International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

United States: Growth of the Unemployed Movement

· International Viewpoint No. 40, 14 November 1983 · pp 19-23 · 4,813 words

United States Trade unions World economy

The growth of the unemployed movement

Dianne FEELEY

PITTSBURGH, U.S.A. - "If you think the system is working, ask someone who isn't. " That is what is on the banner of the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee, the major organization of the unemployed in the greater Pittsburgh area.

This message summarizes the shocking experience of many U.S. citizens who grew up in the post-World War II period, expecting that if they worked hard, they could dramatically improve their lives. As the economic crisis proceeds, they have become painfully aware that even when the economy "picks up," millions of workers will not be recalled.

Gains that women and minorities were able to make over the last decade, especially through affirmative action programs [preference in hiring for historically disadvantaged groups], have been wiped out. Older workers, who thought their seniority protected them, find their plants shutting down. They are too young to retire and too old to compete on the job market. And for the first time in decades, more and more young people are unable to find work.

This economic crisis is the worst since the depression of the 1930s. At that time, unemployed committees sprang up throughout the country, demanding relief and a public jobs program. What little protection laid-off workers have today is a result of that political movement. At that time, the unemployed groups -often led by activists belonging to the Socialist Party, the Communist Party, as well as Trotskyists who played an important role - were the catalyst that revitalized the trade-union movement. They provided it with a social program that built industrial unionism in the U.S. Afterward, especially in the late 1940s and 1950s, an anti-left hysteria led to the "deradicalization" of the labor movement.

Today, on the eve of the fiftieth anniversary of the Toledo Auto-Lite strike, the San Francisco longshore strike, and the Minneapolis teamster strike (1), the trade-union movement is facing a crucial test.

Employers are using the pressure of more and more drastic layoffs to demand far-reaching concessions from the unions, and in some cases are even seeking to destroy them. Moreover, the government is participating in the union-busting attempts. The Reagan administration's vindictive decertification of the airInternational Viewpoint 14 November 1983

WE

DEMAND

JOBS

PHILADELPHIA

UNEMPLOYMENT

PROJECT 10 CHOOL NOT BOMB

Jobs protest in US (DR) traffic controllers union (PATCO) and its blacklisting of all those strikers to this very day symbolizes the aggressively anti-union orientation of the highest government officials. Under attack from powerful corporations and government agencies, the unions today - representing only 20% of the entire U.S. workforce, and for the most part guided by a limited social vision - find themselves in an increasingly vulnerable position.

While the impact of unemployment has created a severe challenge for the U.S. labor movement, it may also be creating new forces which could, one again, contribute to a revitalization.

U.S. unemployment - particularly in such key industries as steel, auto, mining, and transportation - remains quite high. More than 22% of all workers were out of work during part of 1982, with the proportion rising for Hispanic Americans (27.1%) and Blacks (33.4%). Among male teenagers the unemployment rate now stands at 21.1% among whites, but among Blacks it has soared to 56.8%. (2).

Although women as a group do not suffer a disproportionately high rate of unemployment, the reason is that they are a "cheaper" workforce, earning, on the average, 59 cents for every dollar a man earns. Nonetheless, women in certain job categories have suffered proportionately greater losses. Between April and June 1982, women, who make up only 29% of the federal workforce, received 46% of all the job cuts. Additionally, the rate of unemployment for Black women is twice as high as the rate for white women. (3)

Nearly one-fifth of the total workforce now works part-time. By 1982 involuntary part-time work had increased 166% over the last dozen years. Nearly one-third of all women working are employed at part-time jobs. Sar A. Levitan, professor of economics and director of the Center for Social Policy Studies at George Washington Universitv. has stated that. washington University, has stated that many part-time workers are "in almost the same circumstances as the unemployed worker" because income hovers around the minimum wage. Part-time workers frequently have no health care coverage or lost-time benefits, and few part-time workers belong to unions. Of course, workers who belong to unions make higher wages and have a better benefit package. (4)

By August 1983 the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that, out of a total workforce of 120 million, 10.7 million U.S. workers were without jobs, with an additional 7.5 million either accepting part-time employment or giving up looking for work. The average duration of unemployment has jumped from 13 weeks in January 1982 to 20 weeks by August 1983. (5)

Yet of the 10.7 million workers officially counted as unemployed, only 45% receive unemployment compensation. This contrasts sharply with the 1975-76 recession, in which 78% of the unemployed received unemployed insurance. In a study, "Why Is Insured Unemployment So Low?" Gary Burtless, a senior fellow at the prestigious Brookings Institution, wrote: "A principal reason why the number of jobless collecting unemployment insurance was low during the 1981-82 recession is that the President and Congress decided it should be low." (6) 1. The Minneapolis strike was led by trade-unionists associated with the Communist League of America, the Fourth Internationalist organization in the U.S. at the time; the Auto-Lite strike was led by trade-unionists associated with the Workers Party, which later fused with the Communist League of America. Along with the San Francisco longshore strike, these strikes opened the way for modern mass unionization in the United States. All three strikes occurred in the first half of 1934, coinciding with the first upturn after the 1929 crash. - IV. 2. "26.5 Million Lacked Jobs in '82," New York Times, August 10, 1983; "Black teenagers face highest unemployment," Militant, September 16, 1983. 3. Inequality of Sacrifice: The Impact of the Reagan Budget on Women, pamphlet issued by Coalition on Women and the Budget on March 16, 1983.

"Up to a Fifth of U.S. Workers Now Rely on Part-Time Jobs," by William Serrin, New York Times, August 14, 1983.

Statement of Bert Seidman, Director, Department of Occupational Safety, Health and Social Security, American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations before the Subcommittee on Public Assistance and Unemployment Compensation of the House Committee on Ways and Means, September 13, 1983, p. 1. 6. "Study Finds Low Level for 1982 Jobless Claims," by Peter T. Kilborn, New York Times, September 9, 1983.

19

The study also pointed out that the federal, state, and local governments paid out 24 billion dollars in benefits during 1982 to the more than ten million officially unemployed, while in 1976, when 7.6 million were out of work, they paid out 31 billion (in 1982 dollars).

In the U.S. health-care benefits are discontinued when workers are laid off. Unemployment insurance is approximately half of one's wage. Standard coverage is 26 weeks. This can be extended by 13 weeks. There is also the possibility of "supplementary" benefits for an additional period. But while in past recessions the government has voted to extend benefits to a maximum of 65 weeks, the longest benefit period currently available is 53 weeks. Nationally, only 51,000 of the jobless are able to secure the maximum. (7)

The system used for determining when extended benefits go into effect and when they are cut off is so tricky that at present there are only two states and the commonwealth of Puerto Rico that qualify for this federal program.

Twenty-two other states, with unemployment rates ranging between 9% and 14% (as of June 1983) have gone off extended benefits, or "triggered off," according to the officialese used in this case.

Once a state "triggers off," these extended benefits are suspended for at least 13 weeks. For example, Michigan's total unemployment rate stood at 13.4% in August, yet the benefit program "triggered off" in June, throwing 56,000 unemployed out of the program. (8)

The federal, state, and local governments have refused to provide either a meaningful jobs program to put the unemployed back to work or the kind of massive relief programs necessary to help those who are out of work. Many unemployed committees have pointed out that if there had been a natural disaster - such as a hurricane or a flood - special aid to help the victims would have been made available. But in the conditions of this "unnatural" disaster, the government has used the crisis to cut back on already inadequate social service programs.

A CLUB FOR UNION BASHING

Employers are utilizing the economic crisis as a weapon to mount attacks on the unions. They do this through outright attempts to destroy the unions, as well as through attempts to extract concessions. They threaten plant closure unless concessions are made. Throughout the Northeast, plant closures - as whole industries have relocated to the nonunionized South or to other countries -have brought significant job loss. Since some areas have been dependent on one principal industry, certain regions have been devastated. However, as unionized workers see that concessions do not ensure job security, and as they see employer's profits on the rise, fewer workers are willing to vote to cut their pay and benefits. 20

The union movement has been significantly weakened through this combination of layoffs, union-busting, and concession-bargaining. Since 1977, the steel industry alone has eliminated 130,000 jobs. These were union jobs where workers earn 12 to 15 dollars an hour. On the other hand, the "high-tech" computer operator often makes little more than 3.35 dollars an hour in a nonunion job. As the U.S. workforce shifts more into the services, the proportion of unionized workers continues to drop. This will continue unless the trade unions become capable of effectively organizing service industry workers and the white-collar workers who are also largely unorganized. (9)

Although the Reagan administration claims that the U.S. economy is on the upswing, the recovery is irrelevant to many workers. This recovery rhetoric is disputed in an important study by the Committee on the Evolution of Work, a body set up by the American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL-CIO). As the study points out, as many as 6 million U.S. workers may become a permanent "labor-surplus underclass. Shaiken, a Massachusetts Institute of Technology specialist on labor and technology, has explained that "we are looking at the possibility of economic recovery and redundant workers at the same time." In other words, "economic revitalization no longer means re-employment." (10)

While millions of workers are unemployed, corporations such as U.S. Steel require those still employed to work overtime. It is much less expensive to pay overtime rates than to recall laid-off workers. According to the United Steelworkers of America (USWA) Local 1397 in Homestead, Pennsylvania, as many as 46 workers could have been recalled to the mill the week of September 3 to cover the 1,480 overtime hours worked. This is a common experience in factories throughout the country. The union has filed grievances against the U.S. Steel Corporation, but the time lag in the grievance procedure works to the benefit of the employer. The union local distributed a flyer to those still at work: "We are asking you, please, don't work overtime. If they force you to, or try to make you hook up or do somebody else's job, come up to the union hall and file a grievance." (11)

FIGHT BACK

Although U.S. unions have differing requirements for maintaining membership after a layoff - varying from the current two-year period of grace in steel to 30 days in rail - hundreds of local unions responded to the recession in the 1980-82 period by forming unemployed committees. Since layoffs occured in certain key industries where the workforce was unionized, the unemployed first turned to their unions for aid. Committees would be set up inside the union, utilizi can resources. Often ing union contacts and resources. Uiten these committees would work with other union-based unemployed committees in the area on specific projects. That is, as these committees began springing up, they naturally generated other, similar groups and subsequently banded together in informal networks.

In other cases, independent committees of both union and nonunion workers have developed. Even where the unemployed committees are formally independent of the unions, usually they are led by union activists. Frequently these independent, grass-roots committees have a cooperative relationship with a number of the local unions. In many cases, they receive material aid from the unions for specific projects. committees are based within the union structure, or are independent from it, they have similar goals and similar methods.

One concrete task most of these committees immediately took up was the establishment of food banks, to serve the unemployed. Because they can buy in quantity and they actively seek donations, the food banks provide an important resource for the unemployed. Leon Lynch, International Vice President of the USWA, stated that by the summer of 1983 approximately 225 steelworker union locals in Western Pennsylvania alone had food banks. (12)

Some unions initiated a weekly checkoff system through which workers still employed pledge a sum to those laid off. In some of the larger plants, this amounts to 5,000-7,000 dollars weekly. In other areas, the union organizes plant-gate collections. These funds are used for a variety of needs, including fuel, mortgage and rent assistance and emergency medical care. (13)

Unemployed committees that are a part of the union structure have also set up "hotlines, " whereby union members facing emergency situations can call for help on legal problems, referral services, and even temporary employment. In the Pittsburgh area, the various steelworkers unemployed committees worked together from their formation. They 7. Statement of Bert Seidman, pp. 3-4. 8. Statement of Dick Warden, Legislative Director, International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America (UAW) before the House Ways and Means Subcommittee on Public Assistance and Unemployment Compensation Hearing on Federal Supplemental Compensation Program and Related Issues, September 13, 1983, p. 9.

"It's like an industrial holocaust," interview with Mike Stout, USWA Local 1397, Multinational Monitor, Volume 4. Number 6, June 1983, pp. 15-17; " 'High Tech' Is No Jobs Panacea, Experts Say." by William Serrin, New York Times, September 18, 1983. 10. "Recovery Irrelevant to Workers Left Behind," by William Serrin, New York Times, September 6, 1983. 11. "Steelworkers protest overtime at Homestead," Pittsburgh Press, September 23, 1983. 12. Speech by Leon Lynch at Pittsburgh Rally for "Jobs, Peace and Freedom," for August 27th Coalition of Conscience, at Macedonia Church, Pittsburgh, August 8, 1983. 13. Interview with Kwazi Nkrumah and Keith Brooks, National Unemployed News, Vol. 1, No. 1, July 1983, p. 4. Also see interview with Helen Antonishen and Gloria Snyder.

International Viewpoint 14 November 1983

launched a campaign demanding federal extension of unemployed benefits, and jointly collected 10,000 signatures.

One of the first grass-roots unemployed committees to form was the United Committee of Unemployed People (UCUP) in Baltimore, Maryland. Open to both union and nonunion unemployed workers, UCUP has a close relationship to union-based groups. Its leaders are also active in the unions, especially among Baltimore steelworkers and machinists. Along with the AFL-CIO, UCUP rand an offst come to fe organized an effective campaign to force the governor to call a special session of the Mayland legislature, which then passed a bill setting up the state's own 13 week extension of unemployed benefits after it had "triggered off" the federal program.

The Baltimore group also fought for, and won the elimination of a technicality in the extension program that had prevented 10,000 unemployed from receiving the full 13 weeks' benefits. As a result an additional 7 million dollars was allocated to the program. The group also initiated a campaign to pass a state bill which they called the Unemployed Citizens' Bill of Rights. Although the bill was ultimately defeated, the campaign for passage helped to educate people about the specific problems and needs of the unemployed. The bill of rights outlined basic protection to the unemployed against housing foreclosures and evictions, repossession of automobiles and trailer homes, shut-offs of utilities. It also provided for medical and legal assistance and job retraining. The United Committee of Unemployed People was able to build up enough of a campaign to get the bill through the morass of state legislative committees and onto the Maryland Senate floor. It took three days for conservative legislators to narrowly defeat the bill of rights. (14) THE EXAMPLE OF THE MON VALLEY

UNEMPLOYED COMMITTEE

Perhaps the best known of all the grassroots groups is the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee (MVUC), based in western Pennsylvania's Monongahela Valley, where many Pittsburgh area steel mills are located. More than 1,500 people are dues-paying members. While the backbone of the committee is made up of laid-off steelworkers, it is open to all workers, both union and nonunion, and incorporates both unemployed members and workers still on the job. The committee evolved from local union unemployed formations which had worked together over a period of time. Formally it is an independent committee, but it still retains close ties with the trade-union movement.

The Mon Valley Unemployed Committee organized the militant April 1983 demonstration of more than 5,000 to denounce President Reagan and his policies when the president visited Pittsburgh. Reagan's advisers have since concluded that the event was a political disaster for that the event was a poltical alsaster for International Viewpoint 14 November 1983

MORTGAGE AID CALLS

RECEIVED BY MUC

LENGTH OF TIME IN ARREARS

NO. OF CALLS RECEIVED

Not behind yet

118

1-3 months behind

127

4-6 months behind

147

7-12 months behind

80

More than 12 months behind

31

(When one is three or more months in arrears, foreclosure is probable.)

the president, coming as it did at the opening of the campaign for his reelection. The committee launched a coalition consisting of more than 45 organizations to build the rally, receiving significant support from trade unions, women's rights and civil rights organizations, and antiwar groups. Local steelworkers unions provided buses to bring in protesters from outlying areas. (15)

The MVUC has also organized several jobs marches and rallies throughout downtown Pittsburgh and nearby McKeesport. These demonstrations have been very spirited, with a friendly and sympathetic response from most shoppers and workers on their lunch breaks.

THE FIGHT AGAINST FORECLOSURES

Although it has also testified before state and federal legislative bodies regarding unemployment insurance, and has organized speak-outs around issues of concern to the unemployed, the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee is best known for its work on mortgage foreclosure. Members of the MVUC mortgage committee have met with bank presidents in order to work out delayed or partial payments from unemployed workers. They have picketed banks, secured injunctions, and negotiated with the Veterans Administration - which insures homes for veterans - in order to obtain relief programs for unemployed homeowners.

In November 1982 the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee filled the courtroom for the sheriff's monthly foreclosure sale. The auction took place while cardboard vultures swooped down over the heads of the foreclosure attorneys who bid at these sales. The committee refers to these lawyers as the "vultures." The chanted: "No jobs, no sales." They bid pennies for the homes as a form of protest - a method used by the unemployed movement of the 1930s.

As a result of the publicity generated by the aggressive campaign, the Pittsburgh City Council unanimously passed a recommendation last December that lenders call an indefinite moratorium on foreclosures for the homes of the unemployed. When the MVUC attended the January sheriff's sale, they found that the sheriff - who was up for re-election — had pulled the homes of 42 jobless workers from the auction block. (16) Pittsburgh Judge Papadakos has backed the sheriff's decision with a temporary moratorium on the sale of owner-occupied homes. As of the September 1983 sale, the moratorium was still in effect. Between January and July 1983 the MVUC mortgage hotline received 503 calls. The above table indicates the character of these appeals. (17)

During the month of July 1983 - as steelworkers were coming to an end in their supplementary benefits - the various Pittsburgh area agencies that counsel homeowners on mortgage problems received 2,114 calls.

The Mon Valley Unemployed Committee and a similar group in eastern Pennsylvania, the Philadelphia Unemployment Project, have submitted a bill to the state legislature for up to three years relief when a delinquency in mortgage payment is caused by unemployment or illness. It has passed the state House of Representatives, and is still to be considered by the state Senate.

NATION-WIDE ORGANIZATION

The Mon Valley Unemployed Committee helped to establish the first national conference of unemployed groups on June 10-12. Held in Erie, Pennsylvania, the conference gathered 250 activists from 9 union-based unemployed committees, 29 independent unemployed groups, and 36 labor and community organizations in 16 states, to form the National Unemployed Network (NUN). Its program for action consists of four points:

"1. Secure a decent living standard for all:

- Jobs or Unemployment Compensation until jobs are found

- Save our homes

- Health care for all

- Food: full use of surplus food, increase in food programs

- Moratorium on utility shut-offs

"2. Build a unified force of all workers, employed and unemployed, around 14. "Unemployed Committee Wins Benefits Extension for Jobless Maryland Workers," Keith Brooks and Kwazi Nkrumah, Labor Notes, No. 45, October 26, 1982, pp. 1, 14. 15. Thousands of Unemployed Protest Reagan's Visit to Pittsburgh," Labor Notes, No. 51, March 27, 1983, p. 11.

"Sheriff Calls Temporary Halt to Foreclosures on Pittsburgh Homes," by Linny Stovall, Labor Notes, No. 48, January 17, 1983, p. 3. 17. Report by Marion Curcio, MVUC Mortgage Counselor, September 1983.

21

our common interests, such as plant closure, unemployment compensation, job retraining and other vital concerns.

"3. Change the government's budget priorities - Money for jobs, not war; fund social services that help people, not kill them.

"4. Fight the disproportionate effect of unemployment on women, minorities and handicapped workers. Discrimination serves to divide workers. We must support and strengthen affirmative action programs." (18)

Since the conference, unemployed groups are continuing to spring to life. The existence of a national network has helped to stimulate local committees. And the first issue of the National Unemployed News, put out by the NUN, features short histories of how local committees got started and what issues they organized around. It provides a series of sketches about the unemployed committees' day-to-day work.

A second national unemployed organization was formed in Chicago on July 2-3, with 467 representatives from 22 states. The National Congress of Unemployed Organizations (NCUO) was organized by groups and individuals associated with Trade Union Action and Democracy - a group seeking to foster "center-left unity in the labor movement." This would include independent militants, liberal union officials, Communist Party activists, and others. The NCUO has attracted a number of local working leaders - for example, Frank Lumpkin, of the Wisconsin Steel Save Our Jobs Committee. A black steelworker who has proved to be an effective mass leader, Lumpkin was a keynote speaker at the NCUO conference. In his speech, he emphasized the similar purposes of the two national groups by saying, "We welcome the efforts of those who met in Erie, Pa. We want to work with them."

The opinion of some influential NUN activists was expressed in an article in the monthly newsletter, Labor Notes: "The two unemployed organizations have similar goals and overlapping strategies.... If the groups differ, it seems to be in terms of their attitude toward the labor movement's leadership and the Democratic Party....The NUN has...acted independently of labor officials when necessary and has kept its distance from politicians." (19)

Both the NUN and the NCUO have demanded passage of the AFL-CIO's jobs bill, and both were involved in building and participating in the massive August 27 March on Washington for "Jobs, Peace and Justice." The NUN seems to have much more of a grass-roots and activist character at this point. Yet for both groups, the real work has barely begun - that is, expanding local unemployed committees, while at the same time providing effective national coordination in fighting for the right of all workers to have jobs at decent wages.

The breadth of organizing that is occurring on the local level is indicated by the proliferation of newspapers and news22

FIRE! letters produced by various unemployed committees throughout the country. In these publications, some activists have begun to initiate discussions on future directions for the embryonic movement.

In the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee's July newsletter, there is an article outlining the relationship between the Reagan administration's military spending and the lack of jobs. Currently, 60% of the federal budget is allocated to military spending. By challenging that priority, the unemployed are forcing a discussion within the working class over foreign policy questions that have not been so fundamentally challenged since the 1930s. The Vietnam War - however unpopular it became - was nonetheless carried out during a time of relative prosperity. The interrelationship between U.S. foreign policy and its domestic policy is becoming increasingly clear to U.S. workers and the unemployed.

DISCUSSION DEEPENS ON

HOW TO GET FULL EMPLOYMENT

Another article in the Mon Valley Unemployed Committee's newsletter, entitled "We Want to Work, " is a thoughtful discussion-piece raising questions about what kind of job program is needed. The author, Jim Benn, from USWA Local 1256, asks: "Should we underscore the influence of prejudice in hiring and the role of affirmative action? Should we include a demand for the reindustrialization of basic industry? What will our plan be for seriously trying to implement any proposal we decide upon?" (20)

This is an extremely important issue as employers and even some labor officials proto, present the enemy as "foreign im

For many unemployed workers, the question of how to provide jobs for all is still an uncharted field. Some might suggest bailouts to industries like steel and auto, where the corporations consider the profits are too low to keep production going. Uthers may suggest higher tion going. Others may suggest higher tariff laws or "local content" laws. Some have fought for legislation limiting the employer's "right" to close a plant without advance notification, while others have initiated proposals for buying out the employer and operating the plant themselves. The community-based TriState Conference on Steel and the Denominational Mission Strategy (a churchbased group) have initiated a campaign to withdraw funds from Mellon Bank, which has 5.5 billion in loans and deposits overseas. Their campaign leaflet states that "Mellon Bank is committing TREASON against the Mon Valley and America."

Still other activists propose a massive public works program, similar to the WPA of the 1930s, although on a larger scale. They point out that roads and bridges and schools are falling into disrepair, and they discusss the need for better health services and child care programs. Others propose shortening the work week from 40 hours to 30 or 35 hours. At the end of World War II a few unions raised this demand and passed resolutions for a shorter work week. THE NEED FOR A WORKERS PARTY

The discussion over how to achieve full employment is still in its beginning stage. The immediate needs of the unemployed - who are faced with limited and shrinking unemployment. benefits, mortgage foreclosures, utility shutoffs, inadequate medical care - are related to the government's inability to put human needs before business profits. One serious problem facing the unemployed movement is that the United States still does not have a labor party. Both the Democratic and Republican parties are controlled by the corporate interests, although the traditional voting base of the Democratic Party has been key sectors of the working class concentrated in the labor movement, along with oppressed minorities. With a reactionary Republican in office, there will be powerful pressures on the unemployed movement to seek a solution through a "dump Reagan" campaign orchestrated by the Democratic Party.

It remains to be seen whether the unemployed movement will prove capable of maintaining its independence, of keeping its attention focused on the issues as the unemployed — not the politicians -define them. If it is able to remain, this movement could do a great deal to change the political landscape in the United States, to the benefit of the working class as a whole. 18. "Program For Action," National Unemployed News, Vol. 1, No.1, July 1983. Forms at Chicago Meeting," by Dan La Botz, 19. "Second National Unemploved Group Labor Notes, No. 54, July 27, 1983, p. 15. 20. "We Want To Work," by Jim Benn, Mon Valley Unemployed Committee Newsletter, July 1983, p. 3.

International Viewpoint 14 November 1983

FRANCE

← Nicaragua: Human Dignity and Productive Work for All · France: 'France is a major imperialist power' →

Something wrong on this page?