Poland never set out on the road of expansionism," the Ukrainians and Lithuanians should be asked about that. As to whether, "it never came to rule by the army here, " the victims of Brzesc [the concentration camp set up by the dictator Pilsudski] and of the pacifications in eastern Poland [repression of Ukrainian peasant protests in 1930] should be asked about that.

The worst thing is not so much that this picture is a false one but that the authors of the Charter seem sincerely to believe in it. That is the only way to explain the curious "indictment" they make, blaming everything that has happened in the People's Republic of Poland on the Russians. But it was Poles who fired on the workers in 1956, 1970 and 1981. It was Poles — heirs of democratic and republican traditions - who made workers run the gauntlet in police stations, who slandered defenseless people in the press, who tormented people in Barczewo prison. We could go on and on adding to the list, but this is not the point.

It is an obvious fact that the ultimate source of power in the People's Republic of Poland lies in Moscow. At the time, it is Poles who rule Poland, and with a considerable freedom of maneuver....

Moreover, it is not true that the citizens of the present USSR never fought for democracy. From the nineteenth century conspiracies through the revolutions of 1905 and February 1917, the civil war, the long tradition of anti-Communist guerrilla warfare (lasting in some regions up to the 1950s) prove, if any proof were needed, that these people are no less attached to the "distinctively Polish and Western" traditions of democracy and republicanism than any other nation. Nor has this involved only isolated cases, as the authors of the Charter suggest. Moreover, considering the incomparably higher level of repression there, I would like to be able to believe that in a similar situation, if it came to that, that we would be able to stand up as well....

It seems that the anti-Polish policies of the Czarist and Soviet authorities were and are still being carried out with the full approval of the population. But before getting carried away by righteous anger, we might recall the partition of the Ukraine between Poland and the Soviets by the Treaty of Riga [which concluded the Soviet-Polish war in 1921] and the fate of the Ukrainian minority in Poland in the past, as well as the fate of the colonial empires of the western democracies, the price that India or Algeria had to pay for its independence. Unfortunately, chauvinism is not something peculiar to autocracies....

The Charter's rhetoric is such that if the Soviets were to distribute it on a mass scale, it would efface the deep impact produced by the Appeal to the Nations of Eastern Europe issued by the First Delegate Conference of Solidarnosc [in September 1981]. What is more, would seriously compromise the Solidarnosc movement as a whole.

The publication of this Charter is not only morally reprehensible but a display of the most incredible political stupidity. If, to use the language of the authors of this document, history is knocking at someone's door, this can only mean the "knocking of Solidarnos" on the gates of the Kremlin. If history ever "pounds" there, it will only be with the fists of these so scorned, "degraded" Russian people.

Therefore, in my opinion, the Interim Regional Executive Committee in the Gdansk region should take an official stand on this document and distance itself from the contents. I also think that this matter should be discussed in the entire underground press and in the movement for Independent Education. Indeed, there are few matters so crucial for our future as whether the Soviet authorities will be able to keep alive the antagonism between the "Polaks" and the "Ruskis" and thereby prevent these two nations from turning against their common enemy. tradition teso ee part of the Roman Catholic Uniates are catholics of oriental (Greek) church. In the sixteenth century in Poland the Greek-catholic church in the Eastern territories (mostly Ukrainian) annexed by Poland were incorporated into the Roman Catholic church. The catholics of Greek tradition were the victims of discrimination by the feudal state in Poland which forced the unification on them in the framework of suppressing the aspiration of Ukrainian nationalists.

International Viewpoint 24 December 1984

'Jaruzelski does not defend socialism' Below we publish two texts by the Robotnik group. The first appeared in January 1984 and explains the view of this group on the need for political discussion within Solidarnosc. It is in this context that Robotnik asserts that 'among political currents there is room for a socialist current.' Although this is not apparent in the following article, this group nevertheless idealises European social democracy a great deal. The second article declares itself in favour of the reconstruction of the Polish Socialist Party (PPS).

that the repressive measures they use. and the exploitation of waged work in tve measures they use, the factories they direct, are anti-worker and anti-socialist.

Our task, the task of Polish socialists in the 1980s, is the political and economic struggle within the trade union and political parties. It is to take up the ideas and expressions for which Ludwik Warynski and Janek Wisniewski (1), the workers of the Paris Commune, and the Polish workers of the shipyard 'Paris Commune' gave their lives. The first step on this path is to take back our workers' festival of May 1. The next step will be the creation of socialist grouns that

Igor LEWY

Just before the December events,

Jaruzelski's propagandists thought up the slogan We will defend socialism as we do the independence of our country. There is little doubt that, for most people in

Poland, the second half of the equation is a lie. The country is not independent, and therefore there is no independence to defend. But this slogan contains a further falsification: the pretence that Jaruzelski and the apparatus defend socialism.

This cannot be, since socialism does not exist in Poland, any more than independence does. Socialism is not some kind of ideal state. It is not a system that can be decreed to exist, in order to defend it later. There are no socialist states in the world, there are only states that are more or less constituted in accordance with socialist principles. There are certain institutional gains won in struggles by the socialist and workers' movements, such as the 8-hour day, social security, en forms of dirt parliamentary democracy or even differ. forms of direct democracy, ay macy or even differworkers' councils or the system of internal democracy in trade unions, as existed in Solidarnose before December

13, 1981.

All visions of an ideal system in which we are asked to believe, which are supposedly sufficient to make us happy, bring in their wake a dictatorship of one or another skilful ideological group, trying to legitimise their power by basing it on their own supposed infallibility.

The Polish workers' movement that organised itself into free trade unions at the end of the 1970s, still exists and has grown since the December coup by Jaruzelski. It is a truly democratic movethe struggles against the system of econ- ment, born of the rank and file, that leads a can tand te that leads omic exploitation and political enslavement that exists in Poland. The December defeat convinced all the working people of Poland that victory cannot be won in this struggle through negotiation, that the enemy will only bend when forced to do so, and that the only power that could so force it is the workplace and inter-workplace structures of Solidarnose, backed up by its system of publications and clandestine education programmes.

Today, as new political programmes are continually put forward, the SolidarInternational Viewpoint 24 December 1984 International Violini.

nose movement faces two essential tasks. The first is to break with the artificial notion of unity of thought, and constitute different political currents. The second, just as important, is to preserve within the framework of Solidarnose the united front in struggle of different political currents, to achieve aims as elementary as that of the foundation of real direct democracy, that is to say, the implementation of the programme of the self-managed republic.

Among these political currents, there is certainly room for a socialist current. To be a socialist in the People's Republic of Poland and to argue for the principles of socialism is a particularly difficult and important task. The so-called socialists of the Polish United Workers Party (PUWP), who call themselves communists, have not only taken our national property but have also illegitimately appropriated the traditions and demands of the socialist movement. Their regime is essentially anti-worker, in the same way

SOLARN

ZWIAZEK ZAWODOWY NIEZALEZHY SAMORZADNY bile creation ot socialist groups that, in discussion and in struggle, will determine the forms of the Polish socialist movement.

We are facing the task of building a free Poland, in which an elementary sense of justice will be linked with modernism, the effective functioning of the enterprises and the whole of the self-managed economy. There is not such a state in existence in the world. But we can, through our unremitting work and our struggle, move towards such an ideal. Socialism is a movement and a way of thinking of the future, and not the automatic realisation of a vision thought up by doctrinaires.

Robotnik, No 45, Warsaw, January 30, 1984 first workers' party in Poland in 1882, the Pro- Ludwik Warynski was the founder of the letaryat. Janek Wisniewski was a worker. He was murdered in 1970 in Gdynia and then his body was taken by demonstrators all round the town. He became a symbol for all those who struggled from December 1970 to January 1971.

Meeting with Lech Walesa in Wroclaw, July 1981 (DR)

The road to a new party

Jan MORAWSKI

In many social circles the question -should the Polish Socialist Party (PPS) be resuscitated and if so, when? - is being raised. The forced unification between the Polish Socialist Party and the Polish Workers Party (PPR) in 1948(1) was nothing but the liquidation of the humanist, liberal and democratic current of Polish socialism. The banning of legal activity by opposition parties - contrary to the constitution - since 1947 has led to a situation where free discussion of state affairs has been made impossible. Many people have lost the ability to decide their own ideological identity. It is only thanks to August [1980] and Solidarnose that it has become possible to distinguish a social democrat from a Christian democrat, a liberal from a communist. This legacy must be safeguarded. It is a moral obligation for us to founded at the beginning of 1943 by Stalinists 1. The Polish Workers Party (PPR) was in 1948 with the PPS which the Stalinists had parachuted in from Moscow. The PPR fused taken over.

19

develop this ideological gain and organisational experience. Political parties will undoubtedly be the natural form of development of the democratic and libertarian ideas of August.

But it is a long road to the reconstruction of the PPS. To have political strength and authority it would have to have several hundred thousand members at least, and its leaders and programme would have to be widely known. To reach that point, we still need many months of hard work. Impatient and premature attempts now could harm the possibilities of future expansion of the party. This is why the task on the agenda now is to develop cooperation between the independent editors and journals, as well as discussion on different aspects of the alternative programme to the policies of the PUWP, a programme of democratic socialism adapted to the real conditions of the end of the twentieth century. Democratic socialism should therefore be first of all constituted as a current within the existing structures of Solidarnosc. First of all, we have to elaborate a clear vision in the discussions of parliamentary democracy and self-managed democracy as well as the numerous conceptions of economic and social policies that are indispensable for Poland to emerge from the crisis, and avoid the danger of a further retreat of civilisation. We need, not a declaration of principles of a few pages, as for example already exists in the documents of the WSN [see the introduction to the dossier] but developed programmes that really express the interests of the workers. We should have more ideas than necessary in relation to our needs, and the possibilities of implementing them. Only on this condition will we have the moral right to demand a new distribution of political power in the state, and the introduction of new management principles.

For the time being, we still do not have this overabundance of ideas, nor do we even have enough. Nor are there established links between activists or a socialist or social-democratic orientation. We still have, therefore, a lot of work and consistent effort ahead. Every mistake and inconsistent action by the elite in power increases our chances. But their weakness must not be the main source of our strength. An alternative conception of the system could only be serious and expect a kindly interest from the international social-democratic movement if it is based on the Polish experiences, on our internal traditions.

If this work is carried out during 1984, then perhaps the political council of the reborn PPS could appear publicly from the beginning of 1985. Only an open, public presentation of the socialist alternative by people of public esteem, and known for their commitment to democratic socialism would be a challenge of historic importance.

Robotnik, No 44, Warsaw, January 23, 1984

20

Perspectives of a current of the revolutionary left The article we publish below appeared in July 1984 in bulletin No 20 of Wolny Robotnik (Free Worker), the organ of the Union of Workers Councils, National Resistance Movement (ZRP-PRO) of the region of Silesia. This text was preceded by the following introduction.

The abridged version of the article which follows is an introduction to a discussion aimed at working out concrete forms of action. This is a subject to which we have returned more than once in our columns in order to explain the views and conceptions of the PRO. The editorial board is in full agreement with the ideas of the authors in the article published below. The latter estimates that the criticisms levelled at the editorial board of the journal Robotnik, which we have been collaborating with for some time, do not constitute an attack on a political adversary but are rather an attempt to promote a concrete discussion on the perspectives for the Polish left in the as well as the international level.

Robotnik, the Warsaw journal, published an article at the beginning of the year entitled "The road to a new party' (see page 19). The article begins in the following way: "In many social circles the question - should the Polish Socialist Party (PPS) be resuscitated and if so, when? — is being raised.'

The first part of the question, that is, should the PPS be resuscitated, has indeed been raised by some activists in Solidarnosc. This is an important question and implies another to which we absolutely must find a reply: What are the perspectives for the Polish left? Or, more directly: What are the perspectives for the revolutionary current within the Polish opposition movement?

To avoid any misunderstanding let us define straight away the main characteristies of this current. They are that it struggles for the revolutionary overthrow of the current system of power and for its replacement by a self-managed republic. It sees the working class as the motor force of such a revolution. It upholds the traditions of revolutionary thought of the workers' movement, counterposing workers' control and socialism as the alternative to the current Stalinist system.

Although still limited in strength, such a revolutionary current exists in Poland and is struggling within the structures of Solidarnosc. Its views find a growing echo among members of the opposition. Many of the latter would never define their views as revolutionary or to the left, but they, nevertheless, support the main proposals of the revolutionary current. This is because, in their eyes, these positions best answer the political situation in Poland and the conditions in which the working class finds itself.

The journal Robotnik has a clear and simple vision of the future of the Polish left: it will be necessary to reconstruct the PPS and to make it into a social democratic party. The first error of the current situation, on the national editorial board of Robotnik lies in the way they pose the question of organising the left. For these authors, the party - in the case the PPS — is the only possible solution to the problems of organisation, and its construction must be undertaken immediately. And this must be done in several ways, mainly from above, by people with some social standing, who are known for their contribution to the cause of democratic socialism, presenting the socialist alternative.

The article in question states that 'the task on the agenda now is to develop cooperation between the independent editors and journals, as well as discussions of different aspects of an alternative programme to the policy of the PUWP, a programme of democratic socialism

NO

International Viewpoint 24 December 1984

suited to the real conditions at the end of the twentieth century."

Unfortunately, we will not construct a workers' party with just an alternative programme to that of the PUWP. It is not this sort of programme that we need but a programme of struggle against the

PUW and the bureaucracy.

It is significant that the articles on programme and organisation published in

Robotnik fail totally to mention the problems of the present struggle of the working class and of the strategy that the structures of Solidarnose should adopt. For the authors of Robotnik there is a complete separation between on the one hand, the party and the programme, and on the other the perspectives for the struggle against the authorities.

Viewed from this standpoint, the problem of building a new organisation of the left no doubt seems very simple.

But this is just an illusion. The building of an organisation is not just a matter of raising a slogan 'Build the PPS' and putting out an attractive programme.

On the contrary, it is necessary to combine two levels of activity, to draw up a class-struggle programme and, on this basis, to build an organisation of the most active militants. Posing the question of whether it would be useful today to resuscitate the PPS, without raising the question of the role that this party should play in the perspective of overthrowing the totalitarian bureaucracy cannot amount to more than an abstract exercise. That is, unless the party they mean is one made up of a small group of intellectual dreamers....But we know that this is not the sort of party under discussion.

The second major error committed by the editorial board of Robotnik has to do with the political character of any new party. The name itself - Polish Socialist Party - is not crucial. But the assertion that the new organisation of the left must have a social-democratic outlook involves a misunderstanding.

In fact, there are many political ideas put forward in Robotnik that are in direct contradiction, and justifiably so, to the programme and the practice of social democracy. Nonetheless, the authors of the articles published in this journal not only state that social democracy must be the political creed of a future PPS, but they are full of praises for the achievements and work of these Western social-democratic parties.

In another article, the author draws the attention of the reader to the intrinsic stability of the capitalist system, comparing it to the instability of the Polish system. Then drawing the conclusion that 'the communists and their system cannot be negotiating partners for the PPS comparable to what the capitalist system is for the Western social democrats?

Such a gross oversimplification cannot be allowed to pass without comment. The capitalist system is not merely in partnership with the West European social democrats. These parties are integrated into the system; they provide an International Viewpoint 24 December 1984 indispensable safety valve, defusing the spontaneous uprisings of the working class and diverting social protest into the parliamentary road.

Moreover, the main leaders of these

Western social democratic parties often occupy leading posts in the banks and in the large capitalist enterprises. It would be more accurate to compare the Wester social democrats to the liberal currents in the PUWP. Like them, the

Western social democrats criticise certain isolated socio-economic phenomena whilst fiercely defending the system itself.

Is the Robotnik editorial board trying to fool its readers or fool itself? Because in other articles about the current situation in Poland and about the problems of the opposition movement, one finds ideas that are a million miles away from the reformist conceptions of social democracy. ...the task of Polish socialists in the 1980s is... to take up the watchwords and ideals for which Ludwik Warynski and Janek Wisniewski, the workers of the Paris Commune, and the Polish workers of the Paris Commune shipyard gave their lives , Igor Lewy wrote in an article reaffirming that Jaruzelski is no defender of socialism (see page 19).

In another article, the same author talks about 'a total transformation of the power system' , because 'no compromise is possible any longer today'. These words express the political conceptions of the revolutionary left. They have nothing, absolutely nothing, in common with social-democratic ideology. So why has the editorial board of Robotnik, a journal which, without doubt, is one of the best currently produced by activists in Solidarnosc, decided to launch this proposal for building a new party immediately and what is more for building a party of a social-democratic character?

Perhaps the determination to form such a party as soon as possible derives in part from a loss of faith in the effectiveness of political struggle now being waged by the underground mass movement. Some texts published in Robotnik, suggest a certain feeling of disillusion with the attitudes of Polish civil society: "The silent majority watch television, drink vodka, spit, sigh, hate and pray for lightening to strike from a cloudless sky. Civil society allows itself to be easily frightened by the thinking of the vanguard, and that is true in all strata'

But the choice of a social-democratic orientation for the new party seems even more bizarre. One might accept that in present conditions the editorial board of Robotnik considers the term 'social democrat' to be less repellent than the terms 'socialist' or "left-wing' or 'revolutionary, even though they frequently use these words themselves as synonyms - except for the last one of course.

Perhaps the position of Robotnik is explained by the hope expressed in the article entitled "The road to a new party' that the new PPS 'could count on a lively interest from the international social-democratic movement. However, it is out of the question that any European social-democratic party would undertake the risky operation of giving material help to an opposition party in Poland that no one is familiar with.

The reality is that the Western social democracy remains one of the biggest obstacles, in these countries to revolutionary changes similar to the building of workers' self-management as called for in the programme adopted at the Gdansk congress. (1)

The questions raised at the beginning of this article still remain: What are the perspectives for the revolutionary current in the Polish opposition? What are the organisational forms necessary for the consolidation of this current? The time has not yet come for building a revolutionary socialist party. But the class struggle itself forces us to build and develop, within the structures of the union, a broad tendency that declares its support for a revolutionary solution to the Polish crisis.

Such a tendency - the workers' opposition to the totalitarian bureaucracy - will not be united organisationally. The workers' opposition will be made up of various structures, commissions, journals, publications, bound together by a common strategy of struggle for a workers' republic.

Forming such a workers' opposition, which is basically a form of the working-class struggle, is becoming a more and more urgent task. But this requires organisers, a group of activists who will get down to the job of building the workers' opposition as a tendency within the union. The first task of the revolutionary left in Poland is to set up such a grouping.

Let us end by quoting from an article which appeared in issue No 13 of [Polish] Inprekor, the journal of the Fourth International: 'What is needed is to develop an agreement between people willing to take action and united around a common conception of immediate and long-term tasks for the movement, which flow from the objectively revolutionary dynamic of this movement, as well as by a determination and capacity to work together to accomplish these tasks.'

This conception seems to us to be quite correct. The construction of the first organisational structures of the Polish left created on the basis of an understanding among the revolutionary left can only be carried through successfully if we concentrate on the needs of the class struggle itself.

Any elaboration of programme must be linked to this and the struggle itself will show us the right time to transform the revolutionary left into a qualitatively superior form of organisation.

Wolny Robotnik, ZRP-PRO of Silesia, July 1984 1. The first national congress of Solidarnose which took place in Gdansk, September-October 1981.

21

The international logic of the situation

It is not national antagonisms that frighten the Nomenklatura people in the Kremlin and Warsaw contrary to what might be thought. They exploit these antagonisms, setting workers of different nationalities against each other, and thereby keeping them from organizing joint workers action on an international scale. This has made it possible, for example in the USSR, to build up an ideological underpinning of Great Russian chauvinism for the rule of the Nomenklatura, in addition to the regime's base in the administrative and police apparatus.

Moreover, this has a reciprocal effect. Anti-Russian phobias serve as a "national" compensation for the oppression and exploitation suffered at the hands of the native Polish totalitarian bureaucracy. The Russians are fed on descriptions of the hatred that the Poles have for them. In this respect, unfortunately, the Soviet Communist Party propaganda does not have to make up a lot. By way of reaction, this fosters a still greater aversion to Poles among Russians, and so on. While all this is going on, Chernenko and Jaruzelski are having a good time. They would rather not think about what would happen if the workers on both sides of the River Bug [the river running along the Polish-Russian border] got together one day and stopped hating each other.

The Nomenklatura people are not worried about the lack of friendship and still less by hatred among nations, in particular in those countries under the domination of "fraternal parties." Because this is an essential precondition for the functioning of reciprocal interventions (1) within the framework of the "camp." What they are afraid of is that people will take the official friendship seriously, because from that it is only one step to internationalism, that is international solidarity among the workers and revolutionary struggle against the Nomenklatura and capital.

If we do not want to see antibureaucratic movements and uprisings continually end in an impasse, it is necessary to combine social and national objectives with a clear definition of an international strategy. In the present geopolitical situation, we should regard every sort of noninternationalism as - to call things by their proper name — the concentrated expression of political cretinism. And this is both from the standpoint of the struggle for the liberation of the working class, as well as from the standpoint of the national struggle for the right of peoples to self-determination.

The national gulf deliberately widened by the totalitarian bureaucracy, that 22 separates Polish workers from Ukrainian, Czech or Russian workers represents exactly the distance that separates these workers from freedom and these nations from independence, both internally and externally.

There is an objective need for internationalizing the dynamic of the processes of the August revolution that have arisen in Poland, which, as history has shown, is the weak link in the chain of the rule of the totalitarian bureaucracy. The only alternative to this is suicide in isolation. We do not have the means to afford the luxury of a philosophy of struggle confined to a national ghetto in the conditions of a determined political geography in the international arena.

Despite the bureaucratic counterrevolution initiated by the December 1981 putsch and which is continuing today, the revolutionary forces set in motion in August 1980 are continuing to operate. But whether they will be the spark that lights a future flame or the slowly dying embers of the past depends on solving the principal dilemma. Despite the metaphorical way this was put, the dramatic choice before us is quite clear: Either these forces will continue to develop along a revolutionary axis of internationalism, or they will continue to decline in the downward spiral of isolationism.

If we do not want to see Soviet tanks sent against a workers' revolution in Poland or in some other countries, we have to begin eliminating the antiworking-class repressive forces and their social base in the Soviet Union itself. Exactly forty years after the export of the bureaucratic anti-imperialist revolution from the USSR to Poland, we find ourselves obliged to begin to export the antibureaucratic workers' revolution from Poland to the USSR. This is not only possible and feasible, in particular considering the means at the disposal of the leading bodies of Soffdarnose and if there is a strategic reorientation and an attempt to find the concrete way of relating to the working class as the fundamental protagonist in the struggle. It is also necessary.

The present phase can, and must, be characterized as a "revolution halted at the crossroads." The revolutionary situation has to be defined as one that demands a choice between two alternatives - internationalization or continuing self-limitation. Internationalism, so much besmirched by fools and rightists, is first of all a historical social question of achieving the essential precondition for the workers' movement to act to emancipate labor. But it is also, in the striet sense, a practical question, how to fight so as not

Transport strike in Warsaw, August 1981 (DR) to lose again. It does not matter very much in fact whether defeat is the result of foreign intervention, as was the case in Hungary or Czechoslovakia, or of a domestic counterrevolution. The latter was possible in Poland as a result of the revolution being paralyzed by a general awareness of the external threat posed by the Soviet totalitarian bureaucracy.

If our fight for freedom and independance is not to resemble a labor of Sisyphus, we have to reject the substance of nationalism that leads inevitably to isolating the struggle that we are waging and to defeat. Historical and ethnic antagonisms cannot replace the struggle for social and national liberation in its international dimension.

To be sure, we do not want to revive the errors of [Rosa] Luxemburgism, that is, a mechanical notion of internationalism that leads to underestimating the question of national independence. But it will not do either to fall into the opposite extreme, underestimating the importance of international workers' solidarity. Without the latter, and we cannot have any illusions about this, we have no chance of overthrowing the system of 1. In 1969, the Polish army intervened in Czechoslovaka to crush the Prague Spring, along with the armies of East Germany and the Soviet Union. Now, if the Warsaw Pact undertook an intervention against Poland, Czechoslovak forces would probably be included. - IV.

rule of totalitarian bureaucracy. And we are not exaggerating!

As an appendix, we present some concrete proposals for exporting the revolution.

- To wage an informational and agitational campaign directed at the Soviet military units stationed in Poland (for example, distribution of leaflets and press statements in Russian on the bases of these units, either by dumping them there or passing them from hand to hand).

Organizing radio broadcasts from Poland for Byelorussia, Czechoslavakia, Lithuania, East Germany and the Ukraine, in the languages of these countries (for example, regular broadcasts from constantly moving transmitters, a means that is already used in Poland).

- Use of clandestine print shops and print shops outside the country for the needs of dissident and opposition groups in our neighboring countries, but also organization of Solidarnosc's own information service for these countries. Priority should be given to East Germany and Czechoslavakia, whose frontiers are particularly penetrable, and where we will get our first foreign readers.

- The establishment of durable international contacts and coordination of common antibureaucratic actions with opposition groups and independent groups in the nearest countries of the bureaucratic camp and the setting up for them of an independent information service in order to counteract the antiPolish and antirevolutionary propaganda conducted in these countries, for example, by disseminating the major documents of the August [Gdansk] accords.

Besides this "outward work, " it seems important to undertake "inward work" also that will facilitate the former.

- Condemnation of Great Russian chauvinism, which was combatted by Lenin in his time, and clear support for the fight for national independence by the Soviet nations dominated by Russia. This should go hand in hand with stopping and condemning anti-Russian propaganda in the underground press. Just as earlier not every German was a fascist, today not every Russian is a chauvinist.

Combatting the national phobias, as well as having a critical attitude to tendentious nationalist literature and national history....

- Bringing pressure to bear from below on the Solidarnose leadership for developing international collaboration in particular with the Eastern European countries, which should be accompanied by an extensive testing by Solidarnosc of a political strategy and of public and active positions for relating to the national and social problems in the USSR on a fraternal revolutionary basis.

Proletarians of the world, unite for your liberty and ours!

Front Robotniczy (Workers Front) No 1, Warsaw, August 12, 1984 International Viewpoint 24 December 1984

The birth of the people's republic Debates on nationalisation Stalinism has reduced historical science to the level of a method for justifying their errors at any particular point in time. It is also used to muddle society's awareness of history, by separating it from its real roots. For a long time now, their opponents have been trying to counterpose to this official history some kind of 'true' history made up of the oral tradition and of the official histories accepted in the past. The rediscovery, on a mass scale of the works of pre-war or emigre historians was an important phenomenon during the period when Solidarnose could operate legally and it continues today. The historical debate is an important component of the process of political consolidation under way in Poland today. The different left currents are not outside of this debate as this article, published below, illustrates. (1) The article is anonymous and was printed in the form of a short pamphlet by the Warsaw journal, Robotnik, in 1984. Robotnik has also published several historical articles presenting different views to the ones expressed here.

The following article is interesting mainly for two reasons. First, it shows that forces in the antibureaucratic movement feel the need to combat the attempts of the Stalinists to claim all the credit for overthrowing capitalism in Poland. Secondly, it represents an effort by the underground movement to recover the truth about the mass revolutionary upsurge in Poland, toward which the Soviet authorities and their Polish acolytes in fact took a negative attitude, although they later went on, for their own reasons, to abolish capitalism and set up collective economic forms.

The following document is not clear about the contradictions of the Polish Socialist Party in the period in question. But since this party has not existed for decades and the official histories give only a Stalinist version of its history, this is not the first concern of antibureaucratic oppositionists in Poland today. It is, however, a question that oppositionists will have to deal with more as the debates progress, as other articles in this dossier indicate, for example, the article criticising Robotnik for identifying itself with Social Democracy.

The problem of assessing the West European Social Democratic parties is a current problem for the Polish opposition. The contradictions of left Social Democracy in revolutionary periods is not something that the postwar generations in Poland have seen, much less experienced. The fundamental thing for them is to rediscover the objective, democratic and pluralist nature of mass movements for overthrowing capitalism.

In the official histories it is common to hold up the Polish Workers Party (PRP) (2) and the Communist camp as the only consistent supporters of the socialisation of the means of production, in contrast to other groups (legal or illegal) which in some indeterminate way had denied this principle by defending, to a greater or lesser extent, the old capitalist relations.

In reality even a superficial knowledge of the period 1944-1945 allows one to put forward an opposing argument. That is, there were only a small number of isolated individuals who defended capitalism as the future economic system for Poland, and amongst the political parties only the most right-wing (the National Party - SN) supported the idea. The vast majority were in favour of changes in the direction of socialisation of the economy. Amongst these the PRP was not by any means the most left-wing.

In order to counter the official lies it is therefore useful to recall the main ideas for tranforming the economy spelt out by the [World War II] underground in Poland. The proposals for reform were formulated on the basis of the objective situation in society. They cannot be assessed in abstraction from the reality of Poland between the wars and in the period of the occupation.

I do not pretend to be able even to sketch the history of the Polish economy here. Nevertheless, it is necessary to recall certain facts.

The economic system of the Second Republic (3) was a capitalist one. But it was a specific form of capitalism. Its peculiarity lay, first and foremost in the weakness of indigenous private property. 1. Readers interested in the period 1944 to 1948, when the workers' state was established in Poland could also look at the article produced in Polish Inprekor and then reproduced in English in Intercontinental Press, Vol 22, Nos 20 and 21, October 29, 1984 and November 12, 1984, under the headline, 'A strategy for Polish revolutionaries'. 2. The PPR fused with the PPS in 1948 to form the PUWP - the Polish United Workers Party, the Polish Communist Party. 3. The Second Republic is the term used to describe the national bourgeois state in Poland from 1918 to 1939.

23

The remarks of two well-known personalities representing opposite poles of opinion - R. Dmowski and J. Ryng (4) -defining Polish capitalism as a 'capitalism without capital' are symptomatic of this. In this situation, foreign and state capital played the key role. This is apparent in the statistics for company stocks and shares in Poland in 1935, where we read that state and foreign capital together made up about 72% of all company stocks in Poland, as well as 95% of all capital. Indigenous private property represented 28% of company stocks and shares and 5% of all capital.

It is therefore not surprising that the former minister of finance J. Zdziechowski concluded in his book The myth of the gold standard (1937) that: "The nullity of the sort of ownership that exists makes a mockery of the idea of Polish initiative in the private sector.' He added that this is the main reason for the development of a system of state control of the economy in Poland.'

It is true that state control of the economy in Poland in the inter-war years had come a long way. The statistics for the year 1937 illustrate the role of the public treasury in the different branches of production and services: coal mining, 24%; oil refining, 20%; steel, nearly 70%; machine-tool industry, about 50%; car industry, 100%; chemical industry, 25%; electronic industry, 12.5% (but 84 % in the telecommunications industry); merchant marine, 97%; banks, 46%; insurance, 48%.

Across all branches of the economy the participation of the state was estimated at around 44 per cent, which put Poland ahead of all other European contries as far as state intervention was concerned (apart from, of course, the USSR).

In the opinion of Boracz, the publisher of Przebudowa, the theoretical organ of the Polish Peasants Party (PSL), state intervention in Poland in the inter-war period played a dual role: economic, insofar as it complemented the weakness of the private sector; and political in that it was the basis of the influence on the bureaucracy, which dominated the Sanacja regime. (5)

In conclusion, we can say that the system in Poland before the war upheld only certain elements of a classic capitalist system. Important limitations on free competition (a strong private monopoly held by foreign capital, state intervention and a high degree of nationalisation) gave it a peculiar character, typical of a majority of the countries of central and Eastern Europe.

The 1939-1945 war and the double occupation (in 1941) of Polish territory [by the USSR and Nazi Germany] led to a new weakening, from the economic point of view, of the foundations of private enterprise. In both the German occupied territories and in the Soviet part, a resolute policy was instituted of expropriating private enterprise and unifying the structure of property. This meant either takeover by the state, or in the case of territories seized by the Reich, incor24

A Solidarnose headquarters with a poster of Lenin (DR)

poration into German businesses and monopolies. These enterprises were then subordinated to the war policy of the state. This process was reinforced as the war progressed. The remainder of private capital was systematically liquidated, and productive activity [that is, to meet positive human needs] was reduced to a minimum. As a consequence, in those Polish territories that were later included in the People's Republic of Poland, there came ready made, from the economic point of view, a state system dominated by state property and state capitalism, which were subordinated to political needs and to the war. This specific 'economic revolution involved an important challenge to the pre-war property arrangements, shaking the already feeble foundations of Polish capitalism to its roots.

Assessing this state of affairs, the Economic Bulletin (organ of the Polish government in exile in London) wrote that 'a change in the economic and social fabric, which is revolutionary in its scope has been accomplished. It is characterised by the fact that the reestablishment of the previous state is not possible either from a technical or psychological point of view, as well as by the fact that this change has remained incomplete and has not established a new state. The first act of this revolution has already been accomplished. What the second act will be, we do not know'.

The objective changes in the structure of property weakened and even made impossible, the restoration of capitalist relations in post-war Poland, even to their pathetic pre-war level.

Alongside of these changes a perhaps decisive role was played by developments in the consciousness of the masses in an anti-capitalist direction. The 'process of radicalisation' which affected not only Poland, but nearly all of Europe (in a way similar to the revolutionary wave after the First World War) had several causes: internal, national and general. The majority of society, although recognising the authority of the underground state and the London government based on the 1935 constitution, without any hesitation, were not prepared to accept a return to the political and economic system of the pre-war era. These changes developed all over occupied Europe, linked to the struggles of the broad masses against fascism and totalitarianism. Transformation of the political and economic structures in accordance with the principles of democracy was a general aspiration, expressed by everyone. Everywhere, similar demands came up; for nationalisation, economic planning, extension of parliamentary democracy, for social reform, etc. In Poland, where a majority of society was subjected to economic exploitation and fierce political repression, which created an almost completely exploited class of wage-earners, radicalisation developed rapidly (especially in 1943-1944), reaching a level which was easily recognised by the bourgeois heads of the Army of the Interior (AK), as well as by the centre and right-wing components of the Polish underground.

In a special report to the commander. in-Chief dated May 22, 1944, the AK commander Tadeusz Bor Komorowski wrote, for example, that there was "a huge ideological turn to the left.....A more or less general demand for control of economic life by society as a whole, for the ending of the concentration of wealth in private hands beyond a certain minimum and for the end to privileges for individuals or social groups. This is a strong radicalisation. The authorities who try ideologue of the National Party (SN) - the R. Dmowski was the main leader and main reactionary fascist party before 1939. J. Ryng was the leader of the Communist Party. 5. Sanacja, literally 'cleaning up', is the general name given to the regime which e merged from the coup d'etat of Marshal Pilsudski in May 1926. It was a repressive regime, which did not succeed, however, in crushing political and social resistance.

International Viewpoint 24 December 1984

to halt this process will expose the coun- crystallisation of tne real social revolu- Zygmunt Zaremba analysed this phentry to many upheavals.' tion. The description of it as a revolution omenon in the following way: "The ideo-

The theory that it was only the PPR is not accidental. The social content of logical gains of the insurrection - which and the groups working with it that gave the revolution and the political put forward new ideas for the transpolitical expression to this radicalisation ments both accord to it the character of formation of society and which became by developing a programme for the trans- a revolutionary assault, which combined rooted in Polish society during the strugformation of society is simply an obfus- the goal of independence with social and gle against the oceupying forces - have cation by the official histories. This democratic demands, although this revo- lost none of their significance.

counterposes the Communist lution was limited territorially. main the fundamental basis on which camp to the underground 'London group' The August 15, 1944, manifesto of the Polish society needs to develop....The organisations, which were presented as if RJN is significant from this point of view. August Insurrection gave a clear picture they defended the old social structures There we read that 'the system of a of what the organisation and life of the against the aspirations of the majority of future republic will be founded on polit- new Polish state should be, based on society. This theory is just as schematic ical liberty and social justice. the principles of socialist democracy. as the one that even denies the basic facts dations of the system in the democratic They show that the working class radicalisation or claims republic of Poland would be: a demo- cement the collective life of the nation? was the result of 'Soviet influence'. cratic electoral law for the election of One year after the insurrection, in a

The 'London camp' legislative and self-managed bodies, which political situation which was radically lithic. From the beginning within its would accurately reflect opinions within different, the RJN in its final secret leadership there were representatives of society; the transformation of the agri- session on July 1, 1945, proclaimed the the peasants' Peasant cultural system through the parcelling out "Testament of Underground Poland' Party - SL Roch'), and the Socialists of German possessions and all the land. Here are some extracts from this little (WRN, which was the continuation of the holding of more than fifty hectares; the known document concerning the prinPolish Socialist Party - PPS) had a strong socialisation of the main industries, the cipal aspects of the influence. These two parties made up participation of white-collar and manual sought to create in Poland: 'The creation part of the big four (Peasants Party, workers in the management and control of full regional social, economic, educaWRN, Workers Party and the National of industrial production.' tional and cultural self-management; the Party) which dominated under- Zygmunt Zaremba, one of the lead- socialisation of large capitalist properties ground politics inside the country and in ers of the WRN and of the PPS before the and the organisation of a fair redistribuwar, had this to say about the programme: tion of the national wealth; workers'

In the first years of the war (the SL 'Here we find the outline for a real management and control over the whole in 1940 and the WRN in 1941), these democracy, going towards a fundamental economy; freedom parties published their programmes for transformation of the socio-economic sys- working class to fight for its rights within social and economic transformation, in tem of the The Polish Socialist the framework of an independent tradewhich great stress was placed on the need can be proud because these union movement; the implementation of for transformation of important indus- are the kind of programmatic principles agrarian reform.' trial and agricultural properties. that everyone here supports' This document contradicts any based themselves on the radicalisation at The proclamation of the laws and de- tempt to explain in black and white terms the end of the war in order to exercise crees (three volumes of the 'Law Journal"') debates on the social system in Poland. It ideological and programmatic influence was a revolutionary act of the Warsaw also reflects changes in social awareness on the leadership of the underground insurrection that determined the founda- It is the political expression of the radical movement. tions of the new system. Before the de- tendencies that in 1944-1945 imposed a

The general evolution of society crees of the Popular National Council leadership pledged to fundamental change wards the left found its expression in (KRN) (7), the organs of power in under- based on the socialisation of public life. the documents of the underground move- ground Poland voted for the principles of In light of these examples it would be

One example is the statement of agrarian reform, for the socialisation of difficult to doubt the revolutionary the underground parliament, the Council the means of production (the law on the character of the events in Poland. The acof National Unity (RJN) (6) dated Aug- factory councils), and for a self-managed tual movement that spontaneously took ust 15, society (the law on regional self- govern- control of the factories and got produc

People are Fighting For. ment). tion going during the months following scribed in Communist propaganda as con- This revolutionary aspect of the in- the liberation is the real expression of this ciliatory, partial and 'a swindle' (as if the surrection has been neglected both in revolutionary character. This mass movemanifesto of the PKWN - Polish Com- Communist propaganda and in the propa- ment, which created new forms of manmittee for National Liberation, was not ganda of right-wing emigres. They show, agement and organisation of the factoralso 'partial' and 'a swindle'), this statehowever, within society - or at least in ies based on the the ment was in fact an important document the political and cultural centres - the workers, was the expression of the sponillustrating the evolution of Polish polit- existence of a real vision of a new Po- taneous aspirations of the workers for the ical thought and reflecting the political land. public ownership of the workplaces. opinions of both the broad masses and The complex reality of post-war Poelite groups. land does not lend itself easily to gener-

Proposing the reestablishment in the alised assessments. new Poland of a parliamentary republic the situation in and the realisation of fundamental socio- society imposed a clear anti-capitalist economic reforms (agrarian reforms, na- dynamic to any reforms. This does not tionalisation of large industry, economic mean that a new model of society was planning), this statement was the most clearly and definitely drawn up. The radical of all the official expressions of general anti-capitalist tendency expressed

And it is not irrelevant to recall that it was a well-known Socialist militant, for a long time secretary general of the PPS, Kazimierz The Council of National Unity (RJN) Puzak, who was president of the RJN. resistance linked to was the political expression of the anti-Nazi the government in exile

The Warsaw insurrection was often in London. known as the August revolution - a fact 7. The Popular National Council (KRN) was set up by the Stalinists as a kind of provisional that the official histories never mention - parliament. The political sections of the main and it was an important moment in the resistance force - the AK - were excluded from it. International Viewpoint 24 December 1984 25

in the programmes for widespread limitation on private property was, however, common to all political parties and groups of any significance.

The state of consciousness of the masses was the basis of this anti-capitalist dynamie. That is why in post-war Poland, you had all the elements of an authentic revolution. What is in doubt is only what was the social and political expression of this. Was this, as the official versions would like to claim, a 'Communist revolution', spontaneously carried through in the name of the broad masses of which the PPR was the motor force, with the help of its allies in the East? Was it something that was at first supported by a minority of Poles, but a minority which represented 'the most conscious workers and peasants'? Or was it rather a 'demo. cratic revolution for independence' (as ir the insurrection in Warsaw) with a broad programme of basically socialist reforms representing more the left of the London camp' and supported by a real majority of the population, whose demands coincided with the programme of the Communist camp?

Was it not this that allowed the lattel to seize on these demands and use the movement for its own purposes to gain a limited social base which in turn produced an inevitable drift, to the right amongst the opposition in society, a drift that was all too apparent in the years 1947-1948?

It is in this way that Professor Tadeusz Lepkowski (8) in his recent book published by the underground press posed the problem of the Polish revolutions from 1944-1982 and rightly so, in my opinion. He presents the notion of two revolutions which were in conflict at the end of the war; the Communist one which came from 'above' and the spontaneous one with an independent and democratic character.

Pursuing the line of argument a question comes to mind: Were the majority of Poles in favour of socialist reforms?

The reply must certainly be negative, if we understand by socialist reforms a system generally along the lines of the Soviet model. The majority of society was without doubt, anti-Communist from this point of view. But we can assert without fear of contradiction that the basic concept of a new economic system - one involving the socialisation of the means of production was generally accepted.

Poland was not so much faced with the choice of socialism or capitalism.

The differences were about the methods, the forms and the aims of socialisation.

The positions taken by different parties and social movements was a reflection of these programmatic and ideological differences.

8. A historian known for many works on

Latin America and Poland, T. Lepkowski was the president of Solidarnosc at the history institute in the Polish Academy of Sciences.

26

JAPAN

← Poland Special: The Birth of a New Left · Japan: Problems and Debates in the Anti-imperialist Movement — Interview with Ampo Editor →

Something wrong on this page?