International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Israel: The Sad Ending of an Economic Adventure

· International Viewpoint No. 41, 28 November 1983 · pp 9-10 · 1,830 words

Middle East World economy

The sad ending of an economic adventure

Michel WARSCHAWSKI Three days after his appointment to the new government of Yitshak Shamir had been confirmed by the Knesset, Finance Minister Yoram Aridor announced his resignation.

While financial circles in Israel, including a not inconsiderable section of Aridor's own party, had been calling for his resignation for some time, he had hung on to his post, trying to show that it was possible, within the capitalist economic system, to flout the market laws and satisfy both the bourgeoisie and the toiling masses.

It was a leak, in all likelihood orchestrated from within the top financial circles of the country, about the 'dollarisation' project that finally forced the new head of government to rid himself of his finance minister. Ygal Cohen-Orgad, one of the strongest opponents of Aridor's policies, is going to replace him, thus marking the definitive end of an economic adventure that took the Israeli economy to the verge of bankruptey.

THE ECONOMIC POPULISM OF ARIDOR

Contrary to a widely-held belief, Herut — the party of Menachem Begin, Yitshak Shamir, David Levy and Yoram Aridor - is not and never has been the party of the Israeli big bourgeoisie. The great majority of this class has always been within the Labour Party. The social base of the Herut is petty bourgeois and popular, and its leadership has always been very sensitive to the pressure from the popular neighbourhoods of the big cities and the immigrants' towns.

The tensions that have surfaced several times within the Likud between the Herut and the Liberal Party - which is closer to financial circies, and particularly to small industry, commerce and land owners - reflect the class differences between the support for these two formations.

Some months before the last elections to the Knesset, at the beginning of 1981, Begin replaced the then minister of finances, Yigael Horovits, who had tried to implement austerity policies around the slogan "The coffers are empty'

Horovits was replaced with Yoram Aridor, former leader of the Herut group in the Histadrut. The new minister immediately undertook a policy of reducing taxes on consumer goods and International Viewpoint 28 November 1983 of raising subsidies on basic necessities. At the same time Aridor blocked all projects likely to lead to an increase in unemployment. This economic policy, while not arousing great enthusiasm in financial circles, was to guarantee the Likud's victory in parliamentary elections.

Advised by a charlatan, Dr. Yakir Plessner, who stated that the number one priority must be the fight against inflation - 120 per cent at the time - and that this was above all a psychological phenomenon, Aridor decided to follow his economic poliey after the elections also.

Refusal to devalue the shekel and the detaxation of imported goods caused a spectacular rise in the balance of payments deficit. Moreover, it led to a flight of capital from industry to commerce, and to the stock exchange, where one could make spectacular gains of more than 200 per cent per year.

For the workers the Aridor-Plessner tandem had meant more than two years of full employment and a real rise in buying power thanks to the sliding scale, the subsidies and the reductions in taxes on consumer goods, and the stock speculation which was far from being limited to the most privileged sections.

To be sure, the running down of the health, education and social services had been an attack on the living standards of the toiling masses. But it is only in one or two years time that one will be able to see exactly the extent of the disaster in these areas. And, for the great majority, this deterioration in public services will pass unnoticed, overshadowed by their home gadgets, videos, cars, and foreign holidays, the number of which are -proportional to the number of inhabitants - the highest in the world.

A recent anecdote illustrates the scope of the consumer fever that has hit Israel. One of the biggest Japanese producers of videos sent one of his directors to Israel to find out what his customers did with the enormous number of machines they ordered, and to see if they did not export them elsewhere. It was only after he had seen with his own eyes, that he did in fact accept that this huge quantity was sold within Israel itself.

This massive subsidy for consumer goods and the relative guarantee to buying power and jobs are, in themselves, praiseworthy objectives. But they are totally utopian in the framework of the economic reality of the state of Israel and the world capitalist system.

From the capitalist point of view -and this is indeed the point of view of the Zionist regime - the economic policy applied by the Begin government was suicidal.

Local industry was unable to compete with foreign products, not only on the international market but also on the internal market. As a consequence, dozens of factories were closed down and the capital invested in imports.

Agriculture, which for two decades had been the pride of the Israeli economy, and industrial diamond production literally collapsed in the course of the last two years as a result of the reduction in subsidies and the overvaluation of the shekel.

The balance of payments deficit tops 5 billion dollars, and at the end of the year the foreign debt will reach 33 billion dollars. As for inflation, Dr Plessner's theories have turned out to be completely erroneous, as could have been predicted. The present rate will top 200 per cent at the end of the year.

### COHEN-ORGAD'S

DECLARATION OF WAR

Aridor has been succeeded as minister of finance by a fervent supporter of 'rationalisation' in spending. Since his appointment, Ygal Cohen-Orgad has stated that his objective would be to reduce the budget and balance of payments deficits. How does he intend to proceed? Certainly not by substantially reducing the military budget or that for the [West Bank] settlements, which comprise more than 50 per cent of the national budget.

Ygal Cohen-Orgad is not only a faithful mouthpiece of the Israeli bourgeoisie, he is also one of the deputies that voted against the Camp David Accords, considering them too defeatist. He is a declared supporter of the far-right settlers movement Gush Emunim. The new finance minister is on the point of finishish the construction of his new residence at Ariel, a new settlement right on the West Bank.

Since it is not in the area of guns and settlements, it will be in that of butter and jobs that Cohen-Orgad will announce draconian measures. It will be rather reduction of subsidies for basic necessities, a 5 to 10 per cent reduction in the social budgets, which will bring about a new deterioration in social services and huge cuts in jobs.

But the essential axis of the attack by the new finance minister on the workers will be the sliding scale, which he considers as the main cause of inflation, and of the uncompetitiveness of Israeli pro•ducts on the international market.

For the first time in 15 years, it seems that the Zionist government has no other choice than to declare austerity for the workers.

The international banks and the International Monetary Fund have made the Zionist rulers understand that any new loans, which the Israeli economy

6

needs, will depend on this. Today the indices - particularly that of the construction industry, which is traditionally at the forefront of any turn in the economic situation in the country - show that we are on the verge of a crisis. In fact this crisis had been deferred for six years, thanks to an increase in American support and at the price of a growing deficit in the national budget and the balance of payments. The time has come to refill the coffers, or at least to plug the holes through which the government has allowed astronomical sums that it did not really have to drain away. (The war in Lebanon has, up till now, cost at least 2.2 billion dollars.)

THE WORKERS AND PEOPLE'S REACTION

While the collapse of bank shares provoked panic amongst the vast majority of the population, who had been attracted by the high rate of profit on them, the government took the opportunity to raise the prices of basic necessities by 50 per cent and to devalue the shekel by 23 percent.

"This is only a beginning', the new minister told the employers, who were not slow to add 'Now or never is the moment to implement austerity policies, including if that means the end of full employment.' (Yediot Aharonot October 21, 1983)

For the workers, the era of the car and video seems to have definitely ended. The guarantee of buying power by the sliding scale, and the guarantee of employment are the subjects now being discussed in the factories and popular neighbourhoods. A turbulent meeting of delegates from the Workers Committees forced the Histadrut to organise a twohour protest strike which, for the first time for a long time, was observed by almost all the workers.

While pathetic in relation to what is at stake, the strike was, by virtue of the massive participation, a warning as much to the leaders of the Histadrut as to the government.

The workers' organisation and its Labour Party leaders are completely incapable of presenting an alternative economic policy to that of the government. In fact, the only way to at the same time maintain buying power and significantly reduce the budget and balance of payments deficits would be to substantially reduce military spending and the settlement budget.

No significant Zionist party is prepared to do that. This is the reason why one can talk of a consensus within the ruling class about the need for a sharp attack on the living standards of the workers. The Labour Party is content to demand 'an equitable sharing' of the effort.

We still cannot forecast the rhythm and form of the workers fightback. Will it be through committees of workers elected in the factories, co-ordinated at the level of sector and region, as the 10 appeal that the Revolutionary Communist League distributed in the workers centres proposes? Or will it rather be through Action Committees as happened at the beginning of the 1960s?

Will we once again see the popular neighbourhoods flare up, this time linking social and economic demands to the affirmation of the Eastern identity of their inhabitants? It is fruitless to speculate on these questions.

One thing is certain. The workers and people's demands will be, from the outset, political. The first demonstrations organised by the organisations from the popular neighbourhoods have all taken up the slogan, Money for the popular neighbourhoods, not for the settle-

Soldiers' anti-war This article was originally published in issue No 30, dated October-November 1983, of Sharara (The Star - Arab language journal of the Revolutionary Communist League, section of the Fourth International in the Israeli state). Leila KHATIB

← Grenada: How the Grenadians Tried to Build Democracy · Israel: Soldiers' Anti-war Festival at A'hziv →

Something wrong on this page?