International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

China: Dissent inside the Communist Party

· International Viewpoint No. 282, November 1996 · pp 33-34 · 636 words

China Communist parties

China: dissent inside the

Communist Party

Zhang Kai

The Chinese Communist Party theoretical review Qiu Shi, No.13, includes an article by

General SecretaryJiang Zemin, 'On

Politics'. Jiang criticises "some cadres" for:

not reading any books or journals; not studying party documents; not considering issues or problems from political perspectives; lacking political discretion and sensitivity; not implementing party policies they do not like; and ignoring party instructions.

Jiang writes that "regionalism and protectionism in some areas and some departments have become very serious." He acknowledges that, for partial or individual interests, criminal acts have been protected.

Considering that this criticism supposedly refers only to "some" party cadres, the list is rather long.

Xing Fensi, Vice President of the Party Cadre School and the Deputy Head of the Party

Central Ideological Leadership

Team, is more direct than

Jiang. On June 6 he wrote a long article in the People's

Daily entitled "Unwavering in persisting on

Marxism — drawing a clear distinction between Marxism and anti-Marxism", The article admits that "there are indeed differences on some significant theoretical

; and that "there have and practical problems".

already been rather significant interferences with the overall situation."

• He refutes two "erroneous" views, one being that there is no more hope for state enterprises and the only way out is privatization; the other being that the shareholding form for state enterprises is also a form of private ownership. Xing argues that shareholding is not privatization.

• Xing criticises the view that the serious polarization in distribution has caused the emergence of a new bourgeois class.

Nevertheless, three researchers from the

People's University have established that the Gini coefficient in China in 1994 is higher than that of the USA in 1990, indicating serious discrepancies between the rich and the poor in China. (New

China Digest, February 1996). According to the State Statistics Bureau, in 1994 the registered capital of privately run and individual enterprises amounted to 441.8 million Yuan ($1 = 8 Yuan). This is nine times higher than in 1990.

• He argues that it is not valid to negate the Reform by Socialism, or adversely, to negate socialism by the reform, open-door policy and market economy."

• Xing tries to argue that China's

"socialist market economy" is different from the capitalist market economy, because "public ownership is the pillar"

and because of "state macro-economic control.

Xing's defence of Deng Xiaoping's theory of building socialism with Chinese characteristics is rather feeble. In reality, China has become a key site for imperialist investments. The People's Daily of July 14, made a front page appeal for people not to boycott foreign capital by resorting to uncritical defense of the national industries.

Other media have been more independent-minded. China's State and Strength, No.6, argues otherwise, saying that uncontrolled foreign capital will break the domestic economic 'ecology', causing considerable social turmoil. Qiu Xiaohua of the State Statistical Bureau claims that this investment means

• 50-60% of domestic industrial consumer goods will be replaced by foreign capita and one-third of the industrial goods market being taken up by foreign cap

• unequal competition increases the difficulties of state-owned enterprises,

• regional competition for foreign capital has caused the drain of state property: • structural imbalance in investments, = funds concentrating on high-priced property, entertainment facilities and processing industries.

Intra-party struggle is heating up. At least two anonymous papers are circulating. One is entitled *Factors affecting our state security", and the other is against peaceful transformation. These papers warn that a new bureaucrat bourgeoisie and comprador bourgeoisie is emerging, and critique the flooding of bourgeois liberalization since 1992. However, both call for strict party ideological control. It is seen that the papers represent the manifesto of the Stalinist faction within the party. * Reprinted from Ocruber Ranies 10144. Hong King e-mail

BE 280H 961

* Senegal

← South Korea: Student Protest at Yonsei University · Senegal: A Fixed Election Is Worth Fighting →

Something wrong on this page?