International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Israel: Formal Democracy and Illusion

· International Viewpoint No. 25, 7 March 1983 · p 4 · 961 words

Middle East

Formal democracy and the game of illusion in Israel fallen on his feet. He has managed both to avoid a governmental crisis and to throw the mass movement, which had grown dramatically since June 1982, into disarray. Because the peace movement staked everything on the expectation of the political consequences that they thought the commission of inquiry report should have.

There has been no defection from the government coalition. No change of the majority is foreseen because the Labour Paety is more than ever incapable of using the repercussions of Sabra and Chatila to win a majority, or even force

Michel WARSCHAWSKI - TEL AVIV. In the western press, a flood of eulogies on Israeli democracy greeted the Kahane commission of inquiry's report into the Sabra and Chatila massacres. Forgetting what was involved - the massacre of thousands of defenceless Palestinians - Francis Cornu of Le Monde and Serge July of Liberation (French daily papers) were in ecstasies over how special Israel was.

Israel was, believe it or not, ready to look into its own deeds. It had allowed an 'independent' commission to make a pronouncement about the - indirect -responsibility of the Israeli government for the massacres.

However, what is really special about Israel the whole world was able to see clearly a week later. But no-one in the media pointed it up. It was that althrough the commission drew its conclusions and made its recommendations, Sharon, Begin and Shamir are still at the head of the Jewish state. They are applying the letter of the recommendations but disregarding what lies behind them - the denunciation of the immorality of the leaders who are responsible for the criminal adventure in Lebanon.

This is "Israeli democracy' - abstract formulas that hide the reality of repression, racial discrimination - the covering up of all the crimes of the Zionist state by neutral formulas. An example is the laws that exclude Arab citizens of Israel from a whole series of social gains, not because they are Arab, let it be understood, but because they have not done their military service. The content is racist and discriminatory but the form is democratic.

Sharon therefore stays in the government and, so that there will be no misunderstanding, keeps his responsibilities within the enlarged ministerial commissions for military affairs and negotiations with Lebanon. The former minister for defence told the Paris newspaper Le Matin, 'I have won'. For once the man who has made untruths an essential element of his politics spoke the truth.

All this goes to show that those who naively or cynically argued for a moratorium on mass mobilisations against the Begin government while waiting for the conclusions of the Kahane report, were playing the game of Sharon and his acolytes. This gang got five months respite to go on with their criminal 4 policies as if nothing had happened.

What is more, they got a verdict, endorsed by all the big political forces, which says, "The matter is closed'.

As we wrote in International Viewpoint No 24, February 21, 1983, now that the shouting is over Begin, has

Antiwar demonstration in Israel (DR)

1 me 100137

Begin. Sharon Rafulyou murdered my son!

3990

The following message was sent to the a crisis within the government coalition.

Thus, it is not on the parliamentary terrain that the next stage will take place, but in the street. This was confirmed, tragically, by the grenade thrown by far-right activists, which killed Emile Greensweig, a Peace Now militant.

Peace Now has a duty to finally break from the Labour Party. It must take initiatives that will not only be a response to the excesses of the Begin-Sharon government but which can give impetus to a movement that will stay on the streets until it wins over a majority of the population to active and determined opposition to the policy of war and annexation.

It was in such a perspective that the Committee Against War in Lebanon decided not to yield to the many pressures put on it by the moderate pacifist currents to stop its activity. These currents argued that a halt was necessary to avoid widening the split that is more and more dividing Israeli society.

The only hope of putting an end to the criminal and suicidal policies of Sharon is precisely to widen this split. This is to say that Peace Now must commit itself entirely to fight for peace if it wants to justify the confidence that hundreds of thousands of Israelis have placed in it. recent conference of the Palestinian National Council held in Algiers by the Fourth International section in the State of Israel, of which Michel Warschawski is a well-known spokesman. Palestine National Council Algiers Dear Brothers and Comrades,

On the occasion of the convention of the Palestine National Council, we send the delegates of the Palestinian Arab people fraternal greetings from the anti-Zionist Jewish and Arab forces inside the state of Israel.

We are confident that this council will once again express the spirit of unity that distinguished the Palestinian Arab people in the most difficult moments of the battle for Beirut.

We wish to reiterate our commitment to continue the struggle inside the Zionist state, in co-operation with all forces that fight for peace and freedom.

We wish to reaffirm our commitment to the struggle for the achievement of the full rights of the Palestinian Arab people and the establishment of a free society in Palestine in which Jews and Arabs can live in peace, brotherhood, and equality.

As the vanguard of the anti-Zionist struggle inside Israel itself, we shall make every effort to strengthen the solidarity with the PLO, the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinian Arab people. Revolution until Victory.

Revolutionary Communist League - Matzpen

← Africa in the World Crisis — Editorial · A Crucial Year for the Netherlands →

Something wrong on this page?