International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Mauritius: Crisis of Sugar Industry Brings Political Upheavals and Social Tensions

· International Viewpoint No. 63, 12 November 1984 · pp 17-23 · 7,162 words

This article was cut at the top of the page the printed contents gives it, because its headline could not be found in the machine-read text. Its opening may carry the end of the article before it.

Claude Gabriel was the pen name of Claude Jacquin, a member of the Fourth International's leadership from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s, long active in its Africa Commission.

World economy France Britain and Ireland Africa

*5 minutes for peace' (DR) wide 5-minute protest strike against the missiles on October 24 will be a key test of this movement. At the same time, the Social Democratic Party may try to improve its image among the majority of the population who oppose the missiles pushing the Radikale Venstre in a position where it will have to vote against the government on some motion involving this issue.

This is a cup the Radikale Venstre will be extremely reluctant to drink from, since it decided to back this government for the sake of mounting an attack on the unions. But it could be forced to swallow the bitter draught because of its historical antimilitarist program and the antimilitarist attitudes of a large part of its traditional voters.

In the short run, however, the focus for fightback against the capitalists and the government for the workers and other broad sections of the population will probably be the struggle for the 35hour week. In the spring, the contracts covering almost all Danish workers will run out, and the national labor confederation, the LO, will bargain in a centralized way for more than a million workers.

So far, there has been agreement in most of LO's member unions - not only at the rank-and-file level but in most of the leaderships - that the highest prioriiy has to be given to reducing the workweek. And the employers federation and the government are dead set against this, even if the workers were to accept wage cuts in return for shorter hours. The Social Democrats have sided with the LO and are going to campaign for a shorter workweek in the months leading up to the conclusion of negotiations.

Although the LO leaders have undermined the basis for a wholehearted struggle by the working class by announcing that they are prepared to accept zero wage increases for all but the lowest paid sectors in return for a shorter workweek, the situation here is looking more and more like the one that preceded the launching of the strikes for the 35-hour week in West Germany in the spring of this year.

It is looking more and more as if there will be a full-scale strike for a shorter workweek in Denmark some time in the spring of 1985. This may very well present the Schlueter government with its first real challenge.

17

MALIDITILO MAURITIUS

Crisis of the sugar industry brings political upheavals and communal tensions 'One generation has to suffer for the next.' These were the terms in which the Mauritian finance minister presented his recent proposals to reduce the country's foreign debts. (1) Like his counterparts throughout the world, the Mauritian minister is trying to present the international crisis as a very simple question of the almost supernatural effect of monetary mechanisms and, for the time being, is proposing only the 'stepping up of the national effort.

The function of this sort of bland speechifying is to obscure the real social and political factors that contribute to the present economic crisis. Mauritius is a good example of these interlocking problems. Over the last ten years it has been the scene of big structural upheavals, caused by internal as well as external factors.

The mechanisms of dependence affecting the crisis of the sugar industry and the development of a 'free zone' have produced a strong acceleration in political and social changes. The Mauritian case, despite its specificities, thus makes it possible, in many regards, to understand the scope of the damage that the imperialist crisis and the chaos caused by the old ruling classes can do to a neo-colonial country.

wards a fall in prices on the world market. But, in a second phase, because of the chronic surplus that this brought about, it pushed towards the reduction of American and European imports of cane sugar, and thus to the renegotiation of preferential agreements that they had made with certain countries in this field.

The agreement between the EEC and Mauritius is under discussion. The European beet growers would like very much to cut the cord, but for the moment France is playing a moderating role insofar as it can, given that it has to defend its big beet producers and, at least partially, protect cane sugar production in its colonies (Antilles and Reunion) because this is a factor of stability in the colonial order. The sugar tyranny

Thus, Mauritius is at a crossroads in sugar production. That is to say, in other terms, that Mauritian society as a whole is now coming under pressure from the big contradictions related to the crisis of the sugar industry. Sugar cane mobilises the labour force of thousands of workers on the plantations and in the factories, which in general belong to a few families of 'big whites' . Sugar cane provides the income for thousands of fam- vides the income for thousands of families of small and medium planters who own their own land. It guarantees work for the dockers, and justifies thousands of jobs in industry and the service sector.

Thus, in the last analysis, the majority of the population in Mauritius depend on the export of cane sugar. A crisis in this production thus provokes an increase in social tensions. Antagonistic social groups who live on the sugar economy have an increasing tendency to propose contradictory solutions to this crisis.

The big independent planters, organised in the Mauritian Planters Association, and the big white bourgeoisie from the plantations do not have the same resources, and do not make the same proposals for overcoming the crisis. The small planters, subject to the aspirations of the big within the MPA, and the agricultural proletariat could well, in the future, put forward their own demands.

Week End, Port-Louis, July 5, 1984.

On the Lome Convention, which links Mauritius with the EEC, see International Viewpoint, No 51, April 23, 1984.

For more information see Tate and Lyle geant du sucre, Philippe Chalmin, Editions Economica, Paris 1984.

'Suere en danger', Swaley Kasenally, le Mauricien, Port-Louis, July 19, 1984. 5. In accordance with a well-known mechanism of capitalism, a long-term depression in selling prices brings about, little by little, shutting down of the least profitable production capacity. A reduction in supply then follows, establishing a reequilibrium with demand which brings about an improvement in prices. The trading establishments that speculate on this evolution in prices sometimes have an interest in stimulating these rises, in order to maintain productive capacity as far as possible, or for other reasons to do with the manipulation of the market. But other factors can come to interfere with the reproduction of these 'natural' cycles. This is particularly the case for sugar today, given the permanent structural overproduction.

International Viewpoint 12 November 1984

Claude GABRIEL

The Mauritian economy is first and foremost sugar cane. Some 70 per cent of the foreign currency earnt by Mauritius comes from its export. Of an annual production of 616,000 tons of sugar in the last six years, 527,000 could be sold at a preferential price. An agreement guaranteed the sale of 500,000 tons to the European Economic Community (EEC), and the United States bought 27,000 tons at a price above that of the world market. (2)

These arrangements have, after a certain fashion, 'protected' the Mauritian economy, or at least guaranteed political stability there for more than ten years. But this protection was a dangerous gift. It also made it possible for the big sugarproducing bourgeoisie to largely keep up its profits, without having to make big investments, thus encouraging substantial transfers of capital out of the sugar industry.

This price guarantee is in fact glossy wrapping to hide a peculiar system of forced dependence. One of the primary elements of this system is the fact that the multinational Tate and Lyle has a monopoly on the purchase and refining, in Britain, of the 500,000 tons sold to the EEC. This firm, one of the giants of international commerce, manipulates the sugar market, and in so doing hides the essentials of the affair. (3)

Unlike the Mauritius government, it does not decide its poliey for the four or five years to come, but for the next quarter-century. At the moment, it is looking for a substitute for sugar cane and beet based on saccharine, and also, primarily, on new products such as Thau18 matin, extract of a plant growing in West Africa that is said to be between 6,000 and 100,000 times sweeter than natural sugar. At the same time as Tate and Lyle is offering its services to Mauritius, its laboratories are preparing a veritable sabotage of the country's economy, and of several others at the same time that are also based on cane sugar exports. (4)

Another element of the constraint that weighs on the Mauritian economy is linked to the world sugar prices. In July 1984, sugar dropped to its lowest price for thirteen years on the free market. This obviously has an effect on the export income that Mauritius can expect to earn from the approximately 100,000 remaining tons of sugar that it sells on the free market. But the essential point is the consequences that this drop will have in the medium term on the sugar agreement with the EEC, and the sales agreement with the USA.

The drop in world price is not only a result of international trading speculation. The speculators never have an interest in maintaining a downward trend towards prices for too long a time. (5) The length of this depression in world prices is linked to the chronic overproduction of sugar in the world, that is increasing from year to year. World sugar reserves presently stand at 37 million tonnes, 40 per cent of annual world consumption. Thus, the market is saturated.

In this context, cane and beet sugar are in strong competition. Between 1969 and 1980, the EEC increased sugar beet production by 50 per cent, through an increase in the area cultivated and a rise in productivity. The cost of production has thus dropped sharply. At first, this development just exerted pressure to-

A major cause of the political crisis is rooted in these contradictions. An official commission of enquiry into the sugar industry was set up in 1983, the Avramovic commission. Its work cost two million rupees but produced only a banal report and contradictory conclusions, without any serious proposals about work conditions, the organisation of investments or nationalisation. (6)

In reality, the Mauritian government and all the main traditional political parties are trying to hide the direct link that exists between political conflicts and the sugar crisis. If this were publicly discussed, it would show that the interests of the property-owning classes, and the solutions put forward, are divided along racial and communalist lines. (7)

For example, the MPA of the big and medium planters is one of the main bastions of Hindu communalism, while the big industrial plantations retain their white colonialist character. It is undoubtedlv the case that the big Hindu haulage edly the case that the big Hindu haulage contractors do not envisage the same solutions as the big Muslim traders, insofar as each group is capable of defending its own interests.

The big political parties, which are all up to their necks in communalist alliances, have every reason to try to conceal the material and economic base of communalism by attributing it to subjective, religious and moral reasons. They have every reason to try to get the workers to play the role of a pawn in these inter-bourgeois struggles.

The situation can only keep on getting worse. The international economic crisis will, in any case, force a meshaping crisis will, in any case, force a reshaping bourgeois government will be able to resolve these problems in a lasting way without facing social explosions, at least not unless it resorts to the most extreme violence. Only a real agrarian reform organised by a government supported by all the toiling classes could introduce a longterm reform at the cost of the propertyowning classes, starting with the big sugar capitalists. Only a solution of this type, as the product of a revolutionary victory, could loosen the tyrannical grip of the sugar industry.

As well as these structural difficulties in increasing export income, there is the question of foreign debts. As in most other dominated countries, the Mauritian debts are the result of a combination of various factors:

The cost of oil, proportionally very high for a country that produces practically no energy and has, moreover, followed a policy of industrialisation whose financial results have not covered the cost of the new energy needs thereby created.

The rise of the dollar, which is now the main factor of increase in the debt. Although 51 per cent of imports have to be paid for in dollars, only 21 per cent of exports are billed in this currency. At least 60 per cent of debt repayments are made in dollars, and the major part of the inputs for the main International Viewpoint 12 November 1984 productive sectors (fertilisers, cement, raw materials for the free zone) are imported and paid for in dollars. (8) One US dollar was worth 5.19 rupees at the beginning of 1979. In July 1984 it cost over 14 rupees!

- The rise in interest rates on the international financial market, combined with the rise in the dollar. Like many other countries, Mauritius finds more and more difficulty in getting loans from public institutions. Thus it has to apply to the banks for loans in eurodollars, usually under stricter conditions.

The amount owed by Mauritius is obviously quite modest in comparison to the debts of the big Latin American countries for example. But the impact of servicing this debt is far from being negligible on the Mauritian economy. Between the 1981-82 budget and that for 1983-84, debt servicing rose from an equivalent of 14.7 per cent of export income to 23.6 per cent. According to the finance minister, in 1984 more than two-thirds of sugar income will go on debt repayments.

However, confronted with this arrogant squeeze by the imperialists, the Mauritian leaders have responded only by glorifying their dependence: 'We are' , declared the finance minister, 'in an exceptional sitation, where we find ourselves one of the few countries of the third world who pay their debts with a regularity and seriousness that fascinates international institutions. (9) 6. On the cost of the Avramovic commission, see l'Express, Port-Louis, July 25, 1983. On the contradictory conclusions see 'Reports of the Commission of Inquiry into the Sugar Industry' and 'Report of J. Manrakhan and R. Sithanen' of October 26, 1983. 7. The term 'communalism' describes groupings and forms of mutual aid that rest on a religious or ethnic basis. It is also used to denounce the political clientelism based on the specific interests of these groupings. It is directly inspired by the Indian example, insofar as the population of Mauritius is composed approximately as follows: 51.8% Hindus (Including Tamils and Telegus), 16.53% Mus-

Loading up sugar before mechanisation (DR)

Faced with these difficulties and this propaganda, the mass of the people are quite simply invited to remain spectators. The press reports the debates between the government and the opposition, but the latter places itself on exactly the same terrain as the present government. The debate between the finance minister and Paul Berenger, leader of the opposition and of the Militant Mauritian Movement (MMM), is over the best option for rescheduling the debt, or how to appeal to the eurodollar market. Such a discussion, deliberately kept in a purely technical framework, consciously leaves aside all the political and social aspects of the problem. (10)

The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) have thus not had, up till now, any difficulty in getting their policies accepted. All the major parties, whether in power or in the opposition, have, during the last three years, tried to outbid each other to offer the most accommodating agreement with these two imperialist institutions.

The reduction of social spending, pushing down imports by increasing customs tariffs, inviting foreign investment in the export-oriented branches, etc -these, in Mauritius as elsewhere, are major aspects of the policy recommended by the World Bank and the IMF in return for opening up access to credit for the debtor countries. Zealously applied by the Mauritius government, this course has led to a severe drop in the standard lims, 2.91% Chinese, and 28.66% 'general population', a category including the white French Mauritians and Creoles. There are about 50,000 whites out of a general population of 286,867 people. The statistics are from the official census. Communalism is also sometimes combined with rivalry between different Hindu castes. 8. L'Express, Port-Louis, July 26, 1984.

Le Mauricien, July 28, 1984. 10. As Paul Berenger of the MMM declared, it has to be shown to be 'competent' so that Mauritius will 'merit' having its debt rescheduled by the IMF. (Week End, July 15, 1984).

19

of living for the Mauritian masses.

In the space of a few weeks, at the time when a new round of negotiations with the World Bank was opening, the government reduced the subsidies for primary foodstuffs, (flour and rice), decided to raise prices by 20 per cent for the principal medicaments and 21 per cent for cement. In 1984, the health budget was reduced by 8.2 per cent, the housing budget by 49 per cent, and the education budget by 11.2 percent. There is more and more talk of putting into question the notion of free education.

The budget for unemployment insurance, already very small, has been reduced by 40 percent, but, at the same time, the government has injected almost 100 million rupees into investment aid for the private sector. While the rate of interest has been reduced by one per cent, the amount of credit given has risen by 15 per cent in one year.

Price rises such as those for cement offer a good opportunity for the big merchant speculators to overvalue their stocks, but that does not stop the government turning a deaf ear to the workers' demands for wage raises. To add insult to injury, they have just cut taxes for those who employ house servants. But to help the small people' they are content to simply create a fund of several thousand rupees for...Mauritian centenarians!

To help the masses swallow this, the regime claims to be intending to create the conditions for an increase in jobs. Officially, there are 72,000 unemployed, but the real figure is probably over 100,000. In a country of 950,000 inhabitants this is obviously considerable.

Even more than inflation, unemployment is a national curse that affects all families of the mass of the people, particularly young people. However, this does not stop the representatives of the World Bank and the IMF, the inspiration behind these policies, from putting about the most stupid optimism.

The real guides for Mauritius, alongside the representatives of French and British imperialist interests, these imperialist officials act shamelessly as the real masters of the country, passing out good and bad marks to the government's policies, to the workers and to the employers.

This whole panoply of measures proposed by imperialist bodies and applied by successive governments, has done nothing to resolve the structural crisis of the Mauritian economy. The IMF and the World Bank are in fact content to simply propose actions after the event, incapable of resolving the deepgoing causes of the crisis.

One sees the same bluff applied on the famous industrial 'free zone' of Port Louis. Created ten years ago, this zone should, in principle, reduce unemploy. ment and encourage technological advances. Although several thousand jobs have in fact been created, this has not at all resolved the problems of the labour mar-

20 ket, even if only because of the pressure of the growing population.

Moreover, this form of industrialisation has begun to be criticised at an international level, and a recent study by the United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) has begun to make a critical balance sheet of the installation of these free zones.

Having stated that the balance sheet of industrial development from these zones is disappointing, the report concludes that 'developing countries should take care not to give their free zones for export manufacture too important a place in their manufacturing industry. The free zones should be considered as a complement to other forms of industrial and export growth.' (11)

Unfortunately, this is quite contrary to the practice of the Mauritius government The free zone has become a veritable philospher's stone for transforming the country, eliminating unemployment, reducing dependence on sugar sales, etc. Thus, the government is planning on a considerable increase in the free zone, and intends to attract, by any means possible, all the foreign employers, big or small, who want to come and set up there. Crisis provokes social upheavals

The workers there, a majority of whom are women, are already terribly exploited. But the employers have been systematically putting on pressure of all sorts to ensure that the conditions get even worse. The labour code is, in effect, different by definition in the free zone from the rest of the country.

Attracting mainly industries edged out of the imperialist centres because of their outdatedness, this free zone guarantees such concerns a maximum rate of profit through the use of a semi-servile labour force as well as the preferential tax concessions, subsidies and free export of profits allowed to them. The Mauritius government therefore will have to attack the workers in this sector more and more if it wishes to compete with the free zones in the Asian countries. Its problem is that the Mauritius working class remains very far from tame. Even in the free zone, there is presently one strike a week.

Finally, the other measure proposed by the government to reduce unemployment is encouraging immigration and negotiating with other countries on the export of Mauritian labour. This scheme was nothing more than a makeshift solution, and has proved a dud. Since France and Britain have closed their borders to immigrants, the government has had to turn to countries like Zimbabwe, Saudi Arabia and, now, Gabon.

In fact, it has been possible to send only a few dozen people abroad. However, the promoter of this policy, Gaetan Duval of the Mauritian Social Democratic Party (PMSD), did not hesitate a few months ago to promise an end to unemployment through this means. What a keen mind!

There has been a continual political crisis in Mauritius for three years. In the legislative elections in June 1982, the left crushed the reactionary parties in government by a score of sixty to nil elected representatives. However, a few weeks later, the new government was wracked by a crisis that divided it into two blocs.

In August 1983, special legislative elections put the country's affairs back into the hands of the old reactionaries who were defeated the previous year. Hardly had they taken up the reins of power, but this bloc split once more, and the Labour Party (PT), a bourgeois Hindu communalist formation, left the government, although not avoiding a split in its own ranks.

Thus, there has been total political instability for three years, affecting the institutions as well as parties. However, from independence in 1968 to 1982, Mauritius has enjoyed a relative political stability, if only by the retention of power all through those years of a majority around the Labour Party.

Another indicator of the new situation is that while the last rise of communalism was in 1973, now there is a sharp new rise in racial tension, even if it has not achieved the degree of confrontation that exists in India or Sri Lanka. On this terrain of communalist politics, everything has been completely turned upside down in a few years, an additional proof of the major upheavals in Mauritian society.

The Labour Party, traditional representative of Hindu communalism, had already experienced a split, which gave rise to the Mauritian Socialist Party (PSM) a few years ago. And the latter has recently itself undergone a new split. The party that symbolises Muslim communalism, the Mauritian Islamic Party (PIM) has disappeared from the political scene, and now it is the Mauritian Militant Movement (MMM) that portrays itself as the great defender of Muslims. The PMSD of Gaetan Duval, which claims to be the traditional party of Creoles, has lost a good part of its base, etc.

There is no way to explain such an upheaval of the political-communalist scene by mere subjective factors or the vicissitudes of the political game. It is the economic crisis and what is at stake there that has speeded up the confrontation between the different cliques of the bourgeoisie. Because, when the piece of the cake left to them by the imperialists gets smaller, then the fight over the remaining crumbs becomes a pitched battle between the different factions of the bourgeoisie. The quasi-unanimity on a national scale represented by the electoral landslide in June 1982 was the result of special circumstances. It very quickly gave way to a pitched battle between former allies. 11. UNCTAD bulletin, No 200, March 1984.

International Viewpoint 12 November 1984

In the present period, it is divisions within the bourgeoisie, a crisis of the state and neo-colonial institutions, and governmental instability that constitute the continuing elements in the situation.

During the legislative elections of August 1983, the two sides confronted each other on the question of the sugar industry. Moreover, it was during this period that the Avramovic commission was working. The coalition between the Mauritian Socialist Movement (MSM) the PT and the PMSD proposed some nationalisations in the big sugar industry traditionally controlled by the French Mauritians - big white families descended from colonialists and slave owners - and the constitution of a type of state-private comanagement body called the Sugar Authority.

The MMM wanted to keep the credit that Berenger had won with the big sugar firms when he was finance minister a few months previously, and only proposed a body for dialogue and big financial support from the state for the private sector to carry out modernisation. Of course, there was nothing revolutionary in all this.

What the coalition wanted was to promote the interests of the big planters and the Hindu haulage contractors, by reducing the relative weight of the big white employers. On the other hand, what the MMM wanted was to maintain a course of 'realism' and 'national reconciliation' with the big property owners who had directed the actions of minister Berenger. The two bourgeois camps knew exactly where their interests lay. The Hindu capitalists gave substantial aid to the MSM-PT-PMSD coalition, and the big whites discreetly supported the MMM. From that point, this electoral campaign could only take the form of a communalist competition insofar as the respective interests of the Tamil, Hindu and Creole bourgeoisies became integrated into this polemic.

In the absence of a unification of the toilina messes all the nolitical narties toiling masses, all the political parties have been able, up till now, to get the International Viewpoint 12 November 1984

Dockers at Port Louis (DR) people to judge their conflicts on the basis of their racial group. (12) For this reason, if the working class cannot retake the offensive and rediscover the strength that it had in 1979-82, this economic and social crisis could accelerate the process of social decomposition to the point where it would take years to recreate elementary class consciousness in the toiling classes. In the period to come, governments of 'national unity' could certainly see the light of day, but, as anachronistic intermediaries, they could only give rise once more to new communalist divisions and tensions. Imperialist hegemony

But, beyond these events of parliamentary politics, it is useful to ask who really decides the future of Mauritius, and what share of real responsibility the imperialists have left to the Mauritius government. Leaving apart the IMF and the World Bank, who, as we have seen, act behind the scenes as representatives of imperialist interests in general, France and Britain are the main preceptors of the Mauritian bourgeoisie, and thus the real rulers of the country. Thanks mainly to the sales of sugar to Tate and Lyle, 50.9 per cent of exports from Mauritius go to Britain, thus making itthe main customer. As for suppliers, after Bahrein, the main exporter of oil to Mauritius, France comes in second, mainly through sales of manufacured goods and equipment. Britain comes third, just above South Africa.

For historical reasons, Mauritius is still prey over which the British and French imperialists are fighting. (13) Over and above the economic competition between London and Paris, which is partially sorted out within the European institutions, such as the Lome Convention for example, the two imperialist capitals use all the mechanisms possible to improve their respective positions.

At the time of indonendence Pritain At the time of independence, Britain left institutions modelled on its traditions, and English is the main language of the administration, judiciary and legislature. The Hindu majority, which forms the bulk of the ranks of the civil service, is a decisive factor in maintaining the daily use of English there. (14) Constitutionally, candidates for the National Assembly must be able to speak English.

French-speaking other hand, derive fact that the big s French origin, anc PMSD which, for a to become a Crec French imperialists the Creole petty phone culture. T and the Mauritius I iation have a quie the cultural and lins

This produces major identity crisi obstacles to strengt Creole and Bhojpur Education is one oi confrontation betw ist camps, and Ma as they can with English, to get the to their pupils.

The French imp to regain ground dependence. The and military force carene Islands reg their colony on the Reunion as the org policy of investme as their informatio as a state "borderin by all the governme the most 'antiFrance is included agreements in the bourgeoisie of Reur

The Republic o important influen economy. In 192 million rupees wort but bought from i million rupees. Te is linked to the g rica, which buys a price higher than t ket. De luxe tour dustry in which So or less dominant. South African to each year. Little have got used to around. Their pres an accepted feature

While it is still such as Mauritius 12. See 'Communali dependance economi Gabriel, Politique A • June 1983. 13. A former Frenc de France, it became Mauritius is still not A member of the C as head of state is ret a Governor General. 14. Two languages languages of the cour based on French,

Mauritians, on the heir benefits from the ugar bourgeoisie is of I they supported the whole period, wanted le-based party. The therefore try to give ourgeoisie a Francohe Alliance Francaise British Cultural Assoct but deep rivalry on ruistic front. cultural chaos and a s, while increasing the hening the position of i as national languages. : the main areas of this reen the two imperialuritian teachers juggle French, Creole and ichool curriculum over erialists have been able on Mauritius since in• dominant economic in the Greater Masion, they have used neighbouring island of anising centre for their at and trading, as well n network. Accepted g on the Indian ocean' ints in the region, even imperialist' ' colonial in all the commercial zone, and carries the lion in its pocket. f South Africa has an ce in the Mauritian 33, Mauritius sold 32 h of goods to the RSA t goods valued at 449 a-growing in Mauritius ood will of South Afsubstantial share at a hat of the world marism has become an inuth Africans are more

More than 20,000 urists visit Mauritius by little, Mauritians seeing South Africans ence has thus become of everyday life. difficult in a country to justify these comsme, structures sociales et que a l'lle Maurice', C. fricaine, No 10, Paris, h colony then named Ile a British colony in 1814, an independent republic. immonwealth, the Queen ›resented on the island by are really the national try. In first place Creole, and Bhojpuri, based on

The overwhelming majority of

Hindi.

the population speak and understand Creole.

21

mercial relations with the racist regime, the government has been able to use the recent South Africa-Mozambique agreement to back up its position. A journalist summarised this approach with this candid explanation: 'At the time when Samora Machel and Kenneth Kaunda have resigned themselves to shaking hands with the South African prime minister; at the moment when Pieter Botha has been able to get invitations and receptions in six European capitals; at the time when he has asked for and got an audience with Pope John Paul II, you could say that it is not the end of the world if there is [Mauritian] commercial representation in South Africa.' (15) The record of the MMM

The MMM represented all the hopes of the mass of workers. A mass movement of the people, at certain periods it even expressed the unity of the toiling classes and ordinary people. This was particularly the case in June 1982, when the electoral victory was deeply felt by the workers as 'their victory. But this unity of the masses was never really achieved in practice in organisation and daily struggles.

For the last ten years, the MMM leadership has been evolving continuously towards the right. The first important turn was made in 1976, when the MMM was able to create a considerable parliamentary group. The pressure of the institutions, and the new role thus given to this opposition speeded up the crisis in the party, and its social-democratisation. But it is mainly in the last few years that the changes in the MMM have been confirmed.

Unprepared to provide a materialist analysis of communalism and Mauritian society, despite its claims to Marxism, obsessed by the search for a respectable and technocratic image, the MMM leadership brought about, in 1982, a break with the militant traditions of the party's past.

The MMM leadership, reduced to an apparatus that manipulates an unorganiised base, first adopted the role of proselytiser for the ideas of the French government minister, Michel Rocard; and then ended up by aping in words and in practice the Mitterrandist policy being applied in France at that time.

Paul Berenger's MMM is once again in the opposition. Its leadership has, therefore, for its present needs, adopted a rather populist language. But this is far from being a return to the 1970s, when it exonerated imperialism and capitalism. The present course of the MMM in the opposition proves that the policy of defence of bourgeois interests that it practised when in power was neither a passing tactic, nor an orientation imposed on it. Its present attitude, marked by political manoeuvres and communalist alliances, confirms that the last few years have set the seal on its final degeneration. 22

The Mauritian prime minister in the family photo of Franco-African summit (DR)

After its electoral defeat in 1983, the MMM could not retain its friendship with the big sugar bourgeoisie. Once the latter had won from the new government a renunciation of nationalisations and a commitment that the Sugar Authority project would be stripped of its content, it found it more worthwhile to reestablish relations with the parties in power than to support the MMM in opposition. Thus the MMM has to carry out a twofold policy: on the one hand, it has to present itself as the most 'expert' and competent of parties, while waiting for a new governmental crisis, and to then appear as the bourgeoisie's last hope; on the other hand, it has to appear as the party that defends the workers, so as to be able to rebuild its electoral base in the short term.

The workers' vanguard has thus a lot of difficulty in grasping the present reality of the MMM. Placing any hopes in it is particularly illusory as it does not, in the end, offer any real alternative to the government's policy, neither on the question of the foreign debt, on which it would like to be the most respectful of the imperialists' wishes, nor on the sugar industry, for which it has not changed the technocratic positions that distinguished it in 1983. On the question of unemployment, the MMM claims that when it was in government it was the best promoter of the free zone, and it glories in having sent more Mauritians to work abroad than the present government.

All reference to anti-imperialist struggles has been abandoned, and the MMM's time in power allowed it to place a number of its agents in the administrations and big enterprises. This happened in the port administration, where the position of these MMM-backed officials led increasingly to conflict with the party's traditional base among the dockers.

Advanced workers have thus found it difficult to maintain their faith in this party. It is this crisis of confidence in the leadership of the workers' movement that is the primary cause of the clear decline in workers' combativity over the last year and the demoralisation which has begun to set in.

The trade-union movement, the reflection of the political parties, is even more divided and weakened, as much because of corporatist divisions as because of its inability to stabilise its implantation in the workplaces. The MMM failed in its task of unifying the Mauritian proletariat. By proving incapable of maintaining a real influence in certain rural zones, the party showed that it was not really capable of overcoming the communal divisions that exist in the working class. (16)

The MMM, in order to make up the gap, has just entered into another political manoeuvre. It is now preparing to form a bloc with the PT, which is just out of the government. At first, the MMM leadership took care to camouflage what it was doing by trying to place this operation in the context of a broad unitary discussion open to all the parties of the opposition, including the far left. However, this convinced nobody, particularly as there has been an increasing number of articles in Nouveau Militant, the MMM's newspaper, that are simply apologias for the PT. There is no longer any doubt that the agreement has already been sealed by Berenger behind the scenes, even though the MMM central committee was opposed to it. For many rank-and-file militants, this will be hard to swallow because the PT is quite rightly perceived as 'the symbol of the country's neo-colonial and repressive history'. (17)

The left wing in the workers movement still capable of taking initiatives to alter the course of affairs is, at the moment, reduced to very small organised forces. There is a combative fringe which remains sympathetic to the MMM, although more and more critical of Berenger. This layer of militants would not break definitively with the MMM unless it found a real alternative leadership. Outside the MMM there are only two small far left organisations, both of which came out of the MMM, Lalit (The Strug15. Mauritius Today, Port-Louis, July 13-19, 1984. 16. The MMM controls one of the trade-union federations on the island, the General Workers Federation (GWF). This federation has two unions in the sugar industry, the SILU for cane cutters, and the UASI for factory workers, both of them very much minority unions. In Mauritius the cutters are mainly Hindus while the workers are mainly Creole. The task of workers' unionism in this sector is to unify the working class against the communalist unions. 17. Open letter to the MMM from the OMT, published in le Nouveau Militant, July 20, 1984.

"International Viewpoint 12 November 1984 cla str pla tre als thi fig ing gal vic str sio CO1 of pel ecc the gra in WO 18. Th cur whi Th fro tior Int 198 Inte

gle, in Creole) and the Militant Organisation of Workers (OMT), which leads the National Front Against Poverty (FNAS). (18) The latter organisation has just taken the initiative of confronting the MMM publicly on the question of unity with the PT, counterposing a proposal for forming a united front among only the working-class organisations.

As one of the OMT leaders declared, "The leadership of the MMM is misleading the workers about its present opposition to the government. There are lots of forums for discussion on the press or democratic freedoms, but no action. The workers are simply invited to be spectators in these forums. If the MMM returned to government, it would have a policy still more to the right than in 19823

Thus, the OMT considers that it is necessary to get the working-class base of the MMM to make one last effort to make a balance sheet of the leadership's policies, and to break with it. A new workers' party with a serious mass implantation could not emerge unless these hundreds of activists and sympathisers are won definitively to such a project.

But, over and above these conjunctural political battles, the resurgence of the Mauritian workers' movement will depend on much more daring initiatives. This is in part what the OMT is trying to do with its mass front, the FNAS. In Mauritius, where the industrial working class is a minority and the trade unions are very weak, a unifying framework for struggle has to be offered. There has to be some central arena for organising the young unemployed, women, the small planters and fisherfolk, as well as for the free zone workers and the workers in the sugar industry. The failure of the MMM also stems from its inability to provide this sort of broad organisation to the thousands of Mauritians who want to fight the bosses and the rich without being full members of a revolutionary organisation. The FNAS is aiming to provide this unifying framework, even if for the moment it is still a modest force. Through offering a framework for the struggle above the trade-union, professional or communalist divisions in the neighbourhoods, and in the future in the villages and factories, the FNAS could succeed in its objective.

For the OMT-FNAS, as for the rest of the Mauritian left, this is a decisive period. Given the upheavals going on in economic life, as well as social life and in the political parties, now is the time to grasp the significance of what is going on in order to go forward to rebuild the workers' and popular movement. 18. Lalit and the OMT derive from the MMM. These two organisations formed an opposition current which split in 1980. The tendency which formed Lalit left the MMM in 1982. That which gave rise to the OMT was excluded from the MMM in 1983. This latter organisation considers itself revolutionary Marxist. See International Viewpoint, No 49, March 26, 1984. International Viewpoint 12 November 1984

ICELAND

← Denmark: Thousands Strike for Peace · Iceland: Wage-earners Discontent Erupts →

Something wrong on this page?