International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

The SPD's "Social" Capitalism Bites the Dust

· International Viewpoint No. 26, 21 March 1983 · pp 3-4 · 1,800 words

Germany Italy United States

The SPD's "social" capitalism bites the dust in West Germany

Gerry FOLEY

Few times in history has the electoral defeat of a Social Democratic party threatened such serious consequences for working people as the defeat of the West German SPD in the March 6 general elections.

The victory of the Christian Democrats and their liberal allies strengthens the capitalist austerity drive against workers, not only in West Germany but throughout western Europe. It increases the threat of war, and hence the danger to the survival of many millions of people, if not humanity as a whole. It reinforces U.S. imperialism in its counteroffensive against the colonial revolution.

Immediately following the SPD debacle, Reagan made an aggressive speech March 8 aimed at both the Soviet Union and the Central American revolutionists. It obviously threatened an escalation of Washington's counteroffensive against liberation struggles, and of the military threats against the Soviet Union that go hand in hand with it.

The establishment of a hard right government in West Germany came at exactly the time Reagan needed a boost to get congress to accept the cost of increased American involvement on the side of the reactionary and murderous Central American regimes. This was, and remains, a crucial question for U.S. and world imperialism, since it has become clear in recent weeks that the Salvadoran army is faltering.

In its statement on the election results, the International Marxist Group (GIM), German section of the Fourth International, said:

"An iron triangle can now be forged between the Reagan, Thatcher and Kohl/ Strauss governments. The common program of all these regimes is austerity, mass unemployment, stepped-up armament, and military pressures on the Soviet Union. The fact that on the same day as the West German elections, in France, the bourgeois parties got a majority in the municipal elections reinforces this perspective."

In West Germany itself, there is considerable talk in the press and media about a return to the "Adenauer Era," that is to a right-wing political climate and the Cold War.

The Christian Democrats, in fact, won their second largest victory in history, getting just under an absolute majority. In addition, their liberal allies, the Free German Party (FDP) got about 7%.

With the onset of the capitalist crisis, the FDP lined up clearly with the right, and a considerable proportion of its voters went over directly to the Christian Democrats. It is now clearly a right wing party. Its score is explained to a large extent by second-preference votes from Christian Democrats anxious to assure that the party did not fall below the 5% threshold for representation in parliament parliament

The victory of the right, the GIM statement said, marked "a real turn in Bonn. A period of thirteen years of SPDled governments and 17 years of governments in which the Social Democrats were a force has now definitely come to an end. The bourgeois-bloc government that took office in October 1982 will how have a free hand for four years."

However, the bourgeois victory could not bring a return of the sort of capitalist stability that existed in the 1950s:

"The big majority for the bourgeois bloc in Bonn cannot be compared with the apparently similar electoral strength it had in the 1950s and 1960s. Then the bourgeois parties represented the boom. The growth of the economy was bringing everyone a higher living standard, shorter work hours, and longer vacations.

"The 1980s are a quite different period. They are bringing a decline in the standard of living, growing mass unemployment, work speedups, and social cuts. The wage earners have already felt the effects of this. They knew that the Christian Democrat and liberal politicians were for a tough pro-employer policy in the crisis and for cuts at the expense of the masses. This fact marks the turn and is the index of the defeat the working people have suffered."

The Christian Democrat victory marked the total bankruptcy of the "social" capitalism of the Social Democrats. After nearly a generation of SPD governments, unemployment has begun to rise drastically.

In the March 10 issue of Was Tun, the paper of the GIM, Winifried Wolf wrote:

"In West Germany, the country that (former SPD chancelllor) Schmidt used to like to call "The German Model,' unemployment has been growing at an even faster rate than it has on a world scale; it is mounting explosively. At the beginning of 1983, in comparison with 1970/ 71, the rate had grown by ten times. In comparison, with 1976-79, it had grown by three times."

At the time of the 1980 general elections, the poll conducted by the Mannheimer Forschungsgruppe Wahlen showed that 58% of the voters considered unemployment the main problem. In February 1983, this had gone up to 88%.

Some 64% of voters thought that guaranteeing the buying power of pensions was one of the most important issues; 57% included reducing the national debt among the main questions. Fiftythree percent listed price stability as one of their main concerns. The environment was a major issue for only 48% of voters.

A majority of the voters were opposed to the stationing of more nuclear missles on German soil "regardless of what the East does." At the same time, most voters indicated greater confidence in the SPD on the issues of peace and the environment.

Thus, what the election results show is that the immediate worry about making a living had a greater influence on the decisions of voters than more remote threats, no matter how terrible.

The GIM statement noted:

"Geissler, the chief ideologist of the Christian Democrats, claimed: 'We won with the support of the workers....In fact, the Christian Democrats scored their biggest gains in former SPD strongholds. In Nordrhein-Westfalen, where the SPD got an absolute majority, the CDU is now the strongest party. Two million former SPD voters are estimated to have crossed over to the Christian Democrats, whereas the SPD won just about nobody from them.

"On election night, (SPD representative ) Glotz said: "The Christian Democrats won with their talk about an economic upswing? That was one of the few true things the SPD said that evening. But it was only a half truth.

"In fact, the main issue in this election was the mass unemployment and not the missiles. The 19 million who voted for

3

the Christian Democrats, including the majority of wage earners, wanted to vote for an economic upturn.

"The Christian Democrats had said that an upturn was possible only under a Kohl government. This demagogy was backed up with threats of an investment strike and letters from bosses to their personnel calling on them to vote for the Christian Democrats, because if they did not win, there would be massive lay-offs.

"This campaign, however, could be successful only because the SPD offered no alternative. It also promised 'sacrifices' for the wage earners and a 'not so drastic' austerity.

"With this policy, the SPD undermined its positions precisely where it should have buttressed them. It lost specifically on the issue where it has traditionally had the advantage over the Christian Democrats."

"Shortly before the elections, the polis indicated that 57% had the most confidence in the Christian Democrats' ability to cut unemployment.

"If everyone was saying that an austerity policy was necessary, then it would be better to do it 'right,' in order to prepare the way for an upturn. If capitalism was the only possible system, then better vote for the party that has the confidence of the capitalists and not for those whom the bosses threaten with a continued investment strike."

The most positive result of the election was the fact that the environmentalist party, the Greens, based on the protest movements, topped the 5% barrier to get into parliament:

"On election night (Green leader) Petra Kelly said: "We will seek extraparliamentarv action. The only bright parliamentary action. The only bright spot in this vote is that for the first time in the history of West Germany, with the exception of the immediate postwar period, a group to the left of the SPD will be represented in parliament that clearly says that it will use its positions in parliament to promote mass mobilizations, especially against the stationing of the missiles."

The Green vote was much smaller than it could have been, however, because the leadership refused to try to build a broad left block or come out clearly in support of an SPD government against the right.

More fundamentally: The decisive weakeness of the Greens is exactly the same as the SPD, the question of unemployment. The Greens either said nothing about this or did not go beyond abstractions....

"The election result is a rude awakening, moreover, for a section of the left that concentrated entirely on the question of whether the Greens could get over 5%. This goal was achieved. But the decisive thing is that there was no majority for an SPD government."

The GIM denounced the statements by the SPD leaders that the voters had de. livered their verdict and it would have to be respected:

"The voters were not able to decide on the main questions in their daily lives and concerns. The turn in Bonn must not be respected...it must be fought. What is needed is not "constructive oppostion, as the (SPD leader) Vogel says but hard and consistant resistance to Kohl and the capitalists, in the factories, the offices, in the streets, in front of NATO bases.

"Sixty-five percent of the population is against the U.S. missiles. Over half of the population is for a neutral West Germany. The overwhelming majority of the population sees the fight against unemployment as the main issue.

"But this government will do nothing against unemployment. The stock market zoomed up alright on March 7. But to the extent that new investments are made, they will mainly rationalize jobs away.

"Within a year there will be 3 million unemployed. In six months, new U.S.. missiles will be brought in. The majority of the population does not want that. This government was elected only because there was no socialist alternative....

A new and because the Greens offered only a partial program."

The GIM statement concluded:

"March 6 was a defeat for the workers movement and the left....We cannot underestimate the effects of this on the social relationship of forces. The bourgeois bloc is determined to inflict severe defeats on the workers movement and the peace movement. The stationing of the missiles at the end of the year and the labor contract negotiations involving the demand for a 35 hour week may be the key battles. But it would be wrong to concentrate only on these "big' questions.

"Offensives by the right always look for weak points. So, the first targets may be the foreign workers and abortions rights.

← The Fate of the Imprisoned Palestinians · A New Warning for the SP-CP in France →

Something wrong on this page?