Origins of the Indian problem Two weeks after the bombing of Eden Pastora's press conference at a guerrilla encampment in Nicaragua, the smoke has not yet settled.
Pastora himself has said that the agent who planted the bomb probably represented either the Sandinistas or the ex-Somocista guerrillas of the FDN.
The Soviet news agency Tass has raised the hypothesis that the CIA tried to kill Pastora because he was opposed to uniting his own "liberal" counterrevolutionary ARDE with the FDN.
The American Broadcasting Company has tried to put the finger of blame on militant Basque nationalists deported from France to Panama.
The Nicaraguan government has said the bombing was the result of "internal wrangling in the counterrevolutionary groups encouraged by the CIA."
In all of this, one thing seems clear, the attempt to open another counterrevolutionary guerrilla front in the south from bases in Costa Rica has suffered a major, if not decisive setback. This is reflected by the fact that the Costa Rican government has expelled Pastora from its territory.
Clearly, the attempt to build a "liberal" counterrevolutionary operation against the Sandinista government was fraught with contradictions.
There is, moreover, another interesting factor. In its June 2 issue, the Paris daily Liberation reported that the ARDE was left "without troops, since the Indians led by Brooklin Rivera, leader of the organization Misurasata, have decided to wage a struggle for the autonomy of the Miskito Indians on their own."
Because of certain errors by the young revolutionary government, the counterrevolutionaries were able to get a significant base among the Indians of the Atlantic coast area of Nicaragua. Up until now this has been a central element in the counterrevolutionary operation.
So, it seems worth reviewing the Nicaraguan Indian problem. The following articles dealing with the question were published recently in the papers of sections of the Fourth International. The first is by the Berlin ethnologist Robin Schneider. It was published in the February 1 issue of Die Linke, the journal of the Austrian section of the Fourth International. The second is a report of the impressions of an observer from a national organization of Scandinavian Lapps. It is from the April 16 issue of Internationalen, the paper of the Swedish section of the Fourth International.
The Lapps are an ancient people related to the Finns who settled in the northern forests of Scandinavia before the invasion of the Germanic peoples and have been pushed back futher and further into the subartic area. The Lapp organizations have tended to take more and more interest in the struggles of the Indian peoples of the Americas in the framework of a sort of international community of threatened native peoples.
to their demand for regional autonomy, which was charterized as "separatism."
After the raids on their villages carried out by the military, a lot of Indians were disillusioned and turned against the Sandinista government. For the FSLN as a liberation movement and later as the ruling party, the demands of the Indian organization for ethnic self-determination and land were unacceptable.
The revolutionary leadership's anxiety about the unity of the young national state, about a separation of the Atlantic coast from Nicaragua, led to a failure to integrate the native population into the national economy and culture.
The central government no longer saw any solution through working with Misurasata.
After the Indian movement countered by demanding an Indian territory covering a third of Nicaragua, Misurasata was banned outright in August 1981. Then, the counterrevolutionary groups in Honduras and Florida turned the political confrontation into a military one. They managed to organize an armed force of a few hundred Miskitos against the Sandinistas.
Today, the Indian area is a closed military zone. In January 1982, about 8,500 Miskitos were moved against their will further into the interior, and in late November of that year, another 5,000. Twelve thousand Indians took refuge in the UN camps in Honduras.
A rightist guerrilla force made up of former Somoza National Guard, peasants and Indians is waging a bush war against the Sandinista army. The war leaves no room for social and economic construction. The work of building up the fishing industry and mining, as well as the re-forestation projects, and the plans for building a bilingual school system have all been essentially stymied.
The history of the Miskitos explains their fierce opposition to rule by outsiders, even revolutionaries. The result of their long history of rebellions and alliances is that the Miskitos have survived as the largest lowland population in Latin America today. While the forest Indian groups number in the hundreds and few thousands, there are as many Miskitos in Nicaragua and Honduras as all the Indians who live in the gigantic Brazilian Amazon region.
Rebellions against the Spanish conquerors of the Pacific coast region and accompanying alliances with the British colonial power in the Caribbean made it easier for the Miskitos to absorb foreign influences than for other Indian peoples. Since the seventeenth century, they have been a racial mixture, combining the blood of the older Indian people with that of escaped Black slaves.
For 250 years, the Miskitos had their own kings, while the Atlantic coast was a British protectorate. They were able to reduce the smaller Sumu and Rama peoples to tribute-paying status, up until 1894, when Nicaragua, with the help of the US, annexed their country by military force. • International Viewpoint 18 June 1984
Robin SCHNEIDER At the origin of the conflict between the Indian movement Misurasata, and the left government was the question of how the Indian-inhabited areas would be incorporated into the revolution. The Sandinistas had a special interest in the natural resources of the Atlantic coast - hardwoods, gold and shellfish — as a means of meeting the growing deficit of hard currency.
What the Miskitos were concerned about was preserving the traditional life in their more than 200 village communes.
8
IV At the end of 1980, a compromise was worked out. The communes were to be given land titles that would assure that Indian land would no longer be occupied by Spanish-speaking small farmers pushing into the Atlantic coastal region. The state was to pass on 80% of the profits from the lumber industry to the villagers.
The literacy campaign, which had been boycotted by the village communes, was finally to be carried out in the Indian languages.
Positions began to harden in February 1981 when the state security force arrested all the major Indian leaders in response
Today, the culture of the Miskitos is a hybrid one. Since the middle of the nineteenth century, it has been transformed by the puritanical missionaries of the Moravian church and by plantation work. In particular, it has been turned upside down by the big North American banana and lumber companies that came in early this century and plundered the natural wealth of the region, leaving vast areas between Rio Coco and Puerto Cabezas as barren steppeland.
Up until today, the Miskitos have not determined their own history. If the war in Nicaragua lasts a long time, they risk being torn to pieces as a people between a national revolution and an internationally organized counterrevolution.
So, first the war has to end, and then it should be considered whether talks with the Miskitos and Creoles in exile might not be the only way to avert a long-drawn out guerrilla war.
to read and write in Spanish, a completely different language than their own Indian tongues.
"Today, education is conducted in both Spanish and the Indian languages along the Atlantic coasts. The first four years, instruction is through the Indian language, and Spanish is only a school subject. At higher levels, the relationship is reversed.
"The government has published a grammar of the Miskito language. That is in five years after the fall of the dictatorship. We Lapps got our first grammar of Southern Lappish here in Sweden only two years ago. So, they are ahead of us in Nicaragua!"
But people in the audience asked about genocide and forced migration.
Ann Katrin Haakansson had heard no talk about genocide, although she met Miskito leaders who took refuge in Costa Rica and were hostile to the Sandinistas. But there was in fact forced migration of Miskitos from the Honduran border in the north. That was when the "contras," the counterrevolutionaries, started their raids into the country.
"All the belongings of the people, land, animals and so forth were noted down. Then everything was burnt. The objective was to keep the "contras" from getting a foothold in the north.
"The government has since pledged in writing that the people will get replacements for everything as soon as the state of war ceases.
"Naturally, the Indians reacted against this. When I was on the Atlantic coast, it was evident that there is an underlying suspicion of everything the government does. The people here did not participate in the uprising against Somoza. They are not participants in the revolution now. I felt suspicion.
"They have gotten private and collective plots of land. They get education. The Sandinistas are trying to build up a fishing industry. They have now brought drinking water into every neighborhood in Puerto Cabezas, where there are 10,000 refugees from the north. The next step is to bring potable water into every house."
But what about the line being pushed now by the journalist Fritiof Hagland?
"I was shocked when I heard his radio program. I met the same people he did. He has access to the mass media.
"He was the one who brought Armstrong Wiggens [an anti-Sandinista Miskito figure ], and gave him fifteen minutes on the news.
"He had a collection of pictures of murders and acts of violence. The US authorities had to admit afterwards that the pictures were from the Somoza period! Radio Sweden paid for Wiggins' trip here."
Ann Kristin Haaksannson offered an anecdote.
"The traditional life of the Miskito was disturbed fundamentally 150 years ago. A German church was responsible for that. Fritiof Hagland's father was a missionary for that church."
6
FSLN leader Tomas Borge with Miskito Indians (DR)