International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Britain: A Leadership That Stands and Fights — Speech

· International Viewpoint No. 62, 20 October 1984 · pp 11-14 · 3,072 words

Britain and Ireland Trade unions China Cuba

Arthur Scargill addresses Labour Party conference (DR) "A leadership that stands and fights"

### Arthur Scargill speaks

If it's contempt we're talking about, then I plead guilty. But the only contempt I've committed is to fight for my class.' These were the words of Arthur Scargill, president of the British National Union of Mineworkers - NUM, when served with a high court writ [instruction] during Labour Party conference at the beginning of October. The writ ordered Scargill to appear in court charged with contempt of a previous order which ruled that the miners' strike must not be described as 'official'. Two strike-. breaking miners had brought the original action which claimed that the rules of the union had been broken by the refusal to call a ballot. union leadership claimed that a delegate conference was sufficient to make the strike official.

The miners have made it plain that they will not be starved into submission. The use of the courts is a sign of the weakness of the government and the establishment.

Arthur Scargill and the miners' union are now threatened with massive fines for continuing to disobey the court ruling and declaring the strike official. If the money is not paid, the union's assets will be seized.

This is a crucial time for the seven-month-old strike and now, more than ever, the backing of the entire labour movement will be needed to prevent the seizure of the union's assets and the attack on trade-union rights which it signifies.

Arthur Scargill spoke to a Labour Briefing (1) fringe meeting at Labour Party congrence, shortly after the writ had been served, expressing the defiance and determination of the union and its supporters around the country. Here we reprint a major part of his speech.

Chairman, colleagues,

I must confess that last night must have been a worrying time for some people, listening to that worker Lord Denning [a now-retired leading judge] giving forth on television when he said: It will have to be the use of the law against these trade unionists.

And of course we've got a whole series of unelected judges dispensing not justice but class law against our people who are involved in a struggle to maintain jobs, and to maintain the communities in which they live.

There's been a gauntlet thrown down. That gauntlet is being picked up. The • miners' union has been told after seven months of official strike action that the strike is no longer legal or official. What utter nonsense!

In 1981 there was an unofficial strike of the miners' union and the president of the union was Joe Gormley. There was 1. Labour Briefing is a journal in the Labour Party which organises sections of the left wing. It is sponsored by, among others, Socialist Action, a revolutionary Marxist newspaper.

11

no action at that time, no suggestion that there should have been a ballot.

I understand from reports on the media that the High Court today has been hearing an action brought against the National Union of Mineworkers, and the NUM President, seeking the sequestration of the union's funds and seeking to commit the president of the NUM to Pentonville prison.

We're aiso advised by reports in the media that the case has been adjourned allegedly in order that the union and its president can reconsider the position. In order to get clarity that we were aware of the decision of the High Court I thought we'd made our position clear. But if there's any ambiguity or any doubt on the part of the BBC or ITV [the main television stations], then in order to dispel it let's specifically state the union's position.

The national executive committee of the NUM meeting on Monday October 1, 1984 were told that a writ had been issued against the NUM. Following a full discussion the national executive committee unamimously agreed the following steps.

One, to fully endorse and support the views and comments expressed by the national president during the interview on Channel 4 news on Friday, September 28. (2)

Two, irrespective of the High Court decision, the executive unanimously reaffirmed its determination to continue to deal with the mineworkers' internal affairs in accordance with the rules and constitution of the NUM - as befits an independent and free trade union.

Three, to reaffirm as official the strike action in the British coalfields, including Yorkshire and Derbyshire, which has been sanctioned in accordance with national Rule No 41 by a national delegate conference - the governing body of our union which gives instructions to all members of the national executive including the national officials, the president, the general secretary and the vice president.

I want to make it clear the NUM will continue to do all in its power to win support for the miners' official strike in order to force the Coal Board back to the negotiating table. This dispute can only be resolved provided the pit closure programme announced by the National Coal Board [NCB] on March 6, is withdrawn, pits currently threatened with closure are kept open, and the Coal Board honours the Plan for Coal signed by the government, the National Coal Board and the trade unions. (3) They must withdraw their insistence that pits should be closed on economic grounds, which is a clear violation of the Plan for Coal.

I'm not someone who wishes to go to Pentonville prison. I'm not someone who relishes the thought of being committed in that way. But I want to make it absolutely clear that if the choice facing me - and I would hope facing any other marnandible toodonnion loodor - icto ho responsible trade-union leader - is to be 12

WE'LL EAT GRASS BEFORE sPyr

WE PPORT GIVE

DHAA 5 BITH

TAN IN Miners' wives put their point (DR) committed by a high court to Pentonville or any other jail for standing by this trade union or our class, or alternatively having to live with the imprisonment of one's mind for betraying one's class, then there is no choice as far as I'm concerned. I stand by my class.

There seems to be a blind spot on the part of the judiciary, the government and the Coal Board. The miners' union did not go out on strike on Friday, we've been on strike for seven months. We've suffered appalling hardship during the space of that time. We've come too far, we've suffered too much, for there to be any compromise.

On the basis of the NCB official figures of the 43,141 miners made redundant over the past two years, only 72 (only two per cent) have found alternative work. It's nonsense to suggest that miners would be in a position to have an alternative job, particularly with four and a half million people unemployed.

The figures show quite clearly that for one miner to be made redundant, with all the factors to be taken into consideration, such as the redundancy payments scheme, the loss of tax, the state benefits, the unemployment benefit for his son or daughter who cannot have a job, the total cost at the end of seven years is over £91,000. To keep that person employed, to keep that job available for his son or his daughter as well, would only cost £48,000.

It doesn't make economic sense, let alone social, political or moral sense, to create redundancy in this or any other industry.

The cost of the strike described by Neil Kinnock [leader of the Labour Party] in his speech on Tuesday as approximately £2 billion, has been made to look infinitesimal according to the study by Andrew Glyn for the NUM. By September, irrespective of what Nigel Lawson [finance minister] has said, £3.5 billion has been the cost to the British taxpayers of this damaging and costly dispute. There has been £2.3 billion or more in lost production. Fifty four million tons of coal have been lost in the space of this dispute.

The Coal Board claim they wanted to take only four million tons of capacity out of this industry. They wanted to bring supply in line with demand - the capitalists' maxim of the market concept.

Even if one were to accept this approach, rather than the social and sensible one of the NUM, even on that basis the current dispute with the Board, and the fact that they are now prolonging it -with the government aiding and abetting them - does not make sense.

They've got 14 times the capacity reduction that they themselves claim they required. They themselves suggested they wanted a total coal output by 1989 of 497 million tons. That programme would have included pit closure, a programme of about 70 pits and 70,000 jobs.

The Coal Board themselves now concede that due to five million tons of lost production, the maximum coal output that they can achieve in the next five years, by 1989, is no longer 497 million tons. It is only 480 million tons. And that can only be achieved with not one single pit closure on any count.

We are entitled to ask therefore why have the government and the NCB still determined to press ahead with their proposals announced in March of this year? Ill tell you why. It is not about closing a few pits, it goes to the very heart of the economic philosophy of this government.

You can either choose the balance sheet mentality of this government - of producing a political and economic solution that considers profits rather than people — or you can accept the social and sensible approach from the NUM and the labour and trade-union movement that puts at the very centre of its argument the benefit of human beings rather than statistics in the balance sheet of the Coal Board or the balance sheet mentality of Ian MacGregor [chairperson of the Coal Board].

They can tell us there is insufficient money for investment, but then they 2. It was in this television news programme that Scargill reasserted that the strike was official in defiance of the high court ruling issued that day.

The Plan for Coal was drawn up first in 1974 and revised in 1977. It was an agreement between the unions, the National Coal Board and the government to radically increase coal production.

International Viewpoint 29 October 1984

should stop the cruise and Trident missiles programme.

This fellow MacGregor, he really takes the biscuit. I remember during the negotiations, one Saturday evening, Mick MeGahey [Scottish NUM leader], Peter Heathfield [NUM General Secretary ] and I thought we were on our way to settlement. We'd reached a point where we thought seriously that the Board were going to concede, and we adjourned for the night.

We began to drink a cup of tea in the Coal Board office. Mick MeGahey says to MacGregor: I went to the Soviet Union in 1954 and the pits had been devastated, but development was their aim, and the people were regarded as the most important thing. Today the industry has been developed in a most unbelievable way.

MacGregor says: "You known, Michael, I was there in 1956, and I agree with you. Those Russians have done a great job. Not as well as I would have liked, but pretty good, pretty good.'

Peter Heathfield then says: I'll tell you what, I went to China. The Chinese have got coal where previously there were only paddy fields. Terrific. Marvellous'

And MacGregor says: 'You know, Peter, I too have been to China. And those Chinese are doing better than those Russians.'

And I thought, I'm not going to be left out of this. 'Do you know the country I think's the best I've seen? Cuba. Do you know, I said, T've visited the mines in Cuba, in the Oriente province, and to compare those mines today, under the socialist system, with the divisions and the problems they had under the private owners before the revolution was fantastic. Did you ever see them?'

There was then what's called a pregnant pause. And finally it wasn't 'Michael' or 'Peter'. "Mr Scargill I was the owner,' says MacGregor. And he said: 'Your friend Castro, Fidel Castro, took them off me!

MeGahey says: "That's buggered it" And MacGregor changed his mind next day.

What kind of a head of the National Coal Board is it who has no concept of the British labour and trade-union movement? A man who, in the USA, was head of a mining company which was quite openly in association with the development of mines that employed non-union labour. I have no doubt that this will be the kind of policy and philosophy which he will attempt to pursue here in Britain today.

The miners' union today are fighting for their jobs. They're fighting for their communities. They're fighting for a way of life, for a culture.

Someone said to me 'do you believe the resolve of miners is beginning to weaken? But there is one phenomenon over all others which in this dispute has made mineworkers absolutely determined to win. The involvement of women.

I went to a meeting in South Wales, and in the course of that meeting one International Viewpoint 29 October 1984 woman got up and said: 'We want to make it clear no matter what anyone says it's no longer a question of whether the miners feel that this or that can be negotiated. You're not negotiating for the future of your pits, you're negotiating for the future of our livelihood, our communities. No compromise. You'll not resolve this until the Board withdraw their pit closure programme?

I don't know what's going to happen. I do know that since the announcement of the writ being issued on Monday there has been the full meeting of the NUM executive committee. It declared that its intention is to continue to declare this strike official.

And the Yorkshire area NUM council have also unanimously agreed that the strike must continue to be declared official. They too are refusing to accept a decision of the High Court....

Make no mistake, this national executive of the NUM is not prepared to betray its members. Often in the past workers and trade-union members have pointed to leaders and said: They sold us out. They betrayed us. They said one thing before they were elected and another thing once they got their nice job as a full-time trade-union leader.'

When I campaigned for the job of national president of my union I made clear that if the members of the NUM wanted a president who was intent on becoming a lord, then don't vote for me. I said it was more important not to prostitute one's principles, or to compromise the policies of the national conference of my union than to have a seat in the House of Lords. I gave a pledge that throughout my trade-union career I would do everything I could to take forward the aims and aspirations of the members of my union....

We are facing a crunch. We are facing a gover ent that is becoming increasingly fearfu. nd angry. And the twin effects of anger and fear are showing themselves in the wild hysteria of their attacks upon our class and in their attacks upon this union.

It's no accident that thousands of police have been drafted in from all over to turn our villages into places where people can't enter without a passport. If

YOU COULD SE NEXTA people don't understand, they should go and have a look.

We've had public service buses turned back on the public highway because 10 miners pickets have been on board. We've had football teams turned back because they might have been pickets in disguise. We've had people arrested while they were travelling to court. Civil liberties and human rights are systematically being dismantled.

Those of us who do not take warning at what is taking place will do so at our peril. They've come today for the National Union of Mineworkers, and they'll come tomorrow for the rest of the movement.

We are going to resist with all the power we can muster. And if that means that we have to suffer, if I am sent to jail, that is something we will have to accept. We will accept the consequences of our actions because it is more important to stand by one's class, and to stand by one's members, than to cave in and accept the decisions either of an unelected judge, or the diktat of a government that can't even spell the word democracy.

Over the next period we're going to be involved in possibly the most major confrontation that we have witnessed. We're now facing the full might of the judiciary. We've got so many writs we could paper two rooms the size of this one with them.

We've got the South Wales area that's had all their funds sequestrated. We've got an action against the South Wales NUM, North Wales area, Durham area, Yorkshire area, Lancashire area. We've had actions pursued against the Scottish miners. And no doubt writs to come against all the other sections that are involved in this historic dispute.

There are two options available. We can either accept the imposition of the organised might of the state. Or we can stand firmly by the policies not merely of our union but the policies of the Trade Union Congress, and the policies of this party.

Let me remind you that the TUC are on record demanding that there should be no loss of jobs. This party is on record arguing against redundancies. The TUC is on record arguing against the anti-trade-union legislation in all its forms. And so is our party.

Now is the time to turn those words into deeds.

I speak not for myself. I am not speaking for the executive of the miners' union. I believe that I'm speaking for the entire trade-union and labour movement when I say that there is an obligation on each and every one of you to stand up and be counted.

Time and time again people have said we need leadership. If we had proper leadership, we could win. Well, you've got leadership. Leadership that is prepared to stand and fight, whatever the consequences. Comrades, given that leadership, we too have the right to demand your support.

Given that support we are invincible.•

13

GREECE

← Nicaragua: Democratic Elections in a War Economy · Greece: Papandreou Talks Peace but Steps Up Arms Race →

Something wrong on this page?