International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Switzerland: Immigration Control and Racism in Workers Movement

· International Viewpoint No. 58, 30 July 1984 · pp 21-26 · 6,832 words

Racism and fascism Switzerland and Austria World economy Latin America

Immigration control and racism in the workers movement Of Switzerland's total population of 6.5 million, a little over one million are immigrants. Of a total of three million available jobs, 700,000 of them are held by immigrants. In other words, one resident in six and one worker in four has a foreign passport, while seven immigrants out of ten are working. Switzerland, along with Sweden, has the highest proportion of immigrants in employment in Europe — that is, it most efficiently exploits immigrants.

Apart from this very skillful political and economic utilisation of immigration by the Swiss bourgeoisie, the situation of immigrants in this country has a number of special features; the large numbers involved, the long history of discriminatory legislation against immigrants, the inability of Swiss workers and their organisations to defend immigrant workers and the deep and long-standing imprint of the nationalist movepenal reasons, or if the immigrant workers have gone over the time allowed for being unemployed. They are permitted to bring in their families after 12 months.

- Permanent immigrants. After five or ten years residence in the country -the length of time varies according to the agreement with the country of origin -an immigrant can obtain a permanent resident's permit. In principle, this means unlimited stay. Permanent immigrants have the same social entitlements as the Swiss. In the official terminology they are treated as indigenous.

- Seasonal immigrants. These immigrants, working mainly in the building industry, in hotels and in agriculture, cannot stay longer than nine months in the country. Their work contract is also terminated once a year. As a rule, they cannot change the canton they live in nor the industry they work in. Legally they are not regarded as residents of Switzerland, and their families are not allowed to join them. They live in housing belonging to the employer and have no other function but to work. Only a minority of 'seasonal' workers have been able after several seasons of work in Switzerland to acquire permanent residence 7,000 or 8,000 out of a total of 100,000).

- Border workers. These workers have to leave the country every day. They work in the border regions and live in a neighbouring country.

- Short stay permits. These nonrenewable permits are issued for a threemonth maximum period.

Added to these five categories, as in all systems of immigration control, is that of 'clandestine' immigrants who have no rights, and add up to tens of thousands of people.

Since 1962, the Swiss government has set quotas for immigrant workers. Since 1973 this has become very restrictive for 'short term' immigrants. Only a few hundred in this category are admitted into each canton. This quota system is much less restrictive for "seasonal' workers, whilst "border' workers are not affected at all.

The quota policy, alongside the economic recession has led to a stabilisation of the permanent immigrant population, whilst the number of immigrant workers not resident in Switzerland varies according to economic fluctuations - annually, conjuncturally and in different industries.

Stabilisation of the pattern of immigration has meant a predominance of permanent immigrants over 'short-term1. Switzerland invests more capital abroad per head of the population than any other country. 2. Under the Swiss constitution any proposition that obtains the necessary signatories can be put forward for a referendum. With 50,000 signatures, you can force the Federal government to submit parliamentary decisions to a popular vote. This is called a referendum. With 100,000 signatures to the text of a particular proposition, it is possible to get a popular vote making changes in the Federal constitution.

In two Cantons - Jura and Neuchatel -where immigrants of long-standing have the right to participate in local elections — they are barred from standing as candidates.

21 ment led by the extreme right. Urs FAUCHER

Having been an exporter of labour in the last century, Switzerland had, in the period preceding the First World War, a foreign population comparable to today's, representing 15 per cent of the country's inhabitants. Throughout this century, the intake of immigrant workers has followed exactly the course of the economic cycle. After a rapid decline beginning in the 1920s with the lowest point being in 1940 (immigrants were then 5 per cent of the total population), the percentage of immigrants rose steadily to reach 15 per cent in the 1970s.

Leaving aside the very small number of foreign capitalists living off their fortunes deposited in Swiss banks or dodging taxes in their own country, the great bulk of immigrants are working class. In their recruiting of foreign workers, Swiss employers have been past masters in the art of exploiting regional inequalities in international economic development so as to get a destitute workforce, willing to work for low wages. After the Second World War they particularly went after Italian workers, who still represent the largest group of immigrants (412,000 people, of whom 285,000 were working in 1983). Apart from French and German immigration there is also Spanish (100,000 people of whom 87,000 work), Portuguese, Yugoslav and Turkish.

The fact that Switzerland includes four different linguistic regions could have been a favourable condition for the development of an internationalist consciousness in the working class. The bourgeoisie clearly had no such inclination. While building a network of capitalist interests on a world scale (1), since the end of the First World War, the bourgeoisie has instituted legislation that not only denies immigrant workers most of the democratic rights accorded to Swiss International Viewpoint 30 July 1984 workers, but also imposes a strict control of their numbers and on their actions. On the economic level, the bourgeoisie has been able to use this legislation skilfully to manipulate the immigrant workforce to suit the needs of the business cycle. On the political level, immigration has been used to paralyse the Swiss workers movement through exacerbating divisions between immigrants and indigenous workers. Draconian immigration laws

The immigration laws date from 1931. They were adopted after a federal referendum which approved them by a huge majority. (2) Swiss legislation since that period has been marked by three basic characteristics:

- Only the right to stay not the right to work is regularised in Switzerland. - Democratic rights for immigrants are dependent on length of stay in the country. In a sense it is a legislation based on mistrust of newly arrived immigrants. Political rights are denied them. (3)

- The code is built around the political objective of keeping the country from being overwhelmed by foreigners (in German, Ueberfremdung), which gives a lever to the nationalist and xenophobic movements.

The application of these principles means immigrants live and work under different legal conditions that divide and isolate them, undermining their capacity for collective defence. Five different immigrant statutes exist.

- Short term immigrants. Such immigrants have the right to legal residence in Switzerland. They must, however, renew their permits every year. These permits can be withdrawn for political or

ers' and a relative growth in the number of second and third generation immiggrants born in Switzerland (see Table I).

### CATEGORIES OF IMMIGRANTS

(in thousands) Inhabitants Workers 1975 1983 - 1975 1983

Permanent 651 717 329 403

Limited Stay 358 209 240 122

Seasonal - 86 100

Border - 99 105

Total 1,012 926 754 730

In order to maximise profits from the post-war boom, employers from 1945 onwards relied on an extensive increase in production.

The domestic labour shortage nearly wrecked this project, bringing on wage rises even without any trade-union struggle. These twin perils could be avoided thanks to the employment of immigrant labour, available in massive numbers from neighbouring countries and ready to work for low wages.

Production and profits rose spectacularly. In contrast, the average wage rise remained modest. During the 1950s and the beginning of the 1960s, immigration played the classic role of a reserve army of labour.

Since this situation continued uninterrupted in Swizterland until the mid1970s, immigrant workers began to acquire, little by little, a structural role in economic life. In industry as well as in construction and catering (hotels) they occupied a very important position, as Table II shows. Within the manufacturing industry they dominate production jobs. Swiss workers themselves have 'emigrated' towards employment in the One of the 'foreigners' at work (DR)

COBB 22 tertiary sector, taking up technical and commercial jobs and supervisory positions in industry.

The majority of immigrants employed in industry have a skill and a 'long term' permit. But the system of several categories of immigrants still means that many thousands of immigrants with precarious status (border, seasonal, shortstay, clandestine) continue to play the role of a reserve army within the industries in to which they are channelled.

The Swiss ruling class deliberately use the immigration laws to avoid pressure for rationalisation in certain backward regions and industries. The price for this is clearly paid by all the workers concerned, whether they be Swiss or immigrant. A few examples will suffice to prove this. In Tessino, where 36 per cent of industrial jobs are occupied by 'border' immigrants, the 1978 wage levels were 16 per cent less than the national average and 23.2 per cent less than the average wage in industry. In construction, catering and agriculture where the majority of immigrants who work are seasonal, wages are lower than in other branches of industry, and the hours of work much longer (47, 54, sometimes 60 hours per week).

### TABLE TWO

IMMIGRANT WORKERS BY SECTOR IN 1975 (in thousands) Total Immigrants %

Manufacturing 954 289 30

Textiles 43 21 48

Clothing 46 26 55

Metallurgy 176 50 28

Construction 226 106 46

Services 1,324 222 17

Catering (hotels) 159 58 19

Health 177 34 19

Engineering 259 81 31

But the ruling class derive a further important advantage from immigration. The children of immigrants provide Swiss capitalism with a reservoir of unskilled labour for the future. The authorities refusal to make up for the linguistic handicaps that penalise immigrants' children in the school system, keeps a large number of them from getting proper training.

In 1983 the percentage of young immigrants (between 16 and 19 years old) without an education (that is, 42.3 per cent of immigrant youth) is double the national average for Swiss youth (21.6 per cent). Immigration and the unions

The main advantage of the immigration laws for the Swiss bourgeoisie however became clear in the economic recession of 1974. Immigration during that period cushioned the effects of the economic crisis. The number of jobs plummeted, without this showing up in the unemployment figures.

Between 1973 and 1977 the economically active population declined by 280,000, of whom only 73,000 were indigenous workers, the rest being immigrants. Three quarters of the job loss therefore hit immigrants. The conclusion is unavoidable. The immigration laws that make it possible to send unemployed immigrants back to their countries of origin help to export unemployment.

The comparison of trends in immigration with that of the gross national product in 1973 shows a striking parallel. But for the period of economic recovery after the crisis of 1974, this comparison shows also that the ruling class has used the combination of economic fluctuations with the policy of immigrant quotas as a lever for reconverting from an economy of extensive growth to one of intensive growth. The rationalisation of Swiss capitalism in the course of the economic crisis permitted a rise in the GNP after 1977, while the foreign resident population stabilised at the 1965 level.

However, it is unlikely that the ruling class will be able to repeat their 1974 success. Immigration today plays a structural role in the economy, and any move toward rationalisation and restructuring affects both Swiss and immigrant workers. The country is now experiencing real unemployment (1.2 per cent of the active population, 4 per cent in Biel or Basle [Basel].) which is not going to be entirely absorbed as it was in 1974 by the departure of unemployed immigrants.

The ease with which the bourgeoisie has been able to manipulate immigration for their profit is not due to their strength, but flows above all from the total inability of the workers movement to respond to the bosses' manoeuvres with a resolute policy of working-class unity.

In hundreds of decisions taken from the 1950s onwards, workers organisations in Switzerland have opposed immigration. The inflow of foreign workers

International Viewpoint 30 July 1984

was perceived simply as a manoeuvre by the employers. Because of fear of 'communist vermin', no effort was made to integrate these new members into the unions.

The Union Syndicale Suisse (Swiss Federation of Trade Unions - USS), the main union confederation in Switzerland, dominated by the Socialists, was in 1958 the first organisation to call for statutory limitation on immigrant labour and for prioritised protection of the indigenous workers. This approach directly influenced the policy of the unions.

After the Second World War they signed, with the employers, the social peace' accords in which 'both partners' agreed to renounce all forms of strikes and lockouts. In this framework, wage increases for the workers depended entirely on the pressures of supply and demand in the labour market. The recourse to foreign labour enabled the employers to resist such pressures. The union leaderships, their hands tied the the 'social peace' agreement, had no alternative but to try to put this pressure back on through any means which came to hand. For years they did not hesitate to whip up nationalistic and xenophobic feeling to achieve their ends.

Gradually coming to realise that immigration was going to continue and that immigrant workers were an important base of recruitment, the union leaderships did modify their position during the 1970s. Nowadays, they say that stabilising the number of immigrants is an essential corollary to increasing their rights. In practice, however the union leaderships are pressing the government to cut the number of "short-term' or 'seasonal' workers and introduce a quota system for "border' workers. By comparison, they raise fewer and less hard-hitting demands for improving immigrants' rights.

Certainly, the unions and the reformist parties are making some efforts at recruitment of immigrants, but the policy of 'social peace', the dismal record of the unions which flow from it, and their terrible position on immigration do not attract immigrants.

The result is that the unions and the reformist parties have no real impact on the policy which the bourgeoisie conducts against immigrants. The latter are left helpless in the face of agitation from nationalist or far-right organisations.

The anti-foreign movement was born in 1961 in Winterthur. It is most widely known as the 'national action against the foreign takeover. They apply a strictly legal strategy, using institutional methods such as petitions, legal propositions and 1 contes of referendums. Their method consists of accusing the government of not applying the law of 1931 which had the ob. jective of fighting overpopulation by foreigners.

On the electoral front, the anti-foreign movement has registered varying but modest support. However, the propositions they make to reduce the number of International Viewpoint 30 July 1984 immigrants and restrict their rights always have a mass impact. Even though none of their referendum propositions have been approved by the majority, they have all got high votes and the bourgeoisie has been able to take advantage of this for fifteen years to step up their policy of dividing the working class.

In the last few years, the nationalist and racist currents have had the wind in their sails. Their electoral results have improved. In 1982 they managed to bring about the defeat of a referendum proposition for a new law on immigrants, even though in fact it would have done little or nothing to improve the immigrants' situation. At the moment they are participating, alongside the rest of the right, in a hate campaign for the restricting of the right of political asylum. They are also getting signatures for a new antiimmigrant proposition. This has a good chance of getting adopted because it appears moderate. Its application, however, would consolidate the legal division between Swiss and immigrants.

The influence of the immigrant organisations is limited. It is estimated that only 10 per cent of the immigrants are affiliated to an organisation. Only the Spanish and Italian organisations are nationally coordinated and have any impact on the political scene. The Spanish and Italian CPs play a key role but they are only interested in ensuring the immigrant vote. The fight for unity

Before the 1974 recession immigrant organisations intervened actively in Swiss political life against the right wing. Nowadays, they relate mainly to their own countries, although immigrants continue to play an active role in trade-union struggles that have taken place. In 1980 the association of immigrants called Free Italian Colonies launched a national petition to demand civil rights for immigrants and at the beginning of the year they started a petition in support of the proposition put forward by the USS for introducing the 40-hour week.

The impact of this activity is obviously limited by the weakness of the current for unity between indigenous and immigrant workers. Such a current does, however, exist and has not been deterred SUBSCRIBE TO

SUBSCRIBE TO International

VIEWPOINT

SUBSCRIBE TO from its project, despite the difficulties which its activities entail. The Socialist Workers Party (SAP/PSO), Swiss section of the Fourth International, has played an active role in it since its foundation.

In the first half of the 1970s, efforts were concentrated in the fight against the far right. Many immigrants participated actively and mobilised alongside the left. This movement however had strictly no impact on the official labour movement. The latter was pursuing a collaborationist policy leading in 1970 to a joint campaign with the employers and the government 'against xenophobia'

In the mid-1970s, some Christians decided that the time had come to go on the offensive. They launched a referendum under the slogan 'Stick together' . In fact, this proposition took on the language of the official labour movement. They proposed to fight for the demand for equal rights for Swiss citizens and immigrants, the abolition of the seasonal worker status and against the draconian measures to limit further immigration.

This proposal gained real support in the labour movement and drove the USS to at last support the demand for the abolition of the status of 'seasonal worker. All the parties of the left including the SAP/PSO and several other unions called for a yes vote when the referendum was held in April 1981. The result was a debacle. Only one seventh of the electorate voted in favour. This result demoralised many Swiss and immigrant activists. The collaborationist union leadership, the government, the major parties of the right and the left, as well as the extreme right saw their respective postitions as reinforced.

The fight for unity has not ended there, and the SAP/PSO attaches great importance to it, unlike the other left parties that have a tendency to disregard an area of such poor electoral interest.

The SAP/PSO has always demanded equal social and political rights for all those who live and work in the country. It has raised calls for political asylum and denounced the de-facto collusion between ruling class strategy and the vermin of the fascist right. At the same time, the SAP/PSO has sought to convince Swiss and immigrant workers that they are wrong to seek refuge in quotas, with the police surveillance they entail over a section of the working class.

The SAP/PSO currently has twin objectives. Firstly, a current for working class unity has to be built by demonstrating, on the basis of facts, that the need to break the policy of "social peace' goes hand in hand with the need to achieve solidarity and equality between Swiss and immigrant workers. Then on the basis of such an understanding, linking up systematically, the immigrant organisations with activities to defend and extend workers rights in this country.

This will be a long and relatively unspectacular struggle, but it is essential for the future of the Swiss labour movement.

23

ECONOMY.

An economic upturn coupled with a financial crisis The year 1983 was marked by an upturn in the world capitalist economy. It began in the United States, and then over 1983 and the first quarter of 1984, it spread to Canada, Japan, West Germany, Great Britain, some of the minor imperialist powers in Europe, the semi-industrialized countries in Southeast Asia, as well as Brazil. It is beginning to be felt also now in Italy and France. A series of so-called third world countries, however, have been left out of the upward movement.

this industry, since the inventories had been wiped out and current sales were running above current production.

In fact, automobile production rose from 550,000 vehicles in June 1982 to 700,000 in May 1984, an increase more than 25%. The upturn was still stronger in the building industry. The The number of buildings under construction went from 900,000 in June 1982 to 1.8 million in June 1983, and to 2 million in May 1984, amounting to an increase of more than 100% in two years. Overall industrial production increased by 13% in 1983. In the first quarter of 1984, it was growing at an annual rate of 15%.

However, if you take a closer look, you see that this "technical" aspect of the upturn is hardly sufficient to explain it.

First of all, the "renewal of inven- the renewal of inven. tories" lagged behind the upturn. It only started in the third quarter of 1983. Moreover, the upturn has gone ahead of reduction in unemployment, while real wages have been stagnating or declining. Clearly, therefore, there has been a swelling of overall demand not rooted in increased sales (and production) of consumer goods and intermediate products. Productive investment has also been sluggish. The role of military spending

The source of this upturn is, thus, clear - increased public spending, essentially military spending. It is Washington's yearly budget deficit of 200 billion dollars that is at the root of the American upturn. Everything else flows from that.

According to Marxist economic theory — as well as neoliberal economic theory, by the way — a vigorous economic upturn stimulated by military spending should fuel inflation. This is in fact what has happened. The yearly inflation rate in the US now stands at 5.5%, as against 3.5% in West Germany and 4% in Japan and Switzerland. When you recall that the average rate of inflation in the US in the 1950s was less than 2%, you can see that Reagan has by no means overcome inflation.

However, this surge of inflation has been cushioned up until now by two factors. The first is the great excess productive capacity in the US at the start of the upturn (more than a third of installed capacity was unutilized toward the middle of 1982). The second is the massive influx of foreign money-capital. This financial inflow has made it possible to wipe out the deficit in the US's trade deficit, thereby preventing a deficit in the balance of payments, which would have touched off a process of mushrooming inflation.

The rise in US interest rates is linked both to the budget deficit and to a deliberate policy of the Federal Reserve Bank of maintaining a high rate of exchange for the dollar. The fact that the budget deficit has persisted in the midst

International Viewpoint 30 July 1984

Ernest MANDEL

The essential reason for this upturn is a buoyancy of demand in the United States. The North American domestic market, the largest sector of the world market, has attracted a growing mass of foreign commodities, thereby stimulating a new thrust of economic activity in the countries cited above. (See Table I.) The new rise of the economy in these countries, thus, has been brought about by the expansion of their exports to the United States and not by the expansion of their own internal markets.

The peculiar character of this world economic upturn is, therefore, reflected by a growing deficit in the US balance of trade. Such a deficit could send the rate of the dollar plummeting if it were not for the constant inflow of new money capital to the United States. But there is only one way to keep the money coming in. That is to maintain the high American interest rates, which in fact include a high

TABLE I: Evolution of industrial production in 1984 (except Argentina)

compared to the corresponding month of the previous year (in %)

Country Month

Argentina last quarter

1983 + 4.0

Australia March 1984 + 6.2

Belgium February 1984 + 3.3

Brazil (1) February 1984 + 2.0

Canada March 1984 + 10.3

South Korea April 1984 + 7.5

France March 1984 + 4.7

West Germany March 1984 + 3.1

Mexico (2) January 1984 - 13.0

Netherlands March 1984 + 6.3

Italy January 1984 + 4.2

Sweden March 1984 + 9.0

Great Britain March 1984 2.3

Taiwan April 1984 7.5

Japan April 1984 + 12.0

USA April 1984 + -14.4 1. The Neue Zuercher Zeitung gives a 3.9% rate of increase for the first quarter 1984. 2. Compared to January 1982.

Source: The Economist, June 16, 1984, except for the three countries of south-east Asia, Far Eastern Economic Review, June 7, 1984.

24 insurance premium against a devaluation of the dollar.

Such a rise in US interest rates has different immediate effects on the various capitalist national economies, depending on two factors. The first is whether they are heavily indebted or not. In the case of the third world, whose debts are essentially in dollars, with half at a variable interest rate, every increase of 1% in the interest rate imposes additional charges of 3.5 billion dollars. The second factor is whether or not the country in question can expand its exports to the US rapidly. This depends on their relative competitivity, the elasticity of American demand for the specific products they export, the excess productive capacity that they have at the start of the upturn, and so on.

This process explains why not only Argentina, Mexico, and the poorer semi-colonial countries are being drained, but French president Mitterrand, the king of Spain, and Greek premier Papandreou are moaning and groaning too. On the other hand, not only Japan, West Germany and Sweden are rejoicing, but South Korea, Taiwan, Singapore and even India are profiting from this conjunction between upturn and international financial crisis.

At first glance, the economic upturn in the US, which almost immediately brought on a corresponding movement in Canada, seems to have assumed a quasitechnical or automatic form. For several decades, the two lead industries in the economy of the imperialist countries have been auto and building, and the subcontracting sectors linked to these two industries. In these two industries fluctuations in production have been much greater - five times larger in terms of percentages — than in industry as a whole. Drops in production of the order of 30% to 50% in these industries lead to falls in overall industrial production of the order of 5% to 10%.

Over the 1980-82 recession, US automobile production fell from the level of 7 million vehicles a year at the beginning of 1981 to 4.5 million, at the annual rate of production in March 1982. There was, therefore, room for a strong upturn in

of an upturn means that the demand for new money-capital is coming both from capitalist firms and the public authorities. It is, therefore, tending to exceed supply. As a result, interest rates are rising. Given the resumption of inflation and the American trade-balance deficit, foreign capitalists will only place their moneycapital in the US if the interest rate is such as to guarantee them against an anticipated fall in the exchange rate of the dollar. (1)

With nominal interest rates at 13% and inflation at 5.5%, the real interest rate is 7.5%, which is an usurous rate. This affair clears up if you consider that the capitalists are counting on at least a 10% drop in the rate of the dollar, even though no one knows exactly when that will happen and at what level the drop will begin.

However, such interest rates - which could rise still further - are clearly threatening to choke off the upturn. They make necessary profit rates on the order of 20% in order to continue to stimulate credit-financed investments. It is true that there has been a veritable explosion of profits in the US, and that this is continuing. This is primarily the result of the decline in real wages, which is continuing despite the upturn. Thus, in the first quarter of 1984, nominal hourly wages increased by 3.5%, while retail prices went up by 5%.

Nonetheless, the impact of the retooling going on in industry on the rate of profit depends on its effects on the organic composition of capital and the latter's rate of growth compared to the tempo of growth in the rates of exploitation of labor. No individual capitalist is capable of making any definite predictions about this. And the capitalists as a whole, as well as their advisors, cannot do any better.

In these conditions, uncertainty and disquiet prevail, and they have begun to halt the rise in the stock market on Wall Street. The chances that the American economic upturn will continue beyond 1985 are, therefore, slim since the rise in interest rates should choke off the upturn in auto and construction.

In opting deliberately for an overvalued dollar, in order to moderate the inflation caused by the US budget deficit, the Reagan administration has inevitably programmed a gigantic deficit in the American trade balance. It has risen from 25 billion dollars in 1980 to 36 billion in 1982 to 60 billion in 1983. It threatens to go over 100 billion in 1984. In May 1984, it reached an annually adjusted rate of 150 billion dollars.

A dearer dollar is increasing the trade deficit in two ways. First, it is promoting a strong expansion of imports into the US, and secondly it is bringing about an absolute decline in American exports. The latter in fact dropped by 30 billion dollars worth in 1983 and are continuing to go down. The decline in exports of manufactured goods — that is, after you eliminate agricultural and mining proInternational Viewpoint 30 July 1984 ducts from the analysis - is still more pronounced. In fact, the US is losing its place as the world's biggest exporter of manufactured goods, being overtaken by Japan and West Germany.

The American upturn and the overvaluation of the dollar have thus been the locomotives pulling the rest of the world capitalist economy out of the recession, although at very different tempos, extents and timing in the various countries (see Table II). But these forces can only do that insofar as they are not neutralized by rising costs for American industry's principal competitors. So, we get a double paradox. It is Reagan, and not Francois Mitterrand, Felipe Gonzalez, Bettino Craxi, Margaret Thatcher, Nakasone or Helmut Kohl, who is applying a neo-Keynesian policy in the capitalist world today to stimulate an upturn. This policy only benefits Japan, Canada, West Germany and the rest of capitalist Europe insofar as Reagan is the only one to apply it.

### TABLE II

Differences in Price of export prices electric between 1979 machines for and 1982 cal- export in US culated from a dollars in the base in US last quarter of dollars 1982 (100 = 1979)

USA + 31.3% 126

Japan + 0.8 % 90

West

Germany - 12.9 % 83

Source: Lloyds Bank Review, April 1984.

Obviously, the overvaluation of the dollar must not be exaggerated. The deterioration of the United States's position on the world market for manufactured products is, in the last analysis, the result of a long-term structural evolution, of an erosion or wiping out of the lead in productivity of American industry, even in the most advanced sectors. This is shown clearly by the following table.

TABLE III: US share of world exports

Nonetheless, the expansion of imports into the US is in part the result of the overvalued dollar. It has thus partially helped the industries of semi-industrialized dependent countries such as South Korea, Brazil and Taiwan. These contries have been able to keep the exchange rates of their currencies with the dollar stable or have even been led to lower them, at the same time as they were exporting goods to the US, for which the demand is high.

Japan has been obliged to accept a slight upward valuation of the yen against the dollar.

The flood of products from the semiindustrialized countries into the US internal market is spectacular. (2) These countries' share of American imports of manufactured goods now exceeds that of capitalist Europe and that of Japan, as Table IV attests.

These figures should be interpreted with caution. They include in fact a growing volume of exchanges made within the same transnational companies, which organize their own international division of labor. Sometimes, what is involved is imports of products whose production was deliberately shifted to third world countries. But these cases do not change much with respect to the general movement. The growth of imports into the US from these countries more and more involves products of heavy industry and not just currentconsumption commodities. For example, two thirds of South Korea's exports are already in the first category. What this process reflects, therefore, is indeed a weakening of the position of US industry on the world market as a result of a whole series of transformations that have developed over the past fifteen years.

Under these conditions, how can you explain the decline in unemployment and the creation of new jobs in the American economy, the "success" that the bourgeois press is making so much of in Europe? Some 89% of these jobs have been created in the service industries, essentially in very small businesses. Contrary to the widespread myth, these jobs have nothing to do with the high-technology industries, or even with advanced technology. Altogether, "high technology" only employs 2 million people in the United States, and this figure is growing annually only at a rate of 0.1% of the total US workforce. Investments made to take advantage of Reagan's tax breaks for "risk capital" amount annually to one one billion dollars, less than 0.1% of all capital investment in the US.

To understand the difference between the 1974-79 cycle and the cycle that be1. On the "influence of expectations of a change in the value of the dollar on the level of interest rates in the United States," see an article written by the Manufacturers Hanover Investment Corp. of New York that appeared under that title [retranslated from the French] in the February 1984 issue of the magazine Euromoney. 2. We have dealt with the problem of the emergence of of semi-industrialized dependent countries in an article in Quatrieme Internationale, No 13, April 1984.

25

1970

71 %

Aircraft

42 %

Computers

Construction, public works, and mining

39 % machinery

Scientific, medical and

32 % control equipment

Tractors and agri-

32 % cultural machinery

Pumps and com-

29 % pressors

Telecommunications

19 % material

Medical and pharma-

18 % ceutical products

17 %

Machine tools

1980 62 % 36 % 39 % 29 % 31 % 21 % 13 % 16 % 13 %

Source: Foreign Policy, No 53, Winter 1983/

1984.

TABLE IV: Imports of manufactured products by the USA

1973 1977

Total in billions of dollars 42.5 74.7

In % (1)

From Europe 36.0 28.5

From Japan 21.5 24.5

From Canada 24.7 24.5

From Third World countries 12.5 18.8 1. In 1966 the respective shares were: 43% and 10.6% for the Third World countries. 5, 1984. gan with the recession of 1980 for the world capitalist economy as a whole, you have to first see what these cycles have had in common. Both had their upturns, in 1976-1979 and in 19831984, propelled by a considerable new expansion of indebtedness - government debt, business debt and consumer debt. But the direction of the lending has profoundly changed. In 1975-79, the expansion of credit went mainly to governments and big businesses in third world countries (including the OPEC countries), as well as in the bureaucratized workers states. In the period 1980-1984, and this will probably continue in 1985, the expansion of credit has gone mainly to the imperialist states and the big "multinationals" and "national" trusts in these countries.

This lending obviously has come from the banks in the imperialist countries. They continue to be the only ones that have large reserves of money-capital, or, which amounts to the same thing, the only ones who extend credit for large-scale financing operations. (3)

It was not, therefore, because the countries of the so-called third world had big needs for capital in 1974-79 that billions of dollars were lent to them in that period. Their capital needs are always insatiable, as, by the way, are the needs of the bureaucratized workers states for additional credits in the currencies of the imperialist countries.

The reason for this lending was that the demand for new money-capital suddenly fell off in 1974-79 in the imperialist countries, as a result of the decline in investments. So, the big imperialist banks offered their excess capital, which moreover was swollen by petrodollars, to the third world and Eastern Bloc countries.

This inflow of credit obviously came into a context shaped by the model of capital accumulation chosen by the "national" bourgeoisies of the semiindustrialized countries, which is export oriented. But, precisely because of the crisis, the growth in these countries' exports could not keep pace with the rate of increase in their indebtedness.

As a result, like the rising interest rates in the US, the weight of indebtedness has grown continually more serious, especially for Brazil, Mexico, Argentina, Nigeria, Indonesia, Poland, Yugoslavia and Rumania, which are 26

1980 1981 1982 1983

124.2 142.1 145.2 163.0

29.7 27.0 25.0 24.3 24.6 25.4 27.4 25.6 20.0 18.8 18.2 19.0 22.5 23.5 25.0 28.0 for Europe, 23.4% for Canada, 20.8% for Japan, among the "big" debtors. Consequently, the threat of these countries going bankrupt is beginning to loom.

The imperialist banks have begun to be pressed for regular debt rescheduling operations, with the weakest debtors one after the other being pushed into suspension of payments. This unquestionably prolonged the 1980-1982 recession, by narrowing the "substitute markets" created during the preceding cycle.

However, little by little two substitute markets have emerged within the imperialist countries themselves. The first is represented by increased military spending and a sharp rise in public debt in the West. The other is the growing indebtedness of a certain number of big imperialist firms, either to cover enormous losses or to finance large-scale speculative operations (4), notably mergers almost entirely financed by bank credit. (5) Imperialist firms in debt spiral

The growth in these debts has been quite as spectacular, if not more so, than the increase in the indebtedness of Poland or the semi-industrialized Latin American countries. For example, France's debt has risen in the space of a few years from 20 to 70 billion dollars. If the present rate of increase is maintained, it will soon overtake the debts of Mexico and Brazil.

The US public debt has reached the astronomical figure of 1.5 trillion dollars and threatens to go over 3 trillion dollars before the end of the decade, that is six times the total in 1960! The debts of big imperialist concerns have assumed proportions no less gargantuan. Public opinion became aware of this when it came to light that it was necessary to advance more than 6 billion dollars to the Continental Illinois Bank of Chicago in order to rescue it from a bankruptcy that could have brought down the entire American credit system. For the first time, the US really came to the brink of a banking panic, much more so than at the time a Mexican debt moratorium was threatened in the fall of 1982.

It is interesting, moreover, to examine the origin of the near bankruptcy of the Continental Illinois Bank. Once again, contrary to a widespread myth, the

"bad debts" of some Latin American countries to this bank played only a minor part in the lack of cover that appeared. It was, in fact, caused by illconsidered loans to the following sorts of recipients:

- Speculators in the energy sector, such as Nucorp Energy, which went bankrupt, leaving Continental Illinois with the tab of 200 million dollars, or equally speculative lending to the energy portfolio of the Penn Square Bank of Oklahoma City, which reached the figure of a billion dollars.

Big trusts operating at a loss (200 million dollars to the Dome Petroleum company of Canada; 200 million to International Harvester; 100 million to the Alfa group in Mexico; 40 million to Massey-Ferguson; 24 million to Branif Airlines). (6)

← West Germany: Yes to Jobs, No to Anti-immigrant Laws · Economy: An Economic Upturn Coupled with Financial Crisis →

Something wrong on this page?