International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Yugoslavia: The Yugoslav Federal Army Is Carving Out a New Space to Rule Over

· International Viewpoint No. 219, 23 December 1991 · p 11 · 934 words

Eastern Europe Armed forces and soldiers

An army in search of a state THE YUGOSLAV federal Minister of Defence has just called for the rapid creation of a mini-Yugoslavia'. He believes that the army has accomplished "its mission": to protect the Serbs from "a new genocide perpetrated by the Ustashe" and to secure the right to self-determination of those who wish to remain part of

ITALY

Parond

Slavanta

Krailna

O CIRCA RAMNO

HUNGARY

ROMANIA

• Ктако

3 varooma

Zagreb vedcovert? Nowl Sed

CROATIA

•Vihkcowal,

Orascant

Belgrado

BOSNIA -

HERCEGOVANA

•Vudic

SERBIA

Sarajovo.

YUGOSLAVIA

BULGARIA

MONTE •

Adrlalle

NEGRO

Pitaine

800

KOSOVO

Thogr a smaller Yugoslavia. CATHERINE VERLA NATUCOING VCDI A

HE tone is the same as that of Serbian president Slobodan Milosevic: "Serbia is not at war. It does not want the army to conquer the Croat territories, nor to block the exercise of the right to self-determination of the other peoples who have together constituted Yugoslavia and have the right to separate from it" ' Certainly, the Serbian regime and the army top brass add, the unilateral declarations of independence by Croatia and Slovenia are "illegal" in relation to the Yugoslav Constitution which stipulates that the dissolution of the country must be done in a concerted manner.

But they add, 'the will for separation is there. We will not hold by force those who wish to leave Yugoslavia. But we will not allow them to infringe on the right to self-determination of others who wish to remain in Yugoslavia". As to the frontiers, "the Constitution allows that they can be modified but on the basis of common agreement. The declarations of independence change the external frontiers, such was not our wish. But when the equilibrium of the whole, Yugoslavia, is challenged, then it is necessary also to renegotiate the internal frontiers". Such is the argument, extremely coherent with regard to "legality", ", developed by the representatives of the "Yugoslav bloc".

But legality itself can be applied in different ways. And behind the law, there is the relation of forces. It is this latter which in the past has forced the Albanians of Kosovo to accept a "Yugoslav" framework that they rejected (after the defeat of the plan for a Balkan confederation including Albania).

It is also this that has made Kosovo, cradle of the first Serbian medieval kingdom (but with an Albanian population of more than 90%) a province of the Republic of Serbia. It is again this relationship which has denied the Albanians of Kosovo the status of a "nation" (with its own republic/ state), making them instead a "national minority" inside Yugoslavia, without the right of secession.

This double standard is continued in

ITALY

ALBANIA

Stopio

MACEDONIA

"REECE these cease-fire agreements, which, far from treating the Albanians in Serbia and the Serbs in Croatia symmetrically, will recognize the rights of the second and completely ignore those of the first. Until Kosovo explodes again, without doubt this time supported by Albania.

But the relationship of forces is also unequal between the recognized nations: in the first place, of course, the force of the Croatian state has been legally imposed on the Serbs of Croatia, just as that of the Serbian state was legally (but first politically and physically) imposed on the provinces of Kosovo and Vojvodina.

A balance of pressures

Under different forms, it could be said that in the Yugoslav constitution of 1974, the last of the Tito era, a balance between all the pressures from below was realized: Serbian sovereignty on the territory of the Serbian republic would stop at the frontiers of the provinces recognized as quasirepublics with the right to a veto at the level of the federation; Croat sovereignty over the Croatian republic was shared with the Serbs of Croatia, treated as a constituent nation; in the same way, Bosnia-Herzegovina was a state of Serbs, Croats and Muslims (Islamicized Slavs recognized as an ethnic entity).

In other words, Yugoslavia was not only in itself a federation of republics, but these latter were also (for the most part) multinational states, with equal rights. This did not reflect an artificial division, but long term mixes and movements of population (the Albanians moved to Kosovo after the Serbs had fled the Turks, the Serbs of Croatia and of Bosnia-Herzegovina lived for some centuries in the frontier zones between the Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman empires, and so on).

It is obvious that the challenging of the multi-ethnic equilibrium of the 1974 constitution is the product of the overall crisis of the Titoist regime at the turn of the

GREE 1980s. This crisis produced on the one hand the recentralizing tendencies (liberal or backward-looking, respectively behind Milosevic who fought for a recentralized Yugoslavia), and, on the other, tendencies towards a break up of the federation through the reaffirmation of nation-states (states of one principal nation). The Serbian and Croat nationalists share common sources in this process, and have nourished each other in it.

Faced with the defeat of a Yugoslav centralist project, the Serbian powers turned to a "Serbo-slavia" supported by an army whose raison d'être is to have a state to defend (the biggest possible). To maintain the old Yugoslavia by force is completely impossible. But the Serbs of Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina play a dramatic and pivotal role in the project of maintenance of a Yugoslavia without its separatists. To consider that they are simply manipulated by Milosevic's Serbian regime is to pass over the political defeat of Croat president Franco Tudjman, which was not inevitable, unlike the military defeat which became certain when the army took on the role of protector of the Serbs.

An odious assimilation

← Kazakhstan: Re-elected President with 99.8% of the Vote, Pro-capitalist Autocrat Nursultan Nazarbajev Is Feted in Western Capitals · Yugoslavia: The Shadow of Versailles Hangs over European Policies towards Yugoslavia →

Something wrong on this page?