Miners' strike opens new political situation
The September Trades Union Congress was completely dominated by the miners' strike. TUC leaders were forced to make a clear statement of support for the miners' union which had the effect of isolating the right wing of the trade union bureaucracy on this issue. It remains to be seen whether TUC policy can be translated into decisive action, not least in the power stations, over the coming weeks and months. Certainly the National Union of Mineworkers (NUM) leaders made real concessions to get a common statement from TUC leaders.
A statement of total support, overwhelmingly carried on the first day of Congress, calls on unions to bar the carriage of coal, coke and other fuels across picket lines. But, as the Financial Times (September 3, 1984) comments, 'the support is conditional on agreement with the unions concerned. Chapple, rightwing leader of the powerworkers' union, explained his view. "The miners have been outrageous in their behaviour from the start...They do not deserve any support and they will not get it from the power stations.' Nevertheless, miners' leader Scargill claimed agreement with workers at five power stations to boycott the movement of coal within days of the TUC statement being voted through Congress.
Labour Party leader Neil Kinnock spoke to the TUC on the second day, echoing one of the main themes of the ruling class attack on the miners. The NUM, he explained, had provided the government 'with opportunity they have long sought to introduce politically motivated change in the methods of British policing.'
Kinnock's craven speech was a right-wing provocation against the miners who are defending themselves against a vast and unprecedented police assault on their picket lines. He tried to minimise the commitment of the TUC and the labour movement to the miners by his speech, and thereby reunite the right-wing trade union bureaucracy around himself.
Despite Kinnock's speech (which provided legitimation for Channle and other right-wing leaders) earlv refavourable to the miners. In the first place, the dockers' strike has consolidated. Picketing has stepped up. Back to work moves at Tilbury and Hull have been stopped. Secondly, Thatcher was forced to interrupt a visit to Scotland to attend an emergency Cabinet committee meeting to discuss the implications of the TUC. Thirdly, Basnett, architect of the TUC statement, has called conferences of the members of his union (GMBACTU) who work at power stations to discuss the implementation of TUC policy on the miners' strike. Finally, the employers, the National Coal Board (NCB) have initiated further moves towards talks with the NUM, (although the government is not yet prepared to make any serious concessions).
Nevertheless, the unity of the leadership of the TUC, expressed by their statement on the miners' strike, was bought at a cost. It remains to be seen whether the price was too high. Until recently, the NUM has kept the TUC at arm's length, because of its treacherous role in recent disputes with the government. Asked to comment on the TUC statement, TUC leader Murray denied that the statement was aimed at 'buying peace" at the congress. 'The important thing is that the TUC is involved.
Originally the miners' union was set to lead the battle of the left wing at the TUC congress. But fighting amendments to their resolution on the strike were dropped to win a big majority of the union leaderships to support the TUC statement. A great deal now depends on whether the NUM can use the TUC statement to deepen the effects of their strike. In any case, it will be necessary to organise a left wing of the British labour movement around demands such as a national TUC Day of Action, whatever the results of the TUC's agreement. The right wing are still mobilising to defeat the miners. The article below, written before the TUC took place, looks at the political impact of the miners' strike in more depth.
B.H.
tion for Chapple and other right-wing leaders) early reactions to and results of the TUC Brian HERON
From the moment that it started, the British miner's strike was a fundamental class battle. (1) In the first seventeen weeks of the strike, the Thatcher government pretended that it was not involved. Thatcher claimed that the question was one to be solved by the NCB (National Coal Board) and its recently chosen American manager, MacGregor, and the NUM (National Union of Mineworkers.) In fact 20,000 police were mobilised for action against the miners' pickets. So far there have been nearly 4,000 arrests and two pickets have been killed. As well, the social security system has been used to starve miners' families back to work.
By July Thatcher was forced out of her corner. She indelibly marked the future of her government with the aim of victory in the miners' strike. She explained that while Galtieri (the Argen4 statement appear tinian dictator during the Malvinas war) had been the enemy without, during the coal strike 'we are fighting the enemy within? With this particularly inept comment, Thatcher both exposed the role of the Malyinas war and her attitude toward the trade union movement.
Of course her comments caused a storm of protest. But, most importantly, they marked the end of the supposed neutralism of the government. Naturally, the spotlight now moves onto the labour movement response. The coming Trades Union Congress (representing 9.5 million trade unionists) which meets in early September will be the forum where a labour movement response to the government's declaration of war is decided.
In fact, solidarity action by the whole of the working class has always been the issue in this miners' strike. It has been established by the press that considerable government effort has gone into pre-
B.H. September 6, 1984 venting other important sections of workers taking action during the miners' strike. According to the Economist (August 18, 1984), "Two forces could disturb the crumbling of the strike [the Economist article predicts victory for the government by next Spring]. The first would be new trouble at the docks.... Second...executives of the two main rail unions want to fight job reductions on the railways by a one day strike...along with an unlimited work to rule campaign designed to disrupt services.'
In fact there has already been a national dockers' strike after the British Steel Corporation (BSC) broke existing agreements in loading iron ore for steel 1. See Steve Roberts "Miners' strike most serious challenge yet to Thatcher' (International Viewpoint, No 50, April 9, 1984) and Pat Hickey Labour movement left challenges new realism' (IV, No 53, May 21, 1984).
International Viewpoint 17 September 1984
production at the east coast port Immingham. The Transport and General Workers Union (which organises the vast majority of dockers) called a national strike against this breach of the hard-won dock labour scheme (a scheme that guarantees every docker a job, regardless of the demand for dock labour). The scheme had been under attack for some time. On this occasion the port authorities found that BSC had acted to breach the agreement. After two weeks strike by dockers (in which the president of the Confederation of British Industry remarked that only 25 percent of his member companies would be working in two weeks if the strike continued) the climb-down by employers meant a return to work.
The action of the dockers underlined the strategic weakness of the government. The Economist's fears are not without foundation. Any decisive section of the workers' movement coming into struggle alongside the miners will create a desperate emergency for the government.
As we write, a new dock strike has been called. The Ostia, a ship loaded with coal for the Scottish Ravenscraig steel works, has been unloaded at Hunterston docks by British Steel Corporation employees. 'Scab coal delivered by scab labour, said miners' president Scargill. In the first instance Scottish dockers at Scotland's twelve largest prots walked out. A national conference of Transport and General Workers Union dock workers, representing 35,000 docks and waterways workers, called an official strike following the conference on August 24. The bosses' and government's game
Certainly BSC's action is a deliberate provocation which, because of its consequences, must have been agreed to by the government. In fact Transport Union dockers have already offered a substantial coal quota to the Ravenscraig plant (within 5,000 tonnes of BSC's demands). BSC and the government believe that their and the government belleve that their act will 'expose' the fact that dockers are being brought into action because of the miners' dispute, and not to serve their own interests. They seek to weaken the working class response to the miners' strike by a salutory lesson about the divisions inside the trade union movement just before the Trades Union Congress meets.
In fact it is a deadly and dangerous game that the government and the steel employers are playing. In the first place the solidarity action that dockers had taken with the coal miners is strictly illegal according to the government's own trade union laws. And yet, to the disappointment of sections of the employers, the government does not feel strong enough to apply those laws to decisive sections of the trade union movement. International Viewpoint 17 September 1984
In the second place, although some dick=s " sponses have been mixed (Lover and Felixstowe delegates voted against; rue-third of the workers at Imraingham are working normally along with those at Barry in Wales) seventy per cent of British docks are closing or have already closed.
Of course, a huge media campaign is underway to pretend that the dockers are substantially split, but the Financial Times of Saturday August 25, is in no mood to fake the situation. Under the title 'Start to second national stoppage well underway' the article explains the strategy of the dock leaders: "The TGWU's strategy is likely to be to widen the dispute rapidly? What this means quickly became clear with the announcement by the rail unions that they were instructing members not to cross dockers' picket lines. It had not yet been decided whether the action had been limited to freight traffic. There was no indication yet whether dockers would picket crosschannel ferry ports, where railway unions dominate the workforce.
0 WATE
The dockers' action is already incredibly damaging to the British economy. And the 'spread out character of this strike has only just begun. John Connelly, the TGWUs national dock secretary, said on August 24 that an appeal would be made to the union's executive council for "physical support from other sections of the union. Towards the end of July's dock strike, national leaders of TGWU lorry drivers, oil tanker drivers and refinery workers promised support but were not at that stage called on to take any action.
A recent survey of business optimism taken at the end of July shows a dramatic slump from a previous poll. Only 28 per cent of Britain's directors felt that there was reason for optimism, compared with 65 per cent in June. The employers' organisation, the Confederation of British
Industry, said the strike 'could have a disastrous effect on the economy First to be hit would be bulk imported raw materials. The effects would quickly spread to food, components and finished goods. It is clear therefore that the government faces a major crisis.
If the government is relying on the early collapse of the trade union movement, there is no sign yet that it will occur. However, the situation inside the trade union movement is far from rosy. Besides the effects of the crisis and the slump, divided reaction to the miners' strike shows that arguments still have to be won.
The miners' union has, naturally enough, been concerned to win a united front from the TUC to back its struggle. The NUM resolution commits the TUC to a levy, which would raise £1 million per week, and outlaws the crossing of miners' picket lines by other trade unionists. This has been happening on a large scale with lorrydrivers in the TGWU and steel workers in the Iron and Steel Trades Confederation (ISTC). The furniture-builders' union FTAT had an amendment to the NUM resolution calling for a national TUC-called Day of Action.
Initially, this amendment (along with others from the rail unions and seamen on the levy) appeared to be acceptable to the movers of the original resolution, the NUM. The amendment calls on the TUC's governing General Council to organise 'a day of solidarity action as soon as practicable.' But now the amendment appears to have become the victim of back door manoeuvrings by trade union bosses. At the time of writing, the NUM did not support the 'day of action' amendment, apparently in the interests of presenting a united face with the TUC leaders against the government.
In fact, the call for a day of solidarity is not built on sand. Although mass un-
5
NUM leader Scargill addresses women's support demo (DR)
NUM leader Scargill addresses women's support demo (DR)
employment has existed for more than six years and is still growing; although a series of groups of workers (like the steelworkers in 1980) have suffered defeats; important advances in the types of trade-union struggle have also been registered since the election of the first Tory government in 1979. For example, the healthworkers dispute (in 1981) saw enormous solidarity actions taken by millions of workers in 'Days of Action' on behalf of the healthworkers who could not leave the sick.
The beginning of the miners' strike saw a continuation of this tradition at the level of calls to action by the various regional TUC's (Scotland, Wales, these regional Days on Action, etc.)- the North West, Southern Region, etc.). ilised millions of workers behind the miners, often, but not always, through 24-hour strike action. At the same time a massive movement of miners' wives in solidarity with the strike has been established, which spearheads the battle for 'social' solidarity (money, food, etc) and which called a solidarity demonstration of 20,000 in London on August 11. (2) The miners' wives movement is thereby also playing a leading political role in winning support for the strike.
The miners' and the dockers' actions will dominate the coming TUC congress. The question will be hard to avoid of whether these strikes are supported by the leadership of the trade-union movement. The right wing of the trade-union leadership may be let off the hook in terms of the wording of a resolution which they feel they can support. It may now not be necessary to put their own resolution (which up to now was very much on the cards) openly demonstrating the split in the labour movement leadership that everyone knows is there. The left/right divide
The right wing sought, through a genторон не eral resolution moved on behalf of the TUC's ruling committee, to express vague support for the miners and perhaps committing any money to a miners' family "hardship fund' rather than towards the costs of the dispute. Such a motion, claimed the Financial Times (August 18, 1984) 'could be promoted as an addition to the NUM motion rather than as an alternative [which] if passed, would allow Congress the option as to whether to adopt a militant or moderate posture, as necessary to prevent splits' •
But, whether the right wing have their own motion or not as the Financial Times reports (August 18, 1984): "The Congress is increasingly seen as the focus for decisions on the strike at every level? The only question is whether the workers' movement will see the completely opposed right-wing and left-wing choices spelt out, or whether, as is more normal, they will have to read between the lines.
The right wing have found support in some important places. Kinnock, the 9 new leader of the Labour Party, denounced any big bang or general strike in support of the miners in a speech in Parliament when it was raised that miners' leaders were conspiring with left trade-union leaders for this. Up to now, he has contented himself with 'evenhandedly' attacking the violence of the picket lines. Yet, it is apparent to anyone with eyes to watch the nightly edited television commentary that the 'violence' of the picket lines is entirely the violence of a police force mobilised to destroy miners' picket lines. This police violence has already killed two pickets. Despite the obvious role of the police, and the government (most recently exposed in their methods in the North of Ireland with the killing of Sean Downes by plastic bullet at a peaceful meeting), Kinnock remains more frightened of the mobilisation of the labour movement than the results of a victory for Thatcher.
Despite Kinnock, a massive left wing of the labour movement has grown up around the strike. Its head is firmly in the Labour Party, if its feet are on the miners' picket lines. The miners' strike has seen the spectacular expansion and growth in self-confidence of the movement at the base of the Labour Party and trade unions led by Benn and Scargill. The leadership of the movement is, for its own reasons, committed to a victory of the miners.
From the start of the strike, 20 per cent of the miners, mainly based in the Nottingham area, have refused to support the strike. The Notts area has a right-wing tradition; the coalfields there will provide mining jobs longer. But, in the last anlaysis, the split of the miners is a reflection of the divisions of the whole of the workers movement. At the last general election a majority of organised trade unionists voted for parties other than the Labour Party. Of course the miners' union has a tremendous history of militancy and struggle. This means that the divisions they face are less important than those in the labour movement as a whole. Nevertheless, even the miners' union is affected by the dramatic division of Britain's anti-Thatcher majority.
In this context a huge discussion has opened in the Labour Party about the best wayto re-assemble the anti-Thatcher majority around the Labour Party. In this argument right-wing leaders of the Party have argued the necessity of politically displacing the SDP (Social Democratic Party, formed by a right-wing split from the Labour Party) by adopting its policies and - failing that - to prepare the labour movement for coalition.
Benn in the Labour Party and the union leader most associated with him, miners' president Arthur Scargill, have argued instead for the maintenance of the Party's radical policies and the construction of a new alliance of all the oppressed around the labour movement. Key to that vision of a new alliance is that the struggle against the Thatcher government opens out. Unless such a struggle is on the agenda, there would be no reason why anti-Thatcher forces would ally themselves with the labour movement and the Labour Party.
It is from that perspective that Scargill and his allies have been running the strike. To overcome the disunity in the pits, and, for example, between the recently defeated steelworkers and the miners, Scargill has chosen the method of the mass picket. Constantly Scargill explains: "steelworkers had the complete support of miners when they fought closure, we demand the same support. The way to keep steel jobs is for the miners to be victorious.' At the same time thousands of pickets are mobilised to prevent the movement of coal to steel plants and scabs going to work in the still working pits.
These methods have drawn a sharp line through the leadership of the labour movement. Left leaders of the Labour Party, like Benn and Labour leader of the Greater London Council, Ken Livingstone, have totally endorsed the miners' union struggle. At the base, the whole progressive movement inside the British working class has swung behind the miners. This is true in literally every field.
For example, one of the first acts of the national miners' wives movement was to send a delegation to Greenham Common to wish the Women's Peace Camp well. Greenham women now appear on many miners platforms. Around the miners' strike appears a new type of labour movement; in struggle, embracing all the oppressed; using the methods of mass action.
In this perspective, the miners' strike appears as the centrepiece to a whole series of struggles against the Thatcher government including the struggle against the missiles and the battle to keep elected local authorities against new laws designed to do away with them.
But the point has now been reached where a challenge to the right-wing leadership of the trade-union movement has to be made. The success of the miners' struggle depends upon an extension of the support it can win. There is no way of doing that without organising those on the left of the trade-union movement prepared to act now, and, secondly, challenging the role of the right-wing leaders who up to now have given purely verbal support if that. In some cases (like that of the electricians' union leader Frank Chapple) these leaders have called openly on their members to scab on the strike.
From the start of the miners' struggle, the tremendous picket line battles with the police have caused right-wing trade-union leaders to demand the calling off of the mass pickets, for the sake of law and order'. The huge police operation, costing more than £2 million a day, in2. See Janine Inglefield 'Miners' wives on the march' (IV, No 55, June 18, 1984).
International Viewpoint 17 September 1984
### OINT OF AYR
EEDOYOUR HE SHUL volving the banning of movement by miners between certain counties, vast phone taps (exposed by some telecommunications workers), has polarised the labour movement leadership. Against these 'police state' tactics the Labour and trade-union lefts are calling for further support of the trade union and labour movement for the miners' union. Calls for such support have led to the current second dock strike; but the whole labour movement needs to be won to support these strikes if Thatcher is to be beaten.
Such a perspective inevitably requires the defeat of the right-wing leadership of a large section of the labour movement today. The struggle between this left wing of the labour movement and the right wing will dominate this year's TUC Congress however much the curtain is drawn over the struggle. The Bennite left wing has also been thoroughly associated with the important retreat of the Thatcher government on the issue of local government. The government was defeated in the Houses of Parliament (by the Lords!) in their attempt to close down the London local authority, led by Ken Livingstone who is known as one of the country's most radical Bennites. This defeat was seen as part of the process of the government "losing its touch' in British politics.
So, increasingly, the Bennites are seen as the most effective opposition to the Thatcher government. According to the Economist of July 7, 'Mrs Thatcher's second government is stepping out to become Britain's most inept since the
WAEN U *COAL • NOT. DOL: COAL NOT DOLE ENTER D International Viewpoint 17 September 1984
KEEP Your Cont Лог DALE THATCHER
THAT PAYS POLICE SMATCHED
TO
STEALIN STARVE KIDS
BRE Despite real hardship for their families... war.' Much of that can be put down to the actions of the Bennite left wing of the labour movement.
The Bennites are clear in their perspectives for the strike. At the end of June Benn said the following at a public rally in solidarity with the miners:
"There are two things which the movement should be doing right now for the miners. First, trade unionists in a whole range of industries and services should plan to take industrial action where they work. This would be the best and most direct way to help now, and no one need wait for permission to begin. We have learnt that from the women's movement. An extension of strike action would directly assist the NUM and give them a tremendous boost at the same time. Secondly, the National Executive Committee of the Labour Party should organise a national demonstration, invite Arthur Scargill and other trade union leaders and members of the women's support groups to speak alongside leading members of the Labour Party, to launch a sustained national political campaign that must go on until the miners win. The financial and moral support that has come from the movement has been much appreciated. But it has been left to the miners and their families to carry the main burden. They are fighting for us and we cannot let them fight alone?
This is the Bennite programme of action' around the strike. Everybody on the left will wholeheartedly agree with that programme. It remains to be seen how far the fight will be carried to or...miners' wives are militant in their support (FR)
WWW IVICTE COAL FUTURE NATION TO T NOT
COAL 2 MAT -SES MINIS NOT DOLE ganise a left wing now around that programme of action, and how far the Bennites will be prepared to go dividing the labour movement leadership - the better to knit together its ranks. Often, victories at the level of the bureaucratic leadership of the labour movement are confused by the Bennites with victories in the movement as a whole. But at this But at this stage there is no way around the disunity of the labour movement leadership, no way around an open challenge to the scabbing right wing. By bringing forword that hallanda on the icane of tha ward that challenge, on the issue of the miners' strike and now the dockers' strike, a new unity of the broader movement around the strikes is possible. Two decisive congresses
But the Bennite leadership is itself a fraction of the labour bureaucracy (although it is in a tiny minority). Consequently, the struggles which it conducts have as their end the reform of that bureaucracy...on Bennite lines! For that reason there are important limits to how far the Bennites will go at this TUC and the following Labour Party Conference.
The coming TUC and the Labour Party Conference scheduled for the end of September will determine much of the future of the miners dispute, the Bennite section of the leadership of the labour movement which supports that dispute, and the prospects of the Thatcher government itself. But these Congresses will not end the story. A July national conference of the NUM saw miners' leader Scargill prepare the ranks of the miners for a dispute lasting well into the winter. The 'drift back to work' campaign of the employers and the government is, in the words of the Economist, (August 18, 1984) 'hardly even a trickle for the moment, with a rise of only 700 in those working since the start of July?
The Economist (which backs the government to the hilt) sees the spotting of what it calls 'rebel miners' (or scabs) by 'right-wing newspapers' as this season's equivalent to the number of sightings of the Loch Ness monster (another completely unserious activity). In fact, the figures belie any 'drift back to work" Of Britain's 180 pits, 130 are completely stopped. The vast majority of the rest are producing at much below their normal capacity. These figures have been more or less the same since the start of the strike, twenty-two weeks ago.
The resilience and self-sacrifice of the miners and their families has dramatically shaken up the British labour movement. For example, it has produced two dock strikes so far! That process will not stop at the end of the TUC and Labour Party Congresses - whatever their outcome. But in every corner of the British labour movement it is recognised that these two Congresses, should they wish, have the power to bring speedy victory against what increasingly looks like a lame duck' government.
DOLE