The change of regime in the Kremlin
Gerry FOLEY The despotic nature of the rule of the Soviet bureaucracy is revealed most dramatically on the occasion of the death of the supreme bureaucrat himself.
When Leonid Brezhnev's death was officially announced on November 12, virtually every publication in the Soviet Union appeared with exactly the same front page, the same communique, the same picture of the deceased boss, and the same bewailings of the "great loss" by the various levels of the party and of the "working masses."
The next day, November 13, once again all the Soviet papers had the same first page, showing the picture of the new general secretary, Yuri Andropov - "The emperor is dead; long live the emperor!"
The eulogy delivered by the new Kremlin boss also had the monstrously exaggerated, thoughtless, unmeasured character of the official eulogies typical of despotism since the age of the pharaohs:
"Our party and our country, the entire Soviet people, have suffered a heavy loss. The heart of the leader of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union and of the Soviet State, outstanding leader of the international Communist and workers movement, a fiery Communist, a true son of the Soviet people, Leonid Brezhnev, has ceased to beat.
"The greatest political figure of our time has passed away...
"Inseparably bound up with the name and works of Leonid Il'ich are the growth of the power and the all-embracing cooperation of the countries of the great socialist commonwealth, the active participation of the world Communist movement in resolving the historic tasks before humanity in our age, the reinforcing of the solidarity of all forces of national liberation and social progress on the earth."
On this and following days, the Soviet press carried long articles under headlines such as "The World Mourns."
Notably, the messages of condolence featured were those of the heads of capitalist states, such as Reagan and Thatcher. These were placed high above those from revolutionary figures such as the Cuban and Nicaraguan leaders.
The capitalist leaders did express a genuine-sounding sympathy with Brezhnev; he was apparently the sort of Soviet leader they like, completely cynical, and utterly mediocre. "You always knew
Where you stood with Leonid Brezhnev," Willy Brandt wrote in Der Spiegel.
In a number of respects, the ceremonies over Brezhnev's body resembled the ritual for a dead czar. For example, the hall of the trades-union building where the bier was set up was filled with candles, which are an impor tant part of the trappings of Eastern Orthodox church ceremonies.
According to legend, it was the great banks of candles in Constantinople's Saint Sophia that so impressed Princess Olga of Kiev that she adopted Christianity as the official religion of the first Russian state.
As changes of regime in a despotic setup usually are, Brezhnev's death was preceded by rumors of a deadly struggle among his potential heirs, accompanied by the equivalent of muffled thuds in the corridors of power.
In January, General Isvigun, a member of Brezhnev's family, died in mysterious circumstances. The name of the general secretary was notably missing from the list of signatures that are customarily appended to the obituaries of high Soviet officials.
At the beginning of October, Andrei Kirilenko, minister of industry and one of the top Kremlin figures, suddenly fell from the upper circle. On October 3, his name was among the signers of the obituary of the secretary of the first secretary of the Tatar Communist Party; on October 5, it was missing from the obituary of the second secretary of the Ukranian Communist Party.
On November 4, Kirilenko's picture failed to show up in a series of leadership portraits put up in Moscow. His son reportedly fled to the West.
There, was also a perceptible disarray in the Kremlin apparatus after the disappearance of the high priest of the official ideology, Mikhail Suslov, who died shortly after General Tsvigun. For example, a rock theater group found itself the victim of an army commando attack despite the fact that it was praised in the official press.
The French CP organ, l'Humanite, wrote November 13 that the rapid ascension of Andropov should have ended "speculations as indelicate as they were ignorant" about skulduggery involved in determining Brezhnev's successor.
In fact, in normal legal succession, one would not expect the holder of such an imposing office - to judge only by the official eulogies for the former occupant
- to be chosen so quickly or without public debate.
Moreover, one would not expect a smooth transfer of power to be accompanied with such appeals to unity. For example, in his eulogy, Andropov said: "Comrades, in the most difficult moments there is a power that helps us resolve the most difficult problems. That power is the unity of the Party."
The next day, November 14, Izvestia's front page had two articles. One was on the funeral. The other was entitled: "The Unshakeable Unity of the Party and the People."
The November 18 Pravda had a frontpage editorial entitled "The Feelings of a United Family," which said, among other things, "The workers of all nations and nationalities in the USSR unanimously approved the resolution of the special plenum selecting Comrade Yuri Vladimirovich Andropov general secretary of the Central Committee of the CPSU." Lately the Soviet press has had a number of articles indicating increased concern about national resentments in the USSR.
The succession could be expected to be difficult, since the command of the bureaucracy has changed in effect only three times since the rule of the apparat was consolidated in 1928. In two of the three cases, the change has followed the lingering death of the top bureaucrat. Only Khrushchev left office while he could still walk. He was ousted by a palace revolution. In any case, he could be considered a figure thrown up by the post-Stalin crisis, representing both reforms and hare-brained schemes to try to overcome the basic problems of the bureaucratic system. With Brezhnev in 1965, the bureaucracy returned to its historical course.
Brezhnev's position as the continuer of bureaucratic despotism was confirmed by the development of a full-blown "cult of the personality" around him in the later years of his reign.
He became a "literary" as well as a political genius, and the press of all the nationalities began publishing his works in serial form. In the organs of the various republics - in the case of the smaller republics there is no attempt to maintain the fiction of seperation between the government and the party and the same paper serves as the organ of both - many issues were largely taken up with Brezhnev's literary work.
Andropov's eulogy hailed Brezhnev as the defender of Marxism-Leninism and
the developer of such theoretical innovations as the "theory of developed socialism." In fact, he made notably less effort than Stalin or even Khrushchev to present himself as a Marxist thinker. His works are mainly memoirs. And the theory of "developed socialism" is nothing more than a propaganda slogan, a vague promise of a better, more dignified and civilized life for the Soviet people, one which was not kept.
The living standards of Soviets failed to increase significantly throughout the long reign of Leonid Il'ich, and in his last years even began to decline notably.
For the first time in the history of Soviet economist statistics, the government failed to publish the results of the 1981 grain harvest. It offered the population only the meagre reassurance "the state has sufficient grain resources to meet the needs of the people for bread.
In 1981, the production of milk was down by 2.6% from 1980, despite an increase of the milk herd in the same period by 0.5%. The most likely reason for the apparent contradiction is that there was not enough grain to meet the needs of both the people and the cows.
In the economy as a whole, the projected growth for the current five-year plan is only 3.4% annually. Given the relative backwardness of the Soviet economy and the fact that a considerable part of production is useless because of its low quality — to say nothing of falsification of statistics - this figure indicates that the lag of the Soviet economy behind Western imperialism in productivity and modernization is now growing.
Furthermore, the expiration of Brezhnev coincided with the closing of the modest democratic openings made in the Khrushchev period. The possibility of reaching world public opinion through telephone calls and contacts with foreign journalists have been virtually cut off.
In general, the most that can be said is that the repression has become more sophisticated and selective, directed toward accomplishing the objectives of the totalitarian regime without the enormous cost of the Stalin terror.
It is that sophistication of the repressive apparatus that Andropov represents; it is his historic achievement. This goes so far, reportedly, that as secret police head he used theologically trained cops to break religious dissidents.
Andropov is linked to the most sophisticated and therefore presumably the most cynical elements in the bureaucratic leadership — to figures such as Otto Kuusinen, the originally Finnish Stalinist leader; and to the chiefs of the Kadar operation in Hungary.
Kuusinen's career, for instance, spans the whole development of Stalinism. He was one of the early leaders of the CP in Finland, where there was a civil war between the workers movement and bourgeois forces. He was forced to flee to the Soviet Union. He was put in charge of the Republic of Karelia, established in the Finnish territory that remained under Moscow control.
Kuusinen in fact presided over the branches of industry, notably electronics, liquidation of the Finnish nation in the to assure that its needs were met. USSR, since the Karelian republic became Apparently, the more farsighted Soviet so Russianized that it was determined to military chiefs are getting worried that no longer require republic status. Thus, it the poor standards of bureaucratically was a model of the solution to the managed industry are endangering the national question in the USSR to which standing of the Soviet armed forces relathe bureaucrats look forward. tive to the American.
Kuusinen is virtually the only figure in With the pace of the electronics revothe Soviet leadership to survive from the lution, •bureaucratic management results revolutionary period through Stalin. In in more and more grave technological addition, he was virtually the only one lags. That is a basic problem from which with any real Marxist or humanist culture the entire Soviet bloc is suffering. It is or with any intellectual ability. He wrote, logical that this should hit the military for example, a serious Marxist study of hardest. the Kalevala, the Finnish national epic. The test of U.S. and Soviet equipment presumably has his mentor's qualities. He Andropov was Kuusinen's protege, and in the latest Mid-East war indicated that the U.S. is gaining an important lead in is the first top bureaucrat with a know- electronics weapons systems. ledge of foreign languages and societies. According to Adler and other such He even speaks English. He has a diplo- experts, it was the military professionals matic career behind him that allowed him who tipped the balance in Andropov's to get to know all the Soviet bloc con- favor. tries, even Mongolia. Paradoxically, as the long-time head of
Andropov was also Soviet ambassador the KGB, he could be expected to be the in Hungary at the time of the Hungarian most enlightened of the available candirevolution and the Stalinist restoration. dates for power. That is because in the He was reportedly the mastermind behind totalitarian system only the KGB knows the Kadar operation, both the split with what the real situation is.
government and the postIt is interesting in this respect to note restoration reforms. Kadarite experts now that in the wake of Stalin's death, the form an important part of his team, to leadership of the CP in Hungary, at that the extent that the Yugoslav press has extime the sick man of the soviet bloc, pressed concern that a Balkan revival may were called to Moscow, where Beria, then be acquiring dangerous influence at the head of the secret police, read them a full seat of the mighty. indictment of the failures of their bureau-
It was in Andropov's time as head of cratic management of the economy. the KGB that such techniques were per- (Tibor Meray, Nagy Imre, Elete es Halala, fected as forcing dissidents into exile. In an interview published in the Paris daily pp. 13-19.)
It is likely that the Andropov team Liberation, Vladimir Maximov, editor of will try to carry out some Hungarian-type an emigre publication, stressed:
economic reforms and to maneuver poli-
"Today the KGB works with scientific tically more than the Brezhnev regime. and psychological methods. Before letting For one thing, under the supremely a dissident leave for the West, they evalu- immobile Brezhnev problems have accuate his or her physical, psychological and
Emulated to the point of disaster. moral characteristics. Then they try to estimate what the future behaviour of Andropov can be expected to be a more wily defender of bureaucratic such a dissident will be.
"Today, if a gifted but critical young power than the ineffable Brezhnev. But person shows up in a school or a kolkhoz, he has gained the top position when the bureaucratic system is reaching the end of he or she is first observed, and then called in. They are offered an interesting assign- its possibilities. ment. Repression is only the last resort." It is perhaps a measure of how close the bureaucracy has come to the end of
That does not mean that Andropov's its rope that for the first time in its existKGB gave up strongarm methods. They ence it apparently feels that it cannot There is the case for example of a dissi- were used in particular in the Ukraine. afford to let the system be ruled by the sort of inflated nonentity that is the dent priest found strangled in a dive, with image of its own mediocrity, its moral his pockets full of drugs and U.S. capital- degradation, its false pretences. ist cash. But there is no way to maneuver very
The head of the Ukranian KGB, Fedo- long with the exasperationof the immense chuk, who worked under Andropov, has Soviet working class, which has built up a now replaced him as head of the all-union gaint industrial system but after more KGB than half a century of bureaucratic
Well informed Kremlinologists, such as management sees little evidence of conAlexandre Adler, a former French CP tinued real progress toward a decent life. leader charged for many years with Soviet The most extensive and sophisticated relations, linked Andropov's rise to that secret police apparatus will not be able to of General Ogarkov, the most prominent contain a hundred million workers once modernizer in the military hierarchy. they have come to the end of their
Earlier this year, Ogarkov published a patience. And now they have the example book that was virtually a manifesto of the of Poland to show that workers modernizers. Among other things, it sug- organize themselves and take their fate gested the army directly take over certain into their own hands.
• 7