VIUNI INDIA Why Indira Ghandi sent the army into the Golden Temple The shock waves sent through India and around the world by the storming of the Sikh Golden Temple in early June are still reverberating. At the very least, this dramatic incident highlighted explosive contradictions building up in the world's second most populous country.
On June 2, some 72,000 crack Indian troops went into action in the province of Punjab, where the majority of the Sikh religious group live. The adjoining province of Haryana was carved out of old Punjab for nonSikhs who speak or claim to speak other languages than Punjabi.
The Sikh religion arose in the seventeenth century in an area of chronic warfare between Muslims and Hindus.
The traditional expression of Sikh communalism has been through the Akali Dal party, which supports the demands for more political and religious rights for Sikhs summed up in the Anandpur Sahib resolution. There has been increasing agitation over the last few years by Sikhs in pursuance of these demands that has taken increasingly violent forms.
The following article was written in West Bengal shortly after the events, and indicates the complexity of the issues involved.
three types of demands: political, economic and religious. There were some specific demands. There were also a number of grievances and general demands which had not been put in the form of any specific slogan.
To start with, the Anandpur Sahib resolution speaks of the Sikh quom (1) as a nation, and it calls for a federal structure for India, with extensive powers to the provincial governments. Only four items including defence and currency are to be left with the central government, according to the resolution. This demand stems largely from the growing economic might of the Jat-Sikh kulaks, combined with their fear that without these changes, they would remain a minority community deprived of their just dues' , and dependent on the central government and the Hindus.
The demands which mattered most, when the Akali "moderates' were firmly in control of the movement, related to specific problems faced by Punjab. During the setting up of independent states on the sub-continent, it was decided to split Punjab. Lahore, the provincial capital, went to Pakistan. The new capital, Chandigarh, is not a part of the province. It houses the administrative centres of two provinces — Punjab and Haryana, and is itself administered separatelv is itself administered separately. The The creation of Haryana as a separate province was itself an act fraugnt with grave consequences. As we shall see la * • it was formed as much on religious grounds as on linguistic ones. Nor was this done very smoothly. Even now, Haryana insists that final territorial settlement has not been made, and that the Fazilka and Abohar enclaves belong to Haryana rather than to Punjab.
The economic problems are still more complicated. Punjab is one of the provinces in India where the Green Revolution has had extensive success. But the development of capitalism in agriculture was not followed by an equivalent industrial growth. Merchants and other non-entrepreneurial capitalists still have a strong grip over the economy of the region. This has led to demands for concessions to promote industrial investment by private capitalists. But this is being hidden behind a facade of complaints about 'deprivation' or 'oppression' of the Sikh community or the province.
At the same time, the very development of agrarian capitalism has created new problems. The Green Revolution cultivation areas require high irrigation. But Punjab's share of the waters of the rivers Ravi and Beas is quite low. All sections of the local peasantry are up in arms about this. 1. This Arabic word (plural Aqwam) entered the North Indian languages through Persian. It has a vague meaning (people," "tribe," "relations," "family," "group," "sect"). It is generally used in the Middle East to refer to an ethnic group that is not necessarily, or not yet, a nation, something like "nationality." Hor "natsionalnost," in the Soviet usage. For the Anandpur Sahib resolution see IV, No 35, August 1, 1983. - IV
International Viewpoint 16 July 1984
Inder SINGH
CALCUTTA - Several units of the Indian army, including tank battalions, as well as a large number of para-military units, moved in on the province of Punjab from June 2 this year. Their first target was the Golden Temple complex in Amritsar. The Golden Temple, the chief holy place of the Sikhs, was being used a a shelter by 'extremist' Sikh leader Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale and his followers. Attacked on June 5, they held out for two days. Ultimately, around 350 Sikhs were killed before the governmental forces could gain control of the complex. This official figure is contested by Akali leaders. Bacchan Singh Saral, a top leader of the West Bengal Akali Dal, for example, went on record stating that the actual number of casualties is close to double the government figure. This massive terror and murder campaign came in the wake of presidential orders throwing all foreigners out of Punjab, banning the publication of, or commentary on, any news regarding army activities in Punjab from inside the province, ete. Prolonged curfew was declared in Amritsar and other cities. Only the central government-controlled TV, All India Radio and the national news agencies were permitted to put out news. Thus, having apparently secured all its flanks, the government moved in to unleash a wave of terror unsurpassed in recent history.
At this stage, a brief account of events from June 1 would be useful. On the first of June, a gun battle at the Golden Temple complex left 11 dead and 25 injured. The government responded by imposing a 32-hour curfew in Amritsar. The next day, Prime Minister Gandhi 6 delivered a nationally publicised television speech roundly attacking the Punjab movement as 'extremist' and swearing to deal with it firmly before reopening negotiations. The decision to deploy the army was announced on the same day. Shoot-at-sight orders were issued in Ludhiana and curfew was imposed on four more cities.
This was followed by an all-out attack on the Golden Temple complex elsewhere. All kinds of one-sided news started coming out. The 'extremists' were accused of using LMGs, MMGs, mortars, rockets, ete. This was used as a justification for the army-organised massacre, including the murder of priests and others who could not be called terrorists or combatants in any way. By June 8, fighting was over inside the complex. Bhindranwale was 'found shot dead' - with the army disclaiming responsibility for his death. Roots of the Akali movement
Sikhs all over the country were stunned by these events. The only comparison they could make was with the 1919 Jallianwala Bagh massacre, when British imperialists slaughtered over a hundred people in Amritsar. Even Khuswant Singh, a well-known pro-Indira Gandhi Sikh journalist, turned in his Padma Bhusan award in protest.
At this stage we must turn to the history of the Punjab movement and its evolution over the last two years.
The roots of the Akali movement go back quite far. Indeed, in certain respects it is as old as independent India. Broadly speaking, the present movement had
To understand the religious and cultural issues involved in the agitation, we have to start from the 1940s. The partition of India in 1947 was along communal lines. Pakistan was a separate state for the Muslims. India was formally a secular state. But it had a distinct Hindu bias. As the Sikhs complain, at least one clause of the Indian constitution treats them as Hindus. However, given the electoral base of the Indian National Congress at that time [in which minorities were important], it was not possible to be overtly communal.
Even in those days, the Akali Dal led by Master Tara Singh tried to get recognition as a separate group who should be invited to the negotiations in that capacity. But the small, mainly urban-based Akali Dal did not have adequate muscle power to achieve that goal. Sikh grievances
In post-independence India, the status of Sikhism has often mixed with the political issues. On the political level, we should take note of two changes. The passing of the leadership of the Akalis from Master Tara Singh to Sant Fateh Singh reflected the transformation of the Akali Dal into a vehicle for the aspirations of the Jat-Sikh kulak peasantry. But inspite of their being the biggest group in Punjab, the Jats were kept out of power by electoral combinations against them. It was in response to this situation that they hit upon what seemed an ideal solution. If their movement could be given a religious colour, if the Sikhs could be shown as an oppressed community-cum-nationality, the electoral base could be widened substantially, as Sikhs comprise 52% of Punjab's population. International Viewpoint 16 July 1984
This approach was highly seductive, as Sikhs do have very genuine grievances. Moreover, Sikhism's history has been the history of forging a collective identity through political and military means.
The Sikhs have, as a community, no doubt done better than many other Indian communities. But some major legitimate grievances still exist. There is a basic feeling of insecurity. •In the original province of Punjab in post-independence India, the language of the Punjabi people was formally a minority language. Punjabi Hindus, who often could not speak Hindi properly, still declared it to be their mother tongue during census taking. This prevented the formation of a Punjabi majority province. After a (largely Sikh inspired) struggle, in which religious sentiments were freely evoked for the purposes of mobilisation, Haryana was created. But this led to increased Hindu-Sikh mistrust. This was further fueled by the policies of the dominant bourgeois forces and the Central Government. Over the years, and especially since 1967, the electoral base of the Congress has been eroding. Centrifugal tendencies have been developing. In the face of this problem, an intensive 'national integration' campaign has been built up. Hinduisation and the imposition of the Hindi language have been two of its key planks.
Punjabi Hindus are encouraged to declare Hindi to be their mother tongue. Here we may add parenthetically that similar tactics are used in other parts of India as well. Thus, Bhojpuri, Chhattisgarhi, Maithili and some other languages have been declared to be mere dialects of Hindi.
In Punjab, this means that the 48% non-Sikh population also claim, mostly, to be non-Punjabis. One one hand, this has increased Sikh apprehensions about the future. On the other hand, it has strengthened the false claim that the Sikhs are a nation, defined as such by their common religion. Hindu communalism
The last two years have seen a sharp rise in Hindu communalism. It is not the activities of openly communal organisations like Viswa Hindu Parishad, the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh or the Hindu Suraksha Samity that is most worrying, but the turn in Congress (L) policy and the policy of the government. The Congress (I) is even today the only 'national' party of the ruling class. As its old constituency, the so-called 'core minorities' turn away from it, it is making an all-out effort to rally the Hindu uppper and intermediate castes behind it. This is noticeable at all levels - from Prime Minister Gandhi's display of religiosity to the open support given to intermediate caste-based private landlord armies which oppress the low-caste rural poor to equally open support to anti-Muslim, anti-Sikh or anti-tribal communal forces in every province.
The natural reaction of the religious minorities has been to come to distrust the government even more than they had done previously. Those who have a militant community religion tend to turn even more inward and reply to Hindu communalism by a growing minority communalism of their own.
Given this situation, and the necessity to combine religion with politics in order to build up a mass appeal, it was hardly surprising that the 'extremists' in the movement could seize and retain the initiative. Sant Jarnail Singh Bhindranwale represented the organised 'extremist' faction. As religious overtones be-
Akali negotiators on roof of Golden Temple complex (DR)
came ever stronger, 'moderates' such as former chief minister Badal, former union minister Barnala or even Sant Longowal, did not dare to oppose him too sharply.
At the same time, the 'moderates' realised that they had caught a tiger by the tail. They wanted to use the mass movement as a powerful weapon of pressure to achieve their specific economic and political goals. Not a few of them would have preferred to forge a long-term Akali-Congress (I) alliance. Some factions within the Congress (I) also wanted this to happen. But their hopes were dashed by Mrs Gandhi.
To return to Bhindranwale, as his influence grew, the movement became more and more 'uncontrollable'. The demand for Khalistan [a Sikh state] or even for the proposal for restructuring centrestate relations made in the Anandpur Sahib resolutions, was not actually on the negotiation table. Nor were the religious demands like an all-India Gurdwara Act (2), radio broadcasts from the Golden Temple, etc., the key demands. These gradually displaced the demands concerning Chandigarh, Fazilka and Abohar, Ravi-Beas waters, and the like. The role of the left
This rise of extremism was a direct result of the government's tactics. For the last two years, dilatory tactics were adopted deliberately. Every time there was the possibility of a negotiated settlement, some attacks would be made on Sikhs, and the talks would receive a setback. Equally important was the support given to Hindu communalists and their organisations — like the Hindu Suraksha Samity... In Haryana, chief minister Bhajan Lal, Indira Gandhi's creature, openly aided attacks on Sikhs. No effort was made to win over the 'moderates' and isolate the 'extremists'. On the contrary, one might say that it was undeclared government policy to let the 'moderates' be discredited.
The response of the left was weak and inadequate at best. The Communist Party of India (Marxist) was in a total mess right from the start. The CPI(M)'s social base in Punjab is practically the same as the Akali Dal's. As a result, the party took an opportunist stance. Eventually, it gained nothing. Narkisen Singh Surjeet, the Punjab CPI(M) leader, tried to act as a go-between. But he was ultimately treated as an emissary of Mrs Gandhi, rather than as an 'honest broker'
At the all-India level, the CPI(M)'s call for restructuring centre-state relations could have been another theme to bring the party closer to the Akalis. But the CPI(M) is also extremely concerned about 'national integration' , by which it means you have to oppose any movement against national oppression, regional imbalance, etc., the moment it steps out of the purely constitutionalist framework. 8
Rioting Hindus in Punjab (DR) In recent times, more than one CPI(M) leader has voiced the idea that after the next parliamentary polls, they might be in a position to prop up a minority government at the centre, no doubt in return for concessions. With all these calculations, the CPIM) eventually lined up against the Punjab movement when the crackdown began. The political bureau registered its formal unhappiness, but two political bureau members, M. Vasabpunnaiah and West Bengal chief minister Jyoti Basu, also expressed the view that the central government had been left with no options other than sending in the army.
The Communist Party of India, which has its base among a wider cross-section of the Punjabi population, took a more formally correct position. It called for tripartite negotiations between the Akalis, the central government and the 'national' opposition for a political settlement. It supported a few Akali demands, while opposing terrorism and violence on either side, and so on. But when it came to the final reckoning, the CPI issued a statement saying that the 'entire responsibility' for the events leading to the army takeover and the mass killings lay with Bhindranwale and his followers. The CP's English language weekly New Age talked of the relief that the assault brought to Punjab.
Most far-left groups supported a number of the specific Sikh demands, while opposing Sikh terrorism as much as Hindu communal violence, but they also pointed out that the former sprang from the tactics of the centre.
But practically all shades of the left failed in two crucial ways. The first of these related to the problems of the hundreds of thousands of seasonal (migrant) agricultural labourers. In peak season, they come to Punjab from Uttar Pradesh, Bihar and other provinces. Given the extreme poverty in their own areas, they are willing to work for lower
AKING wages than their Punjabi counterparts. This forces down the wage rate. This in turn becomes a communal weapon used by Hindu and Sikh communalistss alike.
The Anadpur Sahib resolutions are, quite naturally, practically silent about the rural poor. A guaranteed minimum wage, based on the Consumer Price Index, is the minimum immediate requirement for the agricultural labourers. Quite understandably, the kulak-based Akali Dal could not offer this and mobilise the agricultural labourers around this slogan. But for the left not to raise this as a major agitational slogan was an error of serious proportions. This was the class issue in Punjab. Even if one had the sole idea of combatting communalism, this slogan could have played a good role. The Sikh agriculturaral labourers' prejudice against their Hindu migrant counterparts could have been broken and the communalists on both sides given a rebuff.
The second failure of the left, including most of the far left, was their inability to understand the role of communalism and how to combat it. Communalism does not mean - contrary to a belief that it is a force that is declining, if slowly - the activities of the fringe groups or a few organisations like the RSS only. Communalism is present in the very fabric of Indian social and political life, including in the constitution and other laws. Even the much vaunted Nehru brand of secularism is a fake and a fraud. The Nehruite definition of secularism, accepted by most of the left, is equal toleration of, and equal patronage for, all religions. What criticisms are made are limited to the questions of how well this equality is applied in practice. This means that the left does not fight seriously for total separation of religion and education, for an end to state aid to 2. Temples. - IV
International Viewpoint 16 July 1984
propagation of religion, etc. The left has failed to realise that the creation of multiple spheres of intolerance, kept from uncontrolled clashes by the army and the police, is not secularism. Given today's situation, there is perhaps no alternative to supporting, as a temporary measure, the demand for equal right to propagate all religions through the radio, especially as Hinduism is propagated in that way. But it is up to the left to challenge this pseudo-secular approach, which actually aids communalism, and to put forward boldly the view that religion is an individual's private matter, and that secularism means total absence of state involvement in the propagation of religion.
The failure to challenge the official version of secularism has often heen version of secularism has often been compounded by a false attitude of sympathy to minority communalism, often for crude electoral advantage. A glaring example is the repeated alliance between the CPI and CPI(M) on one hand and the Muslim League on the other. Similarly, though not for electoral alliances specifically, many far-left groups failed to oppose Sikh terrorism. Instead of clearly pointing out the futility of terrorism as a weapon of struggle, and arguing that a communal response to Hindu communalism will not in the long run benefit the Sikhs, and especially the toiling masses among them, they often kept silent. Against government repression
As a result of the near total disarray among the major (reformist) left even before the military crackdown, their response to that was shabby at best. After the first few days, the CPI and CPI(M) leaders finally stopped congratulating the central government on a job well done. Together with three other parties, they issued a call for the resumption of talks and a quick political settle. cion of talks and a quick political settlement. But they remain firm in their overall appraisal of the situation, and have added their voices to the chorus about the foreign hand which is supposed to be trying to destabilise India.
The far-left groups' positions and campaigns are not all known. With the continuing ban on reporting from inside Punjab, and with total disruption of communications between Punjab and the rest of India, the role of the far left at the present stage in that province remains unknown. In Calcutta, a significant step was taken on June 12. Four organisations - the Provisional Central Committee CPI (ML), the Indian Peoples Front, the Organising Committee of Communist Revolutionaries and the Inquilabi Communist Sangathan (Revolutionary Communist Organisation - Indian section of the Fourth International) organised a public meeting to condemn the repression in Punjab. Several hundred people attended the meeting. Apart from the representatives of the organisers, several other far-left groups also sent speakers or solidarity messages. A leadInternational Viewpoint 16 July 1984 er of the Akali Dal, West Bengal also spoke at the meeting. A resolution was passed, condemning the slaughter in Punjab, and pointing to the central government as the primary guilty party.
The resolution also demanded immediate withdrawal of the army from Punjab, a judicial enquiry into the shootings to be conducted by a Sugreme Court judge, withdrawal of censorship, immediate halt to the use of draconian laws like the National Security Act, and the release of all political prisoners including Akali leaders Longowal, Tohra and Talwandi. It was also resolved to continue this campaign collectively. A number of street corner meetings were held.
The Sikh response was an initial stunned disbelief that this could have
Bengal, etc., rebelled, and in a number of cases shot down officers who tried to stop them. Eventually, over forty soldiers were killed in different parts of the country before these revolts could be quelled. In most barracks, Sikh soliders have been disarmed. Considering the quite high proportion of Sikhs in the Indian army, this poses a serious problem for the ruling class. The 'foreign hand'
A favourite refrain of Mrs Gandhi has been the theme of the foreign hand, which is always trying to destablise India by inciting internal dissent and external aggression through Pakistan, Bangladesh. Nenal. Sri Lanka This rhetorio desh, Nepal, Sri Lanka....This rhetoric has been getting more and more strident in recent times. From the third or fourth day after the army campaign started, the 'extremist menace' took a backseat in government propaganda to the foreign threat. Bangladesh and Pakistan were abused for misreporting events. Huge weapons caches containing Pakistani and Chinese weapons were allegedly discovered. The country was, predictably, asked to rally round the government in this perilous moment. This jingoism was inevitable. Once the 'extremists' had been crushed, or at least their main forces broken up (and that is certainly the case in Punjab, where several thousand people have been arrested), they could no longer be held up as the chief obstacle to 'national integration'. So, the campaign shifted to traditional themes. Pakistan is, of course, India's traditional enemy. One has to remember the complete unity that prevailed in the Indian parliament last time India waged war on Pakistan.
The threat of war is not illusory. As both India and Pakistan face increasing internal dissention, a rousing patriotic war may well seem the best device to extricate the rulers of both countries extricate the rulers of both countries. The Indian bourgeoisie faces the need to restructure industry, and the corresponding need for a qualitative increase in attacks on democratic rights in order to accomplish this. This means more than the 'normal' attacks on the rights of striking workers, ete. The government is out to destroy totally the elementary organisations and defenses of the proletariat, as well as to curtail the rights of sections of the opposition bourgeois forces. In this context, war and the threat of war and accusations of lack of patriotism are means that can serve the government's ends.
At the same time, India also has to take on the task of policing the entire sub-continent and keeping it safe for world capitalist profits. As the weaker regimes in India's neighbouring countries totter from crisis to crisis, Indian intervention tends to loom larger and larger as a possibility. In that sense, the current repression in Punjab is a link in the chain of repression that the Indian bourgeoisie is trying to forge for the entire sub-continent.
•
9 happened, followed agitations. In Hydera dred strong demonstr attacked by the polic were also attacked in Ahmedabad and othe cutta, over 5,000 Sikl responded to the call tion issued by the Aka A 48-hour-long Sikh: served successfully.
Even moderate Sikl tremely embittered a the Golden Temple a hundreds of Sikhs. F ister Swaran Singh, M.P. and others denou
The large scale d army notwithstanding rorist attacks have in the last fortnight. A s bereft of any control, and is merely provi government's mill by same time, the Hindu continues its activities protection.
The Sikh unrest also side the army. Sikh bycountrywide bad, a several hunation was brutally e. Demonstrators Dadar (Bombay), er places. In Cal1 men and women • for a demonstrali Dal, West Bengal. strike was also ob1s have become exiter the attack on nd the murder of ormer central min-
Khuswant Singh aced the massacre. eployment of the , incidence of tercreased sharply in mall minority, now is running amuck, ding grist to the its action. At the • Suraksha Samity under virtual state i spread quickly insoliders stationed in Rajasthan, Bihar, Maharashtra, West
Akali Dal leader Gurchuran Singh (DR)
INDIA Indian women building a dam (DR)