International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

United States: Portrait of a Revolutionary: J. P. Cannon

· International Viewpoint No. 57, 16 July 1984 · pp 25-26 · 1,703 words

United States Fourth International Soviet Union

Portrait of a revolutionary August 1984 is the tenth anniversary of the death of James P. Cannon. Cannon was a founder of American Communism and a central figure in the party until 1928. Subsequently he established the American Trotskyist movement and was the most important leader of the Socialist Workers Party for several decades. Following is a biographical sketch that will also introduce the readers of International Viewpoint to books by Cannon that contain additional information about his life and ideas.

Alan WALD

James Patrick Cannon was born in Rosedale, Kansas, on February 11, 1890, the son of Irish immigrants raised in England. His father, John Cannon, worked as a laborer in a foundry and introduced his son James to the Irish nationalist tradition of Robert Emmett, the Knights of Labor, the Populists and the Socialist Party.

Leaving school to start work at age twelve, Cannon was propelled into radical politics by the Haywood-PettiboneMoyer defense case. He briefly returned to high school but left again to become a traveling organizer for the IWW and a follower of Vincent St. John. He later joined the Socialist Party, replacing Earl Browder as editor of Workers' World in Kansas when Browder was sent to prison during World War I.

Cannon quickly became a leader of the left wing of the Socialist Party. Following the 1919 expulsion of the left wing, he joined the Communist Labor Party led by John Reed and Benjamin Gitlow. When the United Communist Party was formed in the spring of 1920, he was elected to its central committee and assigned as organizer of the party's St. Louis-Southern Illinois District.

Toward the end of 1920 he moved to Cleveland to edit The Toiler, a party organ, and in 1921 he transferred to New York to participate in the top leadership of the party. After an internal struggle to create a legal party and end the underground existence of the Communist movement, Cannon was elected chairperson of the national committee of the Workers Party, the new above ground organization.

In 1922-23 he served on the Presidium of the Communist International in Moscow, and between 1925 and 1928 he headed International Labor Defense. In that capacity he raised money and publicized the cases of the Centralia prisoners, Tom Mooney and Warren Billings, and the McNamara Brothers. He also organized the International Labor Defense's Sacco-Vanzetti campaign.

During these years Cannon's group of followers, including Max Shachtman and

Martin Abern, formed a bloc with William Z. Foster's group against the faction of Charles Ruthenberg and Jay Lovestone over such issues as the attitude toward a labor party, trade union strategy and tactics, the location of the national office and the nature and composition of the party leadership. Cannon's reminiscences of this period were later published as The First Ten Years of American Communism (New York: Lyle Stuart, 1962).

In the summer of 1982 he attended the Sixth World Congress of the Communist International where he received a translation of Trotsky's "Criticism of the Draft Program of the Communist International." Won over to the ideas of Trotsky's Left Opposition, Cannon and his followers were expelled from the Ameriican party in October for circulating Trotsky's views.

Cannon described the first decade of the American Trotskyist movement in The History of American Trotskyism (New York: Pioneer, 1944). Along with Schatman and Abern he founded the Communist League of America (Left Opposition) in mid-1929, and began publishing the Militant newspaper. They had only a hundred followers at first, but doubled their size over the next several years. A theoretical magazine, New International, was launched in 1934.

That same year members of the Communist League of America were in the leadership of the sensational Miuneapolis Teamster strikes, and Cannon traveled there to provide political guidance. This success helped pave the way for a fusion of the Communist League of America with A. J. Muste's American Workers Party at the end of 1934. The new organization was called the Workers Party of the United States and its newspaper was called the New Militant.

In the spring of 1936 Cannon lead the Trotskyists into the Socialist Party and then moved to California where he edited the Socialist Party paper Labour Action. When the Trotskyists were expelled from the Socialist Party in mid-1937, Cannon returned to New York. The Trotskyists founded the Socialist Workers Party in January 1938 with Cannon as national

25

secretary. The following autumn he participated in the founding of the Fourth International in Paris and was elected to the International Executive Committee. The Trotskyist movement had by now grown to over a thousand and had considerable authority in certain sections of the labor movement as well as among New York intellectuals grouped around the literary magazine Partisan Review.

In the all or 1959 a dispute erupted In the fall of 1939 a dispute erupted between factions led by Shachtman and Cannon over questions relating to actions taken by the Soviet Union in the early days of World War II. However, at the heart of the controversy was the famous question of the class nature of the Soviet Union. Shachtman would later on embrace the position, advocated by his ally James Burnham, a New York University Professor of Philosophy, that a new bureaucratic class had come to power. Cannon held to Trotsky's view that the Soviet Union, due to hostile encirclement and a totalitarian political superstructure, was a "degenerated workers' state" (that is, despite the lack of democracy, a post-capitalist society in transition, not yet on the threshold of socialism, and that its nationalized economy should be defended against capitalist nations.

Shachtman's faction split in the spring of 1940, forming the Workers Party. Cannon recorded his version of the dispute in The Struggle for a Proletarian Party (New York: Pioneer, 1942).

In 1941, Cannon and seventeen other leaders of the Socialist Workers Party and the Minneapolis Teamsters Union were convicted under the Smith Act for their opposition to United States government poliey during World War II. Cannon's courtroom testimony is contained in Socialism on Trial (New York: Pioneer, 1942); other writings from the early war period are available in The Socialist Workers Party in World War II (New York: Pathfinder, 1975).

Cannon served thirteen months of a sixteen-month sentence at Sandstone penitentiary in 1944-45, as described in Letters from Prison (New York: Merit, 1968). Following his release, Cannon participated in a factional struggle against two of his long-time associates, Albert Goldman and Felix Morrow. Writings of the late 1940s are collected in The Struggle for Socialism in the "American Century " (New York: Pathfinder 1977).

During the post-war labor upsurge the Trotskyists grew once more to over a thousand, but fell upon hard times during the McCarthy era. In 1953 there was a fierce faction fight, recorded in Speeches to the Party (New York: Pathfinder, 1973), resulting in a split in both the party and in the Fourth International. This was Cannon's last major intervention as the leader of the party. In 1952 he had moved to Los Angeles, and in 1953 Farrell Dobbs took over as national secretary. Cannon became National Chair and then National Chair Emeritus until his death in 1974. His first wife, Lista Makimson, had died in 1929; his second. Rose Karsner, died in 1968. 26

In addition to having the unique capacity to hold a small party together for several decades under difficult circumstances, Cannon was a talented populizer of socialist ideas in his lectures and writings. This can be seen in a collection of his public talks, Speeches for Socialism (New York: Merit, 1971), and of his journalism, Notebook of an Agitator On May 28, Petr Uhl was released from prison, five years exactly after his arrest alongside several other dissidents who had just set up the Committee to Defend the Unjustly Accused (VONS). At the VONS trial on October 23, 1979, Petr Uhl received the heaviest sentence of five years in a maximum security prison. On the eve of his release he was the only one, out of the five convicted in 1979, still in prison. The four others were Vaclav Havel, Jiri Dienstbier, Vaclav Benda and Otta Bednarova.

It was Uhl's ninth year of imprisonment since the occupation of Czechoslovakia by the Warsaw Pact troops in August 1968. He paid dearly for his committment to workers self-management and democratic socialism, argued during the Prague spring of 1968.

In the mid-1960s, Petr Uhl lived in France where he met the group of Communist student activists around Alain Krivine, who were soon to form the Revolutionary Communist Youth (JCR). In their bitter opposition to capitalism as well as Stalinism, Uhl found an echo of his own preoccupations.

On returning to his own country he began to advance the struggle against the cancer of bureaucracy. This was not done in the name of a return to bourgeois 'democracy or to achieve greater delegation of bureaucratic powers in order to present a more 'human face' , as Dubcek proposed, but in the name of socialist self-management and democratic workers power. In the aftermath of August 1968, he was very active amongst students and took part in the organisation of the students' general strike in Prague when it was occupied by Soviet tanks. It was then that, along with other comrades, he helped to set up the Revolutionary Youth Movement (HRM). The programme of this movement expresses clearly the anti-capitalist and anti-bureaucratic beliefs of its founders: 'We live in a system' they stated, 'where capitalist relations of production and the capitalist

(New York: Pioneer, 1958). Additional information about Cannon can be found in the following books: Les Evans, Evans, editor, James P. Cannon as We Knew Him (New York: Pathfinder, 1976); and Theodore Draper, The Roots of American Communism (New York: Viking 1957) and American Communism and Soviet Russia (New York: Viking, 1960). mode of production have been abolished but where the construction of a democratic, socialist society has not even begun. Spurred on by the aim of opposing any abuse of communist ideals and by the belief that it is our duty and our right to fight effectively for these ideals against all those who ridicule, and abuse them, we proclaim (the foundation) of the Revolutionary Youth Movement.

← Colombia: The Truce Between the Government and Guerrillas: PSR's View · Around the World: Czechoslovakia, Canada →

Something wrong on this page?