What is at stake in the trial of Belgrad six What Poland was spared by the recent amnesty faces Yugoslavia this fall - a political show trial against a whole group of critical intellectuals. On the basis of their participation in the Free Üniversities movement in the Yugoslav capital, the following have been charged with "forming a group for the purpose of conducting hostile activity" (Article 139, Section 1 of the Criminal Code), as well as with "constituting a counterrevolutionary danger to the social order" (Article 114, Section 1 of the Criminal Code):
Vlaimir Mijanovic, age 38, the best known spokesperson of the 1968 Belgrade student movement; the translator Pavlusko Imsirovic, age 35; the sociologist Milan Nikolic, age 37, the journalist Dragomir Olujic, 35; the student Gordan Jovanovic, 24; and Midrag Milic, 55.
In mid-Jut handed down against the left sociology professor Vojislav in the Bosnian capital of Sarajevo, an eight-year prison Seslj on the basis of things he wrote in an unpublished manuscript. The authorities clearly wanted to make an example of him. Following this sentence, the Belgrade Six are threatened with prison terms of between five and fifteen years.
emerged. Petitions for the abolition of the "clauses affecting freedom of conscience" in the Yugoslav criminal code, which make it possible to prosecute people just for things they say, or against the death penalty have not only gained hundreds of signatures but also been openly discussed in the media. The Slovenian youth paper Mladina is conducting a full-fledged campaign against the death penalty.
In recent years, the Free Universities have of course no longer played the same role that they did at the time when all these possibilities did not yet exist. In Belgrade, however, the Free University sessions were an important underpinning for those working in the official media. In particular, for the "New Left" coming out of the student movement (this is the term used in the Yugoslav media), they served as a framework for an ongoing exchange of opinions, although the most various tendencies were represented in these sessions.
"In past years, we have concerned ourselves mainly with the economy, but now the Party has to resume the leading role in intellectual life." That was the comment ol government press spokesperson ment of government press spokesperson Ante Gavranovic, editor in chief of the Zagreb Prioredi Vjesnik on the recent events.
In fact, in the past year, there must have been a constellation of power in the party oligarchy that forced the so-called liberal wing on the defensive. Sections of the Serbian and Slovenian party leaderships are considered "liberal." On the other hand, the Bosnian party leadership under Branko Mikulic, the organizer of the Winter Olympics in Sarajevo, is considered to support tougher repression, along with the Croatian leadership and the party heads in the autonomous provinces of Vojvodina and Kosovo.
Since this summer a man who is certainly well used to repression has stood at the head of the federal party organization. He is the Kosovo Albanian Ali Shukria. In recent years 800 Albanian nationalists have been sentenced to shockingly long prison sentences. The wave of trials in this area, moreover, continued unabated this summer.
Since the move against critical intellectuals is bound up with a power struggle in the bureaucracy, in which the present Serbian leadership under Ivan Stambolic could lose its skin, there have also been some other important parallel operations. In early May, the Central Committee of these ship or part well known hardiner. the Croatian party, under the chairStipe Suvar, held an ideological conference in which the intellectual tendencies in Serbia in particular were stigmatized as the expression of a creeping counterrevolution. There were strong protests in the Serbian press and violent arguments in the Central Committee of the Serbian party.
By the way of documentation for the conference, Suvar ordered the preparation of a 237-page white paper, which included a sort of index of all the expres-
International Viewpoint 1 October 1984
Branko BRIZMAN
The six were arrested a few weeks after the police broke up a session of the Free University on April 20 at which Milovan Djilas introduced a discussion on the nationalities problem in Yugoslavia. Three of them then went on hunger strike, and two - Vladimir Mijanovic and Pavlusko Imsirovic remained on it for 42 days up until they were released on bail at the beginning of July.
The release of the six on bail was an unusual occurrence for Yugoslavia and can no doubt be attributed to the campaign on their behalf internationally and, particularly, in Yugoslavia to the thousand citizens who signed petitions to country's highest state bodies. The indictment handed down against them on August 6 indicates, however, that those in the party leadership who advocate tougher repression have for the time being prevailed.
In Belgrade intellectual circles, people stress the complete abitrariness with which the authorities proceeded. Thus, the film maker Lazar Stojanovic said: "For seven years between twenty and fifty people met in private without bother from the police. I can't understand how they can pick out a few people without arresting all those who were there. I was there from the beginning, and, if necessary, I'll say that in court."
A group of philosophers who were around the journal Praxis, which was shut down ten years ago, publicly took responsibility for the Free Universities. One of them, Ljubomir Tadic, said: "After our expulsion from the University of Belgrade, we tried to continue our intellectual activities. The regime knows that very well."
Statements by participants indicate that a wide range of themes were discussed that are taken up too little or not 10 at all in public forums. They discussed Zen Buddhism and Stalinism, Rudolf Bahro and the theory of ideas as reflections, psychoanalysis and the Polish Solidarnose.
No wonder that a lot of Yugoslav intellectuals see the criminalizing of such discussions as a severe blow to the growing liberalization of the intellectual climate in the country in recent years. A communique from the Croatian Philosophy Association issued in early June said: "Since we believe that theoretical discussions cannot be characterized as hostile activity nor public meetings as illegal assemblies, we are totally convinced that these prosecutions must be stopped and those arrested released."
The fact that an indictment was handed down despite many protests of this sort shows that, against the backdrop of a continuing severe economic crisis, a general rollback of the liberalization in the ideological sphere is planned. In fact, in recent years, especially in the Slovenian and Serbian republics, certain areas of intellectual and democratic freedoms developed that are astonishing under a one-party dictatorship. Back to thought control
In Yugoslav bookstores, you can buy the books of Rudolf Bahro as well as those of Solzhenitsyn, those of Ernest Mandel as well as those of George Orwell. Last year the magazine of the Serbian Young Writers Union, Knjizena Rec, published startling articles on the complicity of the Tito leadership in the "persecution of the Trotskyists" (which was aimed 99% against non-Trotskyists) in the 1930s and during the liberation war.
On the basis of the right granted by the Yugoslav constitution to collectively petition the state bodies, a weak but not negligible democratic public opinion has
sions by artists and journalists in recent years that he regarded as anti-party. This "Flowers of Evil" as the Belgrade press mockingly referred to the tom, was banned outright in Belgrade by court order. Power struggle in bureaucracy
After a brief respite, this conflict escalated again in early August. In the Zagreb weekly magazine Danas, the Croatian politician Jure Bilie called for reprimanding a party leadership that had failed to keep the life of the society sufficiently under control. Everyone knew that he was referring to the Serbs.
Ljobomir Tadic summed up: "We now have different currents in the leadership — a very weak liberal current and an unfortunately strong neo-Stalinist grouping." The weakness of the "liberals" is indicated by the suppression of the Free Universities in Belgrade, which was obviously imposed against the will of the Serbain authorities by the Federal authorities and in particular by the State Presidium.
Moreover, before the trial of Vojislav Seselj, the Slovene Mitija Ribicic spoke out in the Belgrade magazine Nin in opposition to taking administrative measures against intellectuals: "The way to fight books is with other books." This advice was not followed, as the condemnation of Seselj showed.
Since it is to be feared that the Sarajevo trial will be taken as a model for the Belgrade case, it is worth taking a more careful look at the judgment of the court. The essential target of the indictment was a manuscript that Seselj sent last fall to the editor of the party journal Komunist, Dusan Bogavac, in Belgrade. It bore a title with historical resonance, "What Is To Be Done?" Bogavac testified that he never got this manuscript. Obviously the state security police took it.
In fact, during the Winter Olympics in Sarajevo the manuscript was seized during a search of Seselj's home, along with 1,700 pages of other unpublished manuscripts. Excerpts from this article, which besides the author only the police had seen, were shortly afterward revealed by leading politicians. Mitija Ribicic did so on April 12 and the then minister of the interior and present member of the State Presidium Stane Dolane did so in a TV interview May 8. It was not they, however, who were arrested for counterrevolutionary propaganda, but Seselj who was jailed on May 15.
Although the prosecution was unable to produce one witness to say that Seselj had put the manuscript into his or her hand, the court upheld the charge that the author had engaged in counterrevolutionary propaganda for the purpose of carrying out common action with others. There are some other interesting facts. After Seselj's arrest, some people in Sarajevo got anonymous letters, along with photocopies of the supposedly inInternational Viewpoint 1 October 1984 criminating article. It is an interesting question who sent them.
The second kind of evidence cited in the indictment were reports of disparaging remarks that Seselj supposedly made to individuals about Yugoslavia's political system. One of these "witnesses" had never seen Seselj in his life before testifying in court. Others are considered to be agents provocateurs at the University of Sarajevo.
Despite such laughable evidence, the court imposed the sentence of eight years, and the judge, Milorad Potpalic even had the nerve to say that this amounted to clemency because Seselj's activity had represented "the strongest attack on the bases of the new Yugoslavia" since Tito's break with Stalin.
In fact, as far as can be judged from Seselj's previously published works and the quotes from "What Is To Be Done?" given in the Yugoslav press, they were intended to be a socialist critique of the political relationships in the country. Seselj criticized the chaos of the unplanned and bureaucratic model of self-management in Yugoslavia, pointed to the undemocratic traditions of the League of Yugoslav Communists, and demanded an investigation into the responsibility of the late President Tito for the present crisis of the country. A decisive test of strength
During the trial itself, witnesses report, despite his 42-day-long hunger strike, he expressed himself with no less vigor and courage. Even colleagues of Seselj in Zagreb and Belgrade who did not agree with his views or actions rejected the disgusting campaign of slander against him in the Yugoslav media, which has sought to present him as venal and a political madman.
The main attack by the media against Seselj was focused on a short passage in his manuscript "What Is To Be Done?," which most dissidents in Yugoslavia would regard in fact as a serious error. In it, Seselj proposed the abolition of the republics of Bosnia and Montenegro and dividing up their territory between Serbia and Croatia, as well as the nonrecognition of the "Muslims" as a nationality.
Either step would undoubtedly dangerously excite national passions in Yugoslavia and, in particular, lead to a grave crisis in Bosnia, which is inhabited by Serbs and Croats, Catholics, Orthodox and Muslims. On this, Ljubomir Tadic said: "These views can be criticized, but all this relates to the questions under discussion - the way our federation is organized, our nationalities policy."
The moral of this farce is quite clear. Every dissident intellectual now knows that he or she can be put on trial any time the authorities feel like it, even if the police cannot produce a shred of evidence of any illegal activity. Already this summer the critical intellectuals in Belgrade got a foretaste of this new procedure. The interrogation of some ninety people, four house searches and numerous confiscations of letters and manuscripts created a climate of constant anxiety and insecurity.
The indictment against the Belgrade Six drawn up by the state prosecutor, Danilo Nanovic, concentrates on counting up the number of time each of the accused is supposed to have been present at Free University sessions since 1977. Vladimir Mijanovic is accused of being "responsible" for the organizational aspects of the sessions.
Miodrag Milie is supposed to have spoken critically about the personality cult around Josif Broz Tito, and Dragomir Olujic is supposed to have stressed the importance of a strong trade-union movement in Yugoslavia. Quotations from the manuscripts of the accused as well as verbal statements attributed to them are supposed to prove the "counterrevolutionary character" of the sessions.
Thus, Srdja Popovic, one of Vladimir Mijanovic's lawyers, said in response to the indictment: "The prosecutor's office suspects the aceused of having done something that has always and everywhere been allowed - visiting people, receiving people and engaging in discussions. It calls all this illegal because it attributes 'counterrevolutionary' views to the accused. There is no proof of this accusation. By this method anyone could be charged or any sort of everyday activity if certain views were attributed to them."
As the Seselj case has shown, the verdict depends little on the strength of the proofs offered by the prosecution or the counterproofs of the defense. Behind it there will be a political decision. It was no accident that days before the official indictment was made, State Chairman Veselin Djuranovic announced at the Central Committee plenum of the Montenegrian party that the trial was going to be held in the near future.
On August 6, Vladimir Mijanovic replied as follows in an "Open Letter":
"Just keep on sowing anxiety, so that you won't have to face any disagreeable questions about your historical, personal and collective responsibility for the economic, political and moral impasse in which the country finds itself! Just keep on demanding that "The Central Committee get off the defensive by sending me and others to prison. I tell you: I'm not goint to let you get away with waging the 'special war' you have dreamed up at my expense. I'm not going to let you get away with making an example out of me to intimidate others! Is there a way? There is one possibility, a general political amnesty now!"
Agence France Press has reported that all six have declared that they will go on an unlimited hunger strike if they are convicted. This trial is shaping up as a test of strength both between the critical intellectuals and the authorities and between the different factions within the bureaucracy that will set the course for the future evolution of Yugoslavia.
11