International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

USA: Snatching Defeat from the Jaws of Victory

· International Viewpoint No. 276, April 1996 · pp 28-30 · 2,045 words

This article was cut at the top of the page the printed contents gives it, because its headline could not be found in the machine-read text. Its opening may carry the end of the article before it.

United States Trade unions

(natching T snaring -The recent defeat of workers locked out by the Staley corn sweetner company of Decatur, Illinois follows a three year battle, combining local militancy with inventive solidarity networking and public outreach. Union leadership bears a heavy responsibility for this defeat, which has discouraged labor militants accross the country. by C.J. Hawking THREE DAYS BEFORE CHRISTMAS, THE US labor movement suffered a terrible blow. The lockedout Staley workers of Decatur, Illinois brought their more than three-year battle against the multinational conglomerate, slaley/lale and Staley/Tate and Lyle, to a close; 56% of strikers voted to accept the company's latest contract. This contract virtually eliminates safety, seniority, and the grievance procedure and demands the harsh conditions of twelve-hour rotating shifts every thirty days. The same offer had been rejected by 96% of the membership in October 1992. Members also voted down by 56%, in July 1995, a similar offer, which demanded twelve-hour rotating shifts every six days. SO WHAT WENT WRONG? In early November 1995, John Sweeney, the newly-elected president of the AFLCIO, promised forty staff members for the Staley campaign, including twelve full timers for the nationwide campaign to pressure Pepsi, which accounts for 30% of Staley's corn sweetener sales. Tens of thousands of callers from across the country complained to Pepsi about their ties to Staley. Sweeney vowed to make the Pepsi campaign the "number one

THANKS TO GLOBALIZATION, MY OFFICE

IS IN NEW YORK, MY FACTORIES ARE IN MEXICO,

HOTURANTY CY MONROM JA, SWITZERLAND,

AND 1 LIVE IN PARIS.

AND WHERE DO YOUR

WORKERS LIVE?

THANKS TO GLOBALIZATION, MY OFFICE

IS IN NEW YORK, MY FACTORIES ARE IN MEXICO,

HOTURANTY CY MONROM JA, SWITZERLAND,

AND 1 LIVE IN PARIS.

AND WHERE DO YOUR

WORKERS LIVE?

at from the Jaws of Victory?

priority" of his new office. But the United Paperworkers International Union insisted that they were in control of the campaign. Sweeney, reluctant to challenge a union president so soon after his close election, bowed to UPIU President Wayne Glenn and apparently ordered his staff to back off. A reliable source inside Pepsi-Co sent word to the Decatur workers that Pepsi would find another supplier if Staley did not end the dispute by January 1, 1996, the expiration date of their Pepsi contract Despite this strong situation, the UPIU imposed a third vote on the striking workers. An assistant to UPIU president Wayne Glenn told a Decatur radio station he would "hate to even think" about the contract being rejected. The International blatantly undermined the local union leadership, while stating its position was "neutral" on the contract vote. The UPIU International was quick to cite the $2 million in picket pay provided to the local as a sign of its loyalty. It has also been quick to take credit for the campaign which convinced Miller beer to stop buying Staley product in November 1994. In fact, this victory was the result of tireless efforts by the Decatur local spreading its message against Miller across the country, rather than any efforts from the International Likewise, efforts of the UPIU International on the Pepsi campaign were mediocre at best, relying heavily on the solidarity committees already established by the local. Twice it thwarted efforts for effective demonstrations at the Pepsi headquarters in Purchase, New York. Consistently, it cautioned workers and supporters in actions against Pepsi, in fear it would be sued for promoting secondary boycotts. LOCAL HARDSHIP In addition to the International's sell-out and blatant undermining of the local's campaign, sustained internal organizing within the local became problematic. The local became splintered as demands for national organizing grew. The local's activists were invigorated by the support of unionists across the country and the success of the Miller campaign, but attention to the less militant members waned. The split in the union became more pronounced when in early December, 1995 Jim Shinall became the Local president-elect. While militant "Road Warriors" were out of town, Shinall and his supporters were going to the picket lines and organizing disgruntled workers into surrendering. Preaching surrender, hetty severance packages, enhanced pensions, and flagrant lies about Road Warriors stealing money, Shinall found a tired and demoralized audience. THE BETRAYAL The day after Shinall's election, the company announced its new contract offer. The company sweetened the severance, offering workers with over twenty years in the plant a $30,000 severance. The company, however, was deceptive about the pension plan, which Shinall also endorsed. THE LONG WAY BACK Of the 760 locked-out workers, only 181 will return to the plant. Most of those returning are in their late 40's and early 50's - too young to retire, too "old" to be hired elsewhere and accumulate a decent pension. After undergoing drug and alcohol testing and a week of "orientation" during which supervisors have already predicted there will be firings, workers will be "trained" by scabs for four months. The contract's unlimited subcontracting, twelve-hour rotating shifts, loss of seniority, grievance and safety conditions have, in effect, snuffed out fifty years of collective bargaining. SPARKING A NATIONAL SHIFT Although the surrender by the 56% majority of Staley workers is a major and tragic defeat, their fight will have a lasting impact with significant lessons for the future. Not only did they educate and inspire unionists across the globe, their battle changed the leadership within the AFL-CIO. In February, 1995 seventy union members from Decatur went to Bal Harbor, Florida to confront the AFL-CIO leadership at their annual meeting. The "New York Times" carried this front-page story as the red-t-shirted unionists questioned AFL-CIO officials in the hallways on their way to meetings. The question was posed with urgency: "What are you doing about the union people in Decatur?" For the first time in history an AFL-CIO President, Lane Kirkland, stepped down from his position shortly thereafter. Several Washington insiders have revealed that Kirkland could not

USA * withstand the pressure brought to bear by the Staley workers and their nationwide network of supporters. In the subsequent October election, Kirkland's appointed successor Tom Donahue was defeated by John Sooney who ran on a vow that "l'd Sweeney, who ran on a vow that "d rather block bridges than build bridges," referring to the futility of labormanagement cooperation and the need for "a new voice" from labor. The newly elected Sweeney invited locked-out Staley worker Dan Lane, who was fifty-seven days into his hunger strike, to address the convention delegates, marking a rare moment indeed that a rank-and-file member addressed the AFL-CIO assembly. BUILDING NATIONAL SOLIDARITY Close to 100 people attended the founding meeting of the Chicago Staley Workers Solidarity Committee just three short weeks into the lockout. The local welcomed these supporters, union and non-union alike. Solidarity committees were formed shortly thereafter in other key cities. As the local designed its strategy, key leaders from Chicago and other cities were invited to participate and advise. Solidarity committees were then able to mobilize hundreds of people to Decatur rallies and to pressure Miller and Pepsi. Soon committees were holding their own local rallies in support of the Staley workers. The local welcomed unpaid, fulltime organizers from Detroit, St. Louis and Chicago into their Campaign For Justice Office, further strengthening the ties to the solidarity committees. In contrast, when the unions from Decatur's Caterpillar and Firestone plants went out on strike in June and July 1994, the UAW and United Rubber Workers (URW) Internationals became fierce gatekeepers of their fights, relying on traditional strategies which discouraged involvement from outside supporters and lacked creativity. Instead, the UAW opted to hire a public relations firm to design a campaign to draw support. This top-down approach was also used in their in-plant strategy, where the International would turn the work-to- rule campaign on and off like a faucet, leaving workers baffled and disempowered. Although the UAW and URW workers faced egregious union-busting working conditions similar to the Staley workers, the Internationals halted grassroots organizing that could have invigorated workers and supporters. Before the lockout, the Staley workers went door-to-door in Decatur explaining the principles of the local's stance. Most Decatur residents were sympathetic and,

International Viewpoint n° 276 29

* USA

THE NEED SEMES OFAMERON

838699764F

2

2

2sc 2

838699764F

Decatur's largest Black church to hear speeches from national civil rights and labor leaders.

Three weeks later, marking the first line in non-violent protest. Police sprayed the crowd with pepper gas, with the rank- and-file Staley workers in front suffering the worst of its effects.

when the lockout occurred, hundreds posted signs of support for the local on their support tor the local on their lawns. Community outreach

Big anniversary of the people crossed over gest General lockout, over 400 the Staley property

Motors Stril future jobs.

As in any union, problems of racism and sexism troubled the local and initially re in 25 Years sacrifice market share and profits to win major concessions from the

UAW. GM is determined to preserve its right to outsource whenever and wherever it needs to do so. The dispute was really about the average U.S. worker puts in an GM's fight to remain "com-petitive" additional 168 hours a year, or in a global economy versus the nearly an additional month's worth needs and aspir-ations of its work of work. This is particularly true in force. the auto industry, where the ninehour day and six-day work week are A GM-UAW agreement was ratified typical. In fact, the UAW estimates by a vote of the Dayton workers on that 59,000 jobs would be created if March 22. While the mainstream plants were limited to a 40-hr. week. media has been downplaying the The media portrays auto workers as significance of the agreement, it significance of the agreement, it highly paid, with no right to complain appears the Dayton workers got about their jobs because they are so what they asked for: GM reaffirmed well compensated. But the suc- its promise of 128 jobs, agreed to cessful 1994 Flint strike to force GM new technology at the Dayton to hire more workers (and thus plants and will pay the work force $5 reduce forced over-time million in compen-sation for past dramatized the fact that workers grievances. Within this framework, want to be able to do something the agreement does allow GM to else with their lives besides work. use outside suppliers. Therefore this That strike was led by militants from strike did not resolve the issue of New Directions, a small but outsour-cing. However no one articulate reform caucus inside the expected that it could UAW. GM agreed to hire 779 workers - the first new hires in the From the beginning of the strike the entire GM system in eight years. UAW International leadership consciously confined the issues to The International UAW authorized the Dayton strike in order to very limited demands. They never strengthen its hand in the weeks used the media's spotlight on before the bargain-ing opens for a Dayton as an opportunity to attack new three-year contract with the Big corporate America's insatiable need Three. (The current contract expires to cut back on decent jobs. At the on September 14.) Since his strike's conclusion Richard election last year, UAW president Shoemaker, UAW vice president in Stephen Yokich has vowed to take charge of GM workers, comon the out-sourcing issue. Yokich's mented, "This doesn't set the stage militant speeches, if backed up by for anything, it simply puts behind us UAW muscle, would be a big the issues in this dispute." turnaround tor the union, which has lost half its mem-bership over the GM intends to shed more of its parts last 15 years, primarily as a result of plants and accelerate its out-sourcing. outsourcing. Only a union comGM drew a line in the sand because mitted to organizing the unorit must cut costs, beat back ganized work force can turn that competitors and arrest a market- situation around. What this strike share drop. According to the Wall showed was that a section of the Street Journal, GM is more U.S. working class is prepared. * committed today to its cost-cutting efforts than it was two years ago, it had more cash to sustain a strike,

The author is a leading member of the U.S. and it showed it was willing to group Solidarity.

← USA: Debt? Look at the Profits! · USA: Biggest General Motors Strike in 25 Years →

Something wrong on this page?