International Viewpoint Archive

The Fourth International’s English-language review, from 1982

Mass Opposition to Begin's War

· International Viewpoint No. 11, 19 July 1982 · pp 3-4 · 2,406 words

Middle East

Mass opposition mounts to

Begin's war of repression

(Statement of the Revolutionary Communist League, section of the Fourth International in the State of Israel, June 24, 1982.)

After three weeks of destruction and slaughter, the PLO still lives and will continue to live.

Despite the overwhelming military superiority of Israel, despite the massacres, the indiscriminate bombing, despite the hundreds of thousands of refugees forced to flee their homes, the Israeli army has not yet been able to achieve its objectives, and no one can deny the basic fact that the PLO is very much still alive and still fighting.

The Begin-Sharon government aimed at liquidating the Palestinian national movement at whatever price. Already a week has gone by since the chief of state boasted that this objective had been achieved. But yesterday, the Minister of Foreign Affairs was obliged to admit that it was impossible to destroy the Palestinian national movement completely.

Thus, while we might say that Israel won the first round on points and not by a knock out, the second is just beginning. Left alone facing the Israeli divisions and bomber squadrons, without any help from the Arab armies, the Palestinian fighters have managed to keep the bulk of their military forces intact for more than three weeks. Fifteen years ago exactly, the Israeli army required only six days to smash the Arab armies and conquer large parts of Jordan, Egypt, and Syria....

The second round is the fight for a political solution and the battle for Beirut....The Israeli army must be stopped at the gates of Beirut and now. Gerry FOLEY

The latest Zionist imperialist war in the Mideast is already fundamentally different than the preceding ones. Politics and mass action have now become the immediate decisive factors.

The crucial battles are those for world public opinion, the minds of the Israeli population, and the unity of the Arab people in Lebanon and Beirut in particular against the imperialists and their agents and collaborators. 4

This is the aim of the Palestinian fighters, the Lebanese national movement, and the Syrian forces that are in the Lebanese capital. It is the urgent objective of all those who refuse to accept the mad logic of a permanent war of destruction.

Thousands of Israelis have already mobilized against this war in the full heat of the fighting. In the army, euphoria is giving way to skepticism, to questioning, and many cases of refusal to obey orders have been registered. This is only the tip of the iceberg of a movement that will grow as long as the war and its horrors continue.

The Revolutionary Communist League is throwing all its strength into building a broad antiwar movement that will open up a second front against the government's plans for a Massada (final solution) against the Arab people.

Resolute opposition to the war is not just a question of solidarity with the Palestinian Arab people. It is above all a question of self-defense for all Jews who want to live in this country. By building a broad movement against the war, we are constructing a united front of Jews and Arabs. A common fight by Jews and Arabs is the only chance we have for living together in peace and security.

-Down With the War in Lebanon, No Adventure in Beirut!

-Immediate Withdrawal of All Israeli Forces from Lebanon!

-Total and Unconditional Solidarity With the Heroic Struggle of the Palestinian Arab People!

-For the Right of Self-Determination of the Palestinian Arab People!

-Lortg Live the Common Struggle of the Jews and Palestinians Against War, Occupation, and National Oppression!

In these battles, the oppressed Palestinian and Arab peoples of the Levant are better than holding their own, and time is on their side. That represents a major weakening of the imperialists and their agents in the region. But it does not mean that the danger to the Arab people is any the less.

"Israel is in a hurry, there are no precise deadlines but Sharon is ready to

(Declaration of the Revolutionary Communist Group, Lebanese section of the Fourth International, June 29, 1982.)

Comrades and fellow fighters, Beirut is a fortress that would be difficult to occupy for the most powerful army in the world. Beirut is a bastion that the Zionist enemy cannot seriously think of occupying.

The enemy can destroy buildings, but they cannot come into our city and destroy our resistance. That is a job that the Zionist army cannot accomplish, because it would require paying an enormous price, one that it is not prepared to pay. The price would have to be paid in soldiers' lives and in the consequences that would inevitably flow from any prolonged battle against patriotic Beirut.

That is the real situation, and in all realism the only way to thwart the aims of the enemy campaign is to advance the following program:

-rejection of all conditions; -rejection of any solution other than the total and unconditional withdrawal of the enemy from Lebanese territory;

-refusal to negotiate with the enemy and in particular rejection of any negotiations behind our back;

-refusal to let the official Lebanese army enter Beirut, this traitor army that has fraternized with the Zionist army and Beshir Gemayel's Falangist gangs;

-the formation of a Government of National Resistance that must be a different one from the traitor government of Sarkis, a government made up of representatives of the parties prepared to continue the fight against the Zionist enemy in actions and not in words;

-organizing the resistance in our city and unifying our military forces in the framework of a National Guard of Resistance. show West Beirut, if necessary, that what it has experienced so far is nothing compared to what awaits it." That is what U.S. negotiator Phillip Habib told associates, according to Le Monde correspondent Dominique Pouchin.

Obviously, the Israeli tactic is to put as much pressure on West Beirut as possible, which includes threats, as well as shelling and bombing. But Habib's statement corresponds to the reali•

ties of the Israeli position.

The Israeli army is mainly a reserve army. It cannot be kept mobilized for long, without this creating intolerable economic and social costs. The war has already gone on too long from the Israeli point of it. It has cost the equivalent of 10% to 15% of the country's annual GNP. The Israeli army is more and more becoming bogged down in repression on a vast scale. This has already had visible effects on the morale of the soldiers, even hardened veterans.

The July 11 issue of the Paris daily Liberation noted in a report on the problems of Israeli state TV in the war:

"Micha Limor experienced only one censorship problem. It was when he filmed a meeting of Israeli soldiers at the gates of Beirut. They were thirty men of the famous Entebbe Unit, which landed at the airport in Somalia to free an Israeli plane taken hostage. That day, ; Limor recounts, 'the soldiers who had come to Beirut held a meeting where they violently criticized the government and the war in Lebanon. One of them said: "I agreed that it was necessary to come 45 kilometers and drive out the terrorists....Today, I'm asking questions....I find myself functioning as a policeman in Lebanon." ' "

Israeli TV's reporting of the massive demonstration against the war in Tel Aviv on July 3 aiso drew fire from the government. It was an enormous demonstration of up to 100,000 persons, an unprecedented event in time of war. In fact, until recent months, it would have been unprecedented in time of peace as well.

The attacks on Israeli TV bring out one of the fundamental contradictions in Israel's role as the main imperialist fortress in the Mideast. It was widespread sympathy for the Jewish refugees that enabled world imperialism to establish the settler state. But this sympathy was and remains tied up with pretences of de. mocracy and humanitarianism. Therefore, no matter how brutal, racist, and rabidly reactionary the Zionist regime, it has remained obliged to maintain an appearance of democracy, at least for the Jewish population.

Now, embroiled in a war that is more and more clearly against a people rather than an army or a state, the Israeli authorities find the functioning of a relatively free press increasingly damaging.

Furthermore, the massive bombing of civilian populations with atrocious weapons such as phosphorous and frag. mentation bombs of the new type is blowing away the democratic cover of the Zionist regime.

The impact of this on world public opinion is indicated by a growing tendency of Jewish notables in France and the U.S. to take some distance from the Begin government's policies and seek formulas that seem to grant some recognition to the rights of the Palestinians.

The second contradiction of the

Zionist fortress is its narrow demographic Arafat replied: "Palestine." and economic base, relative to the role it Avnery was obviously taken aback, is called on to play in the region. The "I mean the solution for tomorrow, not morale, educational level, identification the more distant future." with the state, and inculcated feeling of The PLO leader's response was "Palack of alternatives made the Jewish pop- lestine is our right." Another liberal ulation of Israel a nearly ideal imperialist Zionist reporter asked what he meant by garrison. But the reverse side of this is Palestine. Arafat said: "The whole coun that such a small community is not pre- try. For you and us." This questioner pared to take heavy human losses or asked: "Together?" Arafat said: face declining living standards for a long "Together, why not? ...We are period. those who have suffered aggression, and

A third contradiction of the Zion- nonetheless we have proposed two soluist state is that although it cannot exist tions. Some 60 percent of the Palestinexcept as an agent of imperialism, the ian people are homeless. But in 1969 we direct pressures on it and the needs of proposed to live together in a democratic building up a chauvinist mentality among and lay state...In 1974, we said that we the Jewish population tend to make it an were ready to live in a portion of the awkward tool for the United States in Palestinian territory that the Israelis particular. would leave or that would be liberated."

The Zionists' political needs tend to The PLO's main immediate procome into conflict with those of the im- blem is a political one, how to get broadperialists. Its leaders become more and er support from the Lebanese population more rabid and ready to strike out with- and effectively fight the idea that a sepaout concern for the political cost or wider rate peace with Israel at the expense of ramifications of their actions. Habib's re- the Palestinians would produce a tolermark about the Israeli impatience to situation at least for the nonsmash West Beirut may reflect U.S. worry Muslims. about this. From that standpoint, the longer

Thus, the U.S. itself becomes more the Israeli army is bogged down in Leand more embarrassed by the extension banon, the better the PLO's chances are. of the repressive war against the Arab (One effect of the prolonged civil war people. In the face of the mass protests situation is that most families in West by the Arab population of the occupied Beirut have stocked food and are preterritories, the Israelis felt obliged to re- pared for a long siege.) move even the mayor of Gaza, So, it makes sense for the PaShawa, one of the most capitulationist lestinian leadership to prolong the neof all the Arab officials in the territory gotiations and make every attempt to ruled by Israel. point up the fact that the Israelis

In response, the State Department not interested in compromises and that issued a statement saying: "This very no real compromises are possible. moderate man quite legitimately expres- The PLO leadership has another sed the concerns of the Palestinians under problem, in particular in view of the behis administration....Leaders of this quali- trayals of the Arab governments and left ty will be necessary when the Palestinian forces and the growing reaction against problem is settled in the context of the their empty demagogy. It has to mainCamp David Accords." (Le Monde, July tain the conviction among the Palestinian fighters themselves that they will In fact, in this war the basic reali not be sold out in any deal. Both questies of the situation have emerged very tions come down to one single political starkly, leaving less and less room for problem, a principled democratic apillusions about compromise settlements. proach to organizing the masses by edu-

In an interview in the Wall Street cating them, convincing them, and lead. Journal, Begin declared that he would ing them. never negotiate with the PLO, no matter Here the PLO's primarily military Whether or not it recognized the state conception of the fight against Zionism of Israel. In an interview broadcast over has been the biggest stumbling block. It Austrian TV July 9, Israeli defense minis has paid the greatest price in the war for ter Ariel Sharon said that "there will never its failure in the past to concentrate on be a Palestinian state, either in Gaza or on winning the support of the largest posthe West Bank," sible majority of Lebanese. The new si-

The Western press gave big play to a tuation should drive home the lesson of supposed readiness by Arafat to recognize the need for a new, more political straIsrael in return for political recognition for the PLO. However, in his interview In the new situation also the adwith the liberal Zionist Uri Avnery, the vancement of programs for mobilizing the PLO leader gave a different picture than Jewish and Palestinian masses against the these reports have indicated. "I am ready imperialist plans for permanent war and to safeguard the 600,000 Lebanese who repression in the Mideast takes on a new live in West Beirut, as well as 200,000 importance. The Israeli and Lebanese Palestinians, to find a political solution. sections of the Fourth International are We are negotiating with the Lebanese au- doing this and playing an increasingly imthorities to find a solution.... portant role. That has been particularly

Avnery asked: "If it is possible to true of the section in Israel, where the opget out of this crisis, what would be the portunities for legal political work are solution?" БОД 1181 greatest. greatest.

← Mass Mobilizations Become Decisive in Middle East War — Editorial · The Palestinian Resistance →

Something wrong on this page?