What the rise of
Rabbi Kahane represents
The most dramatic note in the July general elections in Israel was that for the first time an open advocate of driving out all the Arabs remaining on Zionist-ruled territories won a seat in parliament.
At the same time, this sinister figure gained parliamentary immunity for organizing racist rabble-rousing and gang attacks on the Arab communities.
So, Rabbi Meir Kahane began immediately to increase the temperature of
Zionist politics.
trying to touch the bright clothing of the Jewish women, which they obviously admired.
The formal Jewish support for the demonstration went beyond the non-Zionist left. There were speakers from the Israeli Labor Party for instance. But they apparently brought few people. The main body of the demonstrators were people from radical backgrounds in Central and Eastern Europe who were forced to settle in the Zionist colony by forces beyond their control. There were also a number of younger people who looked like the hard-core of US anti-Vietnam war demonstrators.
This contingent did reflect some important contradictions in the settler community, the présence of old radical forces and a terment among the you made and a ferment among the youth made possible by bourgeois democracy. But it did not yet represent a powerful and growing current in the Jewish community.
In the same period, momentum began to build for a demonstration against Kahane at the opening of the Knesset, the Israeli parliament. It was held about two weeks later on the sidewalk of the road running past the hill in West Jerusalem where the Knesset stands. This protest had very wide sponsorship, including from organizations of the Labor Party. But they did not mobilize many people, although the demonstration of about 2,000 was considered respectable for Jerusalem on a workday.
• Even the mayor of Jerusalem, Teddy Kollek, spoke, although after public hesitation. He had said before that he could not take part because he had heard that the demonstration was being organized by the Matzpen group, as the section of the Fourth International in Israel is generally known. - In fact, the Revolutionary Communist League played an important role. They were well regarded as reliable and capable organizers of mass demonstrations, and on this occasion, as well as others, even moderate forces in the Jewish community were ready to accept their help. The RCL is also well known - them as the most intransigent opponent of Zionism. So, when Kollek made his statement, he did not have to explain whom he was talking about. Nonetheless, he ended up coming to the rally as the keynote speaker.
The RCL had fought to make the demonstration against racism rather than against fascism. They argued that Kahane was a result of the logic of Zionism, linked to its institutions by a thousand underground roots, and not the product. of a fundamental crisis of capitalism, as fascism was.
The official theme of the demonstration was opposition to racism. But the Labor Party contingents pushed antifascist slogans, and they also apparently came most easily to the lips of most of the demonstrators. Thus, the main chant was Ha-Fashism lo yavor (Fascism Shall Not Pass").
This framework offered the left
Gerry FOLEY
In August, when I was in Israel, and since, Rabbi Meir Kahane has provided a focus for the deepening crisis of Zionism. Indeed, better than any other single event his rise has highlighted the crisis and the degeneration of Zionist ideology, symbolizing the fading of those elements that reflected the search of oppressed Jews for a solution to their problems and the growing predominance of racist and reactionary attitudes based on the disinheriting and repression of the Arab people of Palestine. In fact, as a founder of the Jewish Defense League in the US, an organization aimed mainly against Blacks, Kahane is a by-product of American racism.
Historical Zionism, moreover, was a mainly secular ideology, offering release from the suffocating religious rules and ritual of the ghetto. Appropriately, the outstanding representative of a decaying Zionism, poisoned by its basic contradiction - the scheme of liberating the Jews through an alliance with imperialism and by crushing another people - is both a religious and racist fanatic.
On the basis of the claim that the Jews have a divine right to supremacy in Palestine, the American-born religious leader has no qualms about referring to Arabs in rallies as "dogs" and organizing pogromist gangs to attack Arab settlements.
By its nature, Kahane's brand of rabble rousing requires provocations. Immediately after his election, he announced his intention to open a "Palestinian emigration office" in Um AlFahum, the largest Arab town near the Zionist core settlements.
In response to the threat, the town leaders called a joint Arab-Jewish rally. It was held on the first weekend in July, just after I arrived in the country.
Although Um Al-Fahum is only about an hour's trip from Tel Aviv by bus, it is a different world. It is high in barren hills still inhabited by Arabs, no doubt because they had little to attract Zionist settlers.
Today, these Arab mountain towns live mainly from the crumbs of the International Viewpoint 17 September 1984
Jewish society, from casual and marginal jobs in Tel Aviv. On the outskirts of the Jewish towns, you can see groups of Arab men and boys standing about. Everyone in Israel calls them the "slave markets." There is no ideological motivation behind this term, no denunciation; it is just a description that everyone accepts as obvious.
I was struck in fact that there had been so little trickle down of Jewish economic development to an Arab town in an area so near the biggest city of the Zionist settlement.
Tel Aviv as a whole has a West European standard of living, poorer than the best off countries but with a more prosperous look than Britain. In the northern part of the city in particular, you could think you were in a middle-class suburb of Miami.
But in Um Al-Fahum, foul smelling water runs down the middle of poorly maintained roads. Skin inflammations are common among the children. And the people in general have an undernourished look - notably thinner, smaller and more gnarled than the Jews.
The town government is in the hands of the Communist Party. In the July elections, the CP-led Democratic Front got 46% of the vote here, and the Progressive List 37%; in all, 83% for the non-Zionist left slates. The CP has a long tradition here, but it has accomodated itself to the backward society, making little attempt to change it. On the other hand, it does use the method of mass mobilization. And the demonstration against Kahane was a good example.
The roughly two thousand Jewish demonstrators walked into the town through serrried ranks of local people clapping and shouting Welcome, Welcome," and Shalom! [which means both "peace" and "greetings"]. Huge banners carried the same slogans. The town was mobilized.
In Israeli conditions, the presence of even a small number of Jewish demonstrators was important to the security of the local people. Their welcome was genuinely enthusiastic. But the social and cultural gap was vast. I noticed, for example, little Arab girls surreptitiously
and liberal Zionist speakers ample room for self-satisfied declarations about how antagonistic the Jewish people were to fascism and how alien it supposedly was to what they claimed were the generous and humane values of Zionism. This gave them a way to avoid saying anything concrete about the racist discrimination that the Arabs under Israeli rule face in every aspect of their lives. Thus, they did not have to pay much of a price for participating in an action in which they had strong material interests. The passing of a kind of innocence
The viability of the Zionist society has in fact depended to a considerable extent on its maintaining a progressive, democratic image, and this is threatened by the rise of the activist right.
Although the Zionist authorities maintain a massive military and repressive machine, it has a rather innocent appearance to the American or European visitor, quite unlike the ugly face of the British military in the North of Ireland or the low-lives of the Irish political police.
In Israel the repressive machine is decent-looking people everywhere in rather casual military dress, carrying weapons but relaxed, convivial, confident. It is the sort of "people's defense force" that could only be built on the basis of the conviction of an entire people that they were engaged, together, in a righteous undertaking.
Even in the military courts, most of the judges, guards, prosecutors, etc. do not have the brutalized look of their counterparts, even in the most bourgeois democratic of countries. Nor do they fit the image of the "hanging judges" of British rule in Ireland, although their historical role is very similar.
For example, in a military court in Nablus, I watched the Israeli personnel as an Arab woman collapsed, hearing her husband sentenced to two years in prison for an alleged minor act of defiance. The occupation authorities had waited two years before even bringing the charge. The Israelis' attitude was wide-eyed surprise, but without much emotion, neither the sort of hatred you see on the part of the British and Orange repressive forces in Northern Ireland, nor sympathy. It did not seem that they were cruel, just that the fate of an Arab did not much concern them. It was only a bit of a shock, unpleasant, like seeing a dog run over.
This was a society that has been able to accept the imposition of the most thoroughgoing official and unofficial terror against a conquered people. (In the Gaza Strip, for instance, I listened to an Arab women recall how the Israeli army executed all the men and boys over 14 years of age in her village in retaliation for a guerrilla bombing.) Yet it was a society that, despite all, retained a kind of innocence. The time for that is now quickly passing. That is what the crisis of Zionism means. 3x5 10