International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Netherlands: Fighting Experience for Public Service Workers

· International Viewpoint No. 45, 30 January 1984 · pp 17-19 · 3,090 words

Low Countries Italy

Fighting experience for public workers -

Pyrrhic victory for hard-nosed government

"There is very little either Christian or democratic about the Christian

Democratic Party." (1) "One thing is clear, this government has to go."

When you hear talk like that at a Dutch union meeting, it means that something is going on. But when you hear these and many other such remarks at a meeting of the Christelijke Federatie van Overheidspersoneel

(CFO - Christian Federation of Government Employees), you can talk functionaries continued to discuss it all night long.

After a sleepless night, even these two conservative unions proved unable to reach an agreement with the government. Lubbers' hard line had brought the four unions together.

Finally, it was a combination of attrition and court injunctions that brought the actions to an end. In particular, when the postal workers and the Rotterdam city workers were ordered back to work, the public workers unions suffered a hard blow. The reiteration by the Liberal and Christian Democratic majority in parlia ment that they would continue to support the government also did not offer much hope. Between December 2 and December 9, most of the actions were December , most of the actions were ended. The reasons for failure

How could a struggle with such mass support be ended in this way? And why was it practically only the public workers union that went into action?

Since the formation of the Lubbers' government in November 1982, the old days when this country was supposed to be an "oasis of social harmony" have been fading fast. But, overall, the union movement remained very much oriented to negotiating in the framework of the tripartite bodies (labor, government and employers) that abound in this country. The various strike waves that hit the Netherlands in the early 1970s hardly affected this traditional attitude.

When the crisis set in in earnest in 1980, it led to a tougher austerity government here in the Netherlands as well. That is what the Lubbers' government represents.

Because of an unfavorable relationship of forces in parliament and the reactions by the union movement to attacks on the workers' gains in 1977, 1980 and 1982, neither the Christian DemocraticLiberal coalitions that ruled the country in 1977-81 and 1982 nor the Christian Democratic-Social Democratic coalitions that governed in 1973-1977 and 19811982 were able to push the austerity drive very far.

Nonetheless, since 1979 real wages in the Netherlands have declined by 8% in industry and by between 16% and 20% in the public sector. But this did not solve the country's serious fiscal problems, for a number of reasons. First of all, up to 1982 the number of persons employed in the public services rose steadily. Secondly, through a complicated mechanism the evolution of wages in the public sector is linked to that in industry. Of course, this system has been breached from time to time, which explains how wages could fall faster in the public sector. But the system as such remains in force. Thirdly, social-welfare expenditures have increased enormously as a consequence of unemployment. In this respect, the Netherlands leads the Common Market, with a 1. In the Netherlands, the Christian Democratic Party is a fusion of Protestant and Catholic political organizations. - IV.

17 about a new political situation in the Herman PIETERSON

The change was brought about by a seven-week-long confrontation between the Christian Democratic-Liberal government headed by Ruud Lubbers on one side and the public-workers union on the other.

Since September, there had been grumbling among the public service workers. And this is a very important sector in the Netherlands. There are 700,000 public service workers, plus another 500,000 workers whose wages and working conditions are tied by law to those of the public workers. This is out of a total working population of about 4 million.

This 1.2-million-strong sector includes such important groups of workers as those at the power generators, on the railroad, all the mass-transport workers and those in the municipal services such as garbage collectors and street cleaners, as well as the post, telecommunications, customs and harbor-service workers. It also includes, of course, teachers, the police and those working in the offices of the various ministries and the provinces.

What prompted the confrontation was a 3.5% wage cut. Under the pressure of the public workers actions, this cut was reduced at an early stage by 0.5%. On December 14, parliament passed a law to meet this agreement. But, although the direct result of the October, November and December actions thus seems very small, it would be wrong to talk about a clear defeat. Transport workers take lead

The terms of the conflict were already evident in October. The government showed in an initial round of negotiations on October 5 that it was not ready to make any concessions to the union representatives. Provocative statements by Rietkerk, the Liberal minister of the interior, provided the match that set the powder alight.

On October 17, the railroad workers in Amsterdam started it going with workto-rule actions (this was three weeks ahead of the plans of the union leadership). The rest of the country followed. The local bus services started rotatInternational Viewpoint 30 January 1984 country. ing strikes. The other public service workers also staged a couple of actions. (Bus and rail workers belong to the transport union, other public service workers to the big civil service union.)

The escalation of the actions can be dated from November 2. The second round of negotiations brought a limitation of the wage cut to 3%. But that was as far as the government was prepared to go. The negotiators for the state said that they were bound by the agreement on which the ruling coalition is based. And that was that.

Within five days the most important actions were underway. The railway workers went from work-to-rule actions to region-by-region rotating strikes. The post was paralyzed by strikes at the sorting centers and by the postal drivers.

The customs workers started work-torule actions, which led in particular to major delays for truck traffic. In Amsterdam and Rotterdam, the sanitation workers went on strike. At the same time, other municipal services started rotating actions. In Amsterdam public transport stopped totally five times for a morning or a day. In Rotterdam after a week the transport workers started an unlimited strike.

In a number of other places also, other public services conducted various forms of actions. In all, tens of thousands of people were directly involved in the actions.

To be sure, the numbers of actual strikers were kept down by the tactic of rotating strikes and strikes at key points, which made it possible for quite small groups of strikers to paralyze enterprises and services.

Between November 18 and 21, the strikes went into a third phase. A judge ordered a third round of negotiations. In the first place, the Algemene Centrale van Overheids Personeel (ACOP), the civil service union belonging to the Federatie Nederlandse Vakbeweging (FNV -Dutch Federation of Trade Unions, the Social Democrat-dominated federation of unions), seemed to be becoming isolated.

A compromise proposal was rejected by the ACOP, but the Christian union and the two right-wing unions of higher

17% unemployment rate.

It was impossible to pursue a severe austerity offensive and at the same time keep up the complex system of social partnership. But the previous governments proved unable to mount frontal attacks on it.

It is the Lubbers' government precisely that has taken on the goal of dismantling this system.

In what is presented as a "no nonsense" cabinet, the leaders of the two big bourgeois parties have worked out a complete program for demolishing the social welfare system and eliminating social expenditures. In every test, the parliamentary majority seems to have given the government very nearly a blank check.

Politically the Lubbers' government has not had an easy time of it. Obviously, an austerity program of this sort also harms the interests of a lot of Christian Democratic supporters. Thus the government's relations with the 350,000-member Christian union federation (Christeliike National Vakverbond, CNV) are already not the best.

Moreover, a considerable number of those who vote for the Christian Democratic Party (the Christen Democratisch Appel - Christian Democratic Appeal, CDA) are pensioners, and so were hit as hard as the public service workers by the 3% cut.

The government's operation as a whole is supposed to produce savings of 10.5

5 to 4 billior US dollars) at the expense of the public workers.

Three of these ten billion guilders are supposed to come from a reduction in the number of jobs. The 3% wage cut is supposed to have another 2 billion. That means that in the coming year still more stringent measures are going to be needed to save the remaining 5.5 billion. More wage cuts are, thus, inevitable.

Recently, the government has floated a draconian plan for social cutbacks. It is supposed to go into effect on July 1, 1984, but it will probably be implemented in stages spread out over a year and a half. This plan is designed to cut back social spending by another 10%. It is, moreover, another step toward a total revision of the system of social spending, which in turn would result in new and drastic cutbacks.

Lubbers is not altogether crazy. So, the government has drawn up an overall plan involving cuts in taxes and social insurance payments that will favor workers in industry in 1984. It needs to play the public and private sectors off against each other to get the political room to launch further attacks on the living standards of working people. In fact, about 180,000 minimum-wage workers in the private sector were also hit by the 3% wage cut.

The government has been able to create divisions. The tendency has always been to look on public workers as people who are paid too much for doing too little. Declining wages in industry have fostered envy against the supposed 18 advantages of public workers.

The fact that wages have been harder hit in the public sector is very little known. The wage differentials that existed before and the relatively small layoffs in the public services up till now have strengthened the impression among industrial workers that public workers are well off.

Of course, this is precisely where the unions had an important role to play in informing the workers of the real situation. The next largest union, the Industriebond-FNV [which includes most industrial workers] deliberately neglected this task. It formally supported the public workers. But in its paper, ZIN, generous space was allotted to opponents of the strikes. Moreover, the union leadership did not bother to correct any of these statements or reply to them.

The FNV (which has about a million members) as a whole supported these actions as a matter of course because they were against cutbacks. But no proposals for organizing concrete solidarity were forthcoming. In many cases, this kind of solidarity had to be organized against the opposition of the FNV. The isolation of the public sector, which naturally came under heavy fire from the bourgeois and petty-bourgeois forces and the media, did not make it any easier to carry out the actions.

There is a constant threat of division between the various unions as well. There are two big labor federations in the Netherlands, plus a number of smaller independent unions.

In the public workers actions, this meant that in addition to the FNV and CNV unions, two small right-wing unions were also involved, the CMHA (Centrale Middelbare en Hogere Ambtenaren — Federation of Middle and High Level Public Servants) and the AC (Ambtenaren Centra - Civil Servants Union).

Only the FNV unions went out on strike, although the CNV unions often participated in the actions. The two smaller groups were involved only in the negotiations. Time and time again they seemed ready to make a deal with the government ahead of the FNV unions, but finally the government's hard line did not permit this.

Thirdly, the forms of action adopted had their limitations. The pinpoint strikes did make it possible to paralyze large sections of public services and enterprises at minimal expense to the unions' strike funds. But this method was an obstacle to extending the actions. It was precisely in the last phase of the strike that this problem became clear, when court orders were sufficient to stop the decisive actions.

Lastly, from the beginning the political stakes of the actions were not clearly understood. The union leaderships apparently thought that they could get some more concessions by a show of force. By November 2, it was clear that this was not so. But the union tactics remained tied to this orientation.

If the actions had won any real success, this would have led directly or indirectly to the fall of the government. Neither the Christian Democrats nor the Liberals wanted to run that risk, in particular since they faced the possibility of defeat in early elections. The polls indicate that the Social Democrats would make big gains and the government parties would lose their majority.

The most important development in this strike is that tens of thousands of people participated in actions for the first time. Before this there was scarcely any strike tradition among public workers, except in mass transport and certain municipal services. Now when the government makes the next round of cutbacks it will have to face a very widespread readiness for action on the part of the public workers.

The public workers unions have grown both in terms of members (the largest civil service union gained more than 10,000 members) and activists. Although a lot of the leaders are politically inexperienced, they continue to enjoy considerable confidence among the membership, especially in the case of the Abvakabo, the main FNV union for the public sector.

The actions were stopped by court orders that banned further strikes. There was a lot of grumbling among the ranks, but most of them did not feel that their leaders had let them down.

The defeat the public workers suffered in this round of cutbacks can, thus, be attributed to the political inexperience of most public workers. The courts have long been regarded as sacred. Now a whole series of decisions have made it crystal clear how judges act in big class conflicts. And the previous respect for the courts is fading. But this process takes time.

Some of the court decisions were quite significant. Although there is no formal strike ban, everywhere that the actions had a real effect the judges banned further strikes. This is an ominous sign. The courts banned strikes at the same time that they recognized the formal right to strike of public employees (except for the police). This sort of reasoning, thus, could be applied to industrial as well as public workers.

It was against this open class justice that the strikes at key-points strategy proved particularly ineffective.

The Netherlands has seen other such strike bans. In the engineering industry on more than one occasion banned strikes have been continued by elected action committees.

Such action committees also played an important role in this strike. The central decisions were left to the union leadership. But the committees had a say in the forms of action, about the most effective way of paralyzing the key point selected for a strike.

In view of this success, it can be expected that in subsequent actions such committees will again be called upon to play a role. Thus, the means is at hand for continuing strikes in the face of court

International Viewpoint 30 January 1984

injunctions.

In the coming months there should be many discussions in the public workers unions. The most important questions are what attitude to take toward the courts and the policy of pinpoint strikes.

The Socialistiese Arbejders Partij (Socialist Workers Party - SAP), Dutch section of the Fourth International publicized its ideas on these questions during the strikes through large-scale leaflet distributions.

Where possible, the SAP members played an active role in the action committees and worked in particular to build solidarity between the public and private sectors. In Amsterdam, for example, this led to the issuing of joint leaflets by leading unionists in various unions and to a common demonstration. The SAP's proposals for working toward a general strike of the public sector were generally well received.

This wave of strikes is the second big confrontation between the Lubbers' government and the opposition. The first, the fight against the Cruise missiles, is not yet decided. In the second, the government won a material victory but one that looks likely to prove politically a pyrrhic one.

Opposition to austerity is now widespread in the union movement. A whole sector that had been quiet has now gone through an important experience in action. And in large sections of the workers movement, there is a climate of strong political opposition to the Lubbers' government, even in the Christian unions.

This does not mean that things are going to be easy in the union movement. This government is determined to push austerity, and so it is prepared for hard confrontations.

In June 1984 we will face the final decision on the Cruise missiles and a first phase of a new offensive against social spending. The need is more and more clearly posed for ousting this government and replacing it with a Social Democrat government not tied to right-wing coalition partners.

Many thousands of people in the unions are beginning to see this. At the same time, we are seeing a process of dif- same time, we are seeing a process or allferentiation among various unions and in various unions between different layers of the apparatus. The most right-wing leadership, the one in the FNV Industriebond is now facing opposition in its own apparatus. Similar processes are going on in other unions.

In the coming six months, we should see important political developments in the Dutch labor movement. Discussion should begin on the most important labor contracts in industry, which will run out on January 1, 1985. There is every indication that the political stagnation that has reigned in the labor movement since the onset of the crisis in 1980 can be broken.

The task of the revolutionary socialists is to help to advance class-struggle answers and to promote the development of a militant left current. International Viewpoint 30 January 1984

Technology has come a long way since Charlie Chaplin started! (DR)

UNITED STATES

← Denmark: The Missiles, Hidden Issue in Elections · United States: The 'Big Change' for US Workers — New Technology →

Something wrong on this page?